Should We Continue This Marriage? - Reviews

Should We Continue This Marriage?
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the divorce bomb Derek drops at the end because MY HANDS ARE SHAKING. Let me back up though — this whole chapter arc is a masterclass in misdirection, and I wasn't ready for any of it. The plot starts by establishing the world: Sylvester Territory is brutal, demon beasts are always lurking, and Derek's punishment system is severe but fair. We learn his philosophy — one person's carelessness spreads like a virus and costs lives. This is where he executed a knight before, and it clearly haunted him. Good worldbuilding, sets the stakes high. Then the inciting incident hits: Etia collapses after a demon beast attack. Derek's reaction is... complicated. He stays at her side for a week straight, skips meals, moves her himself despite also handling border affairs. But here's the thing — the narrator keeps pulling back from his POV to show us what's NOT being said. Every detail about his grief, his self-loathing, his panic gets filtered through Helva's sympathetic observation or Etia's own guilty conscience. We never actually get Derek's raw thoughts until the end, and that's by design. The middle section follows Etia's recovery and her mounting guilt — the coachman died because of her recklessness. She hears servants gossiping about demon beasts crossing the border more frequently, something happening in the Land of Fire. Tiny plot threads being woven in, setting up future conflicts. She's also reflecting on how stupid she was, how she treated danger like fiction. And then — BAM. Derek walks in after three days of absence, looks wrecked, and says 'Let's divorce.' Not 'I want a divorce.' Not 'We should separate.' He frames it as her choice but it's clearly him lashing out at his own inability to protect her. His line 'I can no longer find a reason to maintain this marriage' is devastating because we KNOW that's not true. The coherence here is impressive. Every subplot — the demon beast threat, the political pressure on Sylvester, the failing marriage, Etia's guilt over the coachman — converges on this single moment. The author could've made this melodramatic but instead it lands like a quiet earthquake. Who else predicted this coming? Or was I the only one blindsided?
... Read More
STOP. I need to talk about the dialogue here because this author clearly understands that the most powerful lines are the ones people DON'T say to each other. Let's look at the office scene. Derek: "Did you have something to say?" That's it. That's the entire line. He doesn't greet her. He doesn't ask how she's feeling. He's sitting at his desk, bathed in sunlight (bright, ironic sunlight — the author loves these cruel contrasts), and he addresses her like a petitioner at court. And Etia's response? She can barely form words. She fidgets with her fingertips. She says "No, no. It's not that..." which is the most honest thing she's said all chapter. Then Derek: "The priest will come tomorrow. You should prepare." Not 'I'm sorry.' Not 'I hope you understand.' Not even a pause. Just: the facts. The logistics. The next step. And Etia's counter, which absolutely dismantles everything: "Can't you reconsider?" I swear to god, the simplicity of this exchange is what makes it work. No speeches. No melodrama. Just two people who clearly once understood each other, now speaking in a language neither of them fully knows anymore. But here's what the dialogue VOICE does that I love — Etia's internal monologue is WILDLY different from her spoken words. She bursts into the office with a whole rehearsed case, ready to negotiate. By the time she exits, she's managed exactly: "I... misjudged you, my lord." Five words. That's all she could extract from herself. The gap between what she planned to say and what she actually said IS the story. The narrative prose itself has this quiet, observant quality. It doesn't rush. It lingers on small physical details — Etia's trembling hands, her bitten nails, the way she muffled the door. The author's voice is like a camera that stays on the face just a half-second too long. Uncomfortable, yes. Necessary, absolutely.
... Read More
Let me talk about stakes because this book UNDERSTANDS stakes. Etia has no assets of her own. Her family treated her as currency in a political deal. She lives in a castle that isn't hers. Her husband barely acknowledges her existence. And the country's laws? Men can demand divorce anytime over chastity or succession issues. Women? Good luck. You need evidence priests will accept, and even then most cases never make it to temple. So when Derek—this indifferent, cold, absent husband—finally summons her after two months, the reader knows something is coming. The anxiety builds through every paragraph. Etia herself is readying herself for divorce proceedings. She's researched lawyers, studied law books, prepared for the worst. And then what does he do? Talk about an imperial inspection. Just... that. No confrontation. No accusation. Nothing. But here's where the conflict deepens: the imperial inspection isn't just background. It's a threat multiplier. If the Emperor's people find problems with Sylvester Territory—problems that might be linked to the lord's personal life or the marriage's lack of offspring—everything Etia has worked to secure could collapse. And her father? A man who valued noble honor above all else and sees his daughter as a transaction? He won't take her back if she comes home divorced and defeated. The stakes are personal, political, economic, and survival-level all at once. Every silent dinner, every avoided glance, every moment Derek chooses work over his wife carries weight because we know what's at stake if this falls apart.
