Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First - Reviews

Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to just get this out first: even after they're officially married, he still calls her 'my lady' and it sends me every time. There's something about the way he says it—respectful, devoted, almost reverent—that shows exactly how he sees her. Not as property, not as a tool for political gain, but as someone genuinely worthy of honor. The intimacy scene is interesting because it's so different from how Marcus treated Eleanor in her previous life. There's no domination, no selfishness, just this raw need mixed with genuine consideration. When he whispers 'take all of it and do not let a single drop spill, my lady'—it's commanding, yes, but it's also an act of trust. He's asking her to hold onto something vulnerable, and she chooses to. But the real relationship goldenness comes in the study scene when Eleanor reflects on what Cayel said about not taking her family from her. 'All matters of the family, large and small, proceed according to your wishes.' That line hit me like a truck. In her past life, Marcus stripped her of everything—her father's study, her autonomy, her voice. Here comes Cayel, a man who just inherited a marquisate and could easily consolidate all power for himself, and he's actively giving it back to her. The contrast isn't subtle and I am HERE for it. And Eleanor noticing that Cayel flinched when she mentioned the training grounds—she's paying attention in a way she never did with Marcus. That's growth. That's a woman who's learned to read her partner instead of ignoring red flags until it was too late.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about this whole chapter sequence because holy hell does it pull the rug out from under you. We open with Eleanor deciding she needs to remove threatening people from her life, and then the very next scene she's at 2am knocking on a stranger's door in the worst part of town. That's a bold narrative move—she goes from playing it safe to completely burning her reputation in one night. The plot twist here isn't some big revelation; it's subtler. When Cayel refuses her marriage proposal on the spot, Eleanor doesn't retreat. She actually STEPS INTO HIS HOUSE. That's the turning point of the entire arc. She goes from asking politely to barging in and demanding tea like she owns the place. The author writes: 'Cayel clearly had not expected Eleanor to do something so bold.' And honestly? Neither did I. That shift in agency is everything. What's brilliant is how the plot connects to her backstory. We learn that Marcus is her betrayer—someone who literally killed her in a past life—and Baroness Gotren is the one pushing the unwanted marriage alliance. All of these threads converge in this single visit. The plot feels incredibly tight because every conversation reveals information that pushes Eleanor closer to her goal. She wants to avoid marrying Marcus Damel. She wants Cayel as her shield. She wants to protect her family. And Cayel? He's not some naive pawn. When he says 'I will do as you wish, my lady' but immediately adds 'however, I have two conditions,' the reader knows this isn't a simple transaction. The author sets up a ticking clock too—Cayel is supposed to die in seven months. Eleanor knows this from her past life memories. So every second counts. This urgency makes the pacing feel breathless in the best way.
... Read More
This batch does something I really appreciate: it opens at maximum intensity and then deliberately drops the temperature before building it back up in a completely different direction. The carriage scene is breathless. Short sentences. Fragmented dialogue. Physical urgency. You can feel the carriage bouncing, hear the panting, sense the panic of trying to keep things private while literally riding through the countryside. It's chaotic and hot and barely contained. And then—chapter break, two weeks pass, we're in the garden consulting about flowers. The whiplash is intentional and it works because Eleanor needs that breathing room. She just experienced something overwhelming and the narrative gives her space to exist in her new normal. Then the letters start arriving. One, then another, then four, and the rhythm accelerates again. Each letter adds pressure. The prose gets slightly more formal, more measured, matching the political tone. By the time they arrive at the domain, the pacing has shifted into a slow-burn tension—servants lining up, Loren's wry explanations, Cayel's growing discomfort with ceremony, and that moment when Eleanor mentions the training grounds and his whole demeanor changes. The study scene at the end is the quietest part, but it's doing the most work emotionally. Eleanor sitting at her father's desk, surrounded by his old papers, processing everything that's changed versus everything that hasn't—the pacing here is deliberate, almost meditative. It lets the reader sit with the implications before the next wave of conflict hits. I'm on board.
