Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First - Reviews

Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about Cayel because this guy is such an interesting study in quiet devotion. He appears out of nowhere on that forest road and immediately reads the situation—Eleanor walking alone, shoes in hand, clearly struggling—and without a single word of unnecessary charm he just scoops her onto his horse like it's the most natural thing in the world. The fact that he says 'if you are late returning, His Lordship will worry' is such a Cayel move. He doesn't say 'I was worried about YOU.' He deflects onto Eleanor's father like it's duty, when we BOTH know he risked stopping his training to find her. Then the whole backstory dump hits us—this man STAYED when everyone else left after Eleanor's parents died. Stayed through Marcus taking over. Stayed even AFTER Marcus kicked him out for having an 'ill-omened scar.' And then he comes back anyway, showing up at the training grounds near the garden pond like nothing happened. The way he bows his head so deeply it's almost disarming? That's a man who has learned to make himself small so others won't feel threatened. But Eleanor noticing all of this—really NOTICING him after months of looking the other way—feels like the most important shift in the entire story so far.
... Read More
Let's talk about how this author uses dialogue—and more importantly, strategic silence—to build character voice. Cayel is a man of few words and every line he does speak is calibrated. 'My lady. As I said before we were married, I have no intention of taking your family from you.' That's him laying his philosophy out in one breath. No flourishes, no dramatic pauses, just straightforward declaration. It matches who he is: a former knight who values action over performance. But the most telling moments are when he DOESN'T speak. The way he 'cut off Loren's lengthy explanation' to tell Eleanor 'let's go' to the training grounds—that single interruption tells us more about his priorities than any monologue could. He's bored by ceremony, indifferent to politics, but the second physical training is mentioned, he's fully present. His body language does the dialogue work: 'dark eyes flickering with unusual animation, almost as though asking for permission.' Eleanor's voice, by contrast, is more layered. She performs politeness with Loren ('Oh, where are my manners. Cayel, come and say hello') while simultaneously managing the situation ('He is someone who is not accustomed to this sort of thing'). She's translating between worlds—noble society and the man she married, the domain's expectations and her own authority. The line 'I have been eating well and living well. Look here, I have even put on a little weight' is such a perfectly casual, almost flirty moment that grounds the whole political tension in something human and warm. Anna's reports to Eleanor also have a distinct cadence—efficient, informative, but with genuine enthusiasm when she says 'The young men of the Sivert domain are tremendously excited.' You can hear her energy even through the formal framing.
... Read More
The stakes in this opening are NOT subtle and I respect that. On the surface, Eleanor's conflict is straightforward: her husband and his maid have been destroying her life for years, and now they're trying to kill her. Simple revenge setup, right? Wrong. Because the author immediately complicates everything by having her ALREADY die (or nearly die) and then... come back? Or something comes back. Let's break down what Eleanor stands to lose at every level: Her life — literally, as we witness Marcus and Devlin attempting to smother her. This isn't abstract danger; they are actively, physically killing her in her own home. Her identity — she spent ten years believing she was Marcus's wife, that their marriage had some kernel of truth in it. Every sweet letter, every whispered promise, every 'my Marchioness, my one and only love' — all of it was performance. She wasn't just unloved; she was a complete fabrication in his life. Her child — not just the idea of having a child, but the very real bond she formed with Ethan. She chose to raise him despite having no blood relation, because she wanted to give the Sivert line something to hold onto. And Ethan isn't even hers. He was always going to be Devlin's son. All her maternal love was redirected toward another woman's child. Her only friend — Anna. The one person who genuinely cared for her. Anna discovered Marcus and Devlin's affair and was killed for it. And now... she's back? Standing in Eleanor's room, smiling, saying good morning. Is this Anna? Something wearing Anna? A chance encounter with someone who looks like her? We don't know yet, and that uncertainty IS the tension. And beneath all of that is the imperial subplot — 'someone is coming from the imperial palace tomorrow.' Who? Why now? What do they want with Eleanor? This adds a political layer that could shift everything. If the Emperor or someone important is about to discover what Marcus has done... or if Marcus is trying to eliminate Eleanor BEFORE that person arrives... The conflict isn't just 'wife vs. cheating husband.' It's 'a woman who was systematically erased from her own life, murdered by the people closest to her, and now something impossible is standing in her doorway asking if she's all right.'
