Secret Crush (GL) - Reviews

Secret Crush (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely ruthless and I love it. You start with Aunt Chen's tender, heartbreaking monologue about her missing daughter — warm, nostalgic, painfully slow. Then An Ruxin enters the bedroom and the prose becomes almost reverent, lingering on each object like a camera pan. The diary, the notes, the camera — each discovery comes at a measured pace that lets you soak it in. Then the video plays and for a moment it's just sweet, fluffy, everyday girlhood. And then — BAM. The realization hits. The pacing flips from slow-burn discovery to sudden violent clarity. An Ruxin stumbles, falls, wakes up from her hallucination, drives to the hotel, and immediately confronts Bai Miaoqing. The transition from the dreamlike reservoir sequence directly into that confrontation is masterful — there's no breathing room, no soft landing. She goes from floating peacefully beside Chen Anran's body underwater to shouting at Bai Miaoqing in the same breath. The chapter structure here mirrors An Ruxin's psychological descent: calm surface, growing unease, the plunge, then the furious surface-level aftermath. And it ends mid-sentence basically, with Bai Miaoqing defending herself with 'I felt it — I really felt it!' which is such a perfect cliffhanger that leaves you gasping.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this for a second. The way An Ruxin's feelings for Bai Miaoqing are woven through every single moment of this chapter is so quietly devastating. "Maybe that was the best outcome. The most reasonable one." An Ruxin literally tells herself she just wanted Bai Miaoqing to live a good life, because she used to have a crush on her. As if that makes it pure. As if it doesn't complicate everything infinitely more. And then the dream sequence. Oh god. An Ruxin dreaming about high school — writing Bai's name in her notebook margins, scribbling it out, watching her back without being seen. It's not even romantic in a traditional sense. It's something lonelier. More desperate. "By looking long enough, she could imprint that back view into her eyes, into her heart, turn it into an eternal idol." That line absolutely wrecked me. She's been carrying this for over a decade, idealizing someone who is now physically trembling and unrecognizable from who she was. But the really painful part is how An Ruxin refuses to see the truth. When she finds those defaced photos, her immediate instinct is to protect Bai: "The girl I liked would never make such malicious scribbles." She literally uses her nostalgia as a shield against what her brain is telling her. "That was Bai Miaoqing's past! Her essence won't change." Meanwhile Bai is burning that group photo in a motel trash bin, crying about Chen Anran, envying her. And An Ruxin has no idea any of this is happening. She's just tired and trying to be there for her friend, never suspecting that the person she's been romantically Fixated on for years might be the most dangerous person in this entire story.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters operates on so many levels simultaneously that I'm genuinely astonished. Let me start with one line that has been living in my head on repeat: “Let her see my despair… I deserved all this.” Bai Miaoqing says this to An Ruxin after she's just learned that her best friend died loving her, and that she herself killed her. And the horror of it isn't just in the content — it's in the delivery. She's practically BEGGING Chen Anran's ghost to kill her. She WANTS the punishment. That's not dialogue, that's a confession of moral bankruptcy, and it's devastating. Then An Ruxin responds with this terrifying calmness. Her dialogue is always measured, always precise. Even when she's describing increasingly violent murder methods, she sounds like she's discussing the weather. That contrast between CONTENT and TONE is where the author's voice really shines. An Ruxin doesn't shout. She doesn't tremble. She says “I'd kill you” with the same flat professionalism she uses when she says “Probably just old and worn out” about the broken railing. And THAT inconsistency — the gap between how she speaks and what she means — is what makes her so frighteningly compelling. Bai Miaoqing's voice, meanwhile, has completely shattered by the end. What starts as coherent reasoning devolves into fragmentary whispers: “I love you so much… It's over, Ruxin, it's all over… I beg you, please, just once before it ends, kiss me.” The repetition, the ellipses, the way sentences collapse into each other — this is a character who has lost all narrative control. She's not telling her own story anymore. She's being told by the truth, and she can't stop it.
