Nothing But a Vulgar Game - Reviews

Nothing But a Vulgar Game
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about the absolute voltage between Lisa and Renato? It's not romance, not even close. It's something far more volatile and addictive. Every scene with them crackles. When he corners her at the servant's door, his voice dripping with that 'cold amusement,' my heart was pounding. She's terrified of him, rightfully so, yet she doesn't flee. She stands her ground with those 'upturned eyes' full of timid anger. That push-and-pull is exquisitely painful to watch. He prods her, exposes her vulnerabilities (the drawing, her poverty), and she recoils but also reveals. It's a brutal form of intimacy. And then there's her soft spot for Raoul. 'My brother likes it when I draw for him.' Such a quiet, genuine line amid all the hostility. It shows what he's stripping away from her—not just her possessions, but her small, private joys. The emotional core here isn't about love; it's about power, shame, and the fragile dignity of someone trying to hold onto tiny pieces of themselves. That moment in the guest room where her hands sweat on the rough paper? I felt that visceral anxiety. It's not about sketching; it's about him noticing the last evidence of her inner life and twisting it into an insult. I'm emotionally wrecked and utterly captivated.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about the pocket watch scene because oh my god this man Renato is absolutely ruthless in the most subtle way possible. Let me lay it out: he deliberately leaves his pocket watch on the table. Not an accident. Not clumsiness. He does it on purpose, knowing full well Lisa will come in to clean and will inevitably come across it. Then he walks back in right when she's holding it, watches her absolutely lose her mind with panic, and plays along with the implication that she might have been trying to steal it. Classic gaslight move, honestly. And then he catches it falling with this "unhurried ease" like he's been waiting for this exact moment this whole time. The text literally says: "The intention was simple. He had left the watch behind as a pretext to return later. The thought that a theft might occur had never crossed his mind." That is SO chilling. He never thought she'd steal it because he already knew her. He knew she'd panic. He knew she'd be terrified. He wanted to see her squirm and he got exactly what he wanted. But here's what really got me — after she glares at him, something shifts. She doesn't just accept it. She stares back. And the text says: "The violet eyes that had glared at him, burning with suppressed indignation, refused to leave his mind." That's not a man who's uninterested. That's a man who just found something that actually fascinates him. This entire sequence — from the corridor incident with the meat, to this watch scene — it's building this predatory dynamic between them. But it's not just physical dominance. Renato is intellectually stalking her. He's studying her reactions the way she studies his.
... Read More
I need to talk about how almost nobody in this book actually says what they mean, and how brilliant that is. Take the countess. When she tells Lisa they can stay, she frames it as if she's doing them a favor to herself: 'the right thing to do is to help them out of a sense of duty.' Not 'I apologize for the confusion.' Not 'you shouldn't have had to endure that.' Just: I am choosing to be charitable, and you should feel lucky. The dialogue here is this perfectly calibrated performance. Karolina speaks in the language of grace, but every sentence is a reminder of who holds power. And Lisa's response? 'Thank you.' Three words. That's all she gives. Not because she's grateful, but because she's read the room her entire life and knows that any other response would cost her. She's standing there knowing she was lied to, knowing her fate was decided without a single word from her, and she says thank you because survival has taught her that gratitude is the currency of the powerless. Then there's Renato. His dialogue is almost entirely polite surface. 'I'm sorry to have come alone.' 'Simply having the chance to build a friendship is more than enough.' Every line is correct, measured, designed to give nothing away. But the narration undercuts it constantly — 'socializing was entirely against his nature,' 'the warmth of it sat uneasily on him.' His words are armor. The reader gets the truth through the gaps in his courtesy. Smila is the outlier — genuinely sweet, genuinely simple. 'Mother, what happened?' 'I knew it… I knew Mother would never abandon children in need.' She means every word. And that makes her both the most innocent character and the most tragically positioned. She's being trained to perform kindness while her mother performs charity, and she genuinely believes it's all the same thing. The narrative voice itself is worth mentioning — it's close third person, mostly anchored to Lisa, but it shifts to Renato in Chapter 1 without any announcement. It just happens, like the perspective is a ghost passing between bodies. And the prose has this dry, almost clinical edge that somehow makes the emotional moments hit harder. No purple prose. No forced drama. Just observation, precise and unsparing.
