Please Forget Me - Reviews

Please Forget Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The setting in this stretch isn't just backdrop; it's the emotional thermostat. We're confined to this attic room—that's it. A table with flowers, a bed, a bathroom downstairs. The world outside feels rural, tight-knit, judgmental (the landlady already knows everything, the ladies gave advice). This claustrophobia mirrors their relationship: there's nowhere to run, nowhere to hide from this tension. The scenes are so vividly framed. The hyacinths on the table separating them during dinner? Perfect. The butter block Johann cuts a corner off when she's not looking—that tiny, secret act of craving something made with her 'love'? Chilling. The night scene: her removing her cardigan, the sheer nightwear, his distant gaze dropping to her skin. Then the push, the thud on the floor, the hurt. And the final image: Johann at dawn, leaning against the hallway corner, clutching his rosary, asleep on the floor instead of the bed. That's not just a man avoiding his wife; that's a man exiled by his own conscience. The world is small, the stakes are personal, and every detail—the coarse bread, the honey, the trembling hands, the rosary beads—feels weighted with meaning. It's intimate horror dressed as domestic romance.
... Read More
The imagery in these chapters is SO vivid I could literally paint them. Let me start with the forget-me-not field—the whole scene where they make love is bathed in this spring sunlight warmth, the cool breeze as a blanket, Johann's lap as a pillow. It's domestic intimacy framed against nature, and it ties back to their origin story like the universe was saving this moment all along. Then you've got the church during Paul and Anna's wedding, and the atmosphere shift is incredible. The author moves from the general war context—sweltering summer, lost territory, mountain villages groaning under horror—into this intimate space of tears AND laughter for the first time in a long while. That detail about the church becoming a place of both grief and joy simultaneously? Chills. Then Johann dropping his rosary and pulling Rize out into the square, staring up at the cross with something like determination instead of fear—that visual of him looking at the rooftop cross changed entirely from his usual reverent posture told me everything about his internal state without a single line of exposition. And the attic! Where he proposes again and they end up together. The contrast between the plain chemise she's wearing and the wedding ceremony he's recreating—her as a bride without a dress, him treating it like the most sacred thing. Then waking up to poppies (red and white, by the way—so deliberate) and hearing the wedding reception still going on outside. The world feels lived-in and real because these spaces matter. Each one carries emotional weight.
... Read More
There's this incredible trinity of symbols running through these chapters and I cannot stop thinking about how layered it all is. First: the forget-me-nots. Of course Johann loves forget-me-nots — the flower's very name is a plea against being forgotten. He takes her to see them in full bloom, paints this image of blue snowflakes covering a hill, and says "I wish time could stop here." But the irony is DEVASTATING. She HAS been forgotten — her past self is literally erased from her mind. And he's mourning a woman who no longer exists, surrounded by flowers that symbolize remembrance. Is he trying to create a new memory with her, or is he trapped in the old one? The hill of forget-me-nots might be the most beautiful graveyard in literature. Second: the cross/rosary. Johann is this devout man — the rosary literally FALLS OUT during sex, which is such a perfect visual metaphor for the collision of his faith and his desire. Every time he hesitates before intimacy, he's wrestling with sin. The body as a site of both sacred love and transgression. When she calls him the devil and he replies that HE is the one poisoned by the devil... that's not just dirty talk, that's theological horror. Third: the unborn child. The pregnancy he fears and she craves becomes this symbol of everything hanging in balance. A child would tether them to each other permanently, but it would also mean confronting the reality of their world — war, displacement, uncertainty. The fact that he refuses penetration "because he's afraid" while she offers to embrace any child God blesses them with speaks volumes about their different relationships to hope and survival. What is this story REALLY about beneath all the sexual tension and amnesia drama? I think it's about whether love can survive when one person no longer remembers why they fell in love in the first place.