... Read More
I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay after reading this. There's a moment—just a small one—where Etia is caressing Derek's neck, her hand moving up his skin, and the text says she "didn't notice the simultaneous feeling of sadness creeping in." Did you catch that? She was actively seducing her husband and somewhere underneath all that wine and panic, sadness was just... arriving. Like an uninvited guest who's been standing in the corner the whole time. That's the emotion of this entire scene. It's not romantic. It's not even erotic, despite what's technically happening. It's two people who are completely alone together, reaching for each other in the wrong ways, hurting each other while trying not to be hurt themselves. And Derek—he's struggling so much. His body betrays him. He gets aroused despite himself and worries she'll notice. He's frustrated, confused, concerned, guilty. He wants to say something, to do something, but every instinct tells him to be careful, to be proper, to not take advantage. And when she passes out on his shoulder and he finds those tear stains... god. He wipes her face. Gently. Like she's something precious even though she's been treating herself like nothing. The most heartbreaking line in the whole passage: "So that's why she suddenly suggested drinking wine." Derek, finally understanding that her boldness wasn't boldness at all but desperation. And by the time he figures it out, she's already asleep, already unconscious to the fact that someone finally sees her. I need a minute. Give me a minute.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about THIS moment. The one where Etia offers to sleep on the sofa and Derek basically loses his shit without actually yelling. Like. Read that again. "I'm not such a scoundrel that I'd make a woman sleep on the sofa while I sleep comfortably in bed alone." AND THEN HE LEAVES. Just packs up and walks out. No explanation. No "we need to talk." Just... gone. And Etia is standing there going "what did I do wrong??" When actually she did NOTHING wrong — she was being considerate! She thought he wanted the bed! She was trying to be a GOOD wife according to every rule she's ever known! But here's what gets me — Derek clearly HAD been sleeping separately on purpose. The head steward and maid were looking at her pitifully. Everyone knew. And Etia? She didn't even care until NOW. She was fine with it. Happy even, maybe — her own room, her own space, freedom while waiting for the divorce. But the SECOND she offers to compromise, to give up her sofa for his bed, he can't handle it. Why? I think it's because somewhere underneath all that coldness, Derek still feels something. And Etia's offer — sweet, accidental, unintentional — forces him to confront the fact that she's willing to be close to him if he wants it. And maybe he DOES want it, which terrifies him more than anything else. The tragedy is they're both so bad at communicating. She thinks he wants divorce. He thinks she's uncomfortable. Neither asks. Neither explains. They just orbit each other like two satellites crashing in slow motion.
... Read More
I read this section three times and each time I notice something different about how the author controls the rhythm. It starts slow - walking, talking, awkward silence - and then suddenly Derek's meeting interrupts everything and we're thrust into political and military urgency. The shift is jarring on purpose. You go from "should I ask him about spring?" to "monsters are attacking villages" in three paragraphs and that whiplash IS the point. Etia goes from personal heartache to being locked out of the bigger picture, and the reader feels that same exclusion. Then it cuts back to the personal - Derek maintaining his sword, Etia finding him, the hand-holding moment - and those scenes are written in shorter, tighter sentences, like the emotional stakes are compressing the prose itself. The final section on the fortress wall slows back down to almost meditative, with Derek's thoughts bleeding into each other. It's like the pacing breathes: fast when the world is chaotic, slow when it's just two people being miserable. And the chapter doesn't end with resolution, it ends mid-thought. No period, just him smelling blood and thinking about her. Devastating.
