Nothing But a Vulgar Game - Reviews

Nothing But a Vulgar Game
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This story is about invisibility. Not the magical kind — the social kind. The kind where you're physically present but treated as furniture, as expense, as a problem to be managed. Lisa's silver hair and violet eyes are the first symbol that hits you. She looks noble. She looks like she should belong to a different world. But she's the daughter of a maid, and in this society, appearance that contradicts status is a liability. 'None of it suited the daughter of a maid. That was a clear disadvantage.' Her beauty isn't an asset — it's evidence that she doesn't know her place, and that makes people resentful. There's a deep critique here about how appearance and class interact, how certain bodies are read as threatening simply by existing in the wrong social space. The travel bundle as a snowman is another one I can't stop thinking about. Snowmen melt. They're temporary structures made of the cold, designed to disappear. Lisa is being prepared for the same fate — to be packed up, moved, and eventually dissolved into whatever system (the orphanage) will absorb her. Then there's the whole theme of performance. Every character in this manor is performing: Renato performing warmth for a marriage negotiation, the countess performing maternal charity while quietly deciding two children's fates, Smila performing innocent admiration while being shaped into her mother's replica. The question the book seems to be asking is: when everyone is performing, who gets to be real? And the answer so far is: nobody. Except maybe Lisa, whose lack of performance is read as 'no warmth about her.' Her genuine reaction to betrayal — silence, withdrawal — is pathologized as personality defect rather than recognized as rational response to abuse. Raoul's cracked, blackened hands are the ultimate symbol here. While everyone else is polishing appearances, his body bears the honest record of labor. He is the only character whose exterior matches his reality. And he's twelve years old, carrying guilt for existing.
... Read More
This opening chapter is a masterclass in atmosphere. Let me start with the very first image: Lisa's travel bundle, described as looking 'something like a snowman that had been kicked apart.' A snowman. A thing made of snow — cold, temporary, easily destroyed. That's her entire life reduced to a lumpy, misshapen package in an unheated corner. Genius. The room itself barely catches sun. The sky threatens to open up. This is winter, this is exile, this is a world that has physically frozen around these characters and won't thaw. Even the radiator beside the curved staircase sends up 'a faint shimmer of heat' that distorts the air — and through that distorted air, Lisa's figure wavers and bends like she might not be real at all. She's becoming invisible in the literal sense. But here's what really builds this world: it's not grand descriptions of castles or politics. It's the details. The unpaved road that soils Renato's shoes. The dry winter garden. The broad-shouldered head cook barking orders. The sound of footsteps 'like a wide rake scraping up dead leaves.' These are the sounds and textures of a household running on fear and hierarchy. And the political backdrop — riots, coups, whispers of the aristocracy being abolished — it hangs over everything like incoming snow. You don't need to know the full history because you can feel it in how desperately the Maldinis are performing normalcy. The engagement party disguised as a business meeting. The charity work that's actually reputation management. The way everyone moves through spaces like they're bracing for impact. The most chilling scene has to be Lisa being pushed out to the back courtyard. Sheila's glare alone feels like a scolding. Lisa follows 'like livestock being led to slaughter, pulled by an invisible leash she couldn't see.' That invisible leash — that's the entire social structure of this world. You don't need chains when everyone knows their place.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this chapter made me feel trapped in real time. The first section — Renato summoning Lisa to draw — is all tension and dread, and it moves quickly, almost claustrophobically. Then we cut to Renato's perspective and suddenly the pace stretches out. Days pass. Weeks. The winter sun shines. Workers shovel snow. And it feels tedious because Renato is bored and that boredom is palpable on the page. "The days at the Maldini household passed slowly, as expected." I felt that slowness. I sat with it. And then — BAM — he runs into Lisa in the sitting room and the pace snaps back into something frantic. The Marsimo tea scene is longer, more deliberate. Renato is playing a social game and the pacing reflects that — polite exchanges, measured dialogue, the pouring of tea, the careful observation. Every line of small talk is a line of investigation. And Smila's nervousness is measured in tremors — her hand shaking, her eyes avoiding his, her sudden excuse to leave. The chapter is essentially three movements: the drawing demand (fast/dread), the waiting period (slow/aching), the encounter and aftermath (medium/tense). And then Lisa's walk to Renato's room at night resets the tempo entirely. It's nearly wordless action — footsteps, breathing, counting chimes, heart racing. No internal monologue, just her body moving through space toward danger. "She counted eight chimes to herself." Eight. The grandfather clock becomes a countdown. And the very last image — her foot touching the moonlit floor, the resonant chime rising through the wood — is the perfect cliffhanger. Not a cliffhanger of action but of anticipation. What happens NEXT.
