Please Forget Me - Reviews

Please Forget Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The narrative voice here is doing SO MUCH WORK and I need to appreciate it. Rize's internal monologue is this perfect blend of vulnerable, observant, and genuinely funny. She notices things — like how Johann's shyness makes him blush when he whispers 'because I love you' and she finds it endearing rather than weird. Her voice has warmth. When she tells the spy joke at the barn, that's not just dialogue, that's CHARACTER. She's smart enough to defuse tension with humor, self-aware enough to know she looks suspicious, and brave enough to speak up anyway. But Johann's dialogue is WHERE IT GETS INTERESTING. The man barely speaks and when he does, every word is weighted. 'Please don't play the violin again.' Not 'I don't like it.' Not 'it's dangerous.' Just a plea wrapped in 'please' and 'someday I'll explain.' That's a man who is terrified of saying too much. The village women's dialogue is wonderfully distinct — gossiping about poisoned wells and hanging spies with this casual wartime cruelty that feels authentic. 'If he shows up in our village, I'll impale him on a stake and set him on fire.' That's not menace, that's just Tuesday in a warzone. The way the landlady communicates purely through EYE GESTURES toward Rize — no words needed. The author doesn't waste dialogue on exposition because the characters communicate in layers. And Rize's internal voice when she's watching Johann dance — 'like a nymph enchanted by the sun god' — that's lush without being purple. She's a romantic at heart and the prose lets us see that clearly. The dialogue-to-subtext ratio is approximately 1:10 and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
The forget-me-not motif is doing SO much heavy lifting across these chapters and I need to unpack it. Johann first compares Rize's eyes to forget-me-not petals in the dark forest—that's their origin. They make love in a field of them, commemorating the season they fell in love. Then Rize dreams/remembers standing on a slope holding a branch of them. The flower isn't just romantic decoration; it's a symbol of memory itself. Forget-me-not. What happens when you CAN'T remember? What happens when memory becomes unreliable? The whole Rize-Johann dynamic seems built on this tension between remembering and forgetting. Then there's the wedding ring. Johann removes it and throws it away, saying "We don't need this anymore" before re-proposing. What does that mean? Is the old ring tainted by whatever trauma happened during their actual wedding? Or is he stripping away the symbol to rebuild the commitment from scratch, purely? The fact that he recreates the vows word for word suggests the institutional/symbolic part mattered less than the actual promise. The old wedding dress—worn by ten+ brides, frayed, faded from white—is another layer. War stripping away novelty, forcing people to survive on what's left, to find beauty in damaged things. And Johann saying her heart ached seeing her in it, that she was more beautiful than he imagined despite its condition. Love seeing past damage. That's the theme, isn't it? What's broken doesn't have to stay broken. Though I keep coming back to that second boy in the dream—the one who looked like Johann but wasn't him. Some symbols here feel unresolved and I respect that.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... unpack this. The very first paragraph hits you like a freight train — gun pointed, naked bodies, the narrator literally saying what she just did with another man and calling him a disgusting swindler. And then we CUT to a church service like nothing happened. What? Is this a flashback? A dream? I have so many questions and the author is NOT helping. Then we get Rize, this girl with amnesia who married this 'perfect' guy Johann, and everything about her situation is a puzzle piece that doesn't fit anywhere. She doesn't remember how they met. She doesn't remember if they consummated the marriage. She plays the violin like a pro but has no idea she knows how. And Johann keeps telling her not to play, like her playing is some kind of danger. The spy subplot is simmering underneath everything. These women gossiping about Falkland spies poisoning wells — and the landlady literally gives Rize a side-eye like 'you're an outsider too, huh?' That scene where Rize jokes about being the most foolish spy ever? I love her but also my anxiety was through the ROOF. She's standing right in the middle of a warzone paranoia while her own husband is apparently hiding half his life from her. And that opening scene is STILL haunting me. Who WAS that man? What was their history? The way the text describes the venom spreading through her body — that's not just physical disgust, that's trauma language. I need to know what connects chapter one's gunpoint drama to this quiet village existence.
