Nothing But a Vulgar Game - Reviews

Nothing But a Vulgar Game
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing here is masterful—it's staccato, sharp, and leaves you gasping for air. The author knows exactly when to strike and when to pull back. Take the sequence starting with Titan's death. It's immediate, violent, and then… silence. Renato walks into the hut without a word. The howling wind freezes everything. Bam. Scene over. No lingering, no exposition. It's jarring and perfect. Then we cut to Lisa alone in the snow, processing. The structure moves from high-intensity confrontation to quieter, simmering scenes in the kitchen and study, but the tension never really drops. It just changes frequency. The eavesdropping scene with the Count and Renato is a brilliant breather that actually raises more questions. Why did he cover for her? What's the real dynamic with her father? The pacing mimics Lisa's own heartbeat—racing during confrontations, slowing into anxious observation. There are no flat spots. Even the mundane task of dusting becomes taut because we know Renato could appear at any moment. The chapter endings are particularly effective. We leave Lisa with damp, ruined paper and a sense of profound violation. The narrative doesn't rush; it prowls. It lets moments breathe just long enough for the dread to settle in before the next shock arrives. It's engineered suspense at its finest.
... Read More
I need to talk about Anna because nobody is giving her enough credit for being an absolute menace. Here's this girl who just lost her position as Miss Smila's primary attendant, gets reassigned to 'other duties,' and instead of processing it, she immediately starts flexing her new authority on Lisa. The hierarchy stuff—"my job is looking after Miss Smila, all of it"—this is classic bully behavior wrapped in institutional language. She's making sure Lisa knows exactly where she sits in the pecking order, and she's using Miss Smila's trust in Lisa as leverage to force her into delivering secret messages. And don't even get me started on the letter delivery. Anna essentially conscripts Lisa into doing her errand while she stays warm and safe, and then adds the threat of "this is a secret you can't tell anyone" on top of it. That's not a request, that's coercion dressed up as favoritism. But the real stakes here aren't just about servant politics. Lisa is walking into a snowstorm, alone, on unfamiliar terrain, carrying a secret message to a noble family's son, with a horse that nearly tramples her and then gets killed because of it. Every single conflict in this chapter cascades from that initial decision to say yes to Anna. The physical danger, the emotional humiliation by Renato, the death of Titan—all of it traces back to a woman in a manor hallway who decided Lisa was an easy target. I'm genuinely worried about what happens when Lisa has to return to the manor with news that her errand resulted in a dead horse and a detained noble heir. The stakes have never felt higher.
... Read More
Okay so Lisa. This girl. First impression: she's basically invisible on purpose. Not because she wants to be, but because being seen meant trouble. Her violet eyes, silver hair — she looks like she belongs to nobility, which in this world is apparently a death sentence for a maid's daughter. That detail about her reflection rippling in the corridor window hit me hard. She literally doesn't recognize herself as someone worth looking at. But the real meat is between her and Raoul. Twelve years old, polio, hands blackened from labor, crouching on cold stone steps with his bundle strapped to his back. He hadn't even cried while packing. And then he gets told they might stay — and his first reaction isn't joy, it's pressing his fist to his eye corner like he's ashamed of the relief flooding out of him. Here's what killed me: Raoul thinks they're being kicked out because of him. 'He seemed to have figured out that both of them were being sent away because of him.' A twelve-year-old boy carrying a thousand pounds of guilt on his small shoulders. And Lisa? She holds little resentment toward him. Not because she's some saint, but because they're both 'unwanted burdens equally.' Their bond isn't dramatic. It's quiet. It's devastating. Then there's Countess Karolina — oh man, this woman is a masterpiece of controlled cruelty dressed up as kindness. She reverses her own order with a smile, demands gratitude without offering an apology, and lets Lisa stand there realizing she's been lied to while maintaining the most gracious expression imaginable. 'Shouldn't a misunderstanding come with an apology?' Lisa thinks, and I literally yelled at my screen. The countess doesn't just withhold kindness — she weaponizes it. Makes charity into a performance where the recipient is expected to feel honored to be tolerated. And Renato — barely three chapters in and already he notices Lisa. Already his interest sharpens when the household's fragile composure cracks. He looks at her the way someone looks at a puzzle they want to solve. That final image of him standing above her, pristine and composed, while she's on her knees… I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
I honestly can't stop thinking about Sheila because this woman is a force of nature and I love her for it. So Lisa gets reassigned to Smila's study, which seems like a genuinely kind thing Smila is doing — or at least, Smila thinks she's being kind. And then Sheila descends like a scolding hawk: "Why does that girl have absolutely no warmth about her?" "If you can't be friendly, at least smile. And do something about your hair." And then she PINCHES Lisa. Like physically grabs her and pinches her. This is the head maid of a noble household and she is out here physically assaulting her staff over facial expressions. The most devastating part is when Lisa actually tries. She takes off her head cloth, smooths her hair, and practices smiling. The text describes it perfectly: "The forced expression on her pale face was like a clown caked in white powder." SHEILA LOOKS AT HER AND GOES "That's the best you can do?" Lisa doesn't even argue. She just says "H, how about this?" and tries again. She's been conditioned so thoroughly that she doesn't even have the energy to resist. Which makes me wonder — is this really about hospitality? Or is Sheila policing Lisa for something else? For having that defiance Renato noticed? And then there's Renato's actual dialogue with Lisa, which is barely any dialogue at all. "You called for me." "I was tidying it." "Tidying it... of course." Three sentences. Three sentences and he's completely dismantled her sense of safety in that room. The contrast between Sheila's aggressive verbal violence and Renato's surgical quiet violence — one yells at you, the other makes you question whether you're being accused of a crime you didn't commit.
... Read More
I am not okay. I am genuinely not okay after reading the Raoul scene. Lisa and her brother sharing leftovers on a windowsill, him secretly checking to make sure she didn't give him all the meat, thinking it's a win when they each get one piece? That is the most heartbreaking domestic scene I have ever read in a novel and I did NOT sign up for this. And then the stable boy comes and destroys it all. Just... swaggers over and KNOCKS THE BOWL OUT OF HIS HANDS. Like it's nothing. Like those carrots and that scrap of meat don't represent hours of work and genuine hope. Lisa's reaction—furious, trembling, stamping her feet—only for her stomach to betray her by GROWLING during all of it. She's so hungry her body won't even let her have her anger in peace. But Raoul picking up the second carrot and putting it straight in his mouth because "there's no dirt on it"? I cannot. The fact that he's DESENSITIZED to this. That humiliation is a luxury he can't afford. Hunger overrides everything. And Renato WITNESSES THIS. Standing there in his perfect shoes, watching a starving boy scrape bread crumbs off a dusty floor. What breaks my heart most is Lisa's choice to send Raoul inside. She makes him go eat while she stays and faces this stranger. "I'll handle things here"—she's seventeen or whatever and she's already learned to protect her brother by absorbing every blow herself. And then Renato pulls off her head cloth and looks at her silver hair like she's something he's been waiting to find. Not kind. Not cruel. Just... interested. Which is somehow the most dangerous thing of all.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or