... Read More
There's a reason Titan couldn't survive this story, and it has nothing to do with veterinary science. The horse represents everything Lisa clings to—something magnificent and wild that chose to stay near her, that carried her through danger, that she tried desperately to protect. When Renato euthanizes Titan, he's not just killing an animal. He's dismantling the one thing in this chapter that belonged to Lisa and made her feel capable of caring for something. The way he does it in secret, while she sleeps, is almost more cruel than if he'd done it face to face. He denied her the chance to say goodbye, to believe there might have been a way to save him. Then there's the hair braiding. Lisa spent so much time on it—learning from Anna, fixing it in the window glass reflection, standing proud under a hostile stare. And Renato sees that careful grooming and interprets it as calculation, as some kind of deliberate attempt to attract him. The tragedy is that her hair was armor, a way of maintaining dignity in a world that strips it from her constantly. To him, it reads as flirtation. To her, it was survival. And the repeated kneeling—Lisa on her knees twice in this chapter, looking up at him both times. First literally fallen, then physically forced into that position when he grabs her jaw. There's something deeply symbolic about this recurring posture. She is always below him, literally and figuratively, seeing the world from the whites-of-her-eyes angle. The story keeps putting her in positions where she has to look up to survive.
... Read More
Beneath the surface drama, this passage is brimming with symbolic weight. Titan, the 'finest horse,' represents more than just wealth; he symbolizes natural beauty and strength brutally sacrificed to maintain control and order. His death in the cold mirrors the death of warmth and spontaneity in this household. Renato embodies a rigid, aristocratic coldness that destroys anything imperfect or uncontrolled. Then there's the paper. So much hinges on those sheets of drawing paper. They represent Lisa's inner world, her secret creativity, her attempt to impose color and meaning on a drab existence. The fact that it's 'wasted' paper from a young lady who doesn't value it highlights the class divide—the elite discard what the poor would kill for. Her desire to take it home 'to sketch a little' is a tiny act of rebellion, a claim to an identity beyond servitude. Renato noticing and mocking it is an attack on her very soul. The winter itself is a powerful symbol of emotional sterility and isolation. Everyone is trapped in their roles, frozen like the landscape. Yet, Lisa's drawing is a faint, persistent signal of life and feeling struggling to emerge from the ice. It's a poignant symbol of art as survival.
... Read More
I need to process this dream sequence because it's not just creepy for the sake of being creepy — it's loaded with meaning that sticks with you. "What it had been feeding its young was its own organs." The mother insect literally sustains her children by consuming herself from the inside out. And Renato wakes up from this dream shaken, looking at his own scars — the cigarette burns on his shoulders, the cuts on his thighs — as though they're connected to something primal and terrible. Then the flashback hits: abandoned in a jungle by people who were supposed to protect him. Rotten food. A child soldier fighting snakes with a machete. The same hand that holds a pocket watch with effortless grace was once clawing through rot to survive. So what is this saying about Renato? Is he the mother insect now — feeding on himself to sustain something? Or is he the larva, the thing that devours what sustains it? He calls Lisa's defiance interesting. He says she "gets under his skin." His trauma clearly runs deep and old, and he's wearing this polished, composed exterior like armor. The scars are literally described as "a constellation" — as though his suffering has become a map he navigates by. And then Lisa herself. Abandoned by the orphanage. Thrown out of the manor one day, pulled back in the next like she has no agency over her own life. Both of them are hollowed out in different ways. One was consumed from within. The other is constantly at risk of being stepped on and forgotten. The insect image follows Renato even after he wakes — "the sensation of something collapsing emptily under his fingers lingered as an afterimage." He can't shake it. Neither can I.
