Please Forget Me - Reviews

Please Forget Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This section is packed with symbols that hit way harder than they initially appear. Let me unpack a few because the author is doing something sophisticated here. First: the axe and firewood. Johann sets this condition—not just as a test of physical strength, but as a metaphor for Rize reclaiming agency over her body. She was bedridden, helpless, dependent. Now she's literally swinging a weapon-like tool, rebuilding herself through labor. The fact that she goes from two swings to six in two months mirrors her emotional journey—small gains that accumulate into real change. She's not just stronger; she's proving to herself that she can reshape her own destiny. Then there's the scar. Johann calls it a 'badge of honor' but the narration immediately undercuts that—he 'treated it more like a brand he wanted to hide.' A badge suggests pride; a brand suggests ownership by another. What happened to him? More importantly, why does he associate his past with shame rather than survival? The scar sits on his back—the side he can't see, the side others can witness but he controls the narrative around. That's power dynamics wrapped in skin. The wedding rings are another layer. Scratched, faded, possibly inherited. They're not new purchases; they're relics of a previous life. Rize plans to sell them to buy new ones—symbolically replacing her past with her present. But Johann refuses, wanting to earn new rings with his own money. He's trying to create something that belongs entirely to this version of their marriage, not the one she's forgotten. And the absence of rings on their left hands right now? That liminal space between who they were and who they're becoming. The setting itself is symbolic—the vineyard, the harvest, autumn approaching. There's a cyclical quality to it all. But then the war invades this pastoral scene, and the symbolic meaning flips: what was meant to be gathered and preserved is now under threat. The bunker in the forest replaces the natural shelter of the trees. The command center turns their home into a military zone. The text literally says 'the war dragged on, hardening people's hearts'—and I think that's the central theme. Everything is being hardened: relationships, landscapes, trust. The question is whether Rize and Johann's love can stay soft in a world that's turning to stone.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second. These chapters are about so much more than one creepy soldier harassing a woman. The stakes keep multiplying like dominoes, and by the end I was genuinely worried about every single person in this story. On the surface level, the external conflict is clear: Major Felkner wants Rize. He has military power. He summoned her to a bunker. He watched her in a compromising situation and did nothing to stop it — he enjoyed it. The threat is real and immediate. But the author keeps layering in complications that make this infinitely more complicated. The conscription question hit me hard. Johann avoided the draft due to tuberculosis. The Major presses him on it with this twisted tone that suggests Johann might be hiding something. What if the Major finds out Johann's military record is questionable? What if he uses that as leverage against him? Johann's entire future as a teacher hangs in the balance alongside Rize's safety. Then there's the internal conflict — and this is what made me put the book down and just stare at the ceiling. Johann wants to flee. NOW. Rize is afraid that leaving means abandoning everything and possibly never returning. The argument isn't about logistics, it's about two people who love each other processing terror in opposite directions. That's the kind of conflict that feels devastatingly real. The rationing, the strict landlord, the war, the bunker, the Major's obsession — every threat feeds the others. Rize can't escape the Major without triggering the consequences of being a deserter. She can't stay and face him without endangering Johann. The author has constructed a trap with no obvious exit, and that's what makes these chapters so gripping. I was genuinely scared for them, not just excited for the next chapter.