... Read More
This chapter starts in Etia's head and moves to Derek's perspective, then converges in the drawing room. Classic dual POV structure but the way the author uses it here is masterful. The opening is deliberately slow—Etia alone, crying, packing. We spend time with her thoughts, her regrets, her bleak assessment of her options. It's miserable but necessary because we need to understand WHAT she's losing before we understand WHY Derek is fighting to keep her. Then BAM—Derek's visit. The pacing shifts immediately. We go from solitary grief to forced confrontation. The knock on the door isn't dramatic; it's almost mundane. But it changes everything. What I love is how the author doesn't rush the emotional beats. Derek doesn't immediately apologize or declare love. He stumbles. He asks questions he's afraid to hear answers to. He watches her cry and doesn't know what to do. That's realistic pacing—for people who've hurt each other deeply. The scene with the commoners is both comic relief and heartbreaking. These people are terrified, stammering, but Derek sees through it immediately. He smiles warmly, makes them comfortable, and Etia... forgets her own pain for a moment. That's the pacing at its best—using a brief respite to make the subsequent emotional hit harder. And that ending! "Why are you curious about that?" Etia asks, and Derek won't answer. The chapter cuts right at the moment of highest tension. He's going to ask her something important—something that could change everything—but we don't get the payoff. That cliffhanger is PERFECT. Not manipulative, not cheap, just genuinely where the story needs to pause. The only thing I'd adjust? Maybe shorten the opening paragraph slightly. But honestly, the slow build makes the emotional payoff so much better. This author knows how to control reader engagement through pacing choices.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this batch moved. The alternating POVs between Etia and Derek — it's not just a gimmick, it actually builds this incredible dramatic irony. We see Etia freaking out about her thin nightgown and Derek meanwhile recalling the SAME moment but from his side, realizing he might've been too harsh. That structure choice is so smart. The pacing in the middle section with the Crown Prince inspection is what kept me hooked though. There's this slow burn of political tension underneath what seems like a wholesome country tour. Derek's conversation with the Crown Prince about marriage, happiness, trust — it's layered. The author doesn't tell us anything directly, but every line pushes the larger narrative forward. When the Crown Prince drops 'Does she know too?' out of nowhere mid-conversation about the North? My jaw hit the floor. And then cutting back to Etia, busy and exhausted, not having seen Derek all week — the relief you feel for her is so brief before the author slams the door shut again with the wine scene. The pacing around that wine evening is masterful. Days of dread, the elaborate preparation, the heartbreaking costume choice, Derek's stone-cold reaction. It builds and builds and then just... deflates. The chapter ends on her internal panic and him filling wine glasses in silence. I was FUMING. But honestly, the pacing is mostly solid. The transition between Etia's internal monologue and her conversations with Mary flows naturally. No dragged-out sections, no rushed emotional beats. The author knows when to linger and when to move fast.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this for a second. Two years. Two years these two have been married and Etia literally couldn't describe what Derek looks like before tonight. Can you even imagine? They shared a bedroom, probably shared vows, but she'd never actually SEEN him. Not really. And then she looks at him properly and—okay, the author does not even give me a chance here. Black hair, deep blue eyes like ocean depths, full lips tinted red from wine. Of COURSE Derek is devastatingly handsome. Of course the cold, intimidating Lord of the North is the kind of man other noble ladies blush over. But here's what hit me: Etia notices all this and STILL she's sitting there thinking about divorce. That's the tragedy of this relationship. They're both so focused on survival—her surviving the social consequences of being a divorced noblewoman, his surviving whatever internal war made him avoid the marital bed for two years—that neither of them is actually seeing the person across from them. The lap scene broke me. Etia climbs onto his lap not out of desire but out of sheer terror. She says "it's the duty of a duchess" and I literally gasped. This woman has internalized the cage so thoroughly that she's offering herself as a breeding tool to keep from being abandoned. And Derek—he notices. He catches the sadness on her face even through the alcohol. He says no, not because he's rejecting her, but because he won't take advantage of someone who's this broken. He carries her to bed. Wipes tears off her face. Brushes back her hair. And then he leaves. That man is trying so damn hard to be decent and it's destroying me.
