Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien) - Reviews

Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, I need to process what just happened because this chapter sequence goes from zero to absolutely chaotic in what feels like five seconds flat. Lucienne is just walking through the marketplace, tired from searching for something she can't name, and then BAM—Mark bumps into her, they have a genuinely sweet and awkward little exchange where she reveals her temple hobby and he immediately pivots to being interested in it. It's almost nice. And then soldiers appear. Not just any soldiers, but a short, petulant guard captain named Peterson who accuses her of murdering Baron Bickman. The timing of this arrest is suspiciously convenient, and if you've been paying attention to the parallel storyline with Lars, you know exactly why. Lars is negotiating some kind of secret trade deal, and the baron was his middleman. Someone killed the baron to sabotage or accelerate those negotiations, and Lucienne is the perfect patsy—she's nobody important, she works with herbs, and she has zero protection in this city. The real horror here isn't just that she's been framed. It's that the people framing her are watching her every move and already one step ahead. Peterson has a family badge from the baron found in her drawer. That doesn't happen by accident. This is a setup so thorough it makes my skin crawl.
... Read More
I have SO many thoughts about Kirhin. On the surface he's everything you'd expect from a young baron—extravagant shirt with billowing cuffs, yawning at the breakfast table, demanding sweet desserts, casually deciding which of his father's lovers to invite to the funeral like it's a game. But then he says something that genuinely surprised me: 'Deciding which of Father's lovers to invite and which to ignore. That will determine how peaceful Father's funeral will be.' That's not the words of a fool. That's someone who understands social dynamics in a way that's razor-sharp. He recognizes Lucy is cunning when she proposes a deal—'Honestly. I didn't know you were this cunning.' And yet he's also vulnerable. His brother's body and mind are not sound, he's never dealt with succession politics, and here he is playing baron while everyone watches. The moment with Lucy where he lifts her chin and his blue eyes go cold—that's power play. But then he sighs and taps his foot at her bruise and you see something else entirely. He's performing confidence but he's out of his depth, and Lucy knows it. Their dynamic is this weird dance where she's the survivor and he's the heir, both faking it, both needing each other.
... Read More
There's something haunting about the way this story moves from one space to another, and I want to talk about how the settings themselves tell part of the story. It starts in a marketplace at sunset, which immediately gives you that golden-hour warmth, the bustle of daily life, the sense that the world is still turning normally. Mark's awkward charm, the temple walk recommendation—it all feels like a slice of ordinary life. Then the soldiers appear and the world tilts. The transition is brutal and deliberate. By the time we reach the prison, the sensory shift is overwhelming. Stone walls closing in. Flickering torch shadows. The smell of earth and oil mixed with something faintly fishy that makes your stomach turn. Somewhere distant, someone is screaming. This isn't just a building; it's an organism that feeds on fear. And yet, somewhere between these two extremes, there's a whole city that exists in the margins—the herb shops, the temple grounds where Lucienne finds peace, the cheap inns where men like Lars conduct business that determines whether people live or die. The world feels lived-in because it's divided into spaces of power and spaces of survival, and Lucienne has just been dragged from one into the other without warning. The temple scenes always felt like breathing room. The prison feels like drowning.
... Read More
The pacing in these first seven chapters is absolutely ruthless and I mean that as the highest compliment. Let me walk you through it because the structure is doing something really clever. Chapter 1: Birth to age eight in rapid fire. Siblings die or disappear. Dad is introduced as a gambler who comes home drunk. Mom has affairs. Dad dies in a violent argument. By the end of this chapter, the protagonist is somehow already being sold. Eight years of trauma compressed into pages that feel like they take twenty minutes to read. Chapter 2: The sell happens. Then we get the most brutal time skip I've ever read. Seven years pass. Not a single word about the protagonist's daily life during those years. Just: 'Time flew by. By the time I was greeting my sixth summer in that house, the demon had lost its power.' Six years of surviving Mrs. Vino, reduced to one sentence. And then—immediately—we're at the washing place with a seventeen-year-old protagonist who has learned to calculate, to hide, to pretend. This is where the pacing shifts from rapid-fire to deliberate. The author slows down for the laundry scenes, for the conversation with Laurel, for Marie's assault. Each moment is stretched out, sensory, uncomfortable. And then—Chapter 3—the Senar reveal hits like a freight train. You thought you were reading a slow burn about survival? No. The protagonist has been watching someone else live the life they were sold into, and that person is being whipped. The chapter breaks are sharp. No soft transitions. No 'meanwhile.' The narrative throws you from one reality to the next without warning, which mirrors exactly how the protagonist experiences their life. There is no breathing room because there was never any breathing room. And the cliffhanger? 'I immediately turned my head and ran when I saw...' Cut to black. I need to know what happens next. I need to know what the protagonist does with this knowledge.
