Selfish and Selfless - Reviews

Selfish and Selfless
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Fiona because she is the most complicated person I've met in any book recently and I don't even know how to process her. She loves Lennox. She absolutely, clearly, undeniably loves him. And she lets her younger sister have him. Not because someone forced her, not because there was some grand scheme — she just… gives it up. Every single time. She tells Marienne about the letters. She invites him over. She watches them together from behind curtains like some kind of ghost in her own life. And the worst part? She keeps telling herself it's the right thing to do. "She won't make it past ten. She won't make it past fifteen." She knows her sister is fragile, and she uses that knowledge like a weapon against herself. Like Marienne's illness gives Fiona less of a right to want things. But then you catch these tiny cracks — "why was she feeling a little hateful about it now?" A LITTLE. She's been burying this for years and even she can't pretend it doesn't hurt anymore. The scene where she slides down the door and just sits on the floor hitting yourself emotionally is everything. She calls herself pathetic. Miserable. But also — she doesn't STOP. She never stops doing it. That's not weakness, honestly. That's a kind of devotion so extreme it becomes its own kind of madness. And then Marienne asks about marriage and Fiona's whole world tilts again. Of course Marienne is asking about marrying Lennox. Of course she is. And Fiona still deflects. Still protects. Still performs the role of the selfless older sister like it's a second skin she can't take off. Is she going to break eventually or is she going to keep folding herself into smaller and smaller shapes until there's nothing left?
... Read More
Let's be real for a second — this scene looks like pure romance on the surface, but the stakes underneath are absolutely massive and I'm still recovering from how layered this conflict is. On the external level, Fiona is trapped. Count Ternin wants an heir with Ternin blood. Bayward County needs continuity. She considered bringing in a distant relative as successor because she wanted to give up everything when Marienne died — that's not just dramatic, that's a woman who had genuinely considered walking away from her entire life and responsibility. But she can't. The political machinery doesn't allow it. Then there's the internal conflict, which is where this chapter really cuts deep. Fiona is oscillating between three competing forces: her genuine十年的 love for Lennox, her guilt over replacing her sister in every possible way, and her sense of duty to her house and her people. She tells herself it's all just excuses — "It's all just excuses. This way, that way, she had no choice" — but we both know she's lying to herself. Part of her wants this. Part of her has wanted this for ten years. And Lennox's conflict is equally brutal. He's about to consummate a marriage with the woman he's loved for a decade, and he's nervous because he genuinely cares about her experience. He's worried about being clumsy. He's watching her face, checking in, asking "Doesn't it feel good?" with visible anxiety. He has no idea that the woman beneath him is mentally apologizing to her dead sister. The suspense isn't whether they'll end up together — they're already married. The tension is whether Fiona can ever genuinely be present in this moment, whether she'll ever stop comparing this to Marienne, whether Lennox will ever know how much she's suffering alongside her own desire.
... Read More
This is the kind of love triangle that just refuses to stay a triangle. Like, it officially dissolved with Marienne's death but the ghost of it is EVERYWHERE. Every time Fiona says Marienne's name it hits differently now—I literally felt my chest tighten reading those passages. "Marienne loved you." "I know." "You loved Marienne too." The man didn't answer. That silence? That was everything. I was sitting there like WHAT DO YOU MEAN YOU DON'T KNOW HOW TO ANSWER THAT, LENNOX, OF COURSE YOU DIDN'T LOVE HER THE WAY SHE NEEDED BUT YOU KNEW SHE LOVED YOU AND YOU STAYED ANYWAY OUT OF GUILT AND FEAR OF LOSING FIONA AND NOW MARIENNE IS GONE AND WHAT DO YOU DO WITH ALL OF THIS? And then Fiona asking him "Did you love Marienne?" and him answering "Marienne was happy. Isn't that enough?" I literally had to pause the book. Because what is that answer? Is it deflection? Is it truth? Is it him finally admitting that loving her the way she deserved was impossible but he made sure she was happy anyway, and that HAS to count for something? The emotional landscape here is brutal in the best way. Fiona thinks she's being noble by protecting Marienne's memory, but she's also terrified of heaven's judgment—"If I marry Lennox, I won't be able to meet Marienne again. Even if it was a marriage God permitted, Fiona would fall to hell." BRO. The guilt layers are INSANE. And yet she also wants this so badly it physically hurts her. Both of them are trapped in this web of love, grief, and obligation and I just want to wrap them both in a blanket and tell them to communicate better.
