Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien) - Reviews

Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
But what I really love about this section is how the author structures the reveal. It's not just "oh look, a loose end." It's layered. First we get the Mrs. Almon detail, then the crooked writing on the floor that turns out to be a suicide note attempt, and THEN the punchline where Kirhin basically says "you pass" and takes her in. The pacing here is brilliant - it reads like a series of escalating revelations that keep you leaning forward. And the subtext? Oh, the subtext is delicious. Why did Kirhin care enough to intervene? Was he genuinely concerned about justice, or was there something else going on? The fact that the narrative doesn't immediately answer this is what makes me want to keep reading.
... Read More
I started reading this thinking it was going to be heavy dark academia stuff and then BOOM we're making potato soup like nothing happened. That tonal whiplash is actually genius because it mirrors how the narrator survives—she can't stay in one emotional state for too long or she'll drown. The chapter moves from the whip scene (which is brutal) to laundry hanging in the sun (which is devastating in its normalcy) to Mrs. Vino's declining body (which is horrifying) to the marketplace where a boy winks at her (which is almost funny). And then she Runs to the temple to escape him, Falls Into the Confessional, Has The Most Unconventional Conversation Of Her Life, Comes Out, Goes Home, Cooks Dinner, Looks In The Mirror. That is a LOT of ground covered and yet it never feels rushed. The transitions are seamless—the house silence connects to the marketplace noise connects to the temple quiet connects back to the kitchen heat. And the ending? She catches her own reflection and remembers HIS eyes. Not her own face, not her own beauty—his eyes. That's a pivot that reorients the entire narrative in one sentence. The pacing here is doing something very sophisticated: it's showing us that her world hasn't changed, but her INTERNAL landscape has shifted irreversibly.
... Read More
Okay so Lars's whole plan to blackmail Bickman into breaking trade ties with Freemont was honestly so elegant. Like, here's this guy who's supposedly obsessed with women but has somehow kept his family wealthy through gift exchanges, and Lars figures out exactly how to use that against him. But then—of COURSE—Balshwin catches wind of it and kills the baron first. Ugh, I hate when protagonists get ahead of themselves like that but also... Lars isn't even fully in the room yet and people are already reacting to his moves? That tells you something massive about his reputation. Meanwhile he's just lying there recovering, giving orders like a ghost general. The timing of everything is just... chef's kiss. He sends Yanken to handle the fallout, Kirhin steps up to take the title, and Lucy gets dragged into the middle of all of it. By chapter 19 he finally shows up in the doorway wearing HIS OWN CLOAK that Lucy had been washing. I literally screamed. The man walked into the lion's den wearing evidence, completely unbothered, while Lucy's heart skips. This plot is layered like an onion and I'm here for it.
... Read More
I am still not over the opening image of this passage. Senar getting whipped and the narrator watching from a shadow, and the revelation that Mr. Vernon INSTRUCTED them not to draw the curtains. Let me just sit with that for a second. This isn't a household—it's a spectacle. The fact that the narrator's first reaction isn't horror but resentment toward Senar being watched, and then later seeing Senar flaunting her status and only thinking about those RED WHIP MARKS on her white skin? That's the kind of detail that makes you realize this world operates on a completely different moral axis. And Mrs. Vino's room—the STENCH hitting you before you even open the door, the dried saliva, the rhythmic rough breathing like a small animal about to die. The narrator wipes her face with a wet handkerchief and worries about whether the trembling means she's about to defecate. This is domestic hell painted in such matter-of-fact prose that it hits harder than any dramatic description could. Then you cut to the marketplace with fruit sellers and milk vendors and suddenly the world feels ALIVE in a way that contrasts with the suffocating house. The temple itself—quiet, surprisingly clean, that incense-and-wood scent—feels like a different dimension entirely. Every location in this book has weight. You can smell them.
... Read More
I need to talk about the monk scene because it completely redefined how I see every relationship in this book. The protagonist grabs a monk and asks what to do about a devil. The monk laughs, strokes his beard, and says 'A devil is not something that throws poop at you. It's something that dirties your soul.' Then he touches their shoulder, makes the sign of the cross, and basically leaves. That's it. That whole interaction summarizes the entire world. Everyone in this book offers a different flavor of abandonment. Mom sells them. Dad gets himself killed. The monk offers a blessing that changes nothing. Laurel tries to help but it's patronizing—teaching them to read for candy like they're a charity project. Even the other laundry women, despite their cruel jokes, exist in a hierarchy where the protagonist is always at the bottom. But the relationship with Mrs. Vino is the most complicated one, and not in the way you'd expect. It's not about fear. It's about watching something die and measuring your own survival against its decay. 'Sometimes, doing this would remind me of how she used to stick out her tongue and throw things at me. I don't mean I miss it.' This is a person who has so normalized abuse that the absence of it feels like something worth noting but not welcoming. Then there's Laurel, who keeps calling her 'little one' and giving her books she can barely read. The protagonist knows exactly what Laurel is doing—she needs someone to listen without interrupting. And yet she still shows up. Still brings candy. Still defends her from Marie at the stream. Is it genuine kindness or just another transaction? The book won't tell you, and that's the point. The most chilling relationship dynamic is between Mom and Mr. Jose. Mom calls him 'honey'—the same word she uses for Dad. Dad hears it and dies for it. But Mr. Jose covers the funeral costs. The system doesn't punish this. The system absorbs it and moves on. The protagonist understands this instinctively. They don't rage against it. They file it away.
