Secret Crush (GL) - Reviews

Secret Crush (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is masterclass-level restraint followed by an explosive release. Let me break down why it works so well. It starts with Ruxin and Miaoqing talking — calm, almost casual conversation about a diary. The tension builds SO slowly. Ruxin drops one logical observation at a time, each one a tiny crack in Miaoqing's story. She doesn't accuse, she doesn't raise her voice — she just... lays out facts. And Miaoqing's responses get progressively more fragmented. The first mention of the ghost is almost dismissive. Then 'I already told you!!' — the first crack. Then the full-blown breakdown with the screaming and the hair brushing against Ruxin's face. The structural pivot point is when Miaoqing finally agrees to tell the full story. From interrogation to confession to flashback — the narrative shifts gears and suddenly we're in that bright reservoir scene, which feels almost idyllic compared to what we just witnessed. Then the wish, the crush confession, and the chapter ends on the biggest dramatic question of the whole book. The author trusts the reader to sit with discomfort and doesn't rush to explain anything. That last line about Miaoqing's possible intentions? Absolutely brutal.
... Read More
This book opens with one of the most beautiful metaphors I've ever read and I need to unpack it because it sets up the entire theme. An Ruxin is described as "like seeing a glass of plain water" and in memory she's "like an ink painting smudged by water—blurry, indistinct, impossible to clearly picture." Water as erasure. Water as something that makes things disappear instead of reveal them. She's been invisible her whole life, not because she's ugly, but because she blends into everything. She's the filler person, the background character. But Bai Miaoqing is the opposite. She's stage lights. She's the New Year's performance. She's described with sunlight and models and radiant energy. And here's the thing—the stage is where their worlds briefly collided. When An Ruxin looks at Bai Miaoqing's profile during the curtain call and everything else fades away... that's the only time An Ruxin stops being water and becomes something solid. Something real. Now look at what happens to both of them. The girl who was always seen—Bai Miaoqing—has become a ghost. Greasy hair, sunken eyes, living in squalor. And the invisible girl—An Ruxin—is the one who sees her. Who recognizes her. Who runs toward the scream. I think the book is asking: who is really invisible? Who is really seen? Bai Miaoqing had everything—talent, beauty, popularity—and she still collapsed. An Ruxin had nothing by comparison and she's still standing, still caring, still running back to the door even when she's terrified. The metaphor inverts itself. Water doesn't just erase—water also reflects. And sometimes the thing that seems plain and clear is the one that shows you the truth. That photo of two little girls? Bai Miaoqing scrambling to hide it? I think that's the symbol of everything she's running from. A childhood connection she can't explain, can't show, can't face. And now that connection has returned in the form of a woman with a key.
... Read More
There's something deeply atmospheric about how this author uses the abandoned reservoir as a setting. It's not just a backdrop—it actively shapes the emotional temperature of every scene that takes place there. Think about it: the reservoir is where everything happens. Where Chen Anran died. Where Bai Miaoqing finally screams out all her repressed emotions. Where An Ruxin pieces together the truth. The book describes it as "dead-silent" even after Bai Miaoqing's entire breakdown—her voice echoing around it, chest tearing open with words, and the water just... stays still. Deep green surface, unmoving. After she finishes screaming, the silence doesn't break. The reservoir doesn't react. It just absorbs everything. And then there's the vision of Chen Anran appearing behind Bai Miaoqing—body soaking wet, face pale as porcelain, water dripping from her fingers, arms looking carved from ice or wax, her dress stained with filthy green smudges. The image is haunting in the best way. It reads like a film frame frozen in time. The narrator says it felt like "a spiderweb snaring An Ruxin's heart"—and honestly that's the most accurate description of horror I've read in a while. Not jump-scare horror, but the kind that gets under your skin and won't leave. The reservoir has this innate power to make people spill their secrets. Whether it's the ghost or just the weight of the place, every truth in this story comes out near that water.