... Read More
This chapter sequence is a masterclass in controlled demolition. The author doesn't just reveal information — they orchestrate Bai Miaoqing's psychological collapse with surgical precision, and I was absolutely mesmerized by the architecture of it all. It starts with An Ruxin methodically laying out deductions. One by one, the pieces click into place for both Bai Miaoqing and the reader. “Chen Anran had a crush on Bai Miaoqing. That explained everything.” This is the calm before the storm — logical, almost clinical. Then the tempo accelerates as Bai Miaoqing tries to process each revelation. She asks questions, An Ruxin answers. The back-and-forth creates a rhythm that pulls you forward. But here's where it gets brilliant: once the truth about Chen Anran's crush is fully laid bare, the narrative doesn't stop. It pivots. Bai Miaoqing's breakdown isn't a single moment — it's a cascade. She laughs. She stumbles. The railing breaks. She falls. And An Ruxin catches her. Every beat compounds the dread. The pacing during Bai Miaoqing's monologue — “Every single word is right. Every line is so convincing… This isn't real.” — it loops and spirals like her actual thoughts, and that circular quality makes you feel her disintegration from the inside. Then the author does something I've never seen work this well: after Bai Miaoqing reaches absolute rock bottom, asking for one last kiss, An Ruxin doesn't comfort her. She escalates. The conversation about whether Chen Anran wants to kill Bai Miaoqing could have been the emotional climax. But instead of resolving anything, it becomes the springboard for the SHARPEST twist of the entire book. And that final line—cutting off mid-sentence—is the kind of cliffhanger that makes you immediately open the next chapter without a second thought.
... Read More
The stakes in this story operate on three levels and they keep escalating. Level one: the immediate stakes of the interrogation. Miaoqing is being questioned about her best friend's death and every answer she gives makes her look more guilty. The police already have her diary — if they discover the timeline discrepancy, she's looking at murder charges. That's why she lied initially. But then Ruxin corners her with logic: 'If you truly saw a ghost, why were you afraid of being suspected of murder? A normal cop would assume you were traumatized.' That single question dismantles the entire ghost defense. Level two: the mystery of what actually happened at the reservoir. Was it suicide? Accident? Murder? The ghost? Each possibility carries different moral weight. And level three — the deepest level — is the conflict inside Miaoqing herself. She wanted a wish to come true. Her wish came true. But the cost was Anran's life. So the real question haunting this whole story isn't 'who killed Chen Anran?' It's 'did Miaoqing kill her, or did her wish kill her?' And honestly, I don't think those are mutually exclusive answers anymore.
... Read More
I keep coming back to this idea that everyone in this story is trapped by love — and not the romantic, cinematic kind. It's the ugly, suffocating, reality-warping kind. Chen Anran's love for Bai Miaoqing is the most tragic because it's the most PURE. A fifteen-year-old girl writing secret messages in a diary, planning a delicate confession via diagonal cipher, wearing a beautiful white dress to the reservoir just to look her best for the person she likes — this isn't obsession. This is tenderness. And the worst part? She never forced anything. She planned to walk away if Bai Miaoqing didn't feel the same. “If you didn't like her, she wouldn't have revealed any of this.” That is genuinely heartbreaking. But then Bai Miaoqing's love for An Ruxin — and here's where it gets uncomfortably complicated — she admits it herself: “The ‘average' An Ruxin was just right—she didn't trigger envy or fear, but was enough to foster a romantic longing.” So her love for An Ruxin is built on ANRUXIN NOT BEING CHEN ANRAN. She loves someone WHO ISN'T the person she actually loved. That's not romance, that's a coping mechanism dressed up as devotion. And An Ruxin?? Who is she in love with? We don't know yet, but the author has planted enough breadcrumbs. An Ruxin “quietly looked at the girl in front of her” while processing Bai Miaoqing's breakdown. She went to Chen Anran's parents to get the diary. She has been watching, calculating, waiting. Her final line cuts off because she's “clearly troubled” — and that emotion, rare as it is from her, makes me think her love might be the most dangerous of all. Three people. Three distorted forms of love. And Chen Anran is dead in all of it.
