Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien) - Reviews

Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so Lars shows up RIGHT as she's about to hang herself, interrupts her, catches her—classic rescue—and then the very next thing out of his mouth is basically accusing her of poisoning his father. The tonal whiplash is incredible. One second he's the hero dropping from the ceiling of her despair, the next he's the prosecutor lifting her chin like she's a curiosity at a fair. But here's what's actually brilliant about the plot structure: Lars immediately DISPUTES the obvious theory. Everyone thinks she killed Baron Bickman because he tried to assault her. Lars says no, completely wrong. Not because he's defending her moral character, but because she's NOT his father's type. She's too young, underdeveloped. What an insufferable way to clear her name, honestly—"you're innocent because you're not attractive enough for my dad"—but it opens up the real mystery. If the baron wasn't trying to assault her, then WHY was she at the scene? WHY does she know about aponin grass? And why is Peterson so desperate to close this case and make her the scapegoat? The text cuts off but you can feel the gears turning—Lars is onto something, and he's not done investigating. Also the baron being dead before she even arrived at his house changes EVERYTHING. She's framed for a murder she didn't commit, and the real killer is still out there. That's a solid midpoint reversal that completely reframes what we thought we knew.
... Read More
The pebble. She picks up a pebble from the corner of her cell and it triggers this entire spiral of thought about writing, about Mrs. Vino, about heaven. The mundane object becomes a portal. She decides to write a note about closing Mrs. Vino's window—not a confession, not a plea for help, but a household instruction. The most Lucienne thing possible: even facing death, she's worried about someone catching a cold. "How many diapers have I changed for her?" That line destroyed me. Mrs. Vino threw feces at her as punishment, and her response is calculating the value of her service like a worker negotiating fair wages. The absurdity of measuring human worth in diaper changes is the story's entire thesis in one sentence. And then the heaven fantasy. Walking with the priest in sunlight, wearing a dress only noble ladies would wear, smiling for the first time. She imagines paradise as a place where she's seen as beautiful, where green eyes that were cold to her are soft. Where warmth comes from someone who isn't Peterson. The priest represents something specific here—he saw her name, Lucienne, and treated her as a person. In a world that reduces her to 'the maid' and 'the witch' and 'the worm,' that single act of recognition is revolutionary. Her wish to join him in heaven isn't religious; it's a desire to be remembered by someone who actually knew her. And the window. The open window in Mrs. Vino's room. Small neglect leading to death. The same way small cruelties—a pat on the shoulder from Peterson, a dismissive comment from a noble—add up to a life that feels unworthy of continuation. The story keeps showing us how systemic violence works: not through dramatic executions but through open windows and untreated colds and mended skirts used as rope.
... Read More
I need to unpack the relationship between the protagonist and the Priest because it is SO COMPLICATED and I have thoughts. First—Mark. She goes out with MARK. She sneaks out of Mrs. Vino's room to meet Mark. Mark knows about the underground theater. Mark has a friend who can get them in. Mark spreads out a handkerchief for them to sit on. He's shy. He's flush-faced. He keeps stealing glances at her during the performance. He seems like a normal boy her age who has a crush on her and wants to show her his world. And his world IS dangerous. The basement theater is overwhelming—"a mix of acrid, strong tobacco and the musty scent of rotting fruit." Half the people are "out of their minds." Nudity, violence, alcohol, chaos. She's clearly uncomfortable but she stays because she doesn't want to disappoint him. Then she needs air, she wanders off, and everything falls apart. But here's what I keep circling back to: she blames the Priest. "Actually, I ended up like this because of you, Father." Not Mark. The Priest. Why? What did the Priest do? This implies a history—a history I don't fully understand yet but can feel the weight of. The Priest isn't just a random savior. He's connected to her life in a way that makes her responsible suffering HIS FAULT somehow. Now let's talk about the Priest himself. The physical description when he removes his hood is almost reverent: "Beautiful green jewels sparkled. I could vaguely see his deeply set eyes and high bridge of the nose." He's described in terms of beauty that borders on terrifying. She explicitly compares him to mythological gods—specifically Parki, the bringer of chaos. And yet he SAVED her. He fought off those men. He covered her with a curtain, dragged her to safety, and then appeared on the dark path to prevent her from doing something irreversible. "Perhaps if something were to eat me, at least that beast would be happy." She was about to walk into the dark and die. Or invite death. And he was there. How did he know? Did he follow her? Did he watch? The fact that he was already there suggests he's been tracking her somehow. "I was just taking a walk when I discovered a little lamb entering a secluded path." A LITTLE LAMB. He sees her as vulnerable, yes—but also as something worth finding. Worth saving. And when she asks him to walk with her, he complains but agrees: "If I send you alone, you might end up crying and getting lost again." He's being gruff. But he's also acknowledging