Please Forget Me - Reviews

Please Forget Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about this scene where Johann and Rize end up in the forget-me-not field after his little outburst at the church, because WOW. Like, the author just goes straight from that heart-stopping "I love you" declaration told loud enough for strangers to hear to them making love in a field of flowers they already established as their love symbol? That is so smooth I wasn't ready. But what really got me was Johann asking her to carry his child. I literally gasped out loud. This man who had apparently been resistant to the topic before—now he's like, casually dropping it while still inside her? The way the text describes it, his hand on her lower abdomen, saying it almost like it's a dream... and then she wakes up and it WASN'T a dream. It was real. She was in bed, sore, with poppies tickling her nose. I'm not crying, you're crying. And Johann's transformation throughout these chapters—the sadness lifting, him finally smiling without that shadow underneath—it hit different. When he says "From now on, we live as an ordinary married couple," it sounds simple but you can feel how much weight he's putting into it. Like after everything, he's claiming normalcy as something precious. Rize's response of "I like that idea" with zero hesitation because wherever he is IS home? Devastating in the best way.
... Read More
Okay, so this whole chapter is basically a masterpiece of 'almost.' Like, the author knows exactly how to pull the rug out from under you every five minutes. You start with Johann bringing hyacinths—so sweet, right?—and Rize is all like 'I can do this, I'll initiate!' Then BAM, he recoils like she's toxic. But wait, dinner happens, butter tastes amazing, things are softening. She tries to be brave, pulls him in, and for a second it actually works—he kisses back! Tongue even! I was literally shouting 'yes yes yes!' at my phone. Then she gets bold, moves to his lap, thinks she's cracked the code... and he pushes her like she's a traitor. Thud. On the floor. And he flees to sleep in the hallway. That's not just a setback, that's a whole narrative gut-punch. The plot here isn't moving forward; it's doing a kind of painful, spinning dance where every advance is met with a violent retreat. It's coherent though, because every beat follows from his visible torment. He's not a villain; he's a locked door she's banging on, and the hinges are screaming. Who am I kidding, I still haven't recovered. What is wrong with this man?!
... Read More
There are so many layers happening in this text that I keep coming back to, each one more devastating than the last. Let me start with the colostrum. The landlady explains it matter-of-factly— it's the first milk after giving birth, thicker and more nutritious, packed with everything a newborn needs. But she also milks it all out because if you don't, the milk won't come in as much. You have to open the teats for the calf to suckle comfortably. This is happening right alongside the conversation about Rize's marriage, and I can't unsee the parallel. The colostrum represents potential— nourishment, life, something precious meant for the child. But the calf never gets it because the women milk it all away for their own purposes. Is Rize's intimacy the same? Is something meant for her and Johann being diverted or wasted because nobody knows how to access it properly? Then there's the corpse imagery. Brigitta calls Rize corpse-like, and at first it reads as cruelty, but rereading it, I wonder if Brigitta is actually pointing to something deeper about how trauma makes us feel— hollowed out, pale, disconnected from our own bodies. The bombing took Rize's memory, but it also seems to have taken her sense of herself as a desirable woman, as a wife, as someone capable of receiving pleasure. And the swallowing— God, the swallowing. Rize accidentally swallows cow's milk because her mouth is open in shock, and the landlady tells her not to suck too hard because men shoot milk too. The metaphor is so brazenly obvious and yet so beautiful in its simplicity. Something meant to nourish, something meant to be shared between partners— it becomes comic relief, but underneath it is this real pain of two people who cannot seem to give each other what they're meant to give. Johann's letter is another symbol worth noting. His words are passionate, physical, almost violent in their intensity— but they're about desire, not harm. The misunderstanding itself becomes symbolic of the communication gap between Rize and Johann. Both are trying to express love in their own language, but they're speaking different dialects entirely. The comforter Johann buys— it's warmth, protection, care made physical. He says they can sell it later when they leave, treating it almost like an investment. But really, it's a love letter in object form. He sees her cold and he wants to warm her, even if he doesn't understand why she pulls away. By the end, Rize realizes she's been the one rejecting him all along, not through malice but through ignorance and fear. She wrapped herself tightly in bed and wondered why he couldn't reach her. The image of someone bundled up against the cold, trembling not from temperature but from emotional distance— that's the real symbolism here. War took her memories, but her own body became a battlefield she didn't know how to fight on.