... Read More
The dialogue in this section is absolutely lethal. Like, I've never read a conversation where people are saying exactly what they mean and also absolutely nothing of what they mean. Take this exchange: "Marienne loved you." "I know." "You loved Marienne too." The man didn't answer. Three lines. Three beats. The second "I know" carries the weight of someone who knows they failed at loving Marienne properly, and the silence after "You loved Marienne too" is the loudest thing in the book. That's not a lack of dialogue—that's masterful subtext. And then the proposal scene itself is this beautiful train wreck of miscommunications: "Nowhere does it forbid marrying a sister's husband who has already left this world! Not even God!" "Just because God permits it doesn't mean I must marry a man who is my sister's husband!" These two are talking about completely different things. He's talking about legality and theology. She's talking about emotion and loyalty. They're in the same room but different universes. What I love most is how Fiona and Lennox's voices are distinct even when they're both being painfully reserved. Lennox is more direct, more forceful when he pushes—"Marienne is dead, Fiona" has this rough edge to it. Fiona's dialogue is quieter, more fragmented, full of ellipses and half-thoughts. She stammers. She trails off. She laughs dryly. Her internal voice is where the real drama lives because outwardly she's this composed lady saying "I'll take all the guilt." The line "Do you think Marienne would oppose our marriage, Fiona?" asked almost casually by Lennox? Devastating. He's putting the question in her mouth so he doesn't have to ask it himself.
... Read More
Okay so this whole section about how Fiona's visit pattern changed hit me like a truck. She used to come every three days without fail. Every. Three. Days. And then right after deciding to marry Lennox, she just... stops showing up. Can't face her sister. That single detail does SO much work — in one sentence we learn the entire weight of Fiona's guilt, the magnitude of what she's doing, and the self-loathing underneath it all. No dramatic narration needed. And then the time jumps: three months, half a year, one year. The author slides through these transitions so smoothly I barely noticed until I was already at the wedding. That's actually kind of masterful, because it mirrors Fiona's own desire to just... make it over with. Get it done. She's not sitting with her grief — she's rushing past it. And the pacing of the text itself enacts that same rushing. The scene at the grave feels long and slow, like she's lying there hours, and then suddenly it's the wedding day and she's changing clothes and everything feels numb. The author literally makes us FEEL that time compression. It's like the story itself is holding its breath and then exhaling too quickly.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is razor-sharp, and I have to talk about how natural it feels despite the heavy emotional weight. Most romance novels trip over themselves when characters try to have deep conversations — it turns into prose poetry or melodrama. But here, Lennox and Fiona sound like real people who are terrible at expressing what they actually mean. Take this exchange: 'You loved Marienne, didn't you?' Fiona asks. And then immediately after, 'You made Marienne happy.' She can't even ask the question cleanly. She's so tangled up in her own pain that she circles around the real question without ever landing on it. It's painfully authentic — how many times have you asked someone a simple question and somehow ended up saying something completely different? Lennox's responses are equally revealing. 'I don't know what answer you want, Fiona.' That line alone tells you everything about their dynamic — he's been guessing at her pain this whole marriage, and he's exhausted by it. The short, fragmented sentences he uses when he's emotional ('I!') versus his longer, more measured speech when he's trying to be reasonable — it shows his internal state without any narration telling us how he feels. The author's voice in the narrative sections also deserves praise. Fiona's internal monologue reads like actual thought — rambling, contradictory, jumping between regret and desire and guilt in the span of a paragraph. It's messy in the best possible way.