... Read More
Let me just be honest about the pacing here because THE WHIPLASH IS REAL. Chapter one opens with a GUN to someone's head, a betrayed wife/husband/person whatever they are, a crumpled white sheet, venom metaphors — THIS IS NOT A QUIET VILLAGE ROMANCE OPENING. And then the author just... stops. Cuts to bells. Cuts to church. It's like the most dramatic scene imaginable and then we're back to 'oh hello nice weather in the mountains isn't it.' That structural choice is either brilliant or deeply unhinged and I haven't decided which. From there, the pacing settles into this deceptively slow rhythm. We get festival preparations, violin moments, whispered conversations with Johann, a dance scene, and then the bedroom. It feels almost idyllic — this quiet wartime village life — and that's the TRAP. The author is lulling you into feeling safe while all these threads are pulling in dangerous directions. The violin thing. The spy rumors. The unanswered questions about Rize's past. The section where Rize plays the violin — that's the pacing highlight. Her fingers moving on their own, the mind forgetting but the body remembering. She gets lost in it and only snaps out when Johann SNATCHES the violin away. That moment shifted something for me. The pace quickened. Johann's reaction — dark expression, lie about not knowing the tune, the desperate 'please don't play again' — that's where the story grabs you by the throat. And the ending? 'Our marriage is not ordinary.' After building this whole portrait of a gentle, devoted husband who won't even hold his wife in bed — THAT line lands like a gut punch. The pacing from idyllic to unsettling is so controlled.
... Read More
I have to address the dialogue in this chapter because it's a whole different Johann from what we've seen before. His voice has always been clipped, formal, almost mechanical. Even when he was being cold and distant, his sentences were tight and controlled. But here? He falls apart. 'I don't like men.' 'I swear to God.' 'The person I've loved all my life is only you.' 'I would even abandon my faith for you.' Each line gets progressively more unhinged, and it's BEAUTIFUL to watch this carefully composed man unravel. Rize's voice is also doing a lot of heavy lifting. That early question 'Do you like men?' is such a Rize move — blunt, slightly unhinged, funny but hiding genuine insecurity underneath. And her follow-up 'Did I also look repulsive when I tried to approach you, wanting to sleep with you, like the other women?' — THAT is the line that tells you everything about their relationship. She's been feeling rejected, invisible, and she finally just asks. The banter during the intimate scene is also surprisingly good. 'You're undoubtedly a devil.' / 'Can't a devil be this charming?' / 'When I'm with you, I willingly forget my humanity and want to become a beast.' This isn't just smut dialogue — it's character-revealing. Rize is playful even in vulnerable moments, and Johann is earnest to the point of being almost ridiculous. Their voices feel distinct from each other, which is something I don't always see in this genre. My only complaint: some of the physical descriptions during the intimate scene get a bit repetitive. 'Squelch' appears multiple times, and the 'I love you' refrain, while emotionally powerful, borders on overuse. But honestly? In the moment it works.
... Read More
This chapter is drowning in symbols that scream about duty versus desire. The wedding ring is the big one. It's not just jewelry; it's 'the only proof of our marriage' to Johann, but also an asset they could sell. Rize wants to give him hers to complete the pair, showing she sees marriage as a partnership. He refuses, guarding it like a relic. Then his act of placing it back on her finger is tender but terrified. The hyacinths Johann brings—they're beautiful, decorative, but they sit on the table between them, a barrier of pretty flowers. The butter? Made with 'love,' but consumed secretly. It's love as sustenance but also as something hidden, almost shameful. The rosary in Johann's hand on the hallway floor ties it all together: his faith is the cage. Every moment of connection is filtered through sin, guilt, reverence. The 'forget-me-not' nickname itself is a theme—memory, perhaps a past he can't recall, a promise he can't keep. The whole sequence asks: what do you do when the person who holds your soul is also the one who hurts you? When marriage is a contract but intimacy feels like transgression?