... Read More
Johann is a walking contradiction wrapped in a priestly aura, and it's exhausting to watch. On one hand, he calls her 'my forget-me-not fairy' like it's a secret he's been hoarding. That's intimate! That's past-tense affection bleeding through! But his actions are all about building walls. He flinches at a cheek kiss, turns beet red, prays for too long avoiding her gaze, fumbles the wedding ring like it's a live coal, and then physically shoves her away when she reaches for his arousal. Meanwhile, Rize is performing emotional acrobatics. She's reading Brigitta's advice like a playbook, trying to 'comfort a man,' but she's completely misreading the manual. She thinks desire is the problem; it's not. His terror is. The shift when he touches her between her legs is everything—he recoils not from disgust, but from having his own controlled world shattered. He's not avoiding her; he's avoiding himself. And that parting line, 'let's not talk about us to others'? That's not cruelty; that's a plea. He's ashamed of how much he wants her, and it's destroying them both. Rize's arc here is from hopeful naive to confused pain, still trying to solve him with logic when he's operated entirely by feeling.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about the narrative structure of these chapters because the author is playing 4D chess with us and I am HERE for it. The main plot thread — her amnesia and the mystery of who she was before — has been building since chapter one, and these chapters deliver on that promise in a way that's both satisfying and deeply unsettling. Johann finally reveals that she was once a "Lady" — dignified, strict, respectable — which completely reframes everything we've seen. Every time she acted wild, sexual, uninhibited, we were supposed to read it as a conscious rebellion against the person she used to be. That's not amnesia; that's identity reconstruction. The subplot about Johann's hesitation regarding pregnancy is actually connected to the larger mystery of the war and his secret mission. He's not just being cautious — he's a man living under extraordinary circumstances, possibly with enemies, possibly facing death. A child would make him vulnerable in a way he can't afford. This connects the intimate plot to the geopolitical plot in a way that feels earned, not forced. The cliffhanger ending — Johann revealing he saw her as a child in a forest of forget-me-nots — is a MASTERSTROKE. It recontextualizes his entire emotional arc. He didn't fall in love with the Lady; he fell in love with a girl. The perfect, composed aristocrat was just a later version of the same wild creature he first encountered. This means she doesn't need to mourn her lost self because the core of who she is has always been there — the author is essentially telling us that identity isn't lost, it's buried. Minor gripe: the transition between the intimate scene and the picnic feels slightly abrupt. A bridge paragraph would've smoothed it out. But the payoff at the end is worth it.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the pacing in these chapters is either masterful or manipulative and I can't decide which. The opening section is INTENSE. Full-page, unbroken physical description, no setup, no breathing room. You drop into the attic, the creaking bed, the sweat, the religion, the sin — and you're ON the ride immediately. No chapter header, no "three days earlier" — just raw, unfiltered ecstasy. And it works because it HURTS. You feel overwhelmed in the same way Dana feels overwhelmed. But then — PLOT TWIST — it cuts to BLACK. The cloth thrown into the furnace. The rosary on cold ground. A man praying. The Ten Commandments quoted like a judgment. And THEN we're back to the village ladies gossiping about whether Johann is withering away. The juxtaposition of that religious guilt sequence RIGHT AFTER the sex scene is BRILLIANT. It's like the author is saying: yes, this was heaven. Also, your husband thinks he's going to hell for it. Read on. The pacing throughout the middle section slows dramatically — meals, forest-wandering, butter-churning, the daily rhythm of married life. This isn't filler. This is the AUTHOR deliberately making you breathe so you don't burn out before the next explosion. And when the next explosion comes? The stable scene. The landlady. The horses. It hits like a freight train BECAUSE we had that quiet middle to recover from. The Dana reveals are paced perfectly too. First it's just a whisper during sex. Then she notices he says it with a "sad voice." Then she asks directly and he LIES. Then the text confirms "there was no one in the village with that name" and "it wasn't a Highland-style name." Each reveal is smaller than the last, but each one opens a deeper mystery. The pacing here is essentially: peak, valley, smaller peak, smaller valley, growing dread. And I was HOOKED.
... Read More
Can we just TALK about Johann for a second? This man is the most confused, devout, lustful, gentle, broken human being ever written and I need to sit down. On one hand: he's the kind of guy who kneels with a rosary at 3 AM, who says "I did something to you last night that I shouldn't have" like he's confessing to murder, who promises to punish himself by NOT touching his wife for a while and then immediately breaks that resolution because she's lying there in a silk nightgown and gravity exists. On the other hand: he also literally calls her his heaven. He says "You said you saw heaven. Now I can see heaven in my eyes too." And then later, during one of their more intense moments, he whispers "Now, haah, you're coming with me to hell" like he's fully aware this passion is simultaneously the most beautiful and most destructive thing in his life. He's not a bad man. He's a GOOD man who has been so deeply traumatized — we KNOW something happened to him before the memory loss — that his brain can't process feeling pleasure without attaching guilt to it. Every time he loses control, every time he becomes the "beast" she describes, he wakes up the next morning repentant. But he NEVER stops. That's the thing that got me. The "punishment" of abstinence lasts exactly until she takes off her cardigan and he sees how thin she's gotten. Then POOF. Gone. He's back to being a beast. And Dana — WHO IS DANA — keeps appearing in his intimate moments like a ghost in the machine. Not during the sex, but AFTER. Or sometimes DURING, whispered like a prayer or a curse. "Whenever we were in the midst of passion, Johann would whisper the name Dana with a sad voice." That's not the words of a man thinking about another woman he desires. That's the words of a man carrying something he can't put down. The relationship between them is gorgeous and painful. She feeds him. She learns her own body through him. She initiates because he can't. But she also worries constantly — not about whether he loves her (she knows he does), but about whether HE loves HER or whether she's standing in for someone else.
