Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First - Reviews

Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say: the author does NOT waste words on atmosphere but when they DO describe something, it sticks with you like glue. This entire sequence takes place in what can only be described as the saddest, most intimate bathroom I have ever encountered in literature. A partitioned room behind a kitchen. A black cloth hanging where a door should be. One round wooden tub that would absolutely not fit a grown man without his legs sticking out. This is not a noble's residence. This is somewhere Cayel actually LIVES, alone, with no one to serve him. But here's what makes it work so brilliantly: every detail serves the emotional arc. The heat of the water. The steam blurring everything. The herb leaves Eleanor finds hidden at the bottom of the tub—Cayel placed them there on purpose, quietly, without a word, and he never mentions it. She only discovers it later. That single detail tells us more about him than any declaration of devotion ever could. The visual progression is incredible too. You go from dark windows outside to the glowing steam inside. From Eleanor fully wrapped in layers to slowly uncovering, both literally and emotionally. The black cloth door parting like a theater curtain. The way the narrative zooms in—first on his scar, then his lashes, then his chest, then lower—and each reveal is a beat of escalating tension. And the contrast with her past life is woven into the setting itself. She was a flower in a greenhouse, never stepped outside the mansion. Now she's in a commoner's home, in a wooden tub, water spilling over the rim, completely exposed. The physical environment mirrors her psychological journey: from sheltered protection to dangerous freedom. I also have to mention the sensory details. Swish. Shh. The sound of water. The heat on her skin. The visual of her pale body against dark water. This reads like a film director's shot list and I mean that as the highest compliment.
... Read More
'Hisss. Hisss.' The sound of boiling water in that tiny, dark house—this single detail turned the entire scene into something I could physically feel. The author builds atmosphere like a filmmaker. We start with 'Bang bang bang bang!'—the relentless knocking at night, deep darkness, a noblewoman in a purple robe walking alone through dangerous streets. The prose paints Corynca's class divide beautifully: the western district where nobles live in clustered mansions versus the residential quarter of commoners that requires traveling 'quite far south' where 'even grown men thought twice before going out after dark.' Robberies are frequent. Homes near the outer walls are cheap. This is a world with real geography and real danger. Then we enter Cayel's home and the intimacy hits different. 'Cold, unlit fireplace.' 'Worn wooden table.' 'Sofa with torn leather patched over with cloth.' 'Sword scabbard resting on top of the wooden table.' These aren't decorations—they're the bare essentials of a man who chose duty over comfort. The sword on the table is such a perfect detail. It's always there, even in his home. Even when he's just making tea. The tea scene itself is cinematic. Steam rising in 'soft curls.' The kettle whistle cutting through silence. Eleanor watching Cayel's 'broad back' as he focuses on boiling water. She's sitting perfectly composed but her heart is 'pounding so hard it felt ready to leap out of her chest.' The contrast between her external calm and internal terror is so well rendered. And then—'Please make me some tea.' She's testing him. Seeing if this man will bend to a noble's command. And he does, but on his own terms. The whole sequence feels like a sequence from a period drama where the camera lingers on small details to build enormous emotional weight.
... Read More
Okay so this chapter is wild because it does something I didn't expect. We get the wedding night scene—yes, the full thing—but the real plot momentum isn't in the romance at all. It's in the discovery of that butterfly-shaped mark on Cayel's shoulder blade. I literally stopped breathing when Eleanor noticed it. Think about it: they've been intimate countless times before this, she claims she knows every inch of his body, and yet she just never saw it. That's not just a physical detail— that's a metaphor screaming at me. How many things about Cayel has she been missing while she was too busy being swept up in his presence? And then the ending—'The truth is, I...'—what happened? The chapter cuts off right there. I am SCREAMING. This is the worst kind of cliffhanger because it's not a dangerous cliffhanger, it's an emotional one. She's asking to know everything about him. His scars, his past, his family, why he chose her. And he's finally about to give in. I need the next chapter NOW. Also, the plot mechanics around Madam Seera being sent by the council of elders to witness the 'purity rite'—that subplot is clearly going to matter later. Eleanor's internal response to it was so sharp and bitter ('Why was the council of elders so intent on clinging to such an outdated rite')—this tells me the political structure of this world is actively hostile to her, and Cayel's protection of her privacy is the first real crack in that system.