... Read More
Can we talk about how absolutely devastating this revelation about Johann's true feelings is? Like, I went from being all shipped with them during the intimate scenes to completely unhinged when he calls the old her a "Lady" with all this reverent nostalgia. The guy is literally confessing in the most poetic way possible — "I love you so much that I would willingly die even if you kill me, even if God says my love for you is a sin" — and I'm sitting here like... wait, which version of her are you talking about?? The power dynamic between them is just SO intricate. She's the one who initiates, who pounces on him, who literally begs for penetration and gets frustrated when he pulls away. But underneath all that sexual boldness, there's this trembling insecurity about whether she's merely a replacement. Meanwhile Johann is this controlled, almost priest-like figure who can maintain his composure during heated moments but falls apart emotionally when confronted with her jealousy. That scene where he draws her and gets this soft, tender smile — you can SEE him looking at the past her through the present one. The most painful moment? When she fiddles with the wedding ring and thinks it belongs to someone else. The ring is supposed to symbolize their union, but it's become this cruel reminder that the man holding it might be married to a ghost. And yet — and yet — he STILL stays. He STILL chooses her. But the reader is left wondering if he's choosing HER or just refusing to let go of the memory of who she used to be. Also, side note: his self-control during intimacy is almost comically absurd. The man has a rosary falling out during sex and his FIRST thought is about God and sin. The duality of this character is incredible.
... Read More
I need a moment. I need several moments. The scene where she begs him to make her pregnant and he pulls out — I was SCREAMING into my pillow. Like, here's this woman who has lost everything (her memories, her identity, her entire sense of self) and the one thing she grasps for is literally creating life with the man she loves. It's not about reproduction in a clinical sense; it's about making herself IRREPLACEABLE. If she carries his child, then she IS the mother of his heir, and he CANNOT go back to some phantom memory of a perfect lady. And his response? "I'm afraid you might get pregnant." Not "I don't want children," not "we're not ready" — he's actively TERRIFIED of her carrying his baby. Which, of course, sends her spiraling into even deeper insecurity. She interprets his fear as rejection, when the reality is probably far more complicated. The emotional whiplash in this section is masterful. One moment you have these incredibly tender, almost innocent scenes — her being jealous of a BOOK, him drawing her with this soft expression, calling her beautiful without smiling — and then the NEXT moment you're dealing with this raw, visceral desperation. She goes from playfully thrusting her head between his book and knees to sobbing because he withdrew during intimacy. The contrast is almost too much. But honestly, what broke me was this line: "I enjoyed it, but didn't you? Am I not doing it right?" The vulnerability in those words. She's performing, she's worrying about pleasing him, and he's so gentle about it — telling her she doesn't need to exert herself, that he's already satisfied. But his satisfaction doesn't include full penetration, and that's the wound that never closes.
... Read More
The dialogue in this book is genuinely exceptional, and I need to document every standout moment before I forget them. Her voice is so distinct — sharp, direct, unapologetically sexual but also childlike in her vulnerability. When she says things like "Why don't you put this inside me and shake it up?" you immediately understand this is a woman who has lost all pretense. No false modesty, no games. She wants what she wants and she's not going to pretend otherwise. But then she flips instantly to the insecure wife wondering if her husband finds her boring, and the contrast is what makes her character feel alive. Johann's dialogue is a completely different register. Measured, restrained, almost formal. "You're not a woman selling her body. You don't need to exert yourself to satisfy me." That's not how someone talks to their wife during foreplay unless they're genuinely trying to protect her dignity. His speech patterns reveal his class background, his religious upbringing, his emotional restraint — everything about him is contained in the way he chooses his words. But the absolute peak of dialogue in these chapters has to be his confession: "I love you so much that I would willingly die even if you kill me, even if God says my love for you is a sin and destined me for hell." This is either the most romantic line I've ever read or the most concerning, and I genuinely cannot decide which. It's so over-the-top poetic that it borders on ridiculous, but coming from a character who quotes scripture during sex, it's completely in character. The exchange where she asks what she was like in the past and he says "A Lady" with this capital-L reverence is also devastating in its simplicity. Two words that carry an entire history of class, propriety, and forbidden desire. And honestly, the little moments of humor — her offering six slices of salami as a bargaining chip, him seriously listing exactly what he'd eat — these balance the heavy emotional moments perfectly.