... Read More
I need to talk about Johann because THIS MAN. Up until now, he's been this cold, distant, almost ascetic husband who barely touches Rize unless forced to. All those scenes where he avoids the other women who throw themselves at him, all that weird rigidity — I thought he was just some uptight noble with a grudge against affection. Turns out he's been IN LOVE with Rize this entire time and was too scared or too repressed to show it. The scene where he drops the rosary is so symbolic and I'm still thinking about it. He's been holding onto that thing the whole conversation, and the moment she says 'because you're the only man I love' — CLATTER. It rolls across the floor. His faith literally falls away for her. And then during the intimate scene, when she's hurting and trying to hold it together, he's right there whispering 'I love you' like a mantra. Not just once — over and over. He's trembling, desperate, like he's afraid she'll change her mind. The guy who seemed so composed can't even form coherent sentences anymore. There's this raw vulnerability in him that I didn't expect, and it makes everything he did before — the rejection of other women, the physical distance — make COMPLETE sense. He wasn't unfeeling. He was terrified of wanting her too much. That said, I wish we got more of his POV. His confession is devastating but I want to KNOW what he was thinking during all those years of silence. Why did he marry her? What was he going through? Right now I only have Rize's side of this transformation, and while it's gorgeous, it leaves me wanting more.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying I was genuinely unsettled by Major Felkner after reading these chapters. Not because he's some cartoon villain — well, maybe a little because of that — but because the way he looks at Rize is so viscerally wrong it made my skin crawl. He finds them in the forest while they're literally in the middle of being intimate, and instead of being embarrassed or leaving, he just... watches. Lights a cigarette. Comments on it like he's a critic at an art gallery. That line hit me hard: "So you disappeared only to be found under another man." The entitlement in that voice. The violation. And then later at the bunker, when he calls himself a predator — "when a predator like me comes around" — he's not even hiding it. He knows exactly what he is. But here's the thing that really got me: he never actually touches her. He makes her clean. He makes her wait. He taunts her with words about Johann, about her body, about how insignificant her husband is. It's psychological warfare dressed up as a summons. That's somehow worse than if he'd just been a brute. Johann on the other hand — oh my god, Johann. The moment he hears soldiers have taken Rize, he rushes to the fence in the freezing cold just to make sure she's okay. And when the Major follows them out with a gun, Johann doesn't flinch. He just puts himself between Rize and the threat every single time. "Johann Renner. How did such an insignificant teacher manage to land such a stunning beauty?" and you can just feel Johann's rage bubbling underneath everything he says. He's a man who carries an axe into the forest to protect his wife and would probably die doing it. Their marriage felt so tender in those early forest scenes — the leaf pile, the cold hands, the awkward hesitation about their landlord — and then suddenly it's tested by this external force that wants to destroy it. The fact that they argue after coming back? That felt real. When fear hits a couple, sometimes they turn on each other. Johann packing his bags on day one of the threat, Rize begging him to wait — that wasn't weakness, that was two people terrified of losing each other handling it differently. I need to know what happens next. The Major called her "Rize Einemann" at the end, not Renner. Like he's trying to erase her marriage with language alone. God help them.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is where the whole story basically explodes, and I am NOT okay. It starts with Rize not being able to sleep, and instead of just tossing and turning, she literally asks Johann 'Do you like men?' I laughed out loud at first, because obviously the answer is no, but then it spirals into this huge revelation that Johann has been keeping buried this whole time. He swears to God he loves ONLY her — and gets real dramatic about it, like 'I would even abandon my faith for you.' Which honestly made my heart do this weird thing. Then the chapter pivots HARD into their first intimate scene together, and honestly? The author handled it surprisingly well. It wasn't just fanservice — it was messy and awkward and scary and beautiful all at once. Rize gets hurt during the actual intercourse, tears in her eyes, and Johann immediately stops, looks pale, wipes everything with his shirt (this detail got me for some reason), and tries again more gently. The pain turning into pleasure bit was written without being preachy about it. And that line 'I love you. I love you.' repeated while he's inside her? I swear I need a moment. The chapter ends right as she's starting to feel good, which is either a brilliant cliffhanger or manipulative as hell. Either way, I NEED the next chapter.