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened in these chapters because my emotions are all over the place. First, there's this genuinely heartbreaking moment where Brigitta grabs Rize's arm and calls her pale and corpse-like. I know Brigitta means it as blunt observation, not cruelty, but god, reading it made my chest tighten. Rize is already struggling with amnesia, already feeling like she doesn't belong in this village life, and then her own sister-in-law is holding up her limp body and saying look, it's just bones. But then— and this is what absolutely wrecked me— Johann comes home carrying a comforter. A COMFORTER. Even though they have no money, even though Rize told him not to buy anything, he brings it home anyway because he saw it and thought of her sleeping warm. "I don't mind spending this money if it means you can sleep warmly." That line hit me like a freight train. This man is doing his best with nothing, and his love language is literally making sure his wife isn't cold. And Rize, who can barely remember her own past, looks at this gesture and thinks— how could I not love such a man? But here's the thing that makes my heart hurt the most: she ALSO feels guilty because she lied to him the day before. She's caught between gratitude and shame, between wanting to open up to him and not knowing HOW. The physical intimacy confusion with the landladies is almost comedic relief, but underneath all the laughter and milk-shooting-into-mouths chaos, there's this real ache of two people who love each other but can't find their way back to each other. The upstairs lady literally says "I wish I could fall asleep with Rize's husband in the same bed every day. Johann is so diligent that he must be diligent in bed too." And then the landlady makes this face because THEY LIVE ABOVE HER BEDROOM and she's never heard any sounds from Rize and Johann. NOT ONE SOUND. The silence between them is deafening, and I'm sitting here feeling sorry for both of them in equal measure. Johann, who is trying so hard in his quiet way, and Rize, who is trapped behind her own confusion and shame.
... Read More
These eight chapters move like a rollercoaster and I am exhausted. Let me trace the pace: we start INTIMATE and slow—Johann drawing Rize, them talking about their first meeting, the forget-me-not fairy origin story. Gentle, warm, almost sleepy. Then the dream sequence hits and suddenly we're in mystery territory with that second boy, the stream, the running away. The tone shifts from sweet to unsettled. Then BAM—season change to summer, war context floods in, the church scene begins. What starts as a quiet wedding attendance turns into Johann having this visible breakdown, pulling Rize out mid-sermon, proposing again in an attic, having three rounds of sex, asking her to have his child, then waking up cheerful with poppies. All of THAT happens in the span of roughly what feels like one afternoon and evening. The velocity is insane. But here's the thing—that velocity works because the author earned it. The slow build in the drawing scene makes the explosion feel cathartic rather than chaotic. Every pause matters: Johann staring at his rosary, the silence stretching, Rize picking at her hangnail, the rosary falling and him NOT picking it up. Those tiny beats of hesitation before the storm make the release hit harder. The transition from the field scene to the church to the attic to the bedroom to morning feels almost dreamlike in its speed, which I think is intentional—it mirrors how Rize experiences this transformation of her husband. One day he's distant and sad, the next he's radically present and different. The pacing mimics the emotional whiplash. And that ending line, cut off mid-sentence about him no longer speaking in riddles? Perfect cliffhanger. I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters are layered in a way that keeps me genuinely worried. On the surface: war is raging, territory is being lost, soldiers are dying, dog tags are replacing love letters, funerals happen without bodies. The external conflict is constant background radiation. But the REAL tension is internal—and it's all about Johann. He's been carrying something dark for a while now. At the church, when Rize tries to hold his hand, he jerks away saying "God is watching" but the text explicitly says his question wasn't about the hand rejection, it was about WHY he looked as sad as someone at a funeral. That contrast between his religious restraint and his internal devastation is the core conflict. He won't tell her what happened at their wedding. She guesses at bombing, at parental opposition, at something terrible—and he won't confirm or deny. That silence is TORTURE for both characters and for the reader. When he finally snaps and pulls her out of mass, quoting scripture about perfect love casting out fear, it's clear he's been living in fear. Fear of what? Of losing her? Of whatever secret his wedding held? And then the stakes explode when he asks her to bear his child. After previously opposing the topic. This isn't just romantic—it's desperate. Like he needs something permanent to anchor him, to prove they have a future worth fighting for. The fact that he goes from withdrawn to overwhelming physical intimacy in one day signals someone who's reached a breaking point and chosen to fight rather than retreat. But what is he fighting? And what happens when the war actually reaches their village?