... Read More
I need to talk about Cayel because honestly? He completely stole my attention in this batch. Everyone keeps talking about Eleanor's bravery, her decisiveness, walking into that palace and claiming what she wanted — and sure, that's impressive — but what about him? The guy who just got married to a noblewoman with zero preparation time, zero social armor, and a private audience with the Emperor that absolutely terrifies him. Think about the moment right before he goes in. Eleanor grabs his wrist. She's shaking. And Cayel? He looks down at her hand and SMILES. He whispers 'Trust me.' Not because he's confident about meeting the Emperor — probably because he's terrified, but he's also reading her panic and choosing to be the steady one. That's not arrogance. That's love, and it's devastating how he keeps hiding it behind that composed exterior. Then inside the carriage after the wedding, when she shows him the marriage certificate and says all these beautiful things — 'you won't betray me, you'll protect me, I believe you'll be a good husband' — he can't even hold her gaze. He looks away. His eyes are 'wavering.' This man faced down the Emperor of the Hyder Empire without flinching, and a woman's sincere words about choosing him? That's what breaks his composure. What strikes me most is the asymmetry. Eleanor has been planning this. She's rehearsed standing before the Emperor in her mind. She knows exactly what to say. But Cayel? He's been 'hesitating since we left the imperial palace.' The man who saved her father's life, who stood by her through every scandal and rumor — he still feels like an imposter in his own marriage. And yet. When she takes his hand, he pulls her close. He doesn't pull away. He never pulls away. His final line before things get heated is basically 'My lady really does not listen, hh, does she' — said while completely ignoring her silent pleas to slow down. Yeah, okay, so maybe some of his confidence is performative too. Maybe he's just as overwhelmed as she is, and he channels it into something else entirely. I'm not saying he's faking it. I'm saying he's trying so hard to be the husband she needs that he might not know what to do when she just needs HIM. That gap between them? I think that's where this story lives. Not in the political intrigue or the class warfare, but in two people who keep choosing each other despite not fully understanding what the other is feeling.
... Read More
Okay so I need to talk about Marcus because honestly my blood is BOILING after reading this. This man — if you can even call him that — had Eleanor fall for him HARD. Ten years ago he was golden hair, blue eyes like the sea, whispering things like 'My one and only love' and 'I swear it on my name, El.' And she, bless her heart, chose him as her live-in son-in-law to save the dying Sivert line. She gave him EVERYTHING. And what did he do? Six months into the marriage, the second he got his formal recognition from the Emperor, the mask completely dropped. Started picking fights over trivial things, humiliated her in public, stopped inviting her to parties, took his personal maid DEVLIN instead. A MAIDSERVANT. To his own wedding celebration. But the real gut punch is the Ethan situation. Eleanor, feeling guilty that she couldn't produce an heir, accepted his proposal to raise his nephew as the future Marquis. She poured a year of motherly love into this boy, and turns out HE'S Marcus and Devlin's actual biological child. The ultimate betrayal wrapped in a lie. And Devlin — UGH. She plays the frail, crying victim in front of Marcus ('Your Lordship! I was so frightened!') but then turns completely venomous toward Eleanor. The scene where she reveals she POISONED Eleanor during every pregnancy all these years... while smiling. Just smiling. 'You made it so you COULD NOT,' she mouths without sound. The audacity. What destroys me most is Eleanor's relationship with Anna. Anna was her ONLY family, the one who stood by her after the marriage soured. When Anna died (apparently murdered by Marcus and Devlin for knowing their secret), Eleanor had no one left. And now she's back... or something is back. Because the girl standing in front of her right now looks exactly like Anna, but ANNA DIED. Half a year ago. Carriage accident, they said. Now she's suddenly here opening curtains and saying 'Good morning, isn't it?' in the most cheerful way possible. I need to know WHO or WHAT this is.
