Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First - Reviews

Mom Was the One Who Seduced Your Dad First
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the symbolism in this section because it is layered in ways that some readers might completely miss on a first read. The wedding contract itself is a massive symbol. Eleanor insists on drawing it up, on making everything explicit. This is a woman who was destroyed by unspoken promises and whispered vows that meant nothing. She doesn't want romance; she wants terms and conditions. She wants the monster to put his claws in writing so she knows exactly what she's signing away. The contract is her armor, but ironically, the more she tries to contain this situation in legal language, the more it escapes into something raw and uncontainable. The herb leaves in the bathtub. This is the quietest symbol in the whole passage and honestly the one that matters most. Cayel adds them without saying a word. He wipes the tub clean. He tests the water temperature. These are acts of care from a man who has never learned to express anything through tenderness—only through possession. The herbs represent the gap between who Cayel is and who Eleanor needs him to be. She notices. She smiles. But she never thanks him. The unacknowledged kindness between them is its own kind of tragedy. Then there's the water. Eleanor submerges herself in hot water in a stranger's home, physically naked and emotionally exposed, and instead of feeling vulnerable, she feels... free? Her skin turning pink, her breathing slowing, the weight lifting off her shoulders. Water as baptism. Water as rebirth. She has spent her entire existence (both lives) being watched, judged, used, betrayed. Here, in this tiny tub, alone with a man she barely knows, she is simply present in her body for the first time. And the body itself is the ultimate symbol. Eleanor has spent a lifetime treating her body as currency—first to secure a political marriage, then to endure betrayal within that marriage. Now she offers it willingly, strategically, as part of a deal. But as she looks at Cayel's scarred, branded, lived-in body, something shifts. She sees not just a instrument of pleasure or protection but a history written in flesh. His scars speak of a life of violence and survival. Her smooth skin speaks of shelter and stagnation. They are complete opposites, and that's precisely why they fit. The final symbolic beat: the towel sliding to the floor. It's the last boundary between them—literally and figuratively. When it hits the ground, there's no going back. The contract has consumed itself. What started as a business arrangement has become something neither of them can define.
... Read More
'Neeigh!' The horse's cry does SO much work in this scene. It's the sound that signals everything has changed—Eleanor's ordinary walk home is interrupted, her plans are disrupted, and suddenly she's airborne, lifted onto a black horse by a man she barely knows. But the imagery throughout is what really lives in my head. The 'reddening sky' casting darker shadows on Cayel's eyes. The desolate forest road with no one around. The garden pond near the training grounds where Cayel later appears, still in his practical clothes from work. And then the shift to the mansion's drawing room—formal, bright, suffocating. The author paints these spaces so deliberately that you can FEEL the difference between the freedom of the open road and the claustrophobia of aristocratic expectation. When Eleanor looks up at the moon and says 'The moonlight is shining on us both,' the entire scene becomes almost painterly. Two figures, silver light, no audience, no performance. It's the only honest moment either of them has had in this entire story and the setting makes it feel sacred somehow.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this opening sequence is *chef's kiss*. Eleanor wakes up ten years in the past, right before the worst decision of her life, and instead of some generic 'I will fix everything!' hero moment, she does something way more interesting: she hides. Like, she literally refuses to see the Baroness for a full week. That's not the typical protagonist energy, and honestly? I love it. It feels real. She's not ready. She's processing betrayal on a level that would wreck most people. The plot structure here is doing a lot of heavy lifting in a short span. We get the murder (Marcus + Devlin poisoning her over ten years), the rebirth mechanism (waking up ten years earlier), the central conflict (she can't avoid this forever), AND a potential new thread with Sir Cayel—all in these chapters. That's ambitious compression. The Baroness Gotren angle is especially sharp because the narrative quietly reveals she was the one who set up the letter correspondence between Eleanor and Marcus. So the matchmaker is also the architect of the betrayal. That's a really satisfying layer of dramatic irony. My only question hanging over all of this: what happens when she finally does have to face Marcus? The author has built this incredibly tense setup where every day Eleanor delays is a day she gains information and resolve. I am fully committed to watching this unfold.