that she's FALLING APART. She's not just physically shaken—she's emotionally unraveling. And he's the only person walking beside her. The spatial relationship here is so telling. He walks "half a step ahead of me." He's leading but not too far. Protecting but not touching. Present but distant. "Not only did I lack confidence in getting home safely alone, but I was also glad and grateful that he had followed me, and I wanted to talk a bit more." She WANTS to talk to him. After everything—the assault, the rescue, the nearly suicidal walk—her instinct is to stay near THIS MAN. Not because he's warm. Not because he's kind. But because he's THE ONE who showed up. And that final line, spoken with such weighted honesty: "Actually, I ended up like this because of you, Father." Is she blaming him? Is she accusing him? Or is she saying—without being able to say it directly—that HE is the reason she's alive right now? That without him, she'd be dead? That his presence in her life is simultaneously the source of her suffering and her salvation? I think it's all of those things at once. And that's what makes this relationship so intoxicating to read.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the narrative voice in this passage? Because it is NOVEL. The protagonist's internal monologue has this incredible quality where she's simultaneously naive and brutally perceptive. She describes the theater audience with this wide-eyed wonder—"Ladies in elegant western dresses and gentlemen with stylishly groomed mustaches"—and then three paragraphs later she's philosophizing about whether life is worth living. And the shift isn't jarring. It's earned. The voice survives trauma and comes out the other side QUITE DIFFERENT. Let me highlight some lines that just stuck in my brain: "I couldn't do anything of my own will. I was no different from a weed on the street. Meaningless to anyone, whether I lived or died, no one would care." That's not angst. That's not teenage melodrama. That's a person who has genuinely confronted their own expendability in a hostile world. And then—here's the voice doing its thing—she doesn't stay there. She picks up a piece of wood. She decides to STAB someone if they come near her again. The pivot from "I'm nothing" to "I have nothing to lose" is devastating and empowering simultaneously. "Because I have nothing." Three words. That's it. The entire philosophy of the character distilled into three words. And then compare that to the Priest's dialogue. It's so distinctly different—short, clipped, almost bored: "Quite spirited. Though your strength is pathetic." "There's no path that way, little miss. Where were you trying to go?" "It's not the time for a child to be wandering alone." "Then what's on your cheeks, snot?" He never once says something nice. Never offers comfort. But that final exchange is where the voice work is actually brilliant: "Um, I know you're busy, but could you accompany me home? I'm asking like this." She's NOT asking like this. She's barely able to ask at all. And he responds: "Alright. If I send you alone, you might end up crying and getting lost again." He's being dismissive while simultaneously agreeing. He's insulting her while protecting her. And she accepts it without question because after everything tonight, having someone walk behind her is better than facing the dark alone. The contrast between her voice—fluid, emotional, spiraling into philosophical territory—and his voice—minimal, dry, almost comedic in its bluntness—creates this incredible dynamic. Every line he speaks feels like it's hiding something enormous. And her opening accusation at the end: "Actually, I ended up like this because of you, Father." This is said with such raw honesty. Not Manipulated. Not poetic. Just straight, bleeding truth. Whatever this man did, whatever his role is in her life, she connects every bad thing that happened tonight to HIM. I love this voice. It doesn't pretend to be refined. It's messy and honest and sometimes it picks up sticks and swings them at shadows.
... Read More
Every conflict in this book is stacked impossibly high and the protagonist meets each one with the same strategy: endure, calculate, survive. But what's fascinating is watching the stakes escalate and realizing that the protagonist is not the same person they were in Chapter 1. The external conflicts are relentless. Mom sells them. Dad dies violently. Mrs. Vino tortures them daily. Marie sexually assaults them at the washing place. Senar's fate reveals the full depth of the exploitation economy this world operates in. And the protagonist does nothing about any of it—not because they're weak, but because they're smart. They know that acting out gets you hurt. So they wait. But the internal conflict is where this book lives. The protagonist has been taught that the world is dark, that no one will save them, that even monks can't help. And yet—they're still here. Still observing. Still planning. The monologue about getting the ten peder back isn't just revenge fantasy; it's proof that somewhere under all that survival calculus, there's a sense of justice that hasn't been extinguished. 'That money should be mine.' This is the thesis statement. Not 'I want revenge.' Not 'I want to escape.' But 'that money was stolen from me and I intend to collect.' The stakes are existential—every chapter makes it clear that death is always one wrong move away. But the deeper stakes are psychological: will the protagonist stay cold and calculating, or will something break them open? The Senar scene seems to be that breaking point. Seeing someone else suffer exactly as they feared suffering, and being unable to intervene—that's the conflict that changes everything. I am so ready for this character to stop running.