... Read More
What strikes me most is how the setting reflects emotional states. The prison passage is described as "long and dark" - Lucy's internal fear made physical. The candlelight flickering in the dead woman's house creates shadows that look like dancing ghosts. And then the Bickman home, with its soft carpets and warm lighting, represents safety and luxury that Lucy has never experienced. The carriage ride itself is a transitional space - Lucy can't close her eyes because she's terrified of waking up back in that cell. Every environment serves the emotional narrative. The world feels tangible, lived-in, and deeply atmospheric. I can practically smell that house.
... Read More
Okay, so I need to talk about this scene in the confessional booth because it is THE scene. The way the protagonist just... falls into that wooden box like she's falling into something deeper than religion? Chef's kiss. And this man—this clearly NOT-normal priest with green jewel-like eyes and this languid, almost mocking voice—he doesn't treat her like some poor corrupted girl. He actually LISTENS. When she says she had bad thoughts about running away, his response is basically: cool, now imagine killing them instead. THAT is a character who knows exactly what kind of world she lives in. Meanwhile Mark from the market is all sunshine and wink-wink offers, but there's something slightly off about how confidently he follows her to the temple. Like he thinks he's being smooth but she's playing a completely different game. And then the mirror moment at the end? Staring at her own reflection and thinking about HIS eyes? That's not crush energy, that's survival energy wearing a pretty disguise. She's not attracted to him, she's attracted to the fact that he saw her when no one else does.
... Read More
Let's talk about the pacing here because the author is a MENACE. Chapter 20 opens with political maneuvering—sister scheme, inheritance drama, Lars being terrifying—and by the end of it you've somehow gotten both a heartwarming moment (pebble nickname, "I'll be your doting big brother") AND a looming threat (the succession procedure hint). That's not accidental. That's the author deliberately keeping you off balance, and it's working. The scene transitions are especially smooth. You go from Kirhin and Damian's tense exchange → to Lars analyzing Lucy's appearance like a commodities trader → to the medicine scene where class dynamics are laid bare → to Nina's quiet rebellion → to Lars's glass-shattering lesson → to Kirhin rushing back with jewelry. Eight distinct beats in one chapter and NONE of them drag. What really sells the pacing is how the author controls information. We learn about the late baron's gambling addiction, the poisoning theory, the golden bull artifact, the succession procedure, and Nina's true power level—all woven naturally into dialogue and observation rather than exposition dumps. By the time Chapter 21 opens with the rumor spreading through the world, you're already invested in whether it'll work. The chapter 20 ending—"We don't have time" followed by them heading to the study—should be a cliffhanger. It functions as one. But it's the quieter moments that ha
... Read More
This book keeps coming back to one devastating idea: in this world, your body is either your prison or your passport, and there is very little difference between the two. Senar gets whipped publicly and then struts around fanned by maids—the whip marks are both her shame and her proof that she survived something that would have destroyed other women. The narrator compares washing shitty diapers to crawling like a dog while getting your ass beaten and chooses the diarrhea. That is not a trivial comparison, that is a philosophy. And the gray lace scarf she borrows from Mrs. Vino's wardrobe—she wraps it around her head to hide her face from the marketplace gaze, and it's hot and completely useless but she wears it anyway. It's armor. Temporary, inadequate armor, but armor nonetheless. Then the mirror scene at the end where she sees her own reflection and notices her silver hair, her gray eyes, and then thinks of the priest's green eyes like jewels? She's starting to see herself as an object of sight—but on her own terms, not Mr. Vernon's. The recurring imagery of eyes throughout this passage—green jewel eyes, men's hungry gazes, her own gray mournful eyes—creates this whole visual economy where who looks at whom and how becomes the central transaction of power.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the Lars and Yanken dynamic because it's honestly one of the most interesting things in this whole book. These two have been together nearly ten years, and you can feel the weight of that history in every exchange. Yanken walks in and delivers the most explosive news—baron murdered—and Lars's first instinct isn't shock or grief, it's calculation. Trade routes, guilds, political alliances. His mind is already three moves ahead. But then Yanken drops the bomb that Lucienne has been arrested, and suddenly Lars's composure cracks. That moment where the narrative describes a crack forming on his forehead? That's not just stress. That's fear. Real, unfiltered fear for someone he barely knows. And then Yanken pushes him, goes too far by suggesting they silence Lucienne before she talks about the priest. Lars's response—cold, immediate, absolute: We're not butchers—reveals something about him that changes how I see everything. He could let Lucienne take the fall. He could disappear into the night and protect his deal. Instead he chooses to intervene, and he does it while making a joke about buying firewood like he's going on a casual errand rather than storming a prison. Their relationship is the kind where one person knows exactly when the other has crossed a line, and Yanken backs off not because he's scared, but because he respects the call. That's loyalty. That's family.
