Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien) - Reviews

Praising You For Surviving (Salute for Lucien)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The relationship between Lucienne and Lars is built on the most fascinating power imbalance I've read in a while. He holds every card — he's a priest, he's physically capable, he's clearly connected to something dangerous, and she's seventeen, poor, powerless, and walking home trembling. And yet, the scene where she grabs his cloak hem and buries her face in it? That's not submission. That's her reaching for the only anchor she has. And then she notices the blood on his knuckles and realizes he fought for her. The shift in that moment — from fear to something warmer, something like protection recognized — is quietly devastating. But what really gets me is how they push against each other. She calls him out: 'What kind of priest are you?' She challenges his theology, his indifference, his entire worldview. And instead of shutting her down, he laughs. That laugh — 'pfft' — is the first crack in his armor. He's clearly not used to being spoken to like that by someone beneath him. Her defiance isn't annoying him; it's surprising him, maybe even impressing him. And then there's the name. She makes him say it: 'My name is Lucienne!' And in Chapter 8, we get his POV — 'Lars didn't think she was a spy.' But he follows her anyway. He says 'hoping never to see her again,' and I completely disbelieve him. The way he traces her house with his eyes, the way he murmurs her name like it's something pretty — this is someone already caught, even if he won't admit it yet. The tension isn't romantic in the cheap sense. It's the tension of two people who see each other clearly for the first time, both of them pretending they don't care.
... Read More
The Bickman mansion is described in this way that feels almost like a character itself. When Lucy first wakes up, the sunlight pouring onto her face is almost shocking—she's never slept until it got this bright, never had warmth instead of two layers of old blankets. But the house isn't gentle just because it's sunny. Nina enters with that 'impeccably neat attire and expression' and you can tell immediately she disapproves of Lucy in every possible way. The dining room scene is perfection—the long table, Kirhin yawning at the head like a spoiled king, the butler Brook whose expression 'seemed unable to laugh or cry.' And then Lucy, who's never encountered nobles before Kirhin, awkwardly bending her knees. The contrast between her world and this one is so sharp you can feel it. The laundry area as a separate annex where maids stay, the whispers and gazes following her, the fact that she's wearing her dead master's former lover's dress because 'there are no women in this house'—every detail builds this world that's beautiful on the surface but suffocating underneath. The manor is magnificent and it's a cage.
... Read More
I need to talk about pacing because what the author does across these chapters is genuinely masterful and kind of terrifying. Chapter 27 starts slow, almost gentle. Lucienne is tired, she's walking, she meets Mark, they have a warm human moment. The reader settles in. Then soldiers arrive and everything shatters. Chapter 28 pulls back to Lars's POV and we get the political puzzle laid out—baron dead, deal at risk, mysterious guild players. It's exposition, but it never feels like exposition because it's delivered through urgency and dread. Then we drop into the prison interrogation and the pace becomes suffocating. Peterson circles her like a shark. Each question is a trap. Each answer is twisted against her. And by the time he pulls out that knife, your heart is hammering. What I love most is how the author controls the rhythm of revelation. We learn about Lucienne's alibi in pieces—not all at once, but gradually, the way trauma fragments memory. She doesn't remember the priest's face. She doesn't remember the people on the road. She only knows she wasn't alone, and saying that out loud in front of Peterson might get an innocent person killed too. The cliffhanger ending—Peterson threatening to peel her layer by layer—left me absolutely breathless. I needed to turn the page immediately.
... Read More
I need to just talk about the voice in this book because it is DISTINCT and I would recognize it anywhere. The narrator's inner monologue reads like someone who has learned to observe before speaking, and every sentence is filtered through that survival instinct. When she says 'I don't want to catch men's eyes' after being told her body is developing into something marketable, that's not innocence—that's exhaustion. And the priest's dialogue? Absolutely delicious. 'You don't seem like much of a priest.' 'Ha. Daring to insult a priest inside a temple, you're quite fearless.' This man is clearly not a priest, or if he is, he's the worst one ever conceived, and the narrator KNOWS it but plays along anyway. Their exchange has this razor wire underneath every line. And Mark—he talks like a guy who's practiced being charming and it shows. 'I, Mark Deluger, don't talk to ugly girls. It's obvious.' Dude, you just met her. The narrative voice itself is what sells this though. It's restrained, dry, occasionally sardonic, and it never explains things the way exposition-heavy books do. It trusts the reader. 'The protagonist of social advancement. A way to live comfortably in this world.' That's her summarizing what other women see for her, and the SNORT that follows tells you everything about where she stands.