... Read More
Okay so the twist when Bai Miaoqing reveals she actually DID like An Ruxin but Chen Anran hijacked her body? That hit me like a truck. The whole middle-school-to-college timeline just reframes everything we thought we knew. Let me rewind. When An Ruxin confesses before the exam, it reads as this tender, hopeful moment—two girls holding hands on the track, promising to go to the same city. Then BAM, the post-exam scene: Bai Miaoqing delivering that devastating line, "Because you're not good enough." We, the readers, were right there with An Ruxin, crushed and confused. And now we learn it wasn't even her words, it was Chen Anran wearing her voice. But here's what really messed with my head—the reveal about Chen Anran. She's not just some random ghost, she's Bai Miaoqing's childhood neighbor who literally possessed her. And the mechanism? Bai Miaoqing had to intentionally deteriorate, become a mess again, to make Chen Anran leave. That's... that's some dark coping mechanism turned supernatural survival tactic. And then the cherry on top: Chen Anran came back the moment Bai Miaoqing started getting better and reconnecting with An Ruxin. So the antagonist isn't just some external force—she's tied to Bai Miaoqing's own history of self-sabotage. The plot doesn't just have a twist, it has layers. Every re-read changes how you see Bai Miaoqing's withdrawal, her dropping out, her isolation. Also, the detail that An Ruxin already knew Chen Anran's address because she used to snoop through Bai Miaoqing's stuff? That's such a perfect character-consistent move. Of course An Ruxin would use her creepy obsession skills for something actually productive. I love how the narrative rewards attention to detail.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about how this whole ghost storyline is basically a house of cards and An Ruxin is systematically pulling each card out. The whole narrative structure here is genius because we're reading Bai Miaoqing's version of events — a girl who supposedly witnessed a ghost push Chen Anran into a reservoir — and then An Ruxin, of all people, becomes the cold, analytical debunker. Remember how earlier An Ruxin was the one losing her mind over ghosts and Chen Anran possessing her? Now she's the voice of reason? That reversal is everything. But here's what really got me — the way the author plants the doubt. Bai Miaoqing has this newspaper clipping, right? Proof. Or at least, evidence she believes in. And An Ruxin's counter-arguments are all just possibilities — water weeds, cramps, tangled debris. Nobody has proof either way. The author deliberately leaves this in that uncanny valley where both interpretations are equally plausible, which is honestly more terrifying than any ghost story could be. Because if there's no ghost, then what Bai Miaoqing did is infinitely worse. The structure also plays with perspective shifts — we get Bai Miaoqing's account, then An Ruxin's analysis, then An Ruxin's own dream sequence at the end where Chen Anran's ghost appears and says "My death wasn't caused by a ghost. It was Bai Miaoqing." Which... is that the truth? Is it Chen Anran's actual spirit speaking, or is it just An Ruxin's subconscious finally accepting the possibility? The ambiguity is intentional and it haunts you.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... what the actual hell did I just read. The way this plot slowly peels itself open is genuinely terrifying. We start with what seems like a ghost story — Bai Miaoqing screams, they see this woman, and Bai immediately drops the bombshell that Chen Anran died at fifteen. Boom. Mystery established. But then An Ruxin goes home and digs deeper, and THAT'S when the real horror kicks in. She finds out Chen Anran was NEVER confirmed dead. The news said 'missing,' not 'deceased.' Bai Miaoqing just... made it up. Confidently. In front of a witness. And it hit me like a freight train. Bai Miaoqing isn't just scared of a ghost — she's lying about a dead girl because this girl is ALIVE and she's terrified of what happens if someone finds out. What did she do to Chen Anran? What happened between the three of them at fifteen? The subplot of the defaced photos is brilliant too. Someone scraped off the heads and crossed them out in red marker. On Bai's own photos, hidden under her own sofa. An Ruxin immediately tries to protect her friend by convincing herself Bai didn't do it, but the logic falls apart so cleanly. If someone was threatening Bai, why hide the photos where only Bai could find them? Why not just throw them away? Because she can't bear to look at her own past? That's so much worse than external bullying, honestly. And that ending — Bai burning the group photo while whispering "I'm so jealous"... jealousy of a DEAD girl? Or a girl everyone thinks is dead? The layers here are insane.