... Read More
There's this one image that's been stuck in my head since I finished this and I can't shake it. Fiona standing at the office window looking down at the garden table where her sister and Lennox used to always sit. That place is empty now. The author doesn't even dwell on it for long—just a beat, a glance, and then Fiona crosses her arms and tells herself it's better this way—but the visual is SO clean. A garden table. A empty chair where someone important used to be. Afternoon light, presumably, because everything in this story feels golden and sad at the same time. And then later, the mansion. Marienne and Lennox's new home, described as peaceful and secluded, with wind coming through windows mixed with the smell of grass. Fiona visiting there, bringing water to her sick sister, the blanket pulled up to Marienne's chin. There's something almost domestic about these scenes—the teacups, the bedroom visits, the way Marienne calls out "Sissterrr" in a listless voice. It's domestic bliss, but viewed through the wrong person's eyes. The castle itself feels like a character. Fiona's office, the corridor where she walks and stops and sighs, the garden where the three of them used to gather. These are spaces that hold memory. The castle was the stage for their trio before the marriage—every visit, every conversation, every accidental encounter. Now it's just Fiona alone in it, and the mansion across the way is where the actual story is happening. I keep thinking about how the author uses physical distance as emotional metaphor. Fiona moves them to a mansion so she doesn't have to watch them live happily under the same roof. Physical separation as self-preservation. But of course she can't stay away. The carriage shows up anyway.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this absolutely devastating layer of Fiona's psychology that I didn't fully appreciate until this chapter. Like, on the surface it's a classic "newly married couple sharing a bed for the first time" scene, right? Standard romance territory. But Fiona is literally wrestling with the fact that this man was previously married to her own sister. The most heartbreaking line in this entire passage is when she thinks: "Lennox was my sister's husband. Meaning didn't it mean he would have had relations with Marienne too?" And then immediately — immediately — she tries to shove that thought away because she "didn't want to imagine that far either." This is the core tragedy of their relationship, isn't it? Lennox has been pining after Fiona for ten years — TEN YEARS — and yet the moment they finally come together, Fiona can't help but measure herself against a ghost. She's not just sleeping with Lennox; she's sleeping with the man who was her sister's husband. And she knows it. She keeps thinking about Marienne even as she's losing herself in the physical moment. But here's what absolutely wrecked me: Lennox doesn't know any of this. He thinks she's finally willing. He says "since it's my first time I'll be clumsy" and he means it. He's nervous. He's tender. And Fiona, who has loved him silently for a decade, is lying there drowning in guilt and comparison while he's just trying to be gentle with her. The asymmetry of their emotional positions in that bed is almost unbearable. The scene where she strokes his back and thinks about how she and Marienne used to fall asleep embracing each other — that broke me. She can't even let herself feel intimacy without invoking her dead sister. How do you live like that? How do you let yourself be happy when every tender moment feels like betrayal?
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about Fiona for a sec because THIS WOMAN. Like, I get that she's the protagonist and all, but the amount of self-sacrifice she's packing is genuinely exhausting to read about. She's sitting there writing a letter telling the guy to marry her SISTER, explaining to him point-by-point how much Marienne loves Lennox, basically hand-delivering the man of her dreams to her own blood relative. And here's the thing that broke my brain—she actually SUCCEEDS. Count Ternin comes back with Marienne's name on the proposal and Fiona has to go deliver that news to her sister like, "Hey good news, you're getting your happy ending!" while internally dying. The sisterhood is so thick it's almost suffocating. Marienne literally throws herself at Fiona hugging her, trembling, eyes sparkling, and Fiona is over there thinking "as long as you're happy that's enough" while pressing her hand against her own chest like she's physically containing pain. But then—plot twist—the marriage happens and Fiona STILL can't walk away. She moved them into a nearby mansion instead of living together in the castle, which I initially read as her being considerate, but honestly? That reads like someone who can't stand to watch her person be happy with someone else in real time. And now she's visiting anyway, bringing tea, checking on Marienne when she's sick, all while Lennox is RIGHT THERE holding her hand. The three of them sitting around that garden table—before the marriage it felt precariously tense, now it's somehow more painful because it's stable. Lennox even apologizes for interrupting. He's a genuinely GOOD guy. That's what makes it worse. He's not some villain taking advantage, he just... doesn't know. Or maybe he does and that's its own kind of cruelty.