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is absolutely thick. I swear I could feel the chill of that forest, the damp leaves under Rize's back, the cold water from the creek on Johann's hands. The author does this brilliant thing where the natural world feels almost alive — the walnut tree they find, the pile of autumn leaves, the way the cold air hits Rize's skin after Johann's mouth leaves it warm. It's sensual but also stark, and it mirrors what's happening between them: something raw and natural that gets interrupted by something artificial and cruel. Then BOOM — you go from that forest intimacy to the bunker, and the shift is so jarring it nearly stopped my breath. Let me describe what I mean. One moment you're under open sky with dappled light and rustling leaves, and the next you're going down a staircase behind a barn, through an iron door, into a corridor lit by intermittent electric lights. "It felt like entering a tomb." That line. That single line. The bunker isn't just a location, it's a metaphor made of concrete and steel. Windowless rooms. Heavy guards. The whole place smells like power and rot. And the village itself? The contrast between Mrs. Bauer's warmth and Mrs. Becker's coldness was such a vivid detail. Mrs. Becker reciting Bible verses about sexual immorality from beneath the floorboards like some kind of spiritual ghost haunting her tenants. "Flee from fornication!" really? From your third-floor apartment? The humor in that was dark and perfect. It told me everything I needed to know about this world — a place where religious hypocrisy lives above you and military tyranny waits below. The farmhouse hidden in dense forest, the heavily guarded fence, the old barn that hides a military installation — all of these locations feel layered with history and menace. This isn't just a backdrop. Every place in this story has a mood, and the moods collide with each other in ways that make the world feel dangerously real.
... Read More
I need to talk about Johann and Rize because MY HEART IS BEING CRUSHED AND I DON'T KNOW WHAT TO DO. On paper, Johann is everything. He brings wildflowers every evening, blushes when he says 'I love you,' treats her like she's made of glass, never raises his voice, prays, works hard, is apparently praised by literally every woman in the village. He's the gold standard of husband material and I should be happy for her, right? But. He doesn't TOUCH her. Like at all. The scene where he drapes his coat over her shoulders and his fingers brush her collarbone — she FLINCHES. And his hand 'quickly retreated.' Rize is sitting there thinking 'what would it feel like to snuggle into that broad and sturdy chest?' and Johann is over here treating her like she's a fragile porcelain doll that might shatter if breathed on. And then the BEDROOM SCENE. Oh god. She asks him straight out 'did we consummate our wedding night?' and he says yes with this weird deflection. She says she's cold and he GIVES HER HIS COAT instead of holding her. He says 'have a good dream' and goes to sleep. LIKE A FRIEND. LIKE A ROOMMATE. She literally narrates 'Our marriage is not ordinary' and I'M SCREAMING. What is NOT ordinary about this?! Is he protecting her from something? Is there a reason? The fact that he lied about knowing the violin piece she played — he KNEW she could play and pretended not to — what else is he hiding?? The romantic tension here is absolutely NONEXISTENT but the emotional tension is off the CHARTS. I keep waiting for some moment of vulnerability, some crack in Johann's perfect husband armor, and I just NEED it.
... Read More
Okay so this section is doing something really interesting with pacing. It starts almost idyllic—Rize and Johann in the vineyard, sweet domestic moments, him reading under the tree—and then BAM, a military truck rolls in and everything shifts. The author doesn't even give you time to breathe before the next paragraph is about a bunker, drafted labor, and a creepy officer who clearly has his eye on Rize. I think what makes this work so well is that the plot doesn't just introduce conflict randomly. Remember how Johann kept saying 'let's forget the past and live for the present'? That line echoed through the whole section, and now it feels almost prophetic. The past isn't going to stay forgotten. The war caught up to them literally overnight. Also, the way the author handles the reveal about Johann's scar is clever on a structural level. It's not just a random detail—it's a loose thread that pulls at something bigger. A burn mark that he calls a 'badge of honor' but clearly wants hidden? That's a character backstory waiting to explode. The major himself is introduced through a gaze first, not a description. I love that. You feel Rize's instinctive fear before you even know who he is. And then his parting line—'We'll see each other again'—that's textbook cliffhanger material but it doesn't feel cheap because the whole section has been building this undercurrent of dread. What I found most effective was how the author juxtaposed two timelines: the quiet present where Rize is rebuilding her strength (literally, through chopping wood) and the looming threat of the war closing in. It's like the story is saying, look how hard she's working to be better, and look how the world won't let her rest. That tension between personal growth and external chaos is exactly what keeps me turning pages.