Secret Crush (GL) - Reviews

Secret Crush (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I keep thinking about that note and what it represents on every level. On the surface it's a playful invitation to explore a haunted reservoir—a fifteen-year-old girl's idea of adventure. But the real message, buried character by character, is a confession of love. The contrast between the two layers is devastating. The number 5. The misplaced word 'joy.' The awkward line breaks. These aren't mistakes—they're a coded language. Chen Anran couldn't say it directly, so she hid it in plain sight. And Bai Miaoqing, despite being so close to her, somehow missed it entirely. Or maybe she understood on some level and refused to accept it. The book asks a painful question: how much of what we think we know about someone is actually just what we allow ourselves to believe? There's also the recurring theme of ritual and intention. Chen Anran wore a white dress—not for exploration, but because the day mattered to her. She changed clothes before coming to the reservoir, treating it with ceremony. Both girls recognized the significance without naming it. And the diary entry—'I'll tell her tomorrow, it's the same anyway'—suggests that even Chen Anran wasn't sure her feelings would be received the way she hoped, so she kept trying different ways to communicate it. The ghost, the note, the white dress, the reservoir—all of these symbols point to the same core idea: love that cannot be spoken aloud finds another way to survive.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this one moment that literally stopped me in my tracks. When An Ruxin sees Bai Miaoqing at the convenience store and Bai Miaoqing is the one who reacts with shock—her eyes widen like she's seen a ghost—and then immediately flinches "like a frightened animal" when An Ruxin says her name. Like. Wait. Back in high school, An Ruxin was literally invisible to her. She was the background character clapping from the audience while Bai Miaoqing was on stage. And now, years later, Bai Miaoqing is the one who recognizes her instantly but is clearly terrified? What does that mean? What happened after graduation? The text drops this line: "Could it be because of that incident after the college entrance exam…" and I am OBSESSED with this mystery. It completely reframes their entire dynamic. An Ruxin thought she was the one hiding, the one with the secret crush, the powerless one. But Bai Miaoqing's reaction suggests something way darker happened—something she's been running from. And that woman with the key? The childhood friend from the photo? Is she connected too? Because Bai Miaoqing's scream at the end isn't just fear—it sounds like pure panic. Like she's finally caught up with whatever she's been avoiding. I keep going back to that photo moment where Bai Miaoqing almost shows it to An Ruxin but scrambles to cover it up. What is she hiding? And why does she still have a key to her own apartment but the stylish woman walks in like she lives there? Something terrible happened between these three people and I need to know what.
... Read More
Every image in this chapter feels like it's been deliberately chosen to haunt you. Let me just pick apart a few of them because they're TOO dense to ignore. The photos under the sofa are the central symbol here — literally a stack of Bai Miaoqing's glory days, heads scraped off and crossed out in blood-red marker. Someone is systematically erasing her identity from her own past. But the ambiguity is what makes it so rich: is it Bai's own self-hatred projecting outward? Is it Chen Anran's ghost punishing the girl who survived? Or is it something even more disturbing — the idea that Bai Miaoqing's current self is so detached from who she was that she can't recognize herself? Then there's the faceless dream. An Ruxin imagines herself watching Bai in high school — a nostalgic, almost tender scene — except when Bai turns around, she has no face. A "blank sheet of flesh." What does that mean? That An Ruxin has been in love with an IDEA of Bai Miaoqing, not the real person? That the Bai she remembers no longer exists? Or that Bai Miaoqing herself has lost her identity so completely she's become a blank slate? And the photo burning — Bai holding the frame, pressing her thumb on Chen Anran's face before torching it. She's destroying the only physical evidence that these three girls were ever connected. The fire turning Chen Anran's "innocent smile" into "charred ash" mirrors how Bai has turned a living girl into a dead one in her story. She's not just hiding the truth — she's actively consuming it. The mirror she smashes in the motel room says it all: she can't even look at herself anymore. She's surrounded by symbols of erasure because she's erasing herself, piece by piece, and she doesn't know how to stop.