... Read More
Okay I need to just say this out loud because I'm still recovering: the bathtub scene is genuinely one of the most visceral, immersive sequences I've read in this book and I think maybe ever. The way the author describes that steam-filled makeshift washroom—it's not just background, it's practically a character. You can feel the heat, the cramped space, the intimacy of two bodies fitting into something never designed for two people. The wooden tub, the water, the physical closeness forced by limited space—it all creates this claustrophobic eroticism that's so much more effective than if it happened in some grand bedroom. And then the scene MOVES. That's what got me. It doesn't stay in one place. From the tub to the kitchen with its black cloth pulled aside to the worn leather sofa to the wooden table where the scabbard had rested—Eleanor and Cayel are practically migrating through his home like they're claiming each room. I swear I could hear each transition. The physicality of it, the way their bodies move through space together, it makes the world feel so lived-in. This isn't some generic fantasy mansion; this is a specific, real-feeling house with specific rooms and specific textures. Then morning comes and we get woken up by the sound of banging—Bang bang bang bang!—and suddenly the whole intimate bubble pops and we're thrust into the social world outside. The contrast between those two worlds—the private, steamy interior and the cold, judgmental exterior where Baroness Gotren and Marcus are waiting—hits so hard. The author really knows how to use setting to heighten emotional stakes.
... Read More
This batch is a masterclass in layered stakes, and I need to unpack why it works so well. On the surface level, the conflict is straightforward: Eleanor wants to marry Cayel, a commoner-born knight, and the entire noble establishment of the Hyder Empire wants that to fail. The Central Noble Assembly has already decided they won't recognize the ceremony. They've pre-judged Cayel as unworthy. They're waiting for the moment he'll stumble so they can use it as proof that the Emperor's favoritism was a mistake. But the real tension isn't external — it's the private, shaking moment right before Cayel meets the Emperor alone. Eleanor grabbing his wrist. Her face 'written with worry and anxiety.' The fact that SHE is nervous about HIM. That inversion is brilliant. Usually in these stories, the noblewoman is the protected one and the commoner is the vulnerable one. But here? Eleanor is terrified that Cayel will say the wrong thing, make the wrong gesture, say something brusque that the Emperor won't forgive. Her fear for him is almost more acute than his own. And then there's the internal conflict — the kind that doesn't make it into any political drama or battlefield scene but might actually destroy them. Cayel's hesitation. His question: 'Was your choice truly the right one?' After everything — after saving her father, after standing by her through scandal, after she publicly claimed him — he still harbors this quiet, gnawing doubt. The stakes here aren't about titles or land or political power. They're about whether one person can truly believe they're worthy of another person's unwavering choice. The Emperor's private audience with Cayel is where all these tensions converge. Edward II could reject them. He could use Cayel's birth as grounds to deny the marriage, and honestly, given how the nobility is already positioning themselves, he might face pressure to do so. Instead, he laughs. He calls Cayel 'the lucky gentleman.' He says 'I will not eat him alive.' These are small moments, barely described, but they carry enormous weight — because the alternative was so clearly possible. Even the carriage scene, on its most basic level, raises the stakes of physical intimacy and vulnerability. They've barely begun this marriage and already they're thrust into a situation where they must navigate pleasure and restraint simultaneously, with a coachman mere feet away and the entire capital watching their every move. The danger isn't just scandal — it's that in their most private moment, surrounded by people who want them to fail, they still can't quite let go of the performance of composure. What keeps me hooked isn't whether they'll face opposition — they clearly will. It's whether they'll face it together, or whether the external pressure will amplify the internal cracks.