... Read More
The stakes in this chapter went from 'will they kiss?' to 'is this marriage viable?' in about three pages. Externally, there's the rumor mill—the ladies saying Johann might be impotent, the landlady thinking they fought. Social shame is a weapon here. Internally, the conflict is nuclear. Rize's desire for normal marital intimacy collides with Johann's profound, almost religious restraint. What's he risking? If he gives in, he breaks some internal vow. If he doesn't, he loses her. He's trapped in a double bind where both choices feel like betrayal. And Rize? She risks her pride, her sanity, her self-worth. Each rejection chips away at her 'I'm fine' facade. The thud when she fell wasn't just physical; it was the sound of hope hitting the floor. Yet the author keeps you hooked because the tension isn't around whether they'll get together—it's about why he's so broken, and whether she'll finally see the wall isn't personal. It's his own demons. The suspense is exquisite: will he ever explain? Will she walk away? The stakes aren't just romantic; they're existential. Two people, one bed, a hallway floor, and a silence so loud it hurts.
... Read More
I need to talk about Johann because this chapter revealed SO MUCH about him and honestly I'm both touched and deeply suspicious. The shift in his religious devotion is huge. Remember how earlier he was the guy attending mass every single morning, practically living at the church? Now he's down to weekends and holidays, and his excuse for being intimate with Rize is this absolutely adorable line: 'God is watching.' 'Rize, love is a gift from God. He too would be pleased to see His children sharing that gift.' I literally laughed out loud. This devout man has basically rewritten his own theology to justify smooching his wife in a grape vineyard. But beneath the humor, it's genuinely touching how much he's changed. The woman who felt like she was always second place to his faith now says 'it seems like I have taken God's place.' That's a massive character arc for one person. BUT. And here's the thing keeping me up at night—his obsession with keeping Rize from recovering her memories. When she says she wants to remember, his response is 'I'd rather you didn't remember anything' with a PAINED expression. Then later: 'Let's forget the past and live for the present.' He says this line TWICE in this section. Twice. That's not protective. That's controlling. Or maybe he's terrified. Maybe her past holds something that would destroy what they have now. The scar on his back, his refused-to-discuss history, his desperate need for her to stay in the present—these threads are all connected and I am NOT okay with that. Also, the detail about their wedding rings being scratched and faded, possibly family heirlooms instead of newly bought ones? That tiny detail hit me like a truck. What was their life before? Who gave her those rings? And Johann finding a teaching job and working so diligently to save for a proper home instead of living in an attic—that shows a man who's genuinely trying to build something real. He's not the same fanatical figure from before. He's becoming someone Rize can really build a life with. Which makes his secrecy even more maddening.
... Read More
I need to just be honest about something: the scene where she realizes she's pregnant — or might be pregnant, or HOPESSLY hopes she is — is the most quietly devastating moment in this entire book and I'm still not over it. After the climax, after everything, he pulls out. He cleans her up. She's lying there and her first thought isn't about the sex, or the love-making, or even the fact that her husband just called her "heaven." Her first thought is: it's a good time for a baby. Even in war. In the countryside. Safe enough. And then she CLOSERS her legs when he tries to clean inside her, because she's HOPING. Hoping that something stayed. Hoping that from this sin — because that's what he calls it, he CALLS it sin — something good might grow. The fact that she doesn't say this out loud? That she just lies there, shivering, thinking about a child that looks like both of them? I literally had to put the book down. But then the book keeps going. Of course it does. Because this author doesn't let you rest. Next thing we know Johann's bringing wildflowers and they're at it again on the dining table, and she's discovering erogenous zones she didn't know she had, and she's pulling down her blouse during sex because her nipples are sore from the fabric and Johann's staring at them like a man who's never seen beauty before and suddenly he's licking them and she's falling apart again. The most heartbreaking part? She says explicitly: "My husband had undoubtedly never tried sucking my breasts before I lost my memory." BEFORE THE MEMORY LOSS. Whatever happened to him, whatever broke him, whatever made him whisper Dana's name in the dark — it happened before she existed in this form. And now she's learning him, relearning him, piecing him together through touch, and she's terrified that underneath all this new intimacy, there's still someone else's ghost haunting her husband's bedroom.