... Read More
"Do you… like me too?" An Ruxin's head was about to explode. This line. This absolutely devastating line from the original confession scene, and then its echo in the present—that's the emotional spine of the entire story. Let me take you back to that bathroom moment. Class 1's advanced classroom, empty except for An Ruxin sitting at Bai Miaoqing's desk, feeling like a pervert, and then—crying. She follows it. She always follows the sound of Bai Miaoqing's pain. And there she is, behind a stall door, red-eyed, trembling. What happens next is the most important scene in the book and nobody talks about it enough. An Ruxin doesn't run. She doesn't pretend she didn't see. She just... stays. And speaks. Stammers. Fumbles through this sentence that's equal parts awkward and devastatingly sincere. "I hope you'll be happy. And even if something makes you sad, it's okay to cry once in a while." She's giving Bai Miaoqing permission to be imperfect. To be human. And Bai Miaoqing's response? A soft, gentle smile. That smile becomes the touchstone An Ruxin clings to for three years. Every anonymous letter, every stolen moment at that desk, every watch from across the cafeteria—it's all fueled by that one instance of being seen by the person she loves. Then the confession on the track. "I like you. I've liked you for a long time." And Bai Miaoqing's reply, which we now know was spoken by Chen Anran in her voice: "I like you too." Joy. Pure, overwhelming joy. They hold hands. They walk laps. Two girls pretending the world won't tear them apart. And then the rejection. The words that shatter An Ruxin: "Because you're not good enough." The phrase that sounds like class prejudice, like social hierarchy, like everything wrong with high school cruelty. But it's not what it seems. The reveal that Bai Miaoqing actually meant it—genuinely, truly liked An Ruxin—turns the entire narrative into a love story about missed timing and stolen voices. Every cruel word Bai Miaoqing spoke was a lie. Every moment of rejection was someone else's doing. And An Ruxin still loves her anyway. That's the emotional core: love that persists through misunderstanding, through supernatural interference, through three years of silence. When Bai Miaoqing finally says "I still like you" in the hotel room, the reader is supposed to feel every single moment of pain that led to those words. The tears aren't just relief—they're grief for all the time lost. And An Ruxin's response? Not anger. Not blame. Just: "I'll fix it. I'll help you." Because of course she does. Because her love has never been conditional.
... Read More
I love how this author writes dialogue that isn't really dialogue at all. Like, the conversations between An Ruxin and Bai Miaoqing are basically a masterclass in what you DON'T say. Let me give you examples because this is chef's kiss level writing. An Ruxin: "Is your place far? We haven't seen each other in ages. Let me call a cab for you?" — trying so hard to be polite and helpful, completely avoiding the million questions burning in her head. Bai Miaoqing: "It's not far... I... walked here." — the hesitation, the trailing off, the admission that she can't even afford a cab ride home. That one ellipsis does SO much work. And then the whole scene at the apartment where Bai Miaoqing apologizes nonstop for spilling water. "I'm sorry, I'm so clumsy… did you get burned?" But she's not actually clumsy—she's panicked. She's trying to get An Ruxin to leave before whatever is coming finds her. The dialogue here is layered with subtext on top of subtext. But what really gets me is the internal monologue. An Ruxin narrating her own life like it's a documentary: "She spent an average four years there, failed her postgraduate entrance exam, found an average job, lived alone in a rented apartment, earned an average salary, and led an average life." This clinical, detached way of describing her own existence—it's heartbreaking because we KNOW she's lying to herself. She's not fine with being average. She just stopped hoping for anything else. And then there's Bai Miaoqing's voice when she's truly scared: "Help me! P-Please help me! Why is she here?! She shouldn't be… I already—" That fragmented, panicked speech is so different from her polished, effortless high school self. The author completely distinguishes their voices without any fancy techniques. Just... perfect characterization through rhythm and word choice.
... Read More
'The person I like is you.' Four words hidden in a piece of paper and I am absolutely destroyed. Let me just sit with this for a moment. Chen Anran, who was so perfect and popular and bright, who made everyone notice her—she went out of her way to hide a confession inside a note about a reservoir trip. And Bai Miaoqing, who spent years believing she meant nothing to her, who convinced herself she was irrelevant, who carried that self-hatred like armor—turns out she was wrong about everything. The worst part is Bai Miaoqing's reaction. She's not crying about missing out on romance. She's devastated because it proves Chen Anran DID care, and she still didn't know how to respond in time. That line—"I didn't think of a way to save you in time, I was too scared, I ran away"—is the kind of guilt that doesn't go away. She's been punishing herself for years over something that wasn't even her fault. And then there's An Ruxin, watching all of this unfold, loving Bai Miaoqing silently while helping her uncover the truth about someone else's love. The emotional layers here are insane. Every character is carrying unspoken feelings. Every relationship is built on things that were never said out loud. This book understands grief the way almost no other book does—the way it twists memory, the way you reconstruct the past through what you wish you'd known.