... Read More
I need to just sit with this for a second because the relationship dynamics between these three characters are absolutely devastating. Bai Miaoqing pushed Chen Anran into a reservoir because she couldn't handle the fact that Chen Anran had someone she liked — someone who wasn't Bai Miaoqing. That is such a specific, ugly, human moment of weakness. And then she spent years telling herself a ghost did it because the alternative was unbearable. And An Ruxin — oh god, An Ruxin. She's been oscillating between loving Chen Anran and loving Bai Miaoqing this whole time, and she finally admits to herself: "She was, without a doubt, a lunatic driven entirely by love." The fact that she can analyze her own madness so clinically and still can't escape it? Chilling. The most powerful moment for me was when An Ruxin thinks about who she actually loves. Is it Chen Anran, the perfect shining girl? Is it Bai Miaoqing, the broken one who confessed and was rejected? Or is it some impossible composite of both — Chen Anran's brilliance, Bai Miaoqing's vulnerability, the way they intersected in her life? She can't separate them anymore, and honestly, neither can we as readers. The text says: "Did the girl she loved even truly exist?" That question destroys everything. And Bai Miaoqing's relationship with Chen Anran — the original sin, if you will — is so tragically pathetic. She wanted to BE Chen Anran, not just be with her. Her wish was so distorted by envy and self-loathing that even the resolution (Chen Anran possessed her) is a kind of twisted fulfillment. They're stuck together forever now, whether they want to be or not.
... Read More
Bai Miaoqing's inner monologue before pushing Chen Anran is one of the most honest portrayals of toxic friendship I've ever read. Like, she actually writes out the math: "As long as she's still my friend, it's all okay." But then Chen Anran talks about this boy — this knight, this prince — and suddenly the equation changes. Suddenly staying friends means watching the person you love most fall in love with someone else. And Bai Miaoqing's thought process is so brutally logical in its illogic: "Saving her = being left alone. Not saving her = being left alone. Whether she dies or not... the result is the same." This is the moment the reader realizes this isn't a ghost story at all. This is a story about a terrified, insecure girl who made the worst decision of her life in a single second, and then spent years building an entire mythology to cover it up. The tragedy isn't supernatural — it's human. And then An Ruxin's emotional journey through all of this is equally devastating. She goes from being the obsessed fan, the girl who nearly tore Bai Miaoqing apart when she learned the truth about possession, to someone so numb she can calmly analyze murder theories. But the ending — that dream sequence where Chen Anran floats in dark green water and says "You've missed me all this time, haven't you?" — that's the raw emotion breaking through the analysis. An Ruxin can intellectualize everything except what she actually feels, and that's what makes her vulnerable. The CP energy between An Ruxin and Bai Miaoqing is so complicated too. Bai Miaoqing confessed to someone she thought was Chen Anran. An Ruxin rejected that someone thinking it was Chen Anran. Neither of them realized they'd been talking to each other the whole time. That dramatic irony is heartbreaking.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how brilliantly An Ruxin dismantles Bai Miaoqing's lies layer by layer? It starts with the diary — which is such a perfect narrative device because it gives us both a physical clue AND a reason for Miaoqing to be lying. The timing discrepancy Miaoqing creates is actually brilliant misdirection. She claims the diary entry was written the day BEFORE Anran disappeared and the reservoir trip was supposed to happen the day AFTER. But then Ruxin casually writes out 'What Actually Happened' and boom — you can see the whole fabrication fall apart in one glance. The genius is that the reader pieces it together alongside Ruxin rather than being told outright. And then the big twist: Miaoqing finally admits she made a wish at the reservoir AND that Anran had a crush on someone. That changes EVERYTHING about how we read the preceding chapters. Was Anran suicidal or was she going to confess her feelings? The plot has been quietly preparing us for this reversal the whole time and I literally gasped when Miaoqing said 'I wish I could become someone like Chen Anran.' A wish that sounds innocent but is actually monstrous in hindsight.