... Read More
I need to talk about the imagery in this chapter because the author is doing something BRILLIANT with light and darkness. The bed curtain is doing SO much work here. It's a literal barrier separating the private from the public, the intimate from the political. Madam Seera is described as 'somewhere in the darkness beyond the bed curtain, watching their every contact'—and even though she's technically just a witness to a rite, the way this is framed makes it feel invasive, almost violating. The darkness beyond the curtain represents everything that wants to consume Eleanor's private moments: tradition, duty, surveillance. Then the moment Seera leaves—'Click'—the door closing is described as a quiet sound, but in context it's the loudest moment in the chapter. The restraints are lifted. The lighting shifts from oppressive to warm. The scene literally transforms from a political performance into a genuine human moment. And the mark itself! 'On Cayel's left shoulder blade, she could see a black mark that looked like a butterfly pattern. Ordinarily, a common mole is mostly round. But the black mark... had a shape that brought a butterfly to mind, like two triangles placed together.' The author takes an ordinary body detail and makes it mythic. A butterfly mark that Eleanor never noticed despite all their intimacy. Symbols matter here—the butterfly as transformation, as something hidden but beautiful, as the soul made visible on skin.
... Read More
'I do not love him!' Eleanor screams it, and then again, and then again, and I swear I felt something crack open in my chest. This is the moment where everything Eleanor has been carrying—all ten years of manipulation, all the grief, all the fear—comes spilling out. The author writes: 'Having let those words pass through her lips, she felt as though the heavy weight pressing down on her chest had been washed away.' And then: 'It even felt strangely satisfying, and so she cried out again.' I had to pause reading after that because I genuinely felt tears. Not because it's tragic—though it is—but because it's SO cathartic. Eleanor spent her first life believing in Marcus Damel, trusting him, loving him, and he destroyed her. Every word she didn't say, every feeling she swallowed, finally escapes through this one shout. She's not performing for anyone anymore. She's alone in a stranger's dark house at midnight and she needs this release. What makes it hit even harder is that Cayel witnesses it. He doesn't laugh, doesn't judge, doesn't try to fix it. He just watches with 'not so much surprise as a quiet calm.' He's seen worse. He's lived harder. And somehow, in that shared silence, something passes between them. Not love—not yet—but recognition. Two people who understand what it means to carry unbearable weight. And the way Eleanor then moves closer to him, step by step, until she can feel his breath... that vulnerability mixed with desperation is devastating. She's laying everything on the line. Her reputation, her freedom, her future. And she says it straight: 'I need you.' No noble pretense, no games. Just a woman who has died once and refuses to die again.
... Read More
I've been turning over some thematic threads from this batch and they keep circling back to three images: the closed study, the training ground, and the unspoken promise between Eleanor and Cayel. The study is the most loaded symbol. In her past life, it was a forbidden space—her father's domain, her ex-husband's trophy. Marcus barred her from it, which means he understood its power. A woman controlling the household archives controls the household. When Eleanor sits there now, surrounded by her father's papers, she's reclaiming three things at once: her father's legacy, her own authority, and the right to exist in spaces of power. The fact that Cayel voluntarily gave her this space is the novel's quietest but boldest statement about what their marriage represents. Then there's the training ground—Cayel's true domain. He may be a marquis on paper, but his identity lives in the sword, in physical discipline, in the meritocratic ideal of his new knight order. Opening it to commoners isn't just policy; it's ideological. The old world of the Hyder Empire separates nobility from birthright. Cayel's new order says ability matters more than blood. That's a revolution wearing a uniform. And the carriage scene—yes, even that has thematic weight. 'Your upper mouth and your lower mouth are saying very different things, my lady.' On one level it's flirtation. On another, it's about Eleanor learning to trust her own desires instead of suppressing them for other people's comfort. In her past life, she couldn't say what she wanted. Here, she's learning to hold onto what's hers—whether that's pleasure, power, or peace.