... Read More
Let me just say—Johann pulling Rize out of Paul and Anna's wedding mass to propose AGAIN is one of the most chaotic and perfect plot turns in these chapters. Like, he abandons his rosary, ignores the priest, drags his wife to an attic, removes her wedding ring, and then re-enacts their entire wedding ceremony from scratch? This man is wild and I'm here for it. But here's what's actually brilliant about the structure: the author layers so many revelations on top of each other. First we get the childhood meeting story (the dark forest, the forget-me-nots, the stream). Then the dream sequence that blurs memory and imagination with that SECOND boy. Then the wedding scene where Johann cracks open and we learn their wedding dress was over ten years old, worn by more than ten brides, frayed and faded. The war context keeps sneaking in—dog tags replacing love letters, funerals without bodies—so every happy moment has this undercurrent of threat. The circular structure is also satisfying: they revisit their first meeting through Johann's story, then Rize dreams/remembers it herself, and the details align. But that second boy? The author isn't letting us settle. Who was he? Twin? Not twin (Johann has an older brother with a big age gap, not a twin)? It's a question mark floating there that I cannot stop thinking about. And then Johann's sudden shift from sad/restrained to suddenly declaring he wants a child—something feels like it finally clicked into place for him, but we don't know what yet.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because this section just went from personal to existential in about five pages. At the start, the conflict is intimate and manageable: can Rize regain her strength? Can Johann and Rize build a life together? Can she recover her memories without destroying what they've built? These are real questions, but they're contained within the frame of a relationship drama. Then the military truck appears. And suddenly the stakes have exploded outward. The capital has fallen to Falkland. The Prime Minister is hiding in a bunker in THEIR forest. The village is being drafted into supporting the war effort. And an officer has marked Rize as someone he wants to see again. What I find masterful is how the author escalates the tension without ever letting you fully exhale. Even when Johann suggests they leave, Rize refuses—not because she's brave, but because she's built something here. She's found work, a community, a husband who's becoming the partner she always wanted. Leaving means starting over again, and the exhaustion of displacement is its own kind of stakes. The Major Felkner is introduced as a personal threat, but he represents something larger: the war has consequences that reach into the most private corners of people's lives. He doesn't just want her attention—he's a man in uniform with power, and his 'We'll see each other again' isn't romantic. It's a threat wrapped in courtesy. And Johann's response to all of this? He's anxious, he's practical, he suggests leaving—but he's also planning lessons for next year and saving money for a house. The tragedy is that his desire for normalcy is exactly what makes the encroaching war so violating. He wants to be a teacher, a husband, a provider. The war won't let him. The highest stakes moment for me personally is when Rize says she wants to recover her memories and Johann responds with 'I'd rather you didn't remember anything.' That's not just romantic tension—that's a bomb ticking inside their relationship. What is she hiding? What did she do? And why does remembering threaten everything? The author has layered conflicts on top of conflicts and I am HERE for it. Personal, relational, societal—all converging on these two people who just wanted a peaceful life.
... Read More
There's a scene in here that I have to address because it wrecked me in the best way. Rize leaning against Johann's back while he reads, listening to the rustling pages and his breathing, taking in his scent, feeling utterly at peace. Just... that simple moment. After everything—the illness, the memory loss, the fear, the constant state of flux—they've found this quiet happiness and the author lets you actually FEEL it. 'I no longer felt anxious about Johann focusing on his book instead of me.' This line though. This is the same woman who used to watch him pray for hours and feel invisible. Now she can exist beside him in silence and feel content. That's not just romance development—that's emotional healing on both sides. And Johann calling her a devil when she gets too close, then immediately pulling her back against his waist? The man is trying so hard to be good and devout and restrained, but she unravels him completely. 'A devil showing heaven? No, I must be an angel'—her response is so perfectly in character, playful and confident in a way that shows how much SHE'S grown too. But then. The Major. Oh god, the Major. From the moment his eyes lock onto hers across the convoy, the entire emotional temperature of the book drops. 'Disgusting.' That's the word the narration uses and it's so understated for what Rize is feeling. Her body knows danger before her mind can process it. She wants to run 'as if he were an enemy soldier, despite him being one of our own.' And that final exchange—'We'll see each other again'—delivered with that hungry, predatory scan of her body. I actually had to pause the book. The shift from warmth to threat happened so fast and so completely. What makes this section so emotionally devastating is the contrast. You just spent pages feeling safe, feeling hope about their future home, feeling hopeful about her recovery of strength... and then in three paragraphs, everything's poisoned. The author doesn't just take away their peace; he makes you miss it while it's gone.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or