... Read More
Okay so I NEED to talk about this scene where An Ruxin completely flips the script on Bai Miaoqing. Like, up until this point we've been reading An Ruxin as this calm, rational friend who's helping Bai Miaoqing piece together the mystery. But then—BAM—she says the most unhinged thing imaginable. The way she describes exactly HOW she would kill someone if she liked Chen Anran? “I'd drown you in the reservoir, or push you down the stairs, stab you to death, strangle you, maybe even cut off your head.” This isn't a character having a moment. This is someone calmly listing murder methods like they're reading a grocery list. And the way she says it — no trembling, no hysteria, just "quite seriously" — that's what makes it so damn effective. The chill doesn't come from drama. It comes from the ice in her voice. And then she drops the bomb: “Because you're not the one I've been in love with.” Bai Miaoqing immediately assumes it's Chen Anran, right? Because of course she does — that's the whole twisted triangle, isn't it? But no. Not Chen Anran either. And that final line — “I've thought about it for a long time,” An Ruxin said, clearly troubled — what??? Who IS it then??? I have been sitting here for twenty minutes staring at my screen trying to decode what that trailing off means. Is she in love with Bai Miaoqing too? That would make her a stalker-level crazy person considering she already found Chen Anran's diary somehow. Or is it someone else entirely? I don't know what to do with myself. Also, the fact that Bai Miaoqing's reaction to all of this is basically “Mm… It's Anran, isn't it?” like she's barely processing anything? She's been so thoroughly destroyed by learning about Chen Anran's feelings that An Ruxin's threat is almost secondary to her. That woman is hollowed out.
... Read More
'At some point, each step she took downward made her surroundings more unfamiliar, the light dimmer and dimmer. Though she should've still been in the stairwell, it was as if she had stepped into a boundless hell… and yet, the hell before her was… the view beneath deep green water.' I keep coming back to this passage. The way the author transforms a mundane apartment stairwell into an actual descent into the reservoir — that's not just good writing, that's something almost supernatural happening on the page. And earlier, Chen Anran's bedroom — pink bedspread, stickers on the desk, certificates on the wall, the wardrobe full of little girl clothes that will never be worn again. Aunt Chen cleaning it every day so her daughter has somewhere to stay when she returns. That image of an elderly woman dusting a fifteen-year-old's room, talking to empty air, saying 'she was always afraid of the cold' — I physically could not look away. Then the video itself, that shaky rooftop footage with the twilight and the static and two girls laughing, completely ordinary and devastatingly tragic because we know what comes next. The contrast between those bright warm moments and the cold green water at the bottom is the emotional architecture of this entire novel.
... Read More
This story knows exactly what it's doing with its pacing, and I respect it. It opens in media res almost—no, wait, it opens with An Ruxin doing what she's always done: slipping away from the sports day, entering an empty classroom, sitting at someone else's desk like she owns the space. Very quiet. Very intimate. The prose is slow here, deliberate, matching An Ruxin's internal rhythm. She's not rushing anything. She's savoring. Then the crying. The bathroom scene hits like a ton of bricks after all that calm buildup. Up until that point, we think this is a straightforward secret crush story—sweet, slightly unsettling, but ultimately innocent. Then Bai Miaoqing appears, tears streaking her face, and suddenly the genre shifts. What was a slice-of-life romance just became something darker, something with stakes. The confession scene on the track is the emotional peak of the first act, and it's handled with this breathless quality—loop after loop, like they're trying to walk the feeling into permanence. Then the post-exam confrontation: short, brutal, clinical. Bai Miaoqing's lines come fast and sharp, each one a small death. The pacing here is almost hostile, which is exactly what it should be. An Ruxin is being dismantled sentence by sentence. And then—we jump. How many years? Not specified. We land in the present with Bai Miaoqing already broken, already isolated, already living in a hotel room staring at windows. The time skip is handled with zero transition, which I think is intentional. An Ruxin doesn't get closure, so the narrative doesn't give us one either. The revelation scene is where the pacing does its most