... Read More
Okay so. The Lisa-drawing scene. I had to stop reading for a second because my heart actually skipped. The way Renato corners her — he just... knows all her buttons. Titan's death. Smila's secret letter. He lays them out like he's reading a grocery list and Lisa is just standing there trembling because every escape route is blocked. And her internal monologue when she's walking to his room? "At least two. Or perhaps three or four." She's counting the shackles like a prisoner. That line alone tells you everything about where she stands with him. But here's what really caught me — the Marsimo meeting. Renato's basically conducting surveillance on his own fiancée's boyfriend and he knows it. "It felt uncomfortably like using cunning to gather evidence of an affair." And yet he does it anyway. Because he's Renato. The Count is playing both sides without knowing it, and Renato is playing the Count while pretending to be the compliant suitor. Three layers of performance happening simultaneously in that tea room and I was leaning forward the entire time. The chapter ends with Lisa climbing those stairs in her slippers, the grandfather clock counting every second, and the moonlight exposing her. Chills. Actual chills. Whatever Renato has planned for when she reaches his door, I am not okay with any of us.
... Read More
I am genuinely shook by Renato's reaction when he saw Lisa smiling at him. Like—read the room, bestie. The woman is literally kneeling on the floor after being terrified half to death, trying to defuse tension with a fumble of a smile because SHE'S TRAUMATIZED, not because she's trying to flatter you. And his response? He physically grabs her face and calls her a brazen little thing? My blood was BOILING. What makes this even worse is the sheer impossibility of Lisa's position. She keeps catching Renato at her most vulnerable moments—first the study incident where she looked up at him with terror in her eyes, and now this. She's trapped between not knowing how to behave around him and whatever he perceives her actions as. The forced smile was her trying to survive social interaction, and he completely misread it as something manipulative. That's not romance, that's emotional violence wrapped in handsome packaging. But honestly? What I found more heartbreaking was how Lisa just takes it. She apologizes. She explains herself. She even thanks him for saving her from the beast earlier, like she's still trying to be reasonable with someone who clearly finds her existence irritating. Her internal monologue where she calls herself a clown performing—I felt that in my chest. Anyone who's ever had to shrink themselves to survive in a space where they don't belong would understand that moment viscerally. And yet... there's something there between them that refuses to stay buried. The way the narration describes their eye contact, how the air shifts, how her breathing becomes difficult—that's not nothing. It's toxic, sure, but it's electric too. Is this love? Is this obsession? I don't know and I'm here for it.