... Read More
Okay so this whole arc with Johann and Dana is giving me major 'I want to throw the book across the room but I literally cannot stop reading it' energy. Let me just say — the plot here isn't a straight line. It's a spiral. Every time I think I know where the characters are heading, the author yanks the carpet out and suddenly Johann is on his knees with a rosary, or Dana's wondering who the hell Dana is, or they're making out in a barn while horses watch them. The first-night-after-wedding scene is the climax — literally AND narratively. That whole paragraph where she says "everything went dark before my eyes... but in an instant, everything brightened up again" reads like she's describing both an orgasm and some kind of spiritual awakening simultaneously. Which, honestly? Perfect for a story that keeps blurring the line between sin and salvation. But then — and this is the part that's been living rent-free in my head — he pulls OUT. Just like that. After everything. And she's sitting there thinking about babies in wartime and he's already cleaning her up with his shirt like nothing happened. The emotional whiplash is insane. She wants a child. He wanted abstinence. The war is ongoing. And yet somehow the NEXT chapter starts with him bringing her WILD FLOWERS for the dinner table and she's like "okay sure, let's just go again." The Dana subplot is the real plot twist though. Who IS Dana? Is it a ghost of his past? A sister? A dead wife? A fictional name he made up in his head during his trauma? The text says "there was no one in the village with the name Dana" and "it wasn't a Highland-style name" — so we KNOW it's not local. And Johann's reaction when she asks about it — "pale," claiming he never said it — tells us EVERYTHING without actually telling us anything. And the stable scene! The landlady catching them! The villagers finally dropping the "is he gay?" rumors because apparently oral sex in a barn is the ultimate proof of heterosexuality??? I am not okay with this writing.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in pacing, or at least it tries to be and mostly succeeds. It opens slow — insomnia, valdrian tea mentioned but never made, Johann sitting up in bed, this quiet atmosphere where something is clearly bothering Rize. The dialogue starts almost comical with the 'do you like men' question, and I think that's deliberate, like the author wants to lower your guard before hitting you with actual emotional content. Then it escalates. Fast. One minute they're talking, the next Johann is confessing his undying love, and within a few paragraphs we're in full intimate scene territory. The transition isn't jarring though because the emotional buildup justifies it — Rize explicitly says she wants to 'do everything that only lovers can do' and Johann practically begs for permission. What I found most interesting is how the author handles the actual intercourse scene. Most novels either skip it or make it pure fantasy power fantasy. Here, there's REAL friction — Rize's fear, the physical pain, Johann's panic when he sees she's hurt, the awkward adjustments. Then the shift from pain to pleasure isn't instant; it comes gradually as she relaxes and he reassures her. By the time the chapter ends, she's 'entering a state of' something beautiful, and it trails off mid-sentence which is either a cliffhanger or just... mid-breath. The only critique I have is that the intimate section runs quite long compared to the emotional conversation beforehand. I kind of wish the author had given equal weight to the confession and the physical scene, because both are crucial to understanding these characters.
... Read More
Let's be real for a second— Brigitta is the most entertaining human being in this entire story and I am here for it. She walks in mid-conversation, grabs Rize's arm without asking, inspects it like a piece of produce at the market, and then delivers the most brutal assessment possible: "Pale and corpse-like. Where's the man who wants a corpse?" The landlady has to SCOLD her for being too harsh, but Brigitta's energy is unmatched. She's the kind of character who says exactly what everyone else is thinking but is too polite to voice. And the way the different characters speak? The landlady is warm and practical, dropping wisdom through cow-milking metaphors like it's the most natural thing in the world. The upstairs lady is cheeky and direct, completely unbothered about discussing sexual topics. Brigitta is sharp-tongued but ultimately caring— she's cruel with her words but she's the one who helps Rize connect the dots about her own behavior. The humor in this passage is extraordinary because it comes from total authenticity. These women are discussing Rize's sex life the way you'd discuss crop yields or weather patterns. No shame, no pretense, just pure rural honesty. "Don't squeeze too hard or pull too forcefully, just gently caress it." The landlady is demonstrating on a cow while explaining how to please a man and I cannot stop laughing. And then milk goes everywhere because Rize is too shocked to react properly. But what I love most is how the dialogue reveals character without any narration needed. When Rize admits she sleeps with a cardigan over her pajamas, the entire room's energy shifts. You can practically see their faces distorting in disbelief. The silence that follows says everything. Even Johann's letter is hilarious— he writes about how he can't wait to see his wife and uses language that makes everyone think he's talking about violence until they realize he's being romantic in the most rustic way possible. "My whole body is itching to see you. From the day I return, you must give up walking on two legs." At first I literally thought the man was abusive. Then everyone starts laughing and I feel so stupid. The letter writers' voice is completely different from the village women— more educated, more formal, but also more raw and honest in a way that feels uniquely Johann.