... Read More
Let me just lay this out plainly because the stakes have shifted SO dramatically. Before this chapter, An Ruxin's conflict was relatively simple: solve the mystery of Chen Anran's death and understand Bai Miaoqing's past. Now? Now her entire romantic identity is in question. The girl she's been pining for since high school — is her crush even real, or was it always directed at a ghost wearing someone else's face? And Bai Miaoqing's stakes are catastrophic. She's been caught in a web of her own making. She claimed Chen Anran was drowned by a ghost, but when pressed, she admits she never actually SAW the ghost — she only 'felt' it. Which means either she's lying about the supernatural explanation, or something truly inexplicable happened and she's been carrying that trauma alone for years. Either way, the reservoir is where the body isn't. Why? Where IS Chen Anran? And the most terrifying question of all: if Chen Anran's ghost is what An Ruxin has been seeing, and that ghost mimics Bai Miaoqing's appearance and mannerisms… then who, or what, is actually controlling this haunting? The author's note says 'no one is entirely good and everyone has their secrets.' I believe that now more than ever.
... Read More
There's a reason water appears everywhere in this story, and it's not accidental. Bai Miaoqing is crying in a bathroom—the most water-associated space in any building. When she washes her face afterward, the sound of running water echoes around her. Later, the rain on the hotel window isn't rain at all but "dark green and inky black" liquid, and Chen Anran presses her pale hand against the glass from the other side. The description turns the window into something translucent, a membrane between worlds. Chen Anran is described as looking like she's underwater—her dress like "the tail of a white fish," her hair floating "like seaweed." She's not just a ghost; she's something aquatic, something that drowns. Water here is both purification and drowning. Bai Miaoqing washes her face to hide her tears, to compose herself, to return to the surface. But the water outside the window is the opposite—it's pulling her under, trying to drown her in the past. Chen Anran is the flood that won't recede. And the window itself is such a rich symbol. It's a barrier that's also a surface for projection. Chen Anran presses her face against it, and An Ruxin mirrors her, pressing her nose to the glass. They're separated by something thin but impassable—just like Bai Miaoqing is separated from her own agency. The glass is the body, and the ghost is on the other side, watching, waiting, mouthing words. Then there's the desk. Bai Miaoqing's empty desk in the empty classroom. An Ruxin sits in it, touches the things left behind, smells the lingering shampoo. The desk is a relic, a shrine, a grave. It's the closest An Ruxin ever gets to possessing something belonging to the person she loves—and later, when we learn that Bai Miaoqing's body was possessed, the imagery loops back on itself. An Ruxin wanted to occupy Bai Miaoqing's space; Chen Anran literally occupied Bai Miaoqing's body. Both are forms of intimacy that cross into violation. The title "Secret Crush" works on multiple levels. It's about An Ruxin's hidden feelings, yes. But it's also about Bai Miaoqing's feelings—secret even from herself, buried under Chen Anran's influence. And finally, it's about Chen Anran herself, whose presence was the most secret crush of all: a childhood neighbor who loved Bai Miaoqing so violently she consumed her. The line that ties everything together: "She took everything from me." Chen Anran didn't just possess Bai Miaoqing—she erased her. And the only way Bai Miaoqing could reclaim herself was through self-destruction. The story is asking: what does it cost to become yourself when someone else has been living inside you? And what does it mean to love someone who spent years unable to speak their own truth?
... Read More
I have to be honest — I read the reservoir scene three times and each time it hit differently. The first read: cute girl hangout, spooky legend vibes. The second read: wait, Miaoqing is lying about her wish. The third read: OH MY GOD. The way the author builds this intimate, almost tender atmosphere between the two girls — Miaoqing noticing Anran's white dress with pockets, the sun blazing down, the quiet moment where neither speaks and Miaoqing feels relaxed for once because she doesn't have to perform — it's so gently painted and then the wish comes. 'I wish I could become someone like Chen Anran.' I literally sat there stunned. Because what Miaoqing is really saying is: I want to erase myself and replace her. And Anran, sweet clueless Anran, asks 'What did you wish for?' and Miaoqing lies and says 'just that we could be best friends forever' and Anran's face lights up. The guilt Miaoqing feels after — 'the guilt and shame surged even stronger' — she knows she's corrupting something pure but she can't stop. This is the emotional core of the entire novel compressed into one scene. And then Anran tells her she has a crush on someone. The timing. The sheer CRUELTY of it, even though Anran couldn't have known. Miaoqing probably wanted to die that day. Or maybe she wanted Anran to.