... Read More
Can we just sit with how good the dialogue in this chapter is for a second? 'You slipped away again without permission.'—Cayel saying this about Eleanor losing control of her own body is simultaneously filthy, dominant, and surprisingly tender. The register shifts between them constantly. He calls her 'My lady' in public and in charged moments, but then there are these flashes of intimacy where the titles drop away and it's just 'Eleanor' or 'Cayel' and you can feel the temperature in the room change. The narrator's voice is also doing incredible work here. Lines like 'Haah, ah! She did not want to make a sound' and 'Cayel had been looking down at her as though to take in her every movement and every moan into those deep, dark eyes'—the prose itself has a rhythm that mirrors the physical intimacy without ever becoming clinical. It's sensual but never gratuitous, which is a much harder balance to strike. And the humor! 'If Your Lordship finds it difficult to confirm yourself, I can do so directly' followed by Cayel's deadpan 'Get out.' The tonal whiplash is perfect. The author knows exactly when to let the scene breathe with comedy and when to let it collapse into genuine emotion. The ending—'I am glad to learn something about you that I did not know before'—that line lands so much harder because we've earned it through every layer of dialogue that came before.
... Read More
I'm just going to say it: the narrative voice in this book is Chef's kiss. Eleanor's interiority is so sharp and so honest that I felt like I was living inside her head the entire time. The way she narrates her own experiences—especially during intimate moments—has this perfect balance of vulnerability, humor, and raw sensation that makes you forget you're reading. Look at this line for example: 'The pleasure that had begun in the steam-filled makeshift washroom carried through to the kitchen with its black cloth pulled aside.' That's not just description—that's Eleanor's voice telling you where things went next with this casually scandalous tone. She's not shy about it but she's also not making a production of it. It's perfectly in character. And the dialogue! Cayel's voice is so distinct from everyone else. His lines are short, commanding, loaded with double meaning. 'Just where do you think you are looking?' whispered with that knowing smile—it's flirtatious but also genuinely dominant in a way that feels earned, not performative. And then later when he says 'When you are with me, think only of me'—that's the moment everything shifted for me. Because up until then, Eleanor had been mentally comparing him to Marcus, and Cayel knew it. He saw straight through her. The fact that he called her out on it in such a quiet, almost gentle way, and it still cut to the core—chills. Actual chills. Eleanor's responses to Baroness Gotren and Marcus too—'My ears work perfectly well, so there is no need to shout'—she goes from flustered bath victim to ice-cold aristocrat in one sentence switch. The voice shift is seamless and so satisfying.
... Read More
Let me just say — the atmosphere in this opening is UNREAL. Like, immediately you're sucked into this suffocating, freezing world and there's no escape. The very first description of Korenca sets up this gorgeous contrast: the capital is divided into four districts around the imperial palace, and the western district is all elegant mansions with lights that never go out, lavish banquets every night. Beautiful, right? Then the author immediately pivots to THE SIVERT MANSION, which is also in the west district but 'at a considerable distance from the imperial palace' and has 'long since shed its former grandeur and fallen into a state of quiet dimness.' That's not just set dressing — that's a statement. This family is on the outside looking in, rich in title but fading in power. And then we go UP to the third floor. The text emphasizes that unlike the bustling first and second floors, the third floor is DEAD SILENT. There's one room at the far northern end where 'not even moonlight reached.' Can you imagine that? No moonlight. The curtains are always drawn shut under the pretense that she 'needs to rest' — which is obviously a lie, they're keeping her locked away. And she's always cold. Summer OR winter. Always cold. The thin linen blanket soaked through with sweat but she can't throw it off because the cold has seeped into her bones. The scene where Marcus and Devlin come to kill her is chillingly domestic in the worst way. A white cloth pressed over her face, her own maid holding down her limbs, her husband whispering almost tenderly 'Don't worry about what happens here. It is time for you to go.' The intimacy of betrayal — she's lying in HER bed, in HER home, being murdered by the people she trusted most. And then — BLINDING LIGHT. The curtains ripped open, sunlight flooding in, and Anna's face smiling down at her like nothing happened. The contrast between the pitch-black darkness of her death and this aggressive, cheerful morning light is honestly cinematic. Whoever or whatever is looking at Eleanor right now couldn't look more different from the cold, dark room she just left.