... Read More
I need to talk about Cayel because wow, what a character. The moment Eleanor knocked on his door at night and he opened it, I could literally feel the tension. He's a knight who just became wealthy through the Marquis's sacrifice, and yet he lives in a place with a 'cold, unlit fireplace' and 'sofa with torn leather patched over with cloth.' The author doesn't judge him for it—Cayel is proud, self-made, and not interested in playing noble games. When Eleanor asks him to be her husband, his immediate 'No' was NOT what I expected. I thought he'd at least hesitate or be intrigued. But he bows politely and walks away. Then Eleanor does this incredibly bold thing—she pushes past him into his home. And the description of him 'letting Eleanor into his home without putting up any resistance' is telling. He didn't throw her out. He just... sighed and made tea. But here's what really got me: 'This should make it a little easier.' He wraps the hot teacup in a handkerchief for her. After she just intruded on his private space, he still takes care of her comfort. That's Cayel. Quiet, practical, not swayed by her status. The dynamic between them is fascinating because it's NOT romance—at least not yet. Eleanor explicitly says 'of course, the feeling called love would not exist between us.' But there's something deeper happening. She trusts him because her late father trusted him. And he sees through her perfectly: 'You intend to use me in order to avoid marrying the young lord of Viscount Damel.' He knows exactly what she's doing. And he agrees anyway. The two conditions he sets reveal his intelligence—he wants it simple and fast. He understands noble politics better than most nobles. He's not falling for Eleanor's charm; he's making a calculated decision.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are suffocating in the best way. Eleanor isn't just avoiding an awkward marriage proposal—she's avoiding the two people who murdered her. And she has to do it while the entire noble world is pressuring her to marry, to produce an heir, to save the marquisate. The Baroness Gotren isn't just being pushy; she's the architect of Eleanor's destruction, and Eleanor knows this now. But she can't just say 'I was murdered by your nephew ten years from now' because nobody would believe her. She has to navigate this minefield with nothing but her knowledge of the future and her wits. What makes this genuinely tense is that Eleanor is still figuring things out. She admitted it herself: 'I don't know who I can trust.' Every alliance she forms is risky. Every person she interacts with could be an enemy. The Baroness threatens to 'force her way through the mansion gates'—so the pressure is escalating, not dissipating. Each excuse Eleanor buys time with also burns a bridge. And internally, the conflict is just as ferocious. She loves the memory of the man she thought Marcus was. She has to actively dismantle a decade of emotional attachment while facing the actual person who wore his face. That psychological violence is barely discussed but absolutely present. She said herself that 'a bitter taste rose in her throat' just thinking about those letters. This isn't a revenge story where the protagonist is already prepared—that's what makes it so compelling. She's terrified, unready, and running out of time.
... Read More
Let me just say—this author does NOT mess around with pacing. We go from a quiet forest encounter → tragic backstory montage → moonlit conversation → social confrontation → physical breakdown. In ONE CHAPTER. And somehow it ALL works. The transition from the emotional depth of the Cayel scene into the brutal realism of Marcus arriving with his aunt is jarring in the best possible way. It mirrors exactly how Eleanor's life feels—just when you think you've found a moment of peace, the world comes crashing back in. The flashback structure inside the Cayel narrative is also brilliantly handled. Instead of info-dumping, the author weaves in the parents' death, the knights leaving, Cayel staying, Marcus driving him out, and the death notice—all through Eleanor's reflections while she's riding. That's not exposition, that's emotional layering. And then the chapter ENDS with Eleanor gagging from nausea and Anna panicking? Chef's kiss. Whatever the reader thinks is happening physically, the emotional stakes are through the roof. The author knows exactly when to speed up and when to let a moment breathe.
