Selfish and Selfless - Reviews

Selfish and Selfless
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This section is a masterclass in dramatic irony and emotional devastation. Marienne spends most of the narrative blissfully unaware, convinced she has secured Lennox's heart. The author carefully plants seeds throughout—Lennox's avoidance of physical intimacy, his lingering gazes at Fiona, the disproportionate care in gifts—but Marienne's illness-clouded perspective filters them all away. The payoff, though, is brutal. The scene where she walks in on Lennox masturbating to Fiona's portrait is one of those moments that recontextualizes everything. It's not just a twist; it's an indictment of her entire happiness. The parallel structure between her childhood longing for love and her adult disillusionment is haunting. She wanted so badly to be loved, and when she finally gets it, she realizes it was never hers. The subplot of Fiona's silent sacrifice—that she knew all along but never spoke up—adds another layer of tragedy. Marienne's realization that Fiona could have had Lennox if she'd only said something is the cruelest cut of all. The author doesn't let her off the hook with easy forgiveness. Even in her pain, Marienne remains selfish, resentful that her sister might be happy without her. The plot refuses to simplify her into a victim or a villain.
... Read More
The text says it outright: "the fact that this delicate relationship had continued for nearly seven years was a miracle in itself." Seven years. Do you know how much emotional labor it takes to maintain a love triangle where you're one of the vertices and you've decided to be the sacrificial one? I keep coming back to the concept of naming. Fiona reads the proposal and the name doesn't change. [Fiona]. The word itself is a blade. Then she writes that massive letter redirecting everything, and the second proposal arrives with [Marienne] instead. Two names. Two fates. One woman who can't decide which version of herself she wants to be—the Count who makes political decisions or the woman who loves a man she can't have. The marriage proposal document itself is such a loaded object. Paper that contains the power to rearrange three lives. Fiona seals it. Writes another letter. Seals that too. The physical act of sealing letters is basically her way of boxing up her own feelings and mailing them somewhere else. And the heir arrangement—making the child her blood successor—this is about immortality through substitution. She can't have him, so she'll have his lineage. It's deeply feudal and deeply human at the same time. The story keeps circling back to what counts as family, what counts as love, and whether sacrifice is noble or just another form of possession. "As long as you're happy, that's enough." She says this six different ways across these chapters. But does SHE get to decide what's enough? That's the real question, isn't it?
... Read More
Fiona's internal state in these chapters is absolutely devastating and I keep coming back to it. She's living with her dead sister's husband, sharing a bed with him, and every sweet moment is poisoned by this relentless voice in her head saying 'he did this with Marienne first.' It's not rational — she knows it's not rational — but that doesn't matter because the feeling doesn't care about logic. The most heartbreaking detail is how she can't even hate Lennox for it. She wants to, she tries to, but he's been genuinely good to her. Affectionate. Present. He brings her tax money from the village himself instead of handing it to an aide. He notices when she's upset. And yet she still imagines him with her sister, still constructs this phantom rivalry with a woman who's been dead for eighteen months. But then Lennox flips the script entirely and admits he never loved Marienne — which means every single one of Fiona's assumptions about their marriage was wrong. He married her because of Fiona, not despite her. The fact that he was kind to Marienne was just... basic human decency, not romantic love. That reframing is supposed to be a relief, right? But read closely and you can see Fiona still doesn't fully believe him. She asks the same question twice. She pushes his hand away. She's trapped in her own grief.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is a study in suppression. Marienne and Lennox rarely say what they mean, and the silence between their words is where the real conversation lives. Take the simple exchange where Lennox says, 'I'll send a letter tomorrow asking Fiona to come again.' It sounds benign, almost helpful, but Marienne hears the desperation underneath. Her response—to press her lips together and lower her head—is all the accusation she can muster without making a scene. Similarly, when Marienne confronts Lennox after catching him, he doesn't deny anything. He offers excuses about her health, his face troubled, and then comforts her while she cries. His dialogue is soft, patient, almost tender. But the voice behind those words is clearly someone holding onto something he can't have. The narrative voice itself is remarkably close to Marienne's consciousness. We get her thoughts in italics, raw and unfiltered: 'It would have been better if it had just ended like that.' There's no narrator correcting her, no omniscient voice offering perspective. We're trapped in her head, watching her reconstruct the entire relationship through a new, devastating lens. The author lets Marienne's voice dominate even her regrets. When she thinks about Fiona's silent suffering, when she wonders whether to divorce Lennox, we hear her selfishness, her guilt, her envy—all tangled together without judgment. That unvarnished interiority is what makes the dialogue feel so honest.