impressive work. Bai Miaoqing's monologue about Chen Anran comes in fragments, like she can barely hold it together. Each piece of information lands like a hammer: she liked you, she was possessed, she had to destroy herself to survive, she never stopped loving you, and now the ghost is back. By the time An Ruxin sees Chen Anran at the window, we're already at maximum tension, and then—"Liar." One word. The story pivots again. The final section, An Ruxin going to Chen Anran's house, feels like the beginning of a new chapter rather than the end of this one. It's purposefully unresolved. The author is setting up the next phase of the story while giving us just enough payoff to not feel cheated. What I love most is how the pacing mirrors An Ruxin's emotional state: slow observation, sudden intensity, long periods of waiting, then brutal moments of clarity. The structure IS the psychology.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Bai Miaoqing's entire meltdown at the reservoir because I genuinely think I screamed out loud reading that. Like—she's always been described as shy, timid, living in Chen Anran's shadow—and here she is UNLOADING absolutely everything. All those dark feelings she'd swallowed for years just Spilling Out In One Go. And the most tragic part? She's so convinced Chen Anran didn't care about her, but the whole thing flips when you realize the note was actually Chen Anran's way of telling her she was loved. But let's talk about An Ruxin for a second because this girl is quietly carrying so much. While Bai Miaoqing is losing it, An Ruxin's just... there. "an expressionless face, pale and clean"—and the narration specifically notes she could vanish in a crowd, yet Bai Miaoqing saw something everyone else missed. The fact that An Ruxin was looking at Bai Miaoqing during that entire outburst and feeling heartache instead of anger? That's some next-level emotional intelligence. She's solving a murder mystery while simultaneously holding space for her friend's trauma. Also the narrator drops this line about An Ruxin's unspoken feelings—her "obsessive passion"—and I am HERE for it. This woman loves in quiet, devastating ways. And Chen Anran—dead the whole time but absolutely present—she orchestrated the entire truth reveal from beyond the grave through that note. That's either the sweetest or most manipulative thing I've ever read. Probably both.
... Read More
I am still reeling. I am literally shaking. Let me just say it clearly: An Ruxin watched that video and then connected the dots, right? She saw Chen Anran's mannerisms on screen — the bouncing, the playful poses, the way she held the camera — and it mirrored EXACTLY the Bai Miaoqing she had fallen for in high school. That moment when she realized the ghost she had been seeing all along, the one who looked like Bai Miaoqing, was actually Chen Anran mimicking the girl she loved... I need to sit down. Because this means everything An Ruxin thought she knew was wrong. She wasn't falling for Bai Miaoqing's ghost. She was falling for Chen Anran's ghost who was dressed up as the person she wanted to see. And Bai Miaoqing knew. Of course she knew. She's been playing both of them this entire time. The plot structure here is so cleverly layered — you have the surface mystery of why Chen Anran died, the romantic mystery of who An Ruxin is actually in love with, and the deeper horror of what Bai Miaoqing did at that reservoir. All three threads converge in this chapter and I cannot breathe.
... Read More
I need to sit with this for a minute. Miaoqing's confession of her real wish is one of the most devastating character reveals I've read in a long time. On the surface, she's the devoted friend who loved Anran unconditionally. But read between the lines and it's something else entirely — she's jealous, insecure, and fundamentally envious. 'That would never change. She was better than me. Happier than me.' Those three sentences just recontextualize their entire friendship. And Anran? She genuinely cared about Miaoqing but clearly didn't understand the depth of what Miaoqing needed from her. The moment where Anran blushes and says 'I have a crush on someone' — she trusted Miaoqing with that. She thought her best friend would be happy for her. And Miaoqing's reaction? 'My brain couldn't process it.' What did she do with that information? The diary entries Miaoqing kept, the notes they passed — is that devotion or possession? When she screams 'I love you the most!' during the interrogation, is that genuine grief or the desperation of someone whose secret desire just got exposed? I keep going back to that line: 'She was my only friend.' Only. Not closest. Only.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or