... Read More
That cloak. I can't stop thinking about that cloak. It appears in three key moments and each time it means something different. First, Lars drapes it over Lucy while she sleeps—protection, warmth, an act of mercy from someone she doesn't understand. Second, she wakes and hugs it to her chest, inhaling the faint fragrance, holding onto something tangible from a night that felt like a dream. Third, she washes it carefully, noticing how clean it is compared to her own clothes, and hangs it to dry while everyone whispers. And then at the end, Lars appears wearing what seems to be the same cloak—or a nearly identical one. Is it the same one? If so, he took it back. If not, he's mirroring her act of care. The cloak becomes this symbol of everything between them: what's given, what's taken, what's returned, what's hidden. Just like Lucy herself—she's been stripped of her identity (former servant, now suspect, now... something else in this mansion), and the dress she wears belongs to her dead master's dead lover. Nobody in this story gets to wear their own clothes. We're all performing, hiding behind layers, waiting for someone to see past the fabric.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened in these chapters because my chest is actually hurting. Let me walk through the emotional arc because it's brutal: She sneaks out. She's nervous but excited. The energy is youthful curiosity—she's been told about this theater, Mark invited her, and she's experiencing a whole new world. The descriptions of the theater crowd are almost WONDERFUL in their observation. She notices everything: the carriages, the elegant ladies, the banter between couples. There's a sense of discovery here, of stepping into something bigger than her small life. Then the basement. The heat. The smell. The performance that makes her physically uncomfortable—"a tingling sensation all over my body"—and she can't breathe. She leaves. She's seeking air, and instead finds hell. The assault scene is written in this fever-dream pace. One moment she's walking through corridors, the next a man's hand is on her waist, his rotten breath in her face, bills being offered like she's an object. "If it's your first time, I'll add another 20 lebls." The dehumanization is so casual it makes my skin crawl. And the man with the cigarette who doesn't even look twice—"casually ignoring my scream" The scream goes nowhere. It literally dissolves into the noise of the theater. No one hears. No one comes. And then—the curtain falls. Darkness. Violence above her. Being dragged. Emerging to find a stranger pointing a weapon at her. And then THE WALK HOME. This is where the emotional devastation really hits. She's alive but she's not okay. She's running, stumbling, gasping clean air like it's oxygen after drowning. And then the tears come—not just from fear but from the sheer accumulation of humiliation, powerlessness, and grief. "Fear, sorrow, bewilderment, and humiliation swirled within me like a whirlpool." And then the darkest moment: she realizes this won't be the last time. "Such incidents would happen frequently from now on." The trauma isn't a single event—it's a pattern she's now trapped inside. The world hasn't changed, but SHE has. She knows now what she's worth to the men in this city: twenty lebls, maybe seventy if she's pretty enough. "Why do people have to live? There's nothing good about living." I had to stop reading here. This isn't romanticized sadness—this is genuine despair from someone who has zero safety net. No family mentioned. No friends who would come searching. Just a girl on a dark path thinking about walking into the woods to be eaten by a beast. "Perhaps if something were to eat me, at least that beast would be happy." And then—the Priest appears. And the emotional shift is so subtle but so powerful. She grips a piece of wood like a weapon. She's willing to kill. She's willing to die. And then she looks up and sees THIS FACE—a face she recognizes, that she connects to something deeper than tonight's trauma. "Did you forget the way home?" The familiarity in his voice. The term "little miss." The moonlight touching his face. And something in her UN clamps. Not because he's gentle—but because he's FAMILIAR. Because despite everything, this man is known to her in a way no one else is. "Not only did I lack confidence in getting home safely alone, but I was also glad and grateful that he had followed me, and I wanted to talk a bit more." After wanting to DIE, she now wants to TALK to him. After feeling like nothing mattered, she finds that his presence changed the color of the entire forest path. "However, with just the presence of the person walking half a step ahead of me, the forest path was changing its color. At least I didn't feel like throwing myself to make a wild animal happy anymore." Changing COLOR. Not brightness. Not hope. COLOR. The path isn't better—it's DIFFERENT. And that difference is enough to keep her walking. And then the final line, dripping with emotional complexity: "Actually, I ended up like this because of you, Father." Blame? Gratitude? Accusation? Confession? All of it. She's telling him that her suffering has a source—and that source is him. But she's also walking behind him. Still talking. Still reaching out. This relationship is so deeply tangled and I am HERE for it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or