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this book is SO rich I could drown in it. Let me just gush about the sensory details because the author clearly puts LOVE into the settings. The opening cathedral bells ringing through the valley while villagers in their finest clothes hurry to mass — you can literally HEAR those bells. You can smell the incense and the damp wool of wet coats. The priest praying for the men at the front while the congregation sniffles, and then the narrator noting all these EMPTY SEATS because all the young men are gone. That single detail — the empty seats — does more worldbuilding than any exposition dump ever could. The war isn't a background element, it's a PHYSICAL absence in the room. And then the village square, post-service, all the festival prep chaos. Kids surrounding old grandpas who are supposed to be the band, making discordant violin sounds. The air must feel thick with that particular wartime festival energy — everyone trying to celebrate because if they stop celebrating they'll remember the war is still happening. But my FAVORITE worldbuilding detail is the turnips. The women gossiping about how turnips near the Argen River are turning black and withering. I laughed out loud and then immediately felt guilty because it's actually horrifying. Poisoned land. A spy. Cattle dropping dead. This is a world where the very ground is poisoned and the border is a river that's now a frontline. The domestic scene of churning milk while women gossip about agricultural destruction — that contrast is MASTERFUL. The farmhouse attic where Rize and Johann sleep, the barn with the newborn calf, the church belfry — every location feels lived-in and specific. This isn't a generic war story setting, it's a PLACE with dirt under its fingernails.
... Read More
There's so much going on underneath this chapter that I want to unpack. The rosary is the obvious one — Johann clutches it through the entire conversation like a security blanket, and when Rize finally convinces him with her words, it RATTLES to the floor. Faith versus desire, duty versus love. But here's the thing: Johann doesn't reject his faith. He just drops it. He doesn't say 'I no longer believe in God.' He says 'I would even abandon my faith for you.' The willingness is what matters. The rosary falling is a choice, not a renunciation. Then there's the blood. When Rize gets hurt during intercourse, Johann's immediate reaction isn't anger or frustration — it's horror. 'The current Johann looked paler than the moonlight, as if he were frightened.' He uses his own shirt to clean her up. This is a man who would rather destroy himself than cause his wife pain, and that's the core theme of their entire relationship so far: Johann's love is expressed through restraint, and Rize's love is expressed through reaching out. The light and dark imagery throughout is also worth noting — the attic room, the moonlight, the darkness where Johann can't find the entrance, Rize having to guide him with her own fingers. It's almost biblical in its imagery. And the heaven/hell motif: Rize says she 'saw heaven' during her first climax, and Johann calls himself a devil. But who's really the devil here? The one who suffers for love, or the one who's been denying it? By the end, when Rize is 'entering a state of' bliss, the chapter leaves us with this image of two broken people finally becoming whole. And I'm here for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the pacing of chapter 60 through 67 because WOW. The author is a sneaky bastard when it comes to tension. Let me walk through how they built this. The chapters open slow — almost leisurely. Harvest season, rationing, a walk through the forest, gathering walnuts. It's domestic, almost cozy. You think, OK, this is a story about survival and love in wartime. Slice of life with stakes. And then — WHAM. Rize gets caught in a compromising position with Johann in the middle of the forest by a man who has already been watching her for two months. The shift from peaceful to predatory happens in three paragraphs. Three. I actually gasped. After that initial shock, the author lets you breathe. The conversation with Mrs. Bauer gives you exposition about Major Felkner's reputation — he doesn't touch married women, he ignored Anna, he's basically a rumor with a uniform. You think, okay, there might be a way out of this. The rumors save them. That's a false sense of security and I HATED it for being so effective. Then two days later — TWO DAYS — the soldiers come. Deliberately when Johann is away. The author didn't even waste time giving you relief. It's immediate escalation. The truck ride, the descent into the bunker, the windowless room. Each beat ramps up the dread without a single action sequence. It's psychological pacing at its finest. And the ending — Johann and Rize arguing about whether to leave, Johann packing on the first day, the soldier's message that the Major will summon her again — it cuts off right when the conflict between them peaks. A cliffhanger that's not about physical danger but about the fragility of their relationship under pressure. Masterful. The author controls my heartbeat like an instrument. I couldn't look away. I stayed up way too late.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or