... Read More
"There's no way my father would have had ill intentions towards this child. She's completely far from my father's taste. Too young, underdeveloped." I NEED to talk about this line. Lars delivers it with the casual confidence of someone who has never once considered that his words might destroy a person. He's trying to HELP her and he's doing it by essentially saying she's not good enough to be assaulted. The incompetence of his empathy is almost comedic if the situation weren't so devastating. And Peterson's voice throughout is just... slime. "Your life is like a worm's anyway"—said with warmth, like affection. The way he pats her shoulder afterwards like a job well done. He genuinely believes he's helping her by breaking her. There's no theatrical villainy here, just institutional cruelty that has never questioned itself. Jason's dialogue is fascinating though. He's a comic relief character who's also deeply uncomfortable. The whole "she came on Tuesday because she remembered liking something new we tried" moment—oh my god. He's giving information away like he's chatting about the weather, and the absurdity of describing sexual positions to investigators while they're trying to solve a murder is both hilarious and horrifying. The author uses humor as a pressure valve without ever letting the reader forget what's actually happening. "I'll pass on the demonstration." Lars says this so dryly. You can almost hear the eyebrow raise. The contrast between Jason's sweating, hunching, awkward body language and Lars's cool detachment defines their entire relationship dynamic in three lines. And Lars's final line in this excerpt—"I'm sorry, but I have to say that hypothesis is wrong. Completely wrong." The apology is fake. The conviction is real. He's about to dismant the entire case and nobody knows it yet.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the inciting incident because this book does not mess around. The protagonist wakes up one day and realizes their own mother sold them for ten peder. Ten. Peder. For a human child. And then instead of just spiraling into trauma (which would be completely understandable), they have this absolutely unhinged thought: 'Shouldn't that ten peder be mine?' I literally laughed out loud. That is such a specific flavor of broken resilience. The money could buy real pork roast and nice clothes. This is a child who has already watched six siblings die or disappear and is calculating ROI on their own exploitation. The plot moves with this brutal efficiency. Chapter 1 ends with Dad dead—bonked on the head with a rake by Mom while the protagonist watches—and Chapter 2 starts with them already shipped off to Mrs. Almon's house. No transition, no mourning period. Just gone. Seven years pass in a few paragraphs and then suddenly we're at the washing place and everything has shifted. But here's what got me: the Senar reveal. You thought Senar was living lavishly with maids? Nope. She's naked on the floor being whipped by a white-haired old man with an apple in her mouth. The protagonist's reaction—turning away and running—is one of the most devastating beats in these chapters. It's not horror. It's recognition. They already know exactly what kind of world this is. The narrative structure is deliberately fragmentary, mirroring how trauma compresses time. Those seven years at Mrs. Almon's aren't described as growth or education—they're described as waiting for someone to die. And the line 'A little more dead than yesterday' said about Mrs. Vino with the same tone you'd use about the weather? That's the plot doing its real work. The protagonist isn't surviving; they're calculating expiration dates. I keep wondering what happens next. Because you can't build a character this cold, this pragmatic, this quietly furious—and then just let them stay small. The plot has set something up. I just don't know if it's revenge or something worse.
... Read More
Can we just talk about the bruise on Lucy's neck for a moment? Because it's EVERYTHING. It's not even mentioned dramatically—it's just there, darkening, impossible to hide unless you're blind, and Kirhin's eyes land on it and suddenly his whole attitude shifts. He says 'Oh boy' and taps his foot like a disappointed parent but the effect is immediate. That bruise represents everything that happened to her: the prison, Mrs. Almon's death, hanging herself on that candlestick holder, being rescued by someone she can't even identify properly. And yet the most tender moment in this entire section comes when Lars notices she's cold and gestures for Yanken to give up HIS cloak. Yanken is SEething about it—'Who was it that was there with me then' stuck in his throat—and Lars just proudly puts it on like he owns the world. But Lucy, clutching that cloak to her chest when she wakes up, feeling the faint fragrance... that's the moment that got me. She doesn't understand WHY he helped her, and neither do I, but the way she holds onto that warmth is devastating. She's survived so much and the simplest act of kindness disarms her completely.