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about how this whole scene with the cow's teat metaphor completely flips the script on what I thought was happening? At first, I genuinely thought Johann was rejecting Rize because of her injuries, right? Brigitta even says it outright — he probably sees her as some broken thing now, like a corpse. That's heavy stuff, seriously heavy. The tension builds up like this thick fog, and you're sitting there thinking, oh no, this marriage is over before it really started. But then Brigitta starts spilling all this tea, and suddenly Rize realizes— wait for it— she's been wrapping herself in cardigans and sleeping fully clothed? Like, actually wearing pajamas OVER her pajamas when it's cold? The women in the room lose their minds, and honestly so did I reading it. "You don't even sleep naked with your husband?" The landlady literally says this like it's the most absurd thing she's ever heard. And that's when it hits you. The misunderstanding isn't one-directional at all. Johann bought her a comforter even though they're broke— he said he didn't mind spending money if she could sleep warmly. Who does that? A husband who's trying to take care of her, not reject her. But here's where the plot twist really lands: Rize has been misreading EVERYTHING. She assumed he wasn't interested in her, so she retreated into this shell of propriety and fear, and meanwhile Johann is just... buying her comforters and not kissing her because maybe he thinks SHE doesn't want it? The tragedy of it all is that neither of them has ever actually communicated. The bombing took her memory, but apparently it also took her instincts for how to navigate intimacy, or maybe she was always this reserved and the war just made her more closed off. Either way, the gap between perception and reality here is massive, and the author plants it so naturally through this ridiculous yet heartfelt conversation with the landladies. "Just suck him once, and he'll be so thrilled, he'll jump on you like a stallion." And then milk shoots into Rize's open mouth because she's too shocked to close it. COMEDY GOLD wrapped around emotional devastation.
... Read More
Some dialogue in these chapters is so sharp it drew blood. Let me give you the ones I immediately Underlined-in-my-mind. Major Felkner's voice is unforgettable. The man speaks like he's tasting every word before he swallows it. "Small mountain villages spread rumors faster than bullets" — that's not a threat, that's an observation delivered like a toast. He's so self-aware about his reputation that it's almost charming in the most horrifying way possible. And then: "See you again, Rize Einemann." Calling her by her maiden name like he's undressing her with language. Chilling. Absolutely chilling. His monologue about what HE would do if he'd wooed such a beauty was grotesque but revealing. It tells you everything about how he sees women — not as people but as trophies and outlets. The way he phrases it, all confident and crude, makes him feel like a real person who's completely unredeemable rather than a plot device. Johann's dialogue is different. Shorter, gruffer, loaded with things he doesn't say out loud. "That's correct." When the Major asks if he's Johann Renner, it's a man who doesn't waste words on politeness. And his explanation about Rize's head injury and memory loss — delivered flatly, efficiently — shows a husband who will lie to protect his wife without hesitation. That single line carried so much weight. The narration itself has this intimate, almost confessional quality. Rize's internal monologue feels like she's telling you secrets. "I felt like prey thrown into a predator's cage." "The man must have inhaled too much poison gas on the battlefield to be so blind." These aren't just descriptions — they're opinions, and they make you feel like you're inside her head, not just watching her from outside. Mrs. Becker's Bible-quoting was pure comedic relief in the darkest way. The contrast between her pious outrage and the reality of thin floorboards between apartments... the author had me laughing out loud while simultaneously feeling sorry for Rize. That's skilled writing.
... Read More
Let me just say — the pacing in these chapters is absolutely filthy in the best possible way. The author knows exactly when to slow down and when to accelerate, and it's giving me whiplash. The chapters open with an extended intimate scene that's both explicit and emotionally charged. This could easily become repetitive if the author just kept doing bedroom scenes, but no — Johann pulls away, the mood shifts, and suddenly we're transitioning to this quiet, almost domestic moment of her being jealous of a poetry book. The contrast is deliberate and brilliant. You go from maximum heat to this tender, almost comedic moment of her shoving her face between his book and his knees demanding attention. The reader breathes. Then — just when you think the emotional intensity has peaked with her crying about pregnancy — BAM, the scene shifts to the picnic. The forget-me-not hill. It's like the author knows we need air, so they give us this expansive, almost cinematic panorama. The blue flowers, the oak tree, the strawberry tart, the clouds like sheep. It's so vividly rendered that you forget for a moment that this woman is fundamentally unhappy inside. The structure itself mirrors their relationship: moments of intense closeness followed by sudden distance, physical proximity masking emotional gap. And the ending — that cliffhanger about Johann seeing her as a child in the forest — is PERFECT. Just when you think you understand their backstory, the author opens a brand new door. One critique though: the intimate scenes run a bit long. I was mostly into it, but the repetition of her frustration with his refusal could've been trimmed. Still, the emotional payoff at the end more than compensates.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or