... Read More
"Sister, I love you." That's it. That's all Marienne gets out before she dies, and I am absolutely wrecked. Let me just... sit with this for a second. So here's the thing that got me about this section. The plot sets you up beautifully, right? Like, classic stuff. Fiona has these unresolved feelings for Lennox, her sister Marianne marries the man Fiona secretly loves, and we're all waiting for the romantic triangle drama to unfold. But the author? The author completely sidesteps that. Instead of the expected love triangle resolution, we get the real emotional core of the story thrust right into our faces: the bond between two sisters. The plot structure here is honestly brilliant in its misdirection. Ch.14-20 builds this whole narrative about Fiona trying to move on, searching for a groom, making plans for her future—all while pretending she's fine with Marianne and Lennox being happy together. And then BAM. Marianne's critical condition pulls her back to the center of everything, and suddenly all those marriage plans feel like a desperate attempt to fill a void that can't be filled. The parallel structure is what really got me. Marianne tells Lennox "I resented you so much. But I was happy." And Fiona is left with nothing but grief, with no such closure because she never even dared to be honest about her own feelings. The plot doesn't give Fiona the same opportunity for emotional resolution—it just leaves her alone, truly alone, for the first time. "The fact that she's lived this long is already a miracle." This line from Fiona's internal monologue is the pivot point of the entire arc. The story spends so long making us believe this is a romance novel, only to reveal itself as something far more devastating—a story about loss, about what we do when the people we love slip away, and about learning to grieve without someone to protect.
... Read More
Okay, this chapter is a turning point and I need everyone to understand how massive that is for the story. Up until now, Fiona and Lennox have been orbiting each other for ten years — unspoken feelings, missed opportunities, painful misunderstandings, Marienne's marriage standing between them like a wall. This chapter is the moment the wall comes down. Whether they like it or not, they are now physically and legally bound as husband and wife, and there's no undoing what happens here. But here's what makes it complicated instead of just romantic: Fiona's first conscious thought during their intimacy isn't about passion or love or even desire. It's about Marienne. Specifically, she lies there and thinks about how she and her sister used to fall asleep in each other's arms. She's physically with the man she's loved for a decade and her mind keeps wandering back to the sister she failed to protect. The plot is setting up something genuinely painful here. Yes, they're finally together. But Fiona hasn't resolved her grief, she hasn't processed her guilt, and she's entering the most intimate moment of her life while carrying all of that weight. Meanwhile, Lennox is approaching this with a kind of hopeful vulnerability that makes my heart ache — he thinks this is the beginning of something new, and he has no idea how haunted she is. I also want to flag the detail about Lennox saying "since it's my first time I'll be clumsy" — if taken literally, this implies he and Marienne never consummated their marriage. That changes EVERYTHING about how we read their backstory. It means Marienne may have rejected him, or chosen someone else, or been unable to go through with it. That detail alone reshapes Fiona's entire understanding of her sister's choices and her own place in this triangle. I need to go sit down.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this: that scene where Lennox finally drops the bomb about never loving Marienne? I literally sat there staring at the screen. The whole book has been building toward this reveal like some kind of emotional landmine, and when he finally says it — 'I never loved Marienne' — you feel your stomach drop because suddenly everything recontextualizes. All of Fiona's suffering, all her guilt about being happy, all those nights she probably cried herself to sleep thinking she was just a replacement — it was all based on a false assumption. What's interesting about the plot structure here is how the author refuses to give us easy answers. Lennox claims he married Marienne out of obligation to Fiona, that he was trying to make the sister happy because 'that's what you would have wanted.' That's... honestly kind of manipulative? Or is it romantic devotion taken to an insane extreme? I still can't tell. And that ambiguity is what makes this scene so gripping. The pacing around the confession is also masterful. He starts soft, saying 'the only one I love is you,' but when Fiona pushes back — insisting he made Marienne happy, that he loved her — he escalates. He gets rough. He shouts. His composure cracks. The tension ramps up until you can barely breathe, and then it pivots into intimacy, which feels both comforting and deeply unsettling at the same time.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or