... Read More
The dialogue in this passage is razor-sharp, and what I love most is how it reveals character without either person actually saying who they are. Lars speaks in statements that land like verdicts: 'God cannot save you. Only you can move for yourself.' That line — it's not compassion, not exactly. It's almost cruel. But it's also the truest thing he says to her. He's not offering comfort; he's offering a mirror. And the narrative voice around it does something brilliant: it describes his voice as 'languid, carrying a soft air and clear in pronunciation, automatically draws one's attention.' The prose itself tells us this is a man who knows his effect on people. Lucienne's voice, on the other hand, is all impulse. She blurts things. 'Is it okay to come if I kill someone?' That's not a genuine question — it's a provocation, a way of testing whether this man has any lines he won't cross. And his reaction — running his hand through his hair, letting out a hollow laugh — tells us everything about how unusual she is to him. Most people don't talk to priests like that. The humor is dark and earned. 'Watch your mouth. If the administrators heard you, they'd arrest you for treason right away.' Coming from a man whose cloak probably costs more than her entire neighborhood, this line works because it's genuinely funny AND it reveals the political danger surrounding him. Every joke carries weight. And the prose narration itself has a voice — one that shifts between Lucienne's restless, observant interiority and moments of almost poetic compression: 'The wordless gaze was burdensome, yet strangely, it made my heart flutter and feel good.' That's not filtered through any character's direct thought; it's the narrator slipping in, and it makes the intimate moments land even harder.
... Read More
Peterson. What a absolutely vile human being. "Your life is like a worm's anyway, there's nothing fun to look forward to even if you live longer, right?" He says this with a smile. A TEACHER'S smile. Like he's praising a student for getting the right answer on a math test. The banality of his cruelty is what makes it so stomach-churning. And then Lars shows up and Peterson's instantly subservient, bowing his head, stammering excuses. The power dynamic is so visible it hurts. This man terrorizes a child because she has no protection, and the moment someone with a bull emblem appears, he's shrinking into himself. But Lars himself—what IS he? He saved Lucienne. That part is genuine. Yanken even says so implicitly, worrying about whether Lars will actually help her. But Lars's methods are infuriating. He lifts her chin, calls her cute, makes assumptions about her victimhood based on his father's preferences. He's protective in the way a collector is protective of a rare bird—curious, possessive, but not truly seeing her. And then there's Yanken, who clearly has feelings for Lars. "Why are you being so sensitive? Like a jealous mistress." The teasing is surface-level, but the underlying current is real. Yanken's primary goal is always protecting Lars, even against his own wishes. That's devotion bordering on self-erasure, and it's quietly heartbreaking. Meanwhile Lucienne is just trying to survive. She thinks about her mother, about Laurel, about the priest. She writes a note about closing Mrs. Vino's window because someone might catch a cold and die. Even facing execution, her last coherent thoughts are about other people's comfort. That's not weakness—that's the kind of strength the story hasn't even started to reward yet.
... Read More
'If that's what you think, you'll always be empty-handed. Finding that is also your job to do.' This line is the thesis of the entire passage, and I keep coming back to it. It's about agency, sure, but it's also about something darker — the idea that the world gives you nothing and expects you to build something from nothing, and that this burden falls disproportionately on those already at the bottom. The cloak is such a loaded symbol. It first appears as something that covers Lucienne at the theater — warmth, protection, something borrowed from a stranger. Then she notices the blood on Lars's knuckles on that same cloak. Protection and violence are the same fabric. That's not accidental writing. The heavy cloak that barely moves in the wind — it suggests a man carrying weight that has nothing to do with weather. Authority, responsibility, sin, power. All of it draping over him. And the temple. The place where God is supposed to be accessible, where prayers are supposed to work — it's also the place where Lucienne can't find Lars. She circles it 'dozens of times.' The sacred space is indifferent to her search. Meanwhile, the theater — profane, chaotic, dangerous — is where grace actually appears. That inversion runs through everything here. The monk in the square is a joke; the priest who beat a man at a brothel is the one who actually sees her. 'Losing faith' in God versus 'losing faith' in the institution — the text never collapses these two things, and that's what makes it honest. Lucienne's crisis isn't abstract. It's about a drunk man's hands on her body and a priest watching from a distance.
... Read More
What's fascinating is the contrast between his public persona and private moments. On the surface he's this flamboyant, confident noble who cracks jokes about preferring to sleep with women because "there aren't many handsome men like me around." But then we see him genuinely shaken after the confrontation - breathing heavily, rubbing his chest, asking Lucy to hold his hand because he has "little courage" for this kind of thing. The vulnerability he shows afterward is so humanizing. He's not some cold, calculating mastermind. He's a guy who stepped up because it was the right thing to do, even if it terrifies him. And the way he ruffles Lucy's hair, calls her cute names, treats her like a person instead of a suspect? That's not manipulation. That's genuine care disguised as playfulness.