... Read More
I need to talk about An Ruxin because this character is so deliciously complicated. On one hand, she's a stalker. Like, full stop. She slips into empty classrooms during PE, sits at Bai Miaoqing's desk, touches her things, smells her imaginary shampoo, ransacks her bag. If you met this girl in real life, you'd call the police. And yet— And YET, when she finds Bai Miaoqing crying in the bathroom, what does she do? She stammers out this incredibly tender, awkward little speech: "You're the best girl I've ever met... it's not your fault... it's okay to cry once in a while. I won't tell anyone!" Like, who says that?? She's basically a stranger and she just weaponized kindness so perfectly. This is the thing that keeps me up at night: An Ruxin's love is both invasive and genuinely selfless. She wants to be close to Bai Miaoqing so badly she'll violate every boundary, but when it matters—when Bai Miaoqing is vulnerable—her instinct is protection, not possession. Even at her most obsessive, she's trying to make Bai Miaoqing happy. And Bai Miaoqing? Her relationship with An Ruxin is its own tragedy. She genuinely liked her—maybe loved her—but was trapped in a body that wasn't fully hers. Can you imagine? Someone you care about confesses to you, and you have to reject them because the thing living inside you doesn't want them to know the truth. Then you have to actively destroy your own life to get rid of it. The moment that broke me was when Bai Miaoqing says, "Until yesterday, when I saw you again... Because I still like you. That's why she came back." She never stopped. Not for three years. Not through college. Not through dropping out and isolating herself. An Ruxin is the anchor, and Chen Anran is the current trying to pull her under. Also—their dynamic shift in the hotel room when Bai Miaoqing is crying and An Ruxin just holds her hand and says "I'll fix it"? That's not the same girl who used to sneak into classrooms. That's someone who's been carrying this love for years and finally found a way to use it.
... Read More
I want to talk about how the author uses dialogue — or rather, the ABSENCE of it — to make you squirm. Bai Miaoqing's first lines in this chapter are almost comically unhinged: "She's already dead! She died when she was fifteen!" She's practically vibrating with panic, grip ing An Ruxin like a lifeline, insisting she's not joking. And yet — she just invented a death certificate for a living human being. The gap between how terrified she sounds and what she's actually doing is the entire mystery. Then there's An Ruxin, who barely says anything that isn't reassuring or deflecting. "Don't be scared," "It's okay now," "Maybe it was just a hallucination." She's performing the role of the competent friend while her internal monologue is completely falling apart. The author does this thing where An Ruxin's narration becomes increasingly fragmented — "I-I...", "...Are you joking?" — mimicking someone trying to maintain normalcy while everything cracks. But Bai's private moment at the motel is where the voice work really shines. Alone, she's not stuttering or performing. She's muttering to herself: "Don't look. Don't look anymore..." and later, "When I accidentally spilled the hot water earlier, Ruxin might've seen the photo... But I hid it afterward. It should be fine..." These aren't spoken to anyone. They're the raw thoughts of someone who has been so thoroughly haunted that she's talking to ghosts in a hotel room. And that final repetition — "Chen Anran. Bai Miaoqing... Chen Anran... Chen Anran..." — reads like a incantation or a prayer from someone who doesn't know whether she's praying to God or to the memory of whoever Chen Anran became.
... Read More
"No one—not even her parents—had ever looked her in the eye and said, 'I believe in you.'" I just. I need a moment. This line absolutely wrecked me. Because think about it—An Ruxin's entire life has been defined by being average, invisible, forgotten. Her parents didn't believe in her enough to push her. She didn't even believe in herself. And then Bai Miaoqing, this radiant girl who could do no wrong, who had everyone's admiration, looked at THIS girl—the one sitting in the back, the one nobody notices—and said: "You have such a lovely singing voice." And later: "I believe you can do it. You have to believe in yourself too—or at least believe in me." That is the most devastating kind of kindness. Because it wasn't pity. Bai Miaoqing genuinely saw her. For one brief moment on that stage, under those lights, An Ruxin felt real. She felt seen. And then... nothing. They never became close after that. The crush continued in secret, quiet and aching, while Bai Miaoqing moved on like everyone else did. Now, years later, An Ruxin runs into the girl she spent three years silently loving, and Bai Miaoqing is a shadow of herself—greasy hair, wrinkled clothes, living in chaos. And her first instinct isn't to reconnect, it's to politely send her away. "Old classmate... let's keep in touch?" said with this pitiful, broken smile. But then she screams. Something comes into that apartment and Bai Miaoqing completely loses it. And An Ruxin—despite her own fears, despite wanting nothing more than to escape this painful encounter—she runs BACK. She bangs on the door. She turns the handle. She's still here. That's not just nostalgia. That's love that never died, even when the object of it became unrecognizable. God, I'm emotional just thinking about it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or