... Read More
Okay so this whole section basically revolves around one absolutely bonkers plot development and I am STILL processing it—Lennox actually proposes to Fiona after marrying her dead sister. Let me just say, the dramatic irony here is so thick you could cut it with a knife. The author sets this up in this really fascinating way where we follow Lennox's POV first, watching him work through his entire internal logic: yeah he loved Marienne too but she's dead, Fiona loved him first, his father wants the Ternin-Bayward connection sealed, marriage of a widow to her sister's widowed husband is technically permitted by God—so why not? And then the scene flips to Fiona, who is just lying there mentally screaming while also kind of... wanting this? Which is honestly the most deliciously tangled plot situation I have ever encountered. What really got me though is the way the author handles the backstory exposition. We get all this through Lennox's memories rather than info-dumping it to us. About three years at the Bayward estate, Marienne falling for him, Fiona pulling away, the contract scene—everything flows naturally from his regret. It's brilliant because it makes us understand his motivation without excusing it. Then when Fiona processes it all, her realization that she's making excuses because she actually loves him too? Chef's kiss. The subplot with Count Ternin is also doing heavy lifting here—Fiona sending that contract to free Lennox from his father's grip is this gorgeous ironic detail because it's her own solution that eventually becomes his weapon. Like fate is just playing the most twisted game at this point. "When your heart is settled, let's marry then"—what a line to end on, so calm and so devastating simultaneously.
... Read More
"I'm considering making the child born between them my heir. Even if, by some chance, I marry and have a child in the future, I intend to give priority inheritance rights of the Bayward County to Marienne's child." I NEED TO SIT DOWN. Fiona is out here literally engineering her own heartbreak into a bloodline strategy. She's not just giving up Lennox—she's making sure his genetic legacy carries HER name forward. That is the most devastatingly romantic gesture I have ever encountered and I am not okay. Like, on the surface it reads as practical political maneuvering. Fiona the Count, securing succession. But read between the lines and what are you actually seeing? This woman is so in love she can't even let him have a child with someone else without inserting herself into the biology of it. Her DNA will survive through that kid. She'll be spiritually the mother. It's disgusting and beautiful and I love her so much. And then the aftermath—seven years of this silent pining and she still hasn't figured out how to stop feeling it. She told herself marriage would be the period at the end of the sentence. It wasn't. It was just a comma. She still gets swept up in emotions when she looks at him standing beside Marienne. She still has those base emotions rising from deep in her heart that she can't even name. The scene where Marienne grabs her collar and says "I'm even happier because you're here too, Sister" and Fiona has to sit there stroking her forehead wondering how to process the fact that love isn't a zero-sum game in her head—she genuinely cannot separate loving Marienne from wanting Marienne's happiness to not involve the man Fiona loves. Those two feelings are at war inside her chest every single day.
... Read More
There's this moment — or rather, the ABSENCE of a moment — that wrecked me. Fiona is standing next to Lennox at her sister's grave, and the reader is screaming internally: ASK HIM. Just ask him how he feels about YOU. Not about Marienne. About you. But she doesn't. She can't. And the text lays out her logic so brutally: "If Lennox answered 'I love you,' she would wonder if he no longer had feelings for Marienne. If he answered 'I don't love you,' she would wonder if the marriage with Fiona was just matching interests. So it would be terrible." SHE'S TRAPPED BY HER OWN LOGIC. Every possible answer destroys her. And she knows it. The worst part? Lennox is literally right there, being gentle — removing grass from her hair, draping his coat over her shoulders — and she's sitting there paralyzed because asking the real question would require her to risk something she hasn't let herself want this whole time. Then later, when he grabs her hand and says "I'm being unreasonable" and "just say yes" — and she can't pull away because part of her doesn't WANT to — the stakes shift from emotional to almost physical. The handshake burns. She presses her forehead to the desk after he leaves. This isn't just about a wedding timeline anymore. It's about two people who are desperately trying not to want the wrong thing from each other, and failing. The suspense isn't whether they'll marry — the author makes that inevitable from page one. The tension is: what happens to Fiona when she finally has to confront what she actually wants?