... Read More
Okay I need to just sit with this for a minute because the emotional whiplash in this section is no joke. Let me start by saying: the contrast between Marcus and Cayel is not subtle and I am HERE for it. Eleanor literally carries the trauma of her previous life into this one. She was promised eternal love, told she was the only woman, and then watched that man press himself against a maidservant while she watched. And now here comes Cayel, the guy who barely spoke two words to her before, dropping the most unhinged, terrifying, kind of breathtaking line: "Even if the day comes when you grow to hate me, I will hold you so you cannot walk away." Now. On paper, this is red flag central. This is the kind of thing that would make me immediately exit the building. But hear me out—the genius is that Eleanor doesn't flinch. She doesn't run. She looks at this man who just told her she'll never be allowed to leave, and she thinks about the woman she WAS in her past life, the woman who chose nicely packaged lies over raw, ugly truth. And she says no, I will not regret this. That's not naive. That is a person who has been burned so badly she's decided to stop fearing fire. The fact that she finds comfort in someone who is openly predatory rather than someone who promises eternal love? That's the most devastating character beat I've read in months. She'd rather be trapped by honesty than abandoned by sweet words. And then—AND THEN—he asks her one more time if she's sure. Not once. Not twice. He checks in. He gives her an out even as he's telling her there won't be one. That tension between wanting to chain her down and needing her to choose him freely? That's not red flag energy, that's tragic hero energy and I am not okay.
... Read More
What strikes me most about this chapter isn't what people SAY—it's what they DON'T say. Cayel's dialogue is barely there and it's perfect. 'Please, get on. I will escort you back to the mansion.' Short. Practical. Guarded. He never once says 'I was worried about you.' He never says 'Are you alright?' He shows up, he acts, he deflects. And that silence is SO much more revealing than any passionate declaration could be. Then contrast that with Marcus, who fills every space with polished words—'I wish I could be of even a little strength to you, Lady Sivert' and later the whisper 'my love.' His dialogue is performative from start to finish, and that's what makes it so chilling. Baroness Gotren's voice is equally distinctive—her exclamations are breathless and overlapping, her apologies tripping over each other ('W, wait, Ellie. What did you just… say?'). But the most powerful line in the entire chapter might be Eleanor's simplest: 'The moon is bright.' Four words that carry the weight of a woman choosing connection over caution, after a lifetime of being told to be good and quiet and obedient. The author's dialogue writing here is restrained to the point of surgery.
... Read More
'The moon is bright.' That's it. That's all she says. And honestly? That sentence wrecked me more than any dramatic confession ever could. Think about what just happened in Eleanor's head before she speaks those words. She's a woman who literally died and came back to this moment. She knows how this marriage ends. She knows Marcus will destroy her family. And yet here she is, choosing to stay on this road a few minutes longer with the one person who never abandoned her, under a moon that shines on both of them equally. The text says 'Perhaps, in the past. Her former self would never have stayed even a moment with an unfamiliar man she barely knew.' That contrast between past-Eleanor and present-Eleanor is EVERYTHING. She's reinvented herself through trauma and rebirth, and this moment on the road is her first real act of agency in choosing who she wants to be close to. I genuinely believe something shifted between them in those minutes under the moonlight. Not a grand romantic gesture—just two people who finally see each other, talking in the dark. I need to know what they actually discussed. The author is playing the longest con and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
This story is fundamentally about trust as a currency—and how devastating it is when that currency is counterfeit. The letters between Eleanor and Marcus aren't just a plot device; they're the central symbol of manufactured intimacy. Baroness Gotren essentially wrote the script for Eleanor's emotional downfall, and Marcus performed it flawlessly. Every word he wrote was calculated. The tragedy isn't just that he deceived her—it's that the deception was beautiful. He gave her comfort during her grief, becoming the person she turned to after her parents died. That makes the betrayal so much more intimate and corrosive. Then there's the scar on Cayel's face. It's described as something he 'would have every right to resent,' yet he bears it silently and never shows bitterness. It's a physical mark of sacrifice—unlike Marcus's words, which were smooth and gilded but hollow. The scar is truth made visible. It says something that letters never could. And the marquisate itself—the title Eleanor was willing to hand over to a man she loved—represents something deeper than wealth or status. It's about legacy, about protecting what your parents built. Her parents died, and she was left alone to decide whether the Sivert line would survive through her. That pressure, combined with her isolation, made her vulnerable to exactly the kind of person who would exploit duty for personal gain. The story is asking: what do we owe to those who came before us, and at what cost?