... Read More
'My ears are freezing.' She cups her hands over her stiffening ears. The sound of falling snow grew muffled, and only her own labored breathing grew louder. This line. This single sentence marks the exact moment the chapter pivots from a mundane errand into full-blown survival mode. One paragraph she's worried about Anna's passive-aggressive comments and whether she dressed warmly enough. The next, a massive creature is launching itself at her from the slope and she's falling backward onto frozen ground praying she doesn't die. The pacing here is masterful because the author doesn't telegraph the danger. There's no creeping dread building over multiple paragraphs—Lisa is just walking, thinking about her hair and the cold, and then WHAM. The narrative equivalent of tripping over a ledge. And what's brilliant is how the author uses the weather itself as a pacing device. The snow starts as a light sleet, then thickens rapidly, trapping them in the lodge and making escape impossible. Each escalation of the storm raises the stakes without a single word of exposition. Then the horse dies. Just like that. All that buildup—Lisa worrying about Titan, Renato's silence, the long evening of waiting—and the animal is gone in one gunshot. The chapter doesn't linger on it either. It cuts straight to Lisa's reaction and her accusation, which is exactly the right choice. Letting it drag would have killed the momentum. Instead we end on pure conflict, raw and unresolved, and I absolutely need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about how Renato picks off mint leaves and uses them to wipe his shoe after Lisa steps on it? THAT IS SO CRUELEND THEN HE FLICKS THE LEAVES ON HER HEAD LIKE THAT'S THE FINAL INSULT AND I ALMOST CHOKED. The way he helps her up would've been almost romantic if he wasn't literally using her to clean his shoe. Classic Renato energy—calculated, controlled, devastating. But honestly the most interesting relationship dynamic here isn't even the Lisa-Renato one. It's Renato and Smila. He's sitting through this entire engagement dinner pretending to care while internally complaining that she's "flat, tasteless water." And you can tell he's NOT trying to be mean—he's genuinely trying to be polite, squeezing out patience he doesn't have, but there's absolutely nothing behind his eyes. That's somehow worse. At least if he was openly hostile, you'd know where you stand. Then there's the scene with Raoul and that stable boy. Lisa throwing her bowl back at the bully and then watching her brother pick carrots off the floor while someone's standing RIGHT THERE. Renato watches ALL OF IT. He doesn't intervene. He just... observes. Like she's some specimen. And then when he finally speaks, he mentions the orphanage like he's testing a trigger and watching the reaction. Which he does. Lisa's hands shake. He notices. Of course he notices. "Something deep inside her screamed. Get away. This man is dangerous." Lisa's survival instincts are the only thing keeping her alive in this house and honestly? She's right. Renato is not a good man but he's also not conventionally evil. He's worse than that. He's indifferent and curious, which is a combination that will ruin Lisa.
... Read More
I need to talk about how this passage moves because the pacing is absolutely brutal in the best way. It starts with Lisa retching on the floor. Not metaphorically — actual physical rejection, bile, tears, lips bitten until they bleed. She hasn't even processed what happened to her yet and we're immediately plunged into Renato's nightmare of insects devouring their own mothers. From vomiting to cannibalistic dreams to child soldier flashbacks to polished suits and fake tea parties. The jumps are so violent they make you feel disoriented, which I think is exactly the point. Neither character has a stable sense of where they are or what's real. But then — and this is where the author is brilliant — the story SLOW'S DOWN. The pocket watch scene unfolds in slow motion. Her knuckles curl. Her hand goes white. The watch slips. He catches it. All of it takes place across what feels like minutes but is probably seconds. Renato moves with "relaxed ease" while Lisa's entire world is contracting. And then immediately after — Sheila's scene. Sharp, snappy, almost comedic in its cruelty. It's like the author knows you need a breather after that level of tension, so they give you the most aggressively practical scene in the book: practice your smile, Lisa. The chapter ends on that note — Lisa failing to smile correctly, Sheila dismissing her efforts, and the vague threat of worse reprimands to come. No big revelation. No cliffhanger. Just the quiet horror of a girl who can't even perform kindness correctly and is being punished for it. That's the real tension here. Not whether Lisa will get caught stealing a watch she didn't try to steal. But whether she'll survive long enough in this house without losing whatever fragment of herself she still has.