... Read More
Okay. Let's talk about Bai Miaoqing's POV section because WOW. Just WOW. She lies there on that hotel bed after confessing to An Ruxin and the author just peels back every single layer of her psychology. She became someone like Chen Anran on purpose — improved her grades, learned to dress up, made friends — all while feeling like her real self was trapped inside, invisible to everyone including her own parents. "Did they only like the way I looked now? Was the real Bai Miaoqing still trapped inside, unchanged, unseen?" THIS. This line absolutely destroyed me. And then An Ruxin found her crying in that bathroom stall and showed her gentleness for the first time — that became Bai Miaoqing's lifeline, her reason to keep pretending to be Chen Anran. But then An Ruxin confessed FIRST. Her true self shouted "I like you too" and then everything was taken away. That's the curse of Chen Anran. That ending note — "That was the happiest moment of her entire high school life. But right after that moment of joy, everything was taken away. That was the curse of Chen Anran." I am not okay. The guilt, the manipulation, the genuine love — it's all tangled together and I don't know who to pity more.
... Read More
'Remember what you promised me? We're going to bring joy to that haunted reservoir! It's going to be a fun day ☆ Let's meet behind the school, at the back mountain. We agreed — no adults allowed. You better come!' I need to talk about this note. Just this one note. Written by Chen Anran to Bai Miaoqing on what was probably the last day of her life. The little star emoji. The excitement. The trust. 'No adults allowed' — she wasn't going to the reservoir to die, she was going on an adventure with her best friend. And below it, the doodle of a crying face and 'So annoying, I forgot to give this note to Bai Miaoqing. Whatever, I'll just talk to her when we meet later…' AND THEN SHE NEVER MET HER LATER. That period before the colon — it hangs there like a knife. Meanwhile, Bai Miaoqing's dialogue throughout this section is so fractured, so desperate. 'Ruxin, what's wrong…? Your tone sounds so strange…' vs. 'I felt it — I really felt it! I didn't describe it because I knew you wouldn't understand, and you'd never believe me!!' She goes from trembling uncertainty to raw explosive defense in one line. And An Ruxin's voice — that clinical, almost detached 'Tell me again — how did Chen Anran die?' followed by the sudden shout — it perfectly captures someone whose entire worldview is collapsing in real time.
... Read More
The stakes in this passage hit different because they operate on three levels simultaneously, and the author layers them so carefully. On the surface, it's a ghost story — did a vengeful spirit kill Chen Anran? But peel that back and it's a mystery — what actually happened at the reservoir that day? And underneath everything, it's a psychological thriller about two girls whose lives were destroyed by something neither of them fully understands. The external conflict is straightforward: Bai Miaoqing knows what she did (or thinks she did), and now she's trapped between confessing and maintaining her delusion. An Ruxin is caught between believing her and protecting her. But the real tension — the thing that keeps you turning pages — is the internal conflict. Every time An Ruxin presents a rational explanation, she's simultaneously trying to convince herself. She asks: "Did she have any definitive proof that ghosts didn't exist?" No. And that uncertainty is the entire story. What makes this so tense is that the author never lets us forget the human cost. Chen Anran is dead. Her body was never found — possibly tangled in weeds, possibly sunk to the bottom. Her family waited years for closure that never came. And Bai Miaoqing ran. She ran because she was scared, and then she convinced herself a ghost made her run, which is honestly the most human response possible. The final image — Chen Anran floating like a water lily, saying her death was Bai Miaoqing's fault, not a ghost's — raises the stakes to maximum. If this is true, then Bai Miaoqing is a murderer who's been lying to herself for years. If it's false, then An Ruxin is just hearing voices. Either way, the conflict is unresolved, and that's what makes it so gripping. The story doesn't give us comfort — it gives us questions that haunt.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or