... Read More
The entire scene is built around small, devastating details. Lucy talking to the dead woman like she's still alive - "Ma'am, I'm sorry I'm late, okay?" The image of dried saliva marks around her mouth. The way Lucy fiddles with the blanket for no reason because she doesn't know what else to do with her hands. And then the internal monologue where she realizes Mrs. Vino was the only person who never complained, never beat her, never threw things - just growled and silently accepted her touch. That's not love in the traditional sense, but it's something real. Something profound. "If I had died earlier, we would have met." My heart. My actual heart. And then she whispers goodbye to people who are already gone - her father, siblings - asking them to say hello to Mrs. Vino. The loneliness of that moment is suffocating. She lost the only person who made her feel like she belonged somewhere.
... Read More
I need to talk about this Priest character because WOW. The way the author describes him after he removes his hood is absolutely loaded with religious and mythological symbolism. "His jet-black hair was slightly disheveled but didn't look rough. His sharp, slanting eyes gave off a cool impression while simultaneously emitting a light so intense it was unforgettable once seen." Wait. A PRIEST who emits LIGHT? That's not exactly orthodox imagery, is it? And then she compares him directly to mythology: "The harmony of his straight nose bridge and firmly closed lips resembled the male gods in the mythology book Laurel had given me." But then she makes this crucial distinction: "Although he reminded me more of 'Parki,' who was said to bring chaos and despair, rather than the benevolent 'Gier' who bestowed kindness." So she's literally saying this priest figure resembles a GOD OF CHAOS. Not a god of mercy. Not a god of protection. A deity of disorder and despair. But here's the thing that got me—and I kept coming back to this—the imagery of DARKNESS and LIGHT runs through the entire passage like a nervous system: - She sneaks out into the NIGHT, moonlit paths - The theater basement is lit by TORCHES, creating a hellish glow - She's COVERED by a thick dark CURTAIN when rescued - The Priest appears wrapped in a BLACK CLOAK "like a shadow" - His eyes are described in terms of light: "emitting a light so intense" - The moonlight finally touches his face when he removes his hood - The forest path shifts from "endless despair" to something else colored by his presence The Priest is literally a being of light who operates in darkness. He's associated with chaos (Parki) but he SAVED her. He's cold and detached, yet she feels safer walking behind him than she has all night. "If you can see which flowers attract bees, you can also see the opposite reason." This line he says to her—I think it's profound. It's almost philosophical. Meaning: if you understand why something draws people in, you should also understand what drives them away. The Priest sees both sides. He understands attraction AND repulsion, salvation AND damnation. He's not a benevolent deity—he's a COMPLETE one. And her final realization that she "ended up like this because of you, Father"—is this blaming him? Or is it acknowledging that her entire journey toward understanding this dark, complex world is guided by someone who IS chaos incarnate? Maybe the real theme here isn't good vs. evil. Maybe it's about finding salvation in unexpected, terrifying places. The Priest doesn't comfort her. He doesn't offer warm words. He calls her snot-cheeks and walks ahead half a step. But the path changes color just from his presence. That's the theology of this novel: salvation isn't warm. It's cold. It's chaotic. It walks ahead of you and makes you follow.
... Read More
'A devil can be recognized from afar by its malice. The stinging smell of sulfur is a sign that it has come from hell.' I keep coming back to this description because the author doesn't just build a world—they build an atmosphere that you can physically smell. The opening chapter alone has moss wedged in stone floors, the strong stench of urine, plump rats you could kick, a stable where children sleep on straw, and a mother having sex with the employer while her kid grills slightly-spoiled fish behind a wall. And then the washing place. God, the washing place. The hierarchy of the stream—upstream for the older women with louder voices, downstream for the child who washes diapers. The wet hand slaps, the laughter, Marie's hand on the protagonist's chest. You can feel the cold water, the summer heat, the rough bark of the laundry paddle. The author writes physical sensation the way some writers write dialogue—like it's the primary mode of communication. There's also this incredibly vivid scene with Mrs. Vino's deathbed. The protagonist places their hand on her nose each morning to check if she's alive. Her breath 'smells of decaying corpses.' Her skin is so dried up the bones are 'struggling to break through.' This isn't gothic horror for atmosphere—it's the protagonist's Tuesday routine. The mundane horror of it is what makes it stick. And the contrast with the storage room where the protagonist sleeps—potatoes, onions, carrots piled in sacks, the 'mellow odor of rotting crops.' At least there's no horse dung. At least there's no neighing. Small mercies in a world that has given them nothing large. The world feels alive because every scene has smell, texture, and temperature. You don't just read about poverty—you breathe it. And that's why the few moments of beauty hit so hard: the breeze cooling sweat on skin, the taste of stolen lemon, the single piece of candy for tracing letters ten times. In a world this harsh, those micro-moments are the only luxury available.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or