... Read More
What a tightly wound coil of a plot this is! The moment with Titan isn't just a dramatic incident; it's the first thread pulled in a sweater that's about to unravel completely. Renato killing the horse feels less like an act of cruelty and more like a ruthless assertion of control—a statement that his judgment supersedes even compassion. But then he covers for Lisa to her father? That's a classic narrative misdirection. It throws you off balance. Is he a gentleman, or is he playing a much longer game? The secret letter from Smila to the Servillo boy is the other mainspring here. It transforms the setting from a simple estate into a pressure cooker of hidden alliances and impending scandal. The plot isn't just moving forward; it's spiraling. Every interaction, from the blizzard to the dusty guest room, feels like a move in a chess match where the pieces are people's reputations and lives. I'm left wondering how many of these seemingly minor conflicts will converge. That final line—'if she could take this paper home safely, it would be the first time she had ever drawn on actual paper'—is a tiny plot point, but it's devastating. It hints at a backstory of deprivation and secret passions that is begging to be uncovered. This story knows exactly how to tease out the dark seams of its characters' lives.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this section is so suffocating I could barely breathe sometimes. Let me start with the blizzard comparison — Renato's study might as well be the blizzard-swept pasture hillside from earlier. "The sofa, plush enough to melt into, was as terrifying as the blizzard-swept pasture hillside." That's the kind of line that makes you appreciate the author's skill. Comfort and terror occupying the same space. And then Lisa's journey through the manor at night — this is where the worldbuilding really earns its keep. The kitchen. The open hall. The polished staircase. She's navigating familiar territory like it's enemy territory now. "She passed through the kitchen and came out into the open hall. She kept to the shadows as she circled the outer edge." You can see her mapping every exit, every shadow, every inch of ground she has to cross to reach him. The manor itself becomes a character — vast, watchful, indifferent. Then there's Renato's internal landscape, which is honestly scarier than any physical setting. "A sticky curiosity lingered in a corner of his mind. Who was giving her grief right now, what cold corner was she wandering through, whether her meals were still slop..." He thinks he's analyzing his own motivations but the reader sees it clearly — he's obsessed. His own self-awareness doesn't save him from it. "So I'm no different from anyone else after all. Renato's self-mockery was dry." The contrast between the warm, excessive refreshments at the tea table and the cold dread radiating from everything else? Masterful. And Marsimo's description — "well-fed, rounded build that spoke of comfortable circumstances" — tells you everything about class and power without a single exposition paragraph.
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely vicious in the best way. You get this long, comfortable dinner scene with Renato and the Maldinis—polite conversation, engagement talk, the whole boring aristocratic routine—and then BAM you're suddenly in a dark hallway at midnight watching a starving boy eat carrots off the floor while his sister tries to hide them from a guest. The tonal whiplash is INTENTIONAL and it works so well. The author builds this slow burn with Renato throughout the dinner. Every detail is slightly off—the napkin sliding, the rouge stain, the hair in Smila's mouth. Small irritations that escalate. You think he's just a neat freak. Then you learn it goes deeper: military training, exile, years of communal living that forged this rigid mental structure. The scuff on his shoe isn't just dirt—it's a violation of order that his trauma response can't process. By the time we reach the passage scene, all that built-up tension has to go somewhere, and it lands directly on Lisa. The orphanage reveal is perfectly timed. Renato could have said anything—comment on her hair, ask about her work, make a rude remark about her status. Instead he hits her with THE thing she's most vulnerable about right now. And then he just... waits. Lets the silence stretch. Lets her squirm. "Rather starve than eat something off the floor?" he asks, completely detached, like he's commenting on weather. The ending with "his trouser crease was sharp as a blade" is such a sharp image to close on. Everything about Renato is weaponized—even his clothing. And Lisa is on her knees while he stands above her. The visual composition alone tells the whole story.
... Read More
The shoe. The fucking shoe. It shows up THREE TIMES in this text and each time it means something different. First, Lisa steps on Renato's shoe and ruins the polish—that's the moment their power dynamic is established. She's beneath him literally and figuratively. Then during dinner, Renato can't stop thinking about that scuff mark, like his mind is physically haunted by being touched by someone below him. And finally, the piece of meat pinned UNDER his shoe in the passage, and Lisa has to KNEEL to get it. The imagery is almost unbearable in its consistency. And the silver hair! Lisa's mother specifically warned her that the platinum blonde would bring her humiliation. It became a secret she hides under a cloth while working, and Renato PULLS IT OFF like he's unveiling a rare specimen. His line "Why are you still here instead of at the orphanage?" isn't just cruel—it's him testing whether she knows she's disposable. The orphanage was supposed to be her escape, and now he's reminding her it's gone. The mint leaves are probably my favorite symbol though. Fresh green leaves, tender, used to wipe dirt off a shoe, then scattered on her head. Life and purity used as cleaning tools and discarded waste. It's such a precise image for Lisa's entire existence in this household—her youth and dignity constantly being used up and thrown away. "Silver hair alone got you halfway with a man"—her mother's advice about money and survival. The irony is that Lisa is surrounded by people who see her as either currency or invisible, and Renato is the first person who sees her as something more than both. A specimen to study. A puzzle to solve. Which should terrify her even more, because curiosity from someone like him is just another form of consumption.