... Read More
Lucy's dialogue shifts from formal and stuttering under pressure to raw and stream-of-consciousness when speaking to Mrs. Vino. The contrast between "No. I've never even met him" (polite, measured, defensive) and the fragmented monologue she has over the dead body reveals her true emotional landscape. The author uses speech rhythm to show psychological state, and it's remarkably effective.
... Read More
That prison cell scene. I read it twice because my brain refused to process it at first. The image of her climbing onto that chair, making a loop from her own torn skirt, and reaching up toward those candle rings in the wall—God. It's so specific and so mundane. She's not some tragic heroine in a gothic tower; she's a maid in a drafty cell with dirt floors, and she's trying to tie a noose with fabric she herself had mended before. The detail about the mended skirt hit me like a truck. She saved that patch, held onto it, and now it becomes the instrument of her escape—or her end. And then the floor feels softer than expected. That moment when she falls and realizes the ground isn't bone-breaking because someone caught her? The sensory shift from cold stone to warm hands, from despair to confusion—it's cinematic without being flashy. The author doesn't need grand descriptions; the body knows what's happening before the mind does. Then Lars appears and everything changes. Red hair, navy velvet, a mole under his eye, silver scarf around his neck. He's dressed like someone who has never worked a day in his life, and that's exactly what makes him dangerous. The bull emblem badge on his chest—family crest, authority, ownership. He calls her cute while her face is probably a mess of tears and dirt, and he says it like he's commenting on the weather. That casual cruelty wrapped in genuine warmth is terrifying. "Embracing a beauty is always a pleasure, but this beauty is a bit young." What kind of person walks into a suicide attempt and makes THAT comment? And yet, he saved her. The contradiction is the point.
... Read More
What strikes me most about this section is how the plot refuses to give us easy answers at every turn. The inciting incident — the encounter at the theater — doesn't just happen once; it echoes. First we see Lucienne trapped by a drunk man, then we get Lars's cold, almost dismissive response, and only in Chapter 8 do we learn from his side that he was the one who intervened. That structural choice to withhold the truth from the reader is bold. It creates this delicious dramatic irony where we sit with Lucienne's frustration — her feeling abandoned by God and the church — while we, the readers, already know the priest was there working behind the scenes. That gap between what the character knows and what we know is where the real tension lives. Then there's the subplot thread about Freemont and the Viscount, dropped almost casually into Lars and Yanken's conversation. These two words carry so much weight. They hint at a larger political conspiracy that Lucienne isn't even aware of yet, but she's standing in it anyway. The author is planting seeds — the spy theory, the suspicion about whether Lucienne heard too much, the quiet decision to follow her home. Every action is doubled with unseen consequence. The plot isn't just moving forward; it's spiraling outward. And the ending of Chapter 9 — circling the temple dozens of times, unable to find him — is such a perfect structural button. After everything, after the vulnerability and the running away and the name reveal, she just can't catch him. It's satisfyingly unsatisfying. The plot keeps pulling away from her, which means the reader keeps wanting more.
... Read More
I've been thinking about this book all day and the symbol that won't leave me is the candy. A single piece of candy for tracing letters ten times. That's the entire education system in this world—a child learning to read not for knowledge or power or freedom, but for a sugary reward that probably costs less than one of Mrs. Vino's diapers. And the protagonist is smart enough to deliberately take their time learning, because if they finish too fast, the candy stops coming. Learning to read as a transaction. Knowledge as currency. This is the thesis of the entire book in miniature. Then there's the devil metaphor, which operates on at least three levels. Literally: the monks speak of devils with sulfur and dark faces. Practically: Mrs. Vino is a devil because she makes life unbearable. Philosophically: the monk says 'a devil dirties your soul,' and the protagonist immediately rejects this because their soul isn't the problem—their body is. 'Washing my only set of clothes every day was inconvenient and tiring.' The spiritual is irrelevant when you're dealing with the physical. This is a person who has been force-fed theology and found it wanting. Water appears everywhere. The stream where laundry happens. The protagonist slipping their skirt into the water. Marie grabbing them by the stream. Water is both cleanliness and danger, both routine and violation. And the diapers—Mrs. Vino's diapers, washed by a child who is themselves barely out of childhood. The cyclical nature of care and degradation, passed down like inheritance. The most powerful symbol though is probably the apple. Senar has an apple in her mouth while being whipped. A fruit of pleasure and innocence, consumed by someone who has lost both. The protagonist watches this and runs. They don't intervene. They don't scream. They run. And that running is the most honest response the book offers to injustice.
