Selfish and Selfless - Reviews

Selfish and Selfless
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
OK let me just start by saying: I thought the stakes were going to be romantic disappointment and I was PREPARED for that. What I wasn't prepared for was GRIEF. Actual, raw, devastating grief. This text took me from "oh cute, love triangle" to "I am not okay" in approximately two paragraphs. Let's talk about the internal conflict first, because Fiona's got layers. On one level, she's fighting her feelings for Lennox—the man her sister loves and married. Every time he touches her arm, every time she sees him with Marianne, she's wrestling with this impossible situation. "What exactly do I need to do to be okay?" she asks herself. And the answer, of course, is: nothing. There's no solution here. She can marry someone else, she can tell herself she's fine, she can build a life—but she can't unfeel what she feels. But then the external conflict arrives and completely shatters everything. Marianne's illness isn't a obstacle to work around or a complication to solve. It's terminal. The stakes escalate from "will Fiona get over her crush" to "will her sister die" and suddenly all her internal drama feels trivial and selfish. That shift is brutal and brilliant. "If it could save her only family, she could do anything. Even if it meant staking Fiona's own life, she could do it." This line right here captures the entire emotional architecture of the conflict. Fiona's love for her sister isn't conditional—it's absolute. And the conflict isn't really about winning or losing anymore. It's about helplessness. It's about watching someone you love slip away and having absolutely nothing you can do about it. The moment where Lennox shakes his head—that's the stakes crystallized. No doctor can help. No prayer will work. The only person who could save Marianne is death itself, and Fiona can't negotiate with that. "Please don't say things like that, Marianne"—Fiona begging her dying sister not to apologize, not to leave, and Marianne doing it anyway. The deepest conflict here is Fiona's realization at the end: "There was no one left for Fiona to take care of." All her life, her purpose was protecting Marianne. Now that role is gone, and she has to figure out who she is without it. That's not just emotional stakes—that's existential. And the text leaves us right at that precipice, not quite falling but definitely not safe.
... Read More
This is where the pacing really starts to bite. We've been building toward this proposal for what feels like forever, and the author knows it—the chapters in this section move in this almost suffocating slow motion that perfectly matches what the characters are experiencing. Look at the structure: we get Lennox's POV, his entire backstory, his justification for the proposal, the actual proposal itself, THEN we cut to Fiona's reaction. That's deliberate. The author wants us to sit with Lennox's perspective first, to understand his reasoning, to even sympathize with him—before we see what it does to the person on the receiving end. It's a structural choice that makes you complicit in something unsettling. You understand him before you judge what his understanding does to Fiona. Then Fiona's internal monologue spans several days. She lies on her bed. She thinks. She agonizes. She doesn't make a decision immediately. The chapter stretches across multiple conversations separated by periods of silence, and the time skips create this anxiety because you're desperate for resolution that keeps getting delayed. Each tea meeting is shorter than the last, each exchange more economical, as if the characters themselves are running out of words to circle around the truth. "When your heart is settled, let's marry then." Lennox says this so casually, like they're discussing a weather report, but the weight of it is immense. He's giving her space but the reader knows there's no real space to give. The pacing of their relationship is this grotesque accordion—stretching and compressing—and by the time the chapter ends with Fiona saying yes conditionally, the relief is almost unbearable. But that grave scene at the very end? Pure narrative cruelty. Cutting off right as she arrives? The author is a monster and I love them for it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or