... Read More
Baroness Gotren basically loses her absolutely COLLECTED after Eleanor drops the bomb that she already has someone who holds her heart and won't marry anyone else. The scene goes from awkward to volcanic in about three seconds. 'What sweetheart could someone like you possibly have!'—and that line really stuck with me because it reveals so much about how everyone perceives Eleanor versus who she's actually become. This woman spent her whole life being called the 'saint of Korenca's social circles,' admired for her propriety and indifference to men, and now that label has become a gilded cage. But the REAL chills come at the end when Baroness Gotren thinks she's won and leaves—except Marcus STAYS. He leans in and whispers 'I will see you again tomorrow, then, my love' with this deep smile, and Eleanor physically GAGES from the nausea. The text says 'She had not been able to bear it the moment she heard that nauseating whisper.' Her old self would've melted at those words. Her new self? She retches. The stakes here are so much higher than just a forced marriage—this is about survival, about whether Eleanor can protect everything her parents built while navigating a man who weaponizes charm like it's a blade.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about this chapter sequence because the plot moves in ways I absolutely did not expect but immediately loved. The intimate scene in the carriage opens up this whole new layer of their marriage—it's not just romantic tension anymore, it's actual physical intimacy shown with this mix of urgency and tenderness that feels very on-brand for these two. But then, just two weeks later, BAM, we're pivoting to political worldbuilding through letters. The domain elders demanding Cayel visit is such a clean escalation. They approved the marriage, they accepted the commoner-turned-marquis situation, but they clearly need to see him with their own eyes to believe it. That tension between political acceptance and personal suspicion is doing a LOT of heavy lifting here. What I love most is how Eleanor isn't just sitting around. She's proactive—sending Anna ahead, briefing her on how to handle the elders, basically setting up a diplomatic first strike before Cayel even arrives. This is a woman who survived a bad marriage and now understands that power requires preparation, not just hope. And then the payoff: Cayel didn't just accept the marquisate as a figurehead. He created a NEW order of knights open to commoners. That's a seismic shift for this world's social structure. The domain's young men are apparently thrilled. I need to know what the conservative nobles think about that.
... Read More
'With this, I declare that the two of you are bound as one soul in marriage.' One soul. That phrase keeps echoing in my head. Because on the surface, this is a romance about a woman claiming the man she loves against all social expectations. But dig a little deeper and it becomes something far more radical — it's about a woman reclaiming agency over her entire life in a world that has spent centuries treating her as property to be negotiated. Consider the weight of what Eleanor did. When her father died, the Emperor granted her 'the exceptional privilege of placing all authority over her marriage entirely in her own hands rather than those of her family's elders.' Think about how extraordinary that is in this setting. She didn't just get to choose her husband — she got to opt out of the entire system that would have traded her to the highest bidder among the noble houses. And yet, even with that privilege, the social circles still assessed her as someone who would 'eventually make his exit' and 'once again seek a live-in son-in-law to lead the marquisate.' They couldn't imagine her actually meaning it. The marriage certificate itself is such a loaded symbol. It's not just legal documentation — it's armor. 'From this moment on, no one could tear the two of them apart.' Eleanor says this almost casually, but it's fundamentally revolutionary. She holds the paper that proves their union is recognized by both church and state, and she uses it almost immediately to accelerate into action. No engagement period. No courtship rituals. Just: get the certificate, get married, get in the carriage, and go. There's also the motif of sight and blindness throughout this batch. People 'hear' rumors but don't understand. The central nobles 'passed judgment' based on incomplete information. Cayel 'could not believe that we are actually married' — he literally cannot see his own worth. And Eleanor? She sees clearly where everyone else is blind. She looks at Cayel and doesn't see a commoner. She sees someone who 'won't betray me, and that you will protect me.' The Emperor's golden crown set with gems matching 'the imperial family's violet eyes' versus Cayel's plain knighthood — the visual contrast between inherited power and earned respect runs through everything. But the most powerful symbol might be the carriage itself. A confined, moving space where social rules don't apply. Inside it, titles don't matter. Status doesn't matter. There's only Eleanor and Cayel, pressed together on a bumpy road, moving toward whatever comes next.