... Read More
I need to talk about Lennox's dialogue because this man is weaponizing kindness and I don't know how to feel about that. "It's been a while, Fiona." — calm, bright smile. The basic man. Absolutely unremarkable delivery of a perfectly normal greeting. And yet it hits different when you know what's happening underneath it. He has no idea. Or—if he does—he's choosing to pretend he doesn't, which is somehow worse. "Sister, we're not interrupting when you're busy, are we?" — OH HE'S DOING IT AGAIN. The polite concern. The gentle touch on Marienne's shoulder. "You think so too, right? That Sister needs rest." He's mediating between his wife and her sister like a tiny domestic diplomat and Fiona is over there dying because he's a GOOD husband and a GOOD friend and that combination is lethal. And then the apology: "I'm sorry, Fiona." On BEHALF of his wife. He's smoothing things over, being the gracious host's brother-in-law, the perfect guest. Every line he speaks is so natural, so unforced, like he genuinely can't perceive the earthquake he's causing. Meanwhile Fiona's internal monologue is a mess of fragmented thoughts—"It would be best if he chose Marienne" followed immediately by laughing at herself, pressing her chest, breathing tremblingly. The contrast between her chaotic interiority and the calm, almost boring exterior of everyone else's dialogue is what makes this section land so hard. Marienne's voice is the opposite—bouncy, rapid-fire, all exclamation points. "Oh my, oh my! Sister!" "Did Lennox come by any chance? When is he coming?" She talks in bursts. Fiona talks in spirals. Lennox talks in complete, measured sentences. Three communication styles, three people who will never understand each other the way they need to.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the physical spaces in this section mirror the emotional claustrophobia because the author is doing something really intentional here. Start with Lennox returning to the mansion and sitting on "the sofa that had become familiar by now." Familiar. Not comfortable. Familiar. That word choice alone tells you everything about his state of mind—he's been living in this house as a grieving widower but it's never truly become home. And then there's the window with the "picturesque landscape" outside, which is this gorgeous ironic contrast. Beautiful world outside, miserable man inside. Classic setup. Then Fiona's room—she's lying on her bed, staring at the ceiling, replaying his words. The domestic intimacy of it is striking. These are two people in their private spaces, both unable to sleep, both haunted by the same ghost. The scenes alternate between their interiors like a call and response, each one feeding the other's loneliness. The grave scene at the end is brief but devastating in its simplicity. "Fiona plopped down in front of Marienne's grave. It was the first..." and then the chapter cuts off. I need the next chapter. I need it now. The fact that she goes to her sister's grave to ask permission to marry her sister's husband—what a perfect, heartbreaking image. She's sitting in dirt and grass asking a dead girl for approval like this is some kind of communion. The author really understands that grief isn't just sadness—it's a constant, ongoing conversation with someone who can no longer answer. The tea scenes are also doing important atmospheric work. Lukewarm tea. Silence. Gaze lowered. These are the moments where nothing happens externally but everything shifts internally, and the quietness of those rooms makes the emotional earthquake hit harder.