... Read More
Okay so Kirhin's plan to pass Lucy off as his illegitimate half-sister is honestly one of those moves where you're like wait that could actually work, but also it's SO delicate it's making me sweat. The whole setup hinges on the rumor mill. You've got Nora Almon already painted as the poisoner in the public eye, and Kirhin basically flips the script: no, the baron wasn't visiting that house for scandalous reasons, he was visiting his DAUGHTER. That's a narrative reversal that's either incredibly clever or incredibly dangerous depending on whether anyone actually buys it. And honestly? The fact that they need to dig up antiques with the golden bull engraving to prove it means this whole scheme is held together with hope and family lore, which is both thrilling and terrifying. But the real plot twist here is Lars showing up. Who IS this guy? A baron bows to him. A baron bows. And he's casually teaching Lucy how to manipulate people by shattering a water glass as a demonstration. The stakes layering is insane—Kirhin is trying to secure his inheritance, Lucy is trying to survive, and Lars is just... watching from somewhere above both of them like a chess player who hasn't even revealed which pieces he's moving yet. I need to know what happens when Nina decides she's had enough. That woman literally dropped a medicine bottle on purpose as a test. She's not going to fold forever.
... Read More
Damian Winton. Say his name and feel the room temperature drop. 'That grotesque dress' was the funniest opening line I've read in months. But then he says something real underneath it and I'm NOT OKAY. This guy's whole energy is 'I will verbally destroy you but also I noticed you were cold and now you have my cloak.' He corrects Kirhin, he calls out Lucy's naivety about noble customs, he makes snide comments about her appearance—and yet he's the one who stays. He doesn't leave when the conversation gets uncomfortable. He sits there, sipping tea, observing EVERYTHING with those green eyes, and when Lucy says 'yes Master' to Kirhin, he FROWNS. Like the title itself offends him. And Kirhin's dynamic with him is just *chef's kiss*. The way Kirhin deliberately provokes him—calling Damian by his title for the first time, the bright eye-smile when he sees the reaction. These two have history. Deep, messy, unspoken history. Damian's threat about watching your mouth wasn't directed at Lucy, was it? It was a warning about the game they're all playing. Also Kirhin calling Lucy 'our little pebble' made me physically melt. The man is a chaotic gremlin but he means well, I can tell. He actually looked at her neck wound and asked for medicine instead of just talking about political strategy. That's... that's someone who's going to survive this.
... Read More
But what elevates this beyond standard suspense is the personal stake of Mrs. Vino's death. It's not just about escaping punishment anymore - it's about surviving the emotional aftermath of losing the only family she had. The question hanging over the entire narrative is no longer just "who killed the baron?" but "can Lucy survive in a world that wants her dead?" And the final reveal about Nina, the head maid whose reputation for haughtiness was rumored, hints at new conflicts brewing within the Bickman household itself. The stakes keep expanding, layer upon layer, and I'm completely invested.
... Read More
Kirhin's voice is SO distinct I can pick him out of a lineup. The man talks in a completely different register than everyone else—he's playful, irreverent, and somehow both flippant and sharp at the same time. 'I think it's a decent story' after proposing to fabricate a half-sister relationship? That's Kirhin in one sentence. The casual cruelty mixed with genuine warmth. When he says 'Call me big brother' after winking at Lucy, it's equal parts manipulation and affection, and you can't tell which one's winning. But Damian's dialogue hits different. Every line from him is weighted. 'I told you to watch your mouth, little one' — five words that contain an entire power dynamic. 'Not everyone is as soft as Kirhin, you know' — that's not just a warning to Lucy, that's Damian telling her he sees something in her that Kirhin's nonsense might not protect. Lars doesn't say much but when he does, the prose leans into it. 'Start by practicing doing nothing. Think of using the people around you as your hands and feet.' That's not dialogue, that's a philosophy lesson disguised as advice. And the narration around his lines always slows down, as if the narrative itself is paying closer attention. The contrast between Kirhin's rapid-fire banter and Lars's measured minimalism creates this rhythm that's honestly cinematic. You can hear their voices. I caught myself audio-playing these exchanges in my head and it was weirdly effective.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or