... Read More
I keep thinking about the scabbard. It's mentioned exactly twice in this entire passage but it's doing SO much work. First, it's resting on the wooden table in Cayel's home—a symbol of his martial identity, his status as a knight, the weapon that defines how society sees him. And then the physical intimacy happens right there, next to it, around it, using the table that held it. The scabbard becomes this silent backdrop to something that quietly undermines everything it represents. Cayel is a commoner-born knight. In this empire's social hierarchy, that scabbard is both his badge of honor and his cage. He earned it through skill and merit, but he'll never escape the fact that he didn't inherit it. And yet here he is, sharing a bed(well, a sofa) with a marquisate's daughter—the very person whose class status he can never truly match, no matter how many battles he wins. The public scandal that follows amplifies this tension beautifully. 'Korenca's pure and virtuous saint was, in truth, a woman of loose morals!'—the rumor mill doesn't just attack Eleanor's character, it attacks the impossibility of their union. 'Could a mere commoner-born knight... truly become her family's live-in son-in-law and inherit one of the most distinguished marquisates?' Every scoffing conversation in the marketplace is really asking the same question the scabbard itself silently poses: does merit matter in a world built on bloodline? And Eleanor's final declaration—'The one who decides my marriage is me, not you, Auntie. His Majesty the Emperor himself has said that only I may choose who I marry'—she's not just defending her love. She's using imperial authority to smash open the very class structure that the scabbard represents. Brilliant.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate for a second how efficiently this author writes dialogue? Cayel speaks maybe three sentences per scene and each one lands like a physical blow. Look at how his voice evolves across just these pages. At the start, he's the ghost of the marquisate—a man who moves only on orders, who never voiced an opinion even as his fellow knights departed one by one. His earlier dialogue (referenced through Eleanor's memories) is minimal, clipped, functional. And then suddenly he's delivering monologues like: "Use me as much as you like. I will gladly move according to your wishes. I will protect your family, protect your people, and protect you. But in return, you will have to give me everything you have." Do you hear the rhythm in that? The deliberate triple repetition of 'protect'? That's not accident. That's a man who has spent his whole life being told what to do finally choosing his own terms. The cadence builds like a drumroll and then BAM—the demand. And then the bathroom scene. His dialogue becomes even more stripped down, which somehow makes it more powerful. "I am coming in." Not a question. Not a request. A statement of fact. "Did you not say you wanted us to come together?" He turns her own words back on her like a blade. "We can wash together." Four words that completely rearrange the power dynamic in the room. Eleanor's voice, by contrast, is sharp, almost performative. She smiles constantly. She uses humor as armor. "Washing before being with someone is basic courtesy." She's testing him, provoking him, trying to stay in control through wit. The dialogue between them is basically two people playing chess while simultaneously trying to seduce each other and I amobsessed. The one line that haunts me though—her internal thought, not spoken aloud: "A man's words are not easy to trust." This is the thematic anchor for everything. Every promise in this book is filtered through that sentence. Even Cayel's most threatening declarations are weighed against the ghost of Marcus Damel's sweet lies. The dialogue isn't just conversation; it's evidence in a trial that's been going on since chapter one.
... Read More
There are symbols layered throughout this passage that I think deserve attention because they carry the novel's deeper meaning. The white cloth covering Eleanor's face during her death is the most haunting image. It appears almost casually—'The image of the white cloth covering her eyes and smothering her mouth and nose rose before her again'—but it represents everything: the loss of voice, the loss of vision, the suffocation of a woman who couldn't escape her fate. It's the ultimate symbol of powerlessness. And now she's awake. Now she's fighting back. The teacup is another symbol that works on multiple levels. It's not elegant or dainty like the cups in her mansion. It's rough, handmade, practical. Cayel wraps it in a handkerchief so she can hold it. The teacup becomes a metaphor for their relationship: something useful, warm, imperfect, held with care. It's not a grand gesture—it's a wrapped cup in a dark room. Then there's the door itself. Eleanor knocking, refusing to leave, eventually pushing past his resistance into his space. The door represents the barrier between their worlds—noble and commoner, sheltered and hardened, dead and alive. When she steps inside, she's crossing a threshold not just physically but thematically. She's choosing to enter a world she's never belonged to. And the sword on the table—that's perhaps the most important symbol. It's always there, even at home, even at night. Duty without rest. A man who cannot put down his weapon. Eleanor notices it but doesn't comment. She understands what it means. The passage asks: What does it cost to survive? What price are we willing to pay to protect the people we love? And can something real grow from something fake—like a marriage built on calculation but tended with honesty?

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or