... Read More
I am still not over the morning-after confrontation and I need to process this RIGHT NOW because my hands are literally shaking. So Eleanor wakes up, slightly disheveled but clearly satisfied, tries to slip out of Cayel's arms, and immediately—BANG BANG BANG. The door is being pounded on by Anna, her ally in this whole scheme. But outside? Baroness Gotren, Marcus Damel, and escort knights. The full weight of social and political opposition, standing at her doorstep before she's even dressed. And Marcus—sweet, supposedly protective Marcus—draws his sword and presses it to Cayel's throat. 'Lady Sivert, did this man do something to you against your will?' He means well. I understand that he means well. But the fact that his first instinct is to assume coercion, to weaponize chivalry as an excuse to threaten a man half-naked in his own home, reveals everything about how he sees Eleanor. Not as a person with agency but as property to be managed. The stakes here are astronomically high and the author makes you feel every single one of them. If Eleanor speaks poorly, if she hesitates for even one second, the narrative could go in a direction that would shatter everything she's built. But she doesn't hesitate. She steps BETWEEN Marcus's sword and Cayel. She invokes the Emperor himself. She tells Marcus directly that threatening her man means she will not stand by quietly. 'Thump thump. Her heart beat fast.' She's terrified. But she does it anyway. That's not bravery—that's love as an act of defiance. And the way she drops the cold expression the moment she turns to Cayel and smiles warmly, offering her hand to come to the mansion with her—it's devastating in the best possible way. She just publicly chose him. Over everything. Over her family. Over her society. Over Marcus.
... Read More
This chapter is structured like a three-act play and I don't say that lightly. ACT ONE: The performance. Everything is restrained, tense, loaded with unspoken politics. The observer creates pressure. Every touch is measured, every sound suppressed. Eleanor 'tried again and again to close her eyelids' but couldn't escape the awareness of being watched. The pacing here is deliberate, almost claustrophobic—you feel the weight of expectation pressing down on them. ACT TWO: The release. Once the door clicks shut, the entire energy of the scene flips. The prose becomes breathless, urgent, unrestrained. Sentences get shorter. Sounds multiply. The rhythm matches what's happening physically—but more importantly, it matches the emotional release. Three days of preparation, three days of political maneuvering, and suddenly it's JUST them. The pacing accelerates like a exhale. ACT THREE: The revelation. This is where most authors would just fade to black or end on a romantic beat. But no—right when you'd expect the chapter to close, the author pivots to something entirely different. The quiet aftermath. The discovery of the mark. The question that cracks open everything. 'The truth is, I...'—and cut. The pacing drops to a whisper right before the explosion. The chapter doesn't drag at any point because each section serves a different emotional function. Restraint → release → vulnerability. That's not just good writing, that's architect-level storytelling.
... Read More
There is a moment in these chapters where Eleanor is standing by a pond at midnight, and the water is described as having 'the same unsteady light as the moon above,' and then a pair of eyes meets hers from the darkness—a man with hair 'as dark as a night sky full of stars' and a scar running from beneath his right eye to his ear. I literally had to pause because this reads like a film direction. The author isn't just describing a scene; they're composing one. Every frame here is intentional. The Sivert Marquisate itself feels alive too. We get the contrast between the bright south-facing room on the second floor (Eleanor's old room, full of light and life) and the grim solitary room on the third floor (where she spent her last ten years). That spatial symbolism is brutal and understated. The estate is literally divided between where she lived as a hopeful young woman and where she died as a broken one. Then there's the tea party scene—so minor on the surface, a girl leaving early, Eleanor deciding to walk home in painful shoes—but it grounds the whole world in physical reality. You can feel the lace-trailing dress, the scraped heels, the darkening road. This is a world that operates on real sensory logic, not just noble etiquette and political maneuvering. The fact that even background details like 'forty minutes by carriage' exist tells me the author has built something substantial here.
... Read More
On the surface, this chapter is about a wedding night. But the real conflict—the one that has my heart in a chokehold—is about TRUTH. Every layer of tension in this chapter traces back to hiding and revealing. Madam Seera represents the external conflict: the council wants to verify Eleanor's 'purity' like she's livestock, like her body is a document to be inspected. The marriage itself is framed as a political arrangement—three days of preparation, witnesses, rites. Everything about this setup screams 'transaction.' But the internal conflict is what gets me. Eleanor admits to herself that she's lost pieces of herself throughout this relationship without fully understanding why. 'To lose herself like this, from stimulation above the waist alone'—her body is betraying her composure, and instead of fighting it, she's starting to accept it. The stakes aren't just about whether she'll be accepted in this marriage. The stakes are about whether she'll keep discovering parts of herself she didn't know existed. And Cayel—the man who guards everything, who drives away observers with a single word, who gets jealous over a birthmark—what is HE risking by opening up? The ending isn't just Eleanor wanting to know more. It's Cayel finally about to say 'The truth is...' and that's worth more than any political alliance. He's offering her access to his unfiltered self, and that terrifies him more than any enemy ever could. No wonder he hesitates. The real stakes were never about purity—they were about who gets to see the real person underneath all the titles and duties and walls.