... Read More
Let me be clear—nobody is going to die in this story. There are no armies marching, no assassins in the shadows, no political coup happening (at least not in this batch). And yet I have NEVER been more on the edge of my seat about a romantic conflict. The stakes here are internal, which means they're invisible to everyone except the protagonist. Fiona receives the marriage proposal and her entire world tilts. Not because she wanted to marry Count Ternin's son for power—she explicitly says she never revealed her feelings through any action or word—but because the universe just handed her the one thing she never dared to ask for and she has to actively refuse it. That's the conflict engine right there: desire versus duty, love versus loyalty to her sister, personal happiness versus familial obligation. And Fiona chooses duty every single time, which makes each subsequent scene infinitely more tense because we KNOW she's still feeling it. The wedding day scene is peak tension despite having zero dramatic events. Marienne is sick from the heavy dress, feverish but happier than anyone. Fiona is smiling and congratulating while internally her stomach churns. The reader knows something the characters mostly don't—that this happiness is built on a foundation of Fiona's unspoken agony. Every cheerful exchange is loaded. Every touch between Lennox and Marienne is visible to Fiona. Every moment of their joined hands is a reminder of what she gave up. And the greatest stakes of all? Fiona might not survive this emotionally. She's been surviving for seven years. The wedding happened. She's supposed to be done. She's not. And that unresolved tension—where does it go from here?—is what's keeping me up at night.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how MARANNE'S DIALOGUE hits different than everyone else's? Like, she says three sentences in this entire text and they accumulate more emotional weight than everything else combined. "I'd have no regrets even if I died." Said so casually, almost playfully, and Fiona has to shut it down immediately. "You always scold me when I say things like this, Sister." But then later, when she's actually dying, she says it again in a completely different way. The repetition hits completely different the second time. That's not accidental writing—that's deliberate, careful craftsmanship. And Lennox! His dialogue is sparse but loaded. "I'm glad if that's the case" when Marianne says she was happy despite resenting him—that faint smile containing "a small apology"—the author doesn't give us a full sentence of explanation, just that gesture embedded in dialogue. Lennox doesn't cry, doesn't wail, just says "...Marianne." Three ellipses and a name. That's it. And it conveys more than any monologue could. But the real voice masterpiece is Fiona's internal monologue. Listen to this: "Wasn't he her sister's husband? No, in the first place, it must have been an action without any particular meaning on his part. She was clearly the strange one for feeling strange emotions over a trivial action." The self-convincing, the rationalization, the pathetic little excuses she tells herself—this is such a distinctly FIONA voice. She's intellectualizing her feelings, trying to logic her way out of emotion, and it's so painfully human. The dialogue between the sisters throughout feels so natural too. "Why are you suddenly talking like that?" "Even though I knew you were giving in to me, I don't think I've said sorry very often." These people have known each other their entire lives, and it shows in how they speak to each other—incomplete sentences, shared context, understanding without explanation. And then the final exchange. Marianne: "Sister, thank you." Fiona, unable to form complete thoughts, just repeating "I love you" while her sister's eyelashes slowly close. The dialogue becomes fragmented, barely audible—because that's how real death conversations go. Not grand declarations, but whispered fragments and unspoken love.
... Read More
"If time passed like this for a long time, would it become so worn that even the letters couldn't be read? As if nothing had been engraved here at all. How nice it would be if everything became insignificant like that." I keep coming back to this image. The gravestone — that's supposed to be the thing that REMEMBERS, right? That's what it's for. But Fiona notices it's getting dirty, rough, and instead of cleaning it, she wonders if it'd be nicer if the words just faded away. Like erasing Marienne would somehow erase her guilt too. That's the most tragic thought in this entire passage, and it's dressed up as a casual observation. And then the sky. She rolls over and sees the blue sky — "The blue sky filled her eyes completely." Bright, empty, indifferent. There's no heavens opening up, no ghost of Marienne appearing. Just sky. Absolutely nothing answering her. And I think that's the book being honest about what grief actually looks like. It's not cinematic. It's just you on the ground, talking to cold stone, with the whole rest of the world continuing above you. The whole chapter is built around this tension between what should be said and what can't be. Fiona rehearses three versions of how to tell Marienne she's marrying Lennox and can't commit to any of them. The aide gives practical answers but not THE answer. Everyone says "it's the right thing" except the person who matters most can't speak. The book is asking: what do you do when the only person whose forgiveness you need can't give it?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or