... Read More
'As the doors swung open with a creak, Eleanor stepped forward along the red carpet laid before her, one step at a time.' I keep coming back to this image. The red carpet inside Seryl Palace — that sweeping, ceremonial entrance that leads to the throne room with its ceiling 'soaring as high as the open blue sky.' It's such a vivid contrast to where the scene ends up. Because what happens next? They don't throw a grand reception. They don't host nobles or exchange elaborate vows in front of half the empire. They rush to a temple on the outskirts of Korenca for a bare-bones ceremony with 'plenty of talk' from people who weren't even invited. And then the carriage ride home becomes this incredible, almost cinematic set piece. Let me just say: the way the author handles that carriage scene is... ambitious. The physicality of it. Every jolt of the wheels, every stone on the road, becomes a punctuation mark for what's happening between them. 'Each time the carriage wheels rolled forward, Eleanor's breasts, hanging downward, jolted upward. Jolt!' I mean, really. The prose doesn't shy away from the absurdity of the situation — two newlyweds caught in a confined space, trying desperately to be quiet while everything around them conspires to make it impossible. What I find fascinating is how the setting mirrors their emotional state. They're literally bouncing along an uneven road, which is exactly what this marriage feels like — not smooth, not planned, full of sudden jolts and impacts. The Grand Temple itself is described almost cursorily compared to the opulence of Seryl Palace. A simple ceremony with High Priest Allegro, no guests, no fanfare. The marriage certificate is the only proof they have. In a world where appearances and social standing matter enormously, their union exists on a single piece of paper and two people who refuse to let go of each other. The corridor outside the audience chamber also hits different. That moment when Eleanor steps out, heart hammering, and Cayel is just THERE — standing quietly, waiting. The chamberlain Rex 'sensing that pressing the matter further risked irritating the emperor' is such a perfect worldbuilding detail. You can feel the power dynamics in the room just from how the staff moves around them. But the carriage? That's the real masterpiece here. It transforms an intimate moment into something almost visceral for the reader. You can hear the wheels, feel the road, sense the coachman's ignorance of what's happening just feet away. The world beyond that carriage window — the capital city, the watching nobles, the Central Noble Assembly plotting their judgment — all of it disappears. There's only the jostling, the heat, and two people who are finally, truly alone together for the first time.
... Read More
The dialogue in this is absolutely vicious and I love it. Every character speaks in a way that reveals everything about them without saying what they mean. Let's talk about Marcus first. This man does NOT waste words on Eleanor. When she finally stammers 'Your Lord...' he cuts her off: 'You won't make it through today.' Not 'I'm sorry, El.' Not even a lie. Just cold, factual information about her impending death, delivered like he's commenting on the weather. And then he says to Devlin, 'She can't still be alive tomorrow. Have you forgotten, Devlin? Someone is coming from the imperial palace tomorrow.' He's not planning her murder — he's scheduling it. Like a task on a to-do list. But the most chilling line has to be when he leans over her and whispers: 'Stop struggling, my lady. I will give my wife a funeral befitting her station. So—' The gentleness in that voice, the almost tender tone as he smothers her... 'My lady' after ten years of calling her nothing at all. What a sick twist of intimacy. Devlin's dialogue is equally nasty, but she masks it differently. With Marcus she's all hiccuping tears and 'Your Lordship!' — performative fragility. With Eleanor she's sharp and precise: 'Do not worry, my lady. Even without your presence, the Sivert Marquisate will be protected by His Lordship and me, and our son.' The 'and our son' at the end is pure cruelty — reminding Eleanor that the child she raised is theirs, that she was never anything but a convenient vessel and fool. And then there's Anna. 'Yes, Miss. Good morning, isn't it? The sunlight is especially lovely today!' Normal. Cheerful. Harmless. Which is somehow MORE unsettling than anything Devlin said, because we KNOW Anna died. We KNOW she was murdered. So why is this thing wearing her face acting like nothing happened? The narrative voice itself is also worth noting — it stays close to Eleanor's perspective, letting us feel her confusion and terror directly. But there are these fleeting moments where the narration seems to almost... smirk? Like when it describes Anna's 'strikingly familiar' face and then reveals she's dead. The narrator knows more than Eleanor, and that gap is where the dread lives.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or