... Read More
I need to talk about the voices in this book because honestly? They're so distinct and so emotionally accurate that I forgot I was reading something written by a person. Dana's internal monologue is the real star here. She's sharp, horny, practical, and deeply insecure all at once — and she never lets you forget it. Her thoughts are like: 'I'm glad my husband doesn't like men, but who is Dana?' and 'How is that a punishment for you? It's a punishment for me.' and 'I might truly be the devil corrupting a human being.' That last line? That's not just dialogue. That's a woman who is simultaneously turned ON by her power over this religious man and TERRIFIED of what that power means. Johann's dialogue is a completely different register. Short. Breathless. Almost never complete sentences during intimate moments. "More." "I can't let go." "You're coming with me to hell." When he's serious — like when he's explaining why he pulls away — his sentences are longer but still halting, like he's translating his emotions from a language he barely remembers. The village ladies' dialogue is comedic relief but also genuinely unsettling. "If you don't want to poke between your thighs with your hand every night, better torment him a bit." This is a woman giving her friend MARRIAGE ADVICE involving sexual torture. The casual cruelty mixed with genuine care is so real it made me laugh out loud and then feel bad for laughing. But the MOST powerful dialogue in the text isn't spoken at all. It's the unspoken stuff. Johann NEVER saying Dana's name aloud to her face. Johann never initiating first, even after he admits it's love. The fact that Dana never presses the Dana question after his pale reaction. The silence between these characters is where the REAL story lives.
... Read More
The dialogue here is less about what's said and more about what's choked back. Johann's lines are full of ellipses and half-truths: 'Ah… that's…', 'Rize, please let go. We, I…'. He can't finish sentences. He's fighting his own mind. And Rize? She's all over the place—attempting breezy flirtation ('Because my love is in it'), then desperate negotiation, then raw, ugly pleading. Her internal monologue is a different voice entirely: crude, sexual, self-loathing, then suddenly poetic ('forget-me-not fairy'). The author nails the generational/class divide in speech too. Brigitta's advice sounds like tavern gossip ('bite down fervently, suck it like a baby'), while Rize's own thoughts are modern, messy, and painfully sincere. Johann's voice is restrained, almost liturgical—when he says 'Stay still' or 'You might catch a cold,' it's practical, deflecting. The real dialogue is physical: the trembling hands, the averted eyes, the recoiling touch. That's where the truth lives. The verbal exchanges are just smoke screens for two people trying to translate feelings they don't have the vocabulary for.
... Read More
Okay so I need to process something. This book is NOT just a romance. It's a theological argument wrapped in a sex scene and I only realized it halfway through. Let's start with the most obvious symbol: HEAVEN AND HELL. Dana literally describes orgasm as heaven — "I felt my body soaring." Johann agrees. But the NEXT scene is a man kneeling on cold ground with a broken rosary, reciting commandments about adultery and lust. The author is asking a question that every religious person has ever asked: if pleasure from your spouse feels like heaven, is it actually sin? Or is the SIN the guilt that follows? The broken rosary is another symbol that won't leave my head. Johann clutches it with "one corner of the cross broken." His faith is physically damaged. Whatever happened to him — whatever made him lose his memory — didn't just erase his past, it BROKE something in his relationship with God. And now Dana is trying to rebuild that relationship for him through touch, through sex, through the most earthly act possible. The stable scene is SYMBOLIC TOO. They make love among animals, in a place of work and warmth and life, while the landlady calls from outside like God herself is calling them back to the moral world. The horses WATCHING is almost comedic, but it's also profound — nature doesn't judge what they're doing. Only humans do. And then there's the BLOODED cloth thrown into the furnace. The text says: "Even if the evidence of sin burned away, the sin itself did not." This is the thesis statement of the entire book. Guilt doesn't disappear because you destroy the proof. And Johann KNOWS this. That's why he keeps kneeling. That's why he whispers Dana's name — because maybe Dana is the person he sinned with before, and maybe he's punishing himself through Dana all over again by loving THIS woman so destructively.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or