... Read More
I need to talk about how perfectly Renato speaks because WOW. His dialogue is so sparse but every word cuts. "Move." Two syllables and Lisa is trembling against the wall. "Your meal... are you going to continue?" Said while watching her kneel in the dirt, completely deadpan, and I swear to god I laughed out loud because that is SO him. The narrative voice during the dinner scene is also incredible. Renato's internal monologue about eating being "the process of placing matter containing nutrients into the mouth and chewing" while forcing himself to stretch it to thirty minutes of social performance? That's not just good writing—that's a whole character study in one paragraph. He's a soldier in a nobleman's body, trapped in a world where efficiency is rudeness and politeness is performance. Compare that to Lisa's dialogue—her lines are basically non-existent. She says "No. I was about to clean up" and "Could you move your foot for a moment" and that's it. But her INTERNAL voice is so loud. The narration follows her thoughts constantly: "What on earth does he want from me," "This man is entirely different," "She had long thought she had flushed whatever self-respect she had down the drain." The stable boy's dialogue is one line: "Hey, Raoul" said in a swaggering tone, and then he knocks the bowl out of his hands. Minimalist, brutal, perfectly captures that kind of casual cruelty that kids display when they know no one will punish them. And Raoul barely speaks at all—just "Sister..." and refusing to take her bowl. The silence says everything. "Nothing like anyone I've known"—Lisa's final thought before the chapter ends. That's the dialogue that matters most. Not what anyone says, but what she realizes about the man standing above her.
... Read More
The dialogue in this excerpt is razor-sharp. Every line feels like a parry or a thrust. Renato's voice is distinctly crafted: short, cruel, laced with sarcastic politeness. 'You're friends with that sloppy maid?' The insult isn't shouted; it's delivered with a sneer, making it cut deeper. His questions aren't inquiries; they're interrogations designed to provoke and expose. 'Are you performing poverty on purpose?' What a devastating line. It shows his complete misunderstanding of her reality, framing her survival as a pathetic performance. Lisa's voice, conversely, is full of half-truths and defensive silences. 'It's a little difficult to say.' 'No! I'm terrible at it.' Her dialogue reveals her anxiety and desire to shrink away. The exchange about the drawing paper is a masterpiece of subtext. He asks why she carries it; she explains it was wasted. He twists it into an accusation of begging for pity. The dialogue never states the obvious. It circles the truth, poking at it with poisoned words. Even the background chatter in the kitchen—Mel's complaints, the cook's grumbling—feels authentic and adds texture. The author's narrative voice is tight, restrained, almost clinical, which makes the emotional explosions in the dialogue hit even harder. I'm obsessed with how each character's speech pattern reflects their power and fear.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about how the author writes atmosphere like they're directing a film? The entire sequence from Lisa setting out into the snow to the storm closing in reads like a series of widescreen shots. The wind howling through gaps, her teeth chattering, the grey sky pressing lower until it feels touchable—this isn't just backdrop, it's a character. The weather actively works against her at every turn. First the cold wind she wasn't prepared for, then the snow that thickens just as they reach the lodge, then the darkness that falls while they're still stranded. The environment is basically the antagonist in this chapter. And the lodge itself! A single-room hut, bare inside and out, well-stocked with firewood but nothing else. You can picture it—just rough wooden walls, a fireplace, straw on the floor. It's the kind of place that exists only in winter, abandoned the rest of the year, which adds this haunting loneliness to everything. Two people trapped in a space that was never meant to hold anyone. The horse's anguished cries echoing through the wall while Lisa tries to sleep—God, that detail. The gunpowder smell hitting her the moment she opens the stable door. These are the kinds of sensory specifics that make a scene stick with you long after you've finished reading. The author doesn't just tell you it's cold or scary, you feel it in your bones.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or