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how Lisa looks at Renato after he lets her go? Because I keep coming back to this moment. He has her trapped. He's touching her arm, she's on her tiptoes, she's absolutely terrified — and then he just releases her like she's nothing. A card he's discarded. And instead of breathing a sigh of relief, she glares at him. She CAN'T voice her grievance. She has no power here. She's a servant who almost got accused of theft by the son of a bank owner. And yet she looks at him with pure, unfiltered indignation. The text says: "Behind the aggrieved expression, her self-respect stood quietly upright." That line destroyed me. Her self-respect stood UP. While her body was trembling. While her hands were white from lack of blood flow. While she was practically shaking on tiptoes. Something in her refused to break. And Renato notices. Of course he notices. He's the kind of person who notices everything, and what he noticed in that moment wasn't weakness — it was something dangerous. Defiance. The same defiance he apparently saw in his mother, who used to clean in a maid's uniform with frostbitten feet. But here's the thing that worries me: Renato is fascinated by Lisa's spirit. Smila is the "kind" one offering her a better job. Smila is the safe option. But Renato? Renato is the one who sees her and finds her interesting. And in this world, being seen by someone like Renato isn't a gift. It's a target. Lisa might think she's standing up to him. But she's just given him exactly what he wanted: a reason to keep watching.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are layered in ways that make my head hurt, and I love it. On the surface: Lisa vs. Renato. He wants her to draw. She refuses until he threatens to expose everything. But beneath that — and this is where it gets devastating — she has a brother. Raoul, snoring through the hard day, completely dependent on her. "In a heart as meager as the last dregs of lamp oil, her brother was a small flame she could hold onto." If something happens to her, "both their lives would fall apart at once." That's not just fear of personal consequences. That's fear for someone else's survival. Every step she takes toward Renato's room is a choice made under that weight. Then there's Renato himself, who I realize now is trapped in his own web. He's being used by Smila's duplicity, maneuvering against the Count, playing at engagement to a woman who wants someone else. "A perpetrator, perhaps, but not a victim." But is he? He's chasing Lisa out of something that looks a lot like need, not just power. The stakes for him are less visible but possibly higher — he's discovering feelings he's actively fighting against. And Smila! She's the biggest mystery of stakes. Her father thinks she's being a good hostess. Renato knows she's lying. Marsimo thinks they're just childhood friends. But the text says it plainly: "A woman who cultivated an innocent image with oversized bows and curly hair while carrying on something behind the scenes." The stakes for Smila are losing everything — her reputation, her father's trust, possibly her social standing. She's trembling through every cup of tea. "Those sharp eyes still had some fight in them now, but before long everything would be drained away by the people around her until only an empty shell remained." Renato says this about Lisa, but honestly? I think it applies to almost everyone in this chapter.
... Read More
The atmosphere in this book is a character in itself. The winter isn't just weather; it's a relentless, oppressive force that mirrors the emotional climate. From the opening, you're hit with the 'howling winter wind' that freezes Titan's body into a 'solid, cold mass.' Chilly. Perfect. The Maldini estate feels less like a home and more like a gilded cage, with its vast pastures and strict hierarchies. I love how the setting enhances the tension. The blizzard isolates them in the lodge, forcing confrontation. The guest room, with its crystal ashtray gleaming 'like a jewel' and ornaments lined up in a 'neat row,' is a stage for Renato's meticulous control and Lisa's creeping dread. Even the light feels different—sharp and exposing when Renato enters, dim and safe in the servants' quarters. The author doesn't just describe places; they use them to reflect power dynamics. The servants' entrance is a threshold she tries to cross, but he blocks it. The study is tidy, a place of order that contrasts with Lisa's chaotic, poor existence. Every scene is visually rich and deeply atmospheric. It feels like a painting by Vermeer meets a Gothic thriller. You can almost feel the cold seeping through the pages and the weight of all those unspoken words hanging in the frigid air.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or