... Read More
The author understands something most writers don't: what you leave out matters more than what you include. Two years of this marriage, and instead of filling us with tedious daily interactions, we get one wedding night scene and then a clean time jump. Efficient. Brutal. Perfect. The pacing creates this extraordinary sense of isolation. By skipping those two years, we experience the same emotional emptiness Etia feels—we're left in the dark, just like her. We don't get to watch them slowly fall apart; we arrive at the wreckage and have to reconstruct what happened. That's sophisticated storytelling. Then the return sequence: immediate bath, straight to study, back and forth between work and training grounds. No meetings with his wife. Nothing. The author maintains this rhythm of absence, of almost-notices, of things unsaid. Even when Derek finally summons her, he delivers the news about the imperial inspection and goes right back to work. The scene could have dragged into drama, but instead it ends almost anticlimactically—with Etia asking about the timeline and leaving. The tension comes FROM what doesn't happen. The three-week countdown to the imperial inspection creates a subtle ticking clock that pulls you forward without ever raising its voice. Every chapter builds toward that moment without announcing it. That's pacing mastery.
... Read More
'I can no longer find a reason to maintain this marriage.' That's it. That's the line. Three sentences. Twenty-eight words. And I am emotionally compromised. Let me talk about dialogue in this section because the author's restraint here is what makes it devastating. Almost no one says what they actually mean. Every conversation is happening on two levels simultaneously, and the gap between them is where the story lives. Take Derek and Etia's scene. It starts with polite, almost sterile exchanges: 'How are you feeling?' 'Much better. I think I could walk around now, but everyone's being too overprotective.' 'Are things at the border alright?' These are the lines people say when they don't know what else to say. And the narration keeps telling us they DON'T know what else to say — Etia 'hurriedly composed her face,' Derek's expression 'didn't change,' both of them hiding behind social performance. The dialogue is ice. The narration is fire. Then Derek sits down. The physical proximity shifts something. His face 'looked even worse up close' — he's lost weight, he's exhausted, he's been falling apart for days. And then: 'Please speak.' Silence. 'Let's divorce.' The simplicity is staggering. No elaboration. No 'I did this because...' No emotional explanation. Just the statement, delivered like a verdict. And Etia's response — 'Um, my lord... no, Derek.' — is where the voice work is most brilliant. She accidentally uses his real name, and the text tells us she wasn't even aware she'd done it. The dialogue itself betrays what her consciousness won't admit yet. The servant dialogue is a different texture entirely — Hannah's chatter is fast, unfiltered, slightly embarrassing. Mary's attempts to rein her in create a rhythm of interruption and escalation. These scenes of everyday noise contrast sharply with the suffocating silence between Derek and Etia. And the internal monologues! Derek calling himself a 'pathetic bastard' and Etia comparing her experience to novels — these voices feel completely distinct from each other AND from the narrated dialogue. Two different people experiencing the same crisis in completely different ways. The author's prose style here is clean, restrained, almost clinical when describing Derek's actions, but the emotional subtext is overflowing. It's the literary equivalent of someone smiling while their hands tremble.
... Read More
"It's the duty of a duchess, isn't it?" Six words and the entire theme of this novel just collapsed onto the page like a building losing its foundation. Etia isn't just worried about divorce—she's terrified of what happens to women who survive it. The text lays this out with almost clinical precision. In her homeland, divorced women face social execution. Not legal punishment, not financial ruin (though that probably follows too), but something worse: the complete erasure of their honor. People inflate nonexistent scandals. They torment divorced women. And for nobles, who value appearances above all else, a divorced noblewoman is apparently the ultimate social death. So Etia is essentially bargaining with her own body to maintain her status. She's not trying to have a happy marriage or find love—she's trying to produce an heir to lock in her position. The entire system is designed so that a woman's survival depends on her ability to reproduce for a man she barely knows. And who created these duties? Etia literally asks this question internally: "Who decided and created those duties?" Nobody answers. Nobody ever answers. That's the point. The oppression is so diffuse, so baked into the culture, that there's no single villain to confront. It's just... everywhere. The wine itself is symbolic too. It's her courage, her weakness, her confessional, and her undoing. Every glass she drinks is another layer of truth she can barely contain. She wants to demand answers but can only demand children instead. The intoxication strips away her political calculations and leaves only raw fear. Derek's guilt at the end—he feels "displeasure" at the system that made her see herself as a duty-bearing object rather than a person—is the novel's quiet indictment. He's part of the problem even though he's trying not to be.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or