... Read More
Okay, let me just say—this sequence had my heart absolutely hammering. The way the author builds tension is unhinged in the best way. You go from curiosity to dread to pure survival mode in like three paragraphs. Remember the moment when she's wandering through those passages? "Even standing in front of a door for a moment, you could hear the languid moans of women and the grunting, panting sounds of men." This is such a brutal world-building detail. The author doesn't need to describe the brothel rooms directly—the DOORS themselves tell the story. And then she finds the one quiet corner, thinks she's safe, and BOOM—the door clicks open. The stakes escalate so quickly after that. First it's the drunk man grabbing her arm, offering bills like she's merchandise. "Your skin is so smooth. It's like it's never been touched by a man before. If it's your first time, I'll add another 20 lebls." I literally had to pause and stare at my phone. The casualness of it—that's what made it so suffocating. He's not even aggressive in a dramatic way. He's bored. And the scream going nowhere? "A man with a cigarette in his mouth passed by, but he only glanced sideways, casually ignoring my scream." That line hit me like a physical blow. No music swelling, no hero running toward the sound. Just... indifferenc e. The stakes here aren't just physical danger—they're existential. She's realizing that in this world, her life literally has no value to anyone around her. Then the rescue happens, but it's not heroic in a conventional sense. She gets covered by a curtain, dragged through darkness, and emerges to find a man holding a sharpened piece of wood pointed at HER. The reversal! The tension doesn't release—it shifts direction entirely. But here's what made me stay up past midnight: the walk home. After surviving actual violence, she's still not safe. On the dark path, she hears footsteps. "There was someone other than me in this space." She grabs a weapon. She's ready to kill or die. And then the Priest appears—taller than her by two heads, wrapped in black like a shadow. He disarms her effortlessly, and instead of continuing the violence, he says something almost mundane: "There's no path that way, little miss. Where were you trying to go?" The stakes never actually drop. They just transform. From physical danger to something far more complicated. I'm still thinking about that final line of the chapter: "Actually, I ended up like this because of you, Father." What does that even mean?! She's blaming him for everything that happened tonight. But also—she's the one who snuck out. Who brought Mark along. So why is it HIS fault? And more importantly—what did the Priest do that led to this moment?
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is something else, and I want to focus on how every character uses words differently because it tells you everything about who they are. Peterson's dialogue is the most revealing—he speaks in accusations wrapped as questions, in threats disguised as advice. When he says 'Innocent people have nothing to hide,' he's not trying to be fair. He's trying to corner her. The way he transitions from mocking to intimate to violent in three sentences shows a man who enjoys power more than justice. Mark, on the other hand, speaks like someone who's still learning how the world works. 'Does it have to be around the temple?' he asks, genuinely confused by her devotion, and there's no malice in it. That line 'I don't work at the herb shop. I just helped the lady a few times'—Lucienne's defensive precision here is heartbreaking because she's already knowing, even at sixteen, that every word matters in this world. And then there's Lars, whose dialogue is sparse but loaded. 'We're not butchers'—four words that define his entire moral compass in a story full of people who've forgotten that line. The narrator's voice during the interrogation scenes is also worth noting. It's restrained, almost clinical, which makes the horror hit harder. When Lucienne thinks 'That must not happen. Absolutely not.' about the priest being implicated, it's internal dialogue so quiet it screams.
... Read More
Every single interaction in this section feels like someone's about to lose everything. Like, ACTUALLY lose it. Nina is the most underestimated threat in fiction. She's the head maid who runs the household while pretending to serve, and when Kirhin announces Lucy as his sister, her eyes tremble. Just for a moment, but Lars notices. He always notices. The way she drops the medicine bottle—calculated. She's testing Lucy, testing Kirhin, testing everyone. And Lucas's response? Shattering a glass himself and teaching her to use people as her hands and feet. That's not advice, that's a survival manual for a girl who's about to walk into a lion's den wearing a dress that doesn't belong to her. The external stakes are clear: if this sister story falls apart, Lucy gets expelled or worse, and Kirhin's legitimacy as baron gets questioned alongside it. But the internal stakes are what get me. Kirhin genuinely says 'I like you, Lucy' and then follows it with 'it would have been better if you were a little less intelligent.' That's not cruelty, that's fear. He's afraid she'll see through him. He's afraid she'll be too smart for her own good in a house full of wolves. And Lars—Lars is the walking embodiment of stakes. His mere presence raises the temperature in every room. When he tells Kirhin to come to the study for the succession procedure, the chapter just ends like that. No elaboration. Just the unspoken understanding that whatever happens in that study could change everything.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or