... Read More
The structure of these opening chapters is genuinely masterful and I need to unpack why it hits so hard. We start IN MEDIA RES essentially — we find Eleanor already dying on the third floor, breathing at its limit, no one visiting, no warmth, just this slow fade into darkness. The maidservants hear her breathing and deliberately walk past, pretending not to. That's your opening hook: a woman so forgotten that even the help won't acknowledge her suffering. Immediate question: WHY? Then — BAM — the flashback to five months ago. The inciting incident that destroyed her entire world. The confession. 'Your... child?' 'That is correct.' Four words that dismantle ten years of her life. The pacing here is surgical. We get the shock, we get the slap, we get the scene of Marcus comforting Devlin while Eleanor stands frozen in the background, and then Devlin drops the absolute nuclear bomb: she reveals the poisoning. Every miscarriage. Every 'failed' pregnancy. All sabotaged. The flashback doesn't go on too long either. After Devlin mouths those words and leaves, we snap back to the present — Marcus and Devlin deciding Eleanor can't survive until tomorrow because 'someone is coming from the imperial palace.' This is where the tension THRESHELDS. They're not just going to neglect her anymore. They're going to murder her. Tonight. And then the killing attempt itself is handled with brutal efficiency. No drawn-out battle, no last-minute rescue. She struggles, she fails, her arm falls lifelessly over the edge of the bed. Thud. Blackout. Which makes the final moment — her eyes opening to blinding sunlight and Anna's voice saying 'Miss?' — absolutely DEVASTATING. We just watched her die, or almost die, and now she's... back? The pacing from 'she's dying alone' to 'she's being murdered' to 'she wakes up and someone who died six months ago is standing in front of her' is relentless. I did NOT see that ending coming and now I am OBSESSED.
... Read More
The structure of this chapter sequence is really something. It opens with Eleanor's decision—'I need to remove those people from my life'—and then immediately cuts to night, to knocking, to darkness. No transition. Just: Bang bang bang bang. Bang bang bang bang. Bang bang... Click. The author uses sound as a structural device here. The banging establishes urgency. The click of the door establishes tension. The hissing kettle establishes intimacy. Each sound marks a shift in the scene's emotional temperature. By the time Eleanor is shouting 'I do not love him!' the sound design has moved from violent noise to near silence, and that contrast is masterful. What I love about the pacing is how the author controls reveals. We don't get exposition dumps about Marcus's betrayal or Eleanor's past life. Instead, each piece of information comes organically through action and dialogue. The Baroness's journey from Bioram, the viscount's relative, the white cloth covering Eleanor's face—these are dropped like stones into still water, and we see the ripples. The chapter ends on a cliffhanger that isn't dramatic but is deeply unsettling: 'the two of them would become an officially recognized couple from that moment on.' The stakes just multiplied. They're committing to a lie that will entangle them permanently. And Cayel's last lines hang in the air—'I have two conditions'—leaving us wanting to know what they are. Some parts breathe slowly (the tea scene) while others move fast (Eleanor's internal panic). The author trusts the reader to keep up. There's no hand-holding, no over-explaining. Just confidence in the material.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or