... Read More
I need to talk about Sir Cayel because WOW. Eleanor finds him at midnight near a garden pond, he starts walking away politely, and she blurts out his name—and his reaction is just... 'You... remember me?' That single line hit me like a truck. This man carried that scar from saving her father, declined a family name out of humility, and clearly had feelings for her that went completely unacknowledged in the previous timeline. In the original timeline, did she even notice him? The text implies she didn't—not even a flicker of interest back then. And now here he is, alive and present, and she recognizes him immediately. But let's also talk about Eleanor's transformation. Ten years ago she was weak, passive, easily swayed by 'elders' and well-meaning but manipulative women like the Baroness. She walked home barefoot in pointed shoes rather than ask for help. This version of Eleanor—the one with ten years of lived betrayal behind her eyes—is already different. She's strategic. She makes Anna complicit in her deception of the Baroness without even asking. She sets boundaries. The shift isn't instant superpower energy; it's more like someone who has learned that kindness without boundaries gets you killed. And Marcus—oh god, Marcus. The fact that he was writing sincere-seeming letters while Baroness Gotren was orchestrating everything from behind the scenes makes him even more disgusting. He wasn't just a Gold Digger; he was a calculated actor who played the long game for a TITLE. The line 'I will give my wife a funeral befitting her station' while strangling her—how is someone supposed to read that and not feel physically ill?
... Read More
'Cayel... do you like that mark more than you like me?'—I am not okay with this. I am genuinely not okay. Here is a man who just told a woman sent by the council of elders to 'get out' like it was nothing. Here is a man who commands armies and territories and speaks in low, controlled voices that make Eleanor's knees weak. And yet—YET—he gets sulky and tries to pull away because his wife was admiring a MARK on his skin. This is the most human moment in the entire book. I love how Eleanor reads him though. 'No. To be more precise, it is less that he is upset and more that... He seems jealous.' She figures it out herself without needing him to explain. That's growth. That's the woman she's becoming—someone who can see past the surface, past the title and the reputation, into the actual person underneath. And her response wasn't mockery. It wasn't 'oh you're cute.' She kissed him. She said 'I am glad to learn something about you that I did not know before' with genuine warmth. This is what makes their dynamic work—she doesn't dominate him or coddle him, she MATCHES him. The scene where she closes her thighs around him to stop him from withdrawing because she doesn't want him to leave—that's not just physical. That's her saying 'I want to know more, and I want you here while I do it.'
... Read More
There's a scene in this batch that doesn't have explosions or declarations or even dialogue, and it's easily the most powerful one: Eleanor sitting at her father's desk in the marquis's study. The description is spare but precise. 'It remained as neat and orderly as it had always been.' Those five words carry an entire lifetime of memory. In her previous life, Marcus barred her from this room. He controlled every space she occupied, every document she could touch, every corner of the house that symbolized power. And now? She walks in freely. She looks around at the traces of her father that fill every corner. She sits down and starts working. The physical space tells us everything about Eleanor's arc without the author having to spell it out. The study is both a prison she was once excluded from and a throne room she now claims. The stacks of reports and petitions on the desk represent real governance, real responsibility—things Marcus would never have shared with her. The Sivert domain itself is sketched in efficiently: three days from the capital, populated by collateral relatives and retired elders, a marquis's castle with renovated training grounds and large flowerbeds. Loren's description of the upgrades—the relaid floors, the added windows, the cleared weeds for mounted training—gives us a sense of a place that's been maintained but is now being actively improved. It feels lived-in, functional, not ornamental for its own sake. What strikes me most is how the worldbuilding serves the character journey rather than existing for its own sake. Every detail about the domain, the castle, the study exists to show Eleanor what she's gained and what she's fighting to protect.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or