Improper Relationship - Reviews

Improper Relationship
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I've been thinking about this chapter and the way the author uses everyday objects as stand-ins for emotional intimacy, and it's actually really clever. The skincare products. Yan Hai'an asking to borrow Sun Yan's skincare is such a small thing but it's loaded. You don't borrow someone's skincare unless you're comfortable in their space, unless there's some established intimacy. It's an act of provisional belonging—'I am allowed to use your things in your bathroom.' And Sun Yan's response isn't just practical, it's almost tender: 'Do you need a razor?' He's thinking ahead, planning for the next time Yan Hai'an might need something. The implication that there will be a next time hangs in the air between them. The shredded chicken porridge is another one. Sun Ling making it. Xu Hong serving it. The whole household gathered around this one dish that represents care, routine, family. Yan Hai'an is offered this warmth and he can't stay. He's rushing back to buy breakfast for Mo Yisheng—who is somewhere in City B, probably not thinking about buying breakfast for anyone. The porridge becomes this symbol of the domestic life Yan Hai'an keeps choosing not to sit down for. And then there's the WeChat likes. In our current digital age, a like is the cheapest form of attention you can give someone. But when it's consistent—when it's every single post, across time—it becomes a pattern that means something. It's Yan Hai'an's version of finding love letters hidden in books. Quiet. Persistent. Easily dismissed if you're not looking closely. The author seems to be asking: what counts as proof that someone cares? Is it grand gestures or is it showing up in the mundane?
... Read More
Okay so here's the thing about this arc - Sun Yan just fully loses his damn mind in the most predictably hot way possible. One second he's being all tender with that kiss, like 'I'll take our relationship seriously,' and the next he's pivoting to 'either you move out or I move in' like it's the most logical next step after confessing feelings. And honestly? The plot doesn't even let him get away with being reasonable. It's almost like the author needed to establish that yes, they're together now, but NO, Sun Yan isn't suddenly going to be the chill boyfriend everyone hoped for. The house inspection scene is genius plotting because it does triple duty: it advances the plot (they're discussing living arrangements), it reveals character (Sun Yan's wealth is staggering and he has zero awareness of how crazy this sounds), and it raises the stakes (Yan Hai'an is already feeling the pressure of debt and obligation). When Sun Yan suggests buying him a car and Yan Hai'an refuses, that's when the real conflict ignites. The author doesn't let up - Sun Yan gets serious about car safety, which is actually touching in a twisted way, but then immediately pivots back to 'just be with me and be obedient.' The narrative rhythm here is masterful: every time Yan Hai'an thinks he might have a moment of agency, Sun Yan steamrolls it with affection and money. What really struck me is how the author handles the Mo Yisheng complication without making it a huge dramatic moment. It's dropped in almost casually - 'who will take care of Yi Sheng after I move out?' - and Sun Yan's response is hilariously dismissive. He offers to hire a nanny, then immediately forgets about it and starts planning their future together. This tells us everything about Sun Yan's character: Mo Yisheng is important to Yan Hai'an, but to Sun Yan, he's just an obstacle to be managed. The plot is building toward something bigger with this arrangement, I can feel it.
... Read More
'The mooncake bought from China were placed on the white iron table and ruby-colored wine was flowing in the goblet next to them.' I keep coming back to this scene. The writer doesn't go overboard with descriptions, but every detail lands. The European-style balcony, the hazy night, the grape air rippling around them — it's cinematic without feeling forced. You can see it. You can feel it. What I love is how the setting mirrors their emotional state. They've survived chaos, violence, near-death experiences, and here they are — watching the moon rise over vineyards, drinking wine, reading poetry. The world outside is still there (Sun Ling closing business deals, Mo Yisheng in Iceland), but for these two, everything has narrowed down to this exact moment. The grape harvest season timing is perfect too. Life continuing, nature doing what it does, while two men who almost lost everything get to sit in the aftermath and pretend — no, actually believe — that this peace is permanent. It's a writer who trusts the atmosphere instead of drowning it in exposition. Rare and beautiful.
... Read More
Okay so can we just talk about Sun Yan for a sec because the man does NOT ask for favors. He asks for help, sure, but it's always packaged in something that benefits HIM. The whole art museum pitch? Brilliant. He frames it as Yan Hai'an choosing his own salary, making it sound like a dream opportunity, but let's be real—he just wants someone competent running his side projects while keeping our boy close. And Yan Hai'an knows this. He literally thinks about how they can't communicate well but still says yes. That's not naive—that's a man who's been around blockheads long enough to know when someone's actually pulling out all the stops for him. The birthday trip thing is what gets me though. The way Sun Yan goes from sullen "Oh. You can go." to literally jumping up and chasing after him with "DO YOU WANT TO TAKE ME TO SEE YOUR PARENTS?!" is the most honest reaction in the whole book. This is a guy who orchestrates ruin via media manipulation for breakfast, but ask him to meet his boyfriend's dad and he short-circuits into pure panic-energy. And Yan Hai'an's little power move—pretending he doesn't need Sun Yan to come, then walking away—shows he absolutely understands how to play this guy. Every time.
... Read More
So there's this one image that keeps running through my head from this chapter and honestly it's stuck with me. Yan Hai'an catching his own semen on the floor-to-ceiling windows last night, turning red, and then scrubbing it away with a napkin while Sun Yan sleeps like a baby. The sheer contrast between the obscene and the mundane is so good. These two just had an intense encounter, barely prepared, wild energy between them, and now the aftermath is just... yellowed stains on glass and someone eating potato chips in a bathrobe. The author writes these details with such casual observation. Not romanticized, not dramatized. Just: morning light, half-covered body, breathing rhythm, muscle definition, random junk food crumbs. It makes the world feel lived in. You can picture this hotel room. You know what the breakfast looks like — fish porridge, steamed buns, fried noodles. The specificity grounds everything. This isn't some vague fantasy setting; these people exist in real cities, real hotels, real phone calls to real assistants named Su Yin. The door scene too — midnight doorbell, the dramatic crack in the door, Sun Yan's casual "Yo?" like he owns the place. The whole setup of it feels cinematic without trying too hard. I could see this as a show. The lighting, the positioning, the tension — it all reads like a camera movement. And the fact that Sun Yan just walks in and forces his way past Yan Hai'an's resistance shows the power dynamic without narration explaining it. The environment does the work.
... Read More
The imagery in this passage is so deliberate it almost hurts. Yan Hai'an is described as a "quiet tree" — tall, restrained, providing shade and protection. Mo Yisheng is a "diamond that doesn't know how to hide itself" — brilliant, valuable, but also exposed and fragile. The contrast isn't accidental. One shields, the other shines. One endures, the other dazzles. Then there's the whole motif of blindness and sight. Mo Yisheng is literally "worldly ignorant" — he can't see the danger Sun Yan represents. Yan Hai'an has to be his eyes. But Sun Yan sees RIGHT THROUGH Yan Hai'an. That sharp gaze that pokes at his face? Sun Yan notices everything. He sees the tension, the fake excuse, the protective instinct. And Li Qing — she sees even more. She understands the family history, she reads Yan Hai'an's real concern beneath his polite words. The painting theme matters too. Mo Yisheng wants to paint Greek mythology — stories of gods and mortals, tragic relationships, people destroyed by forces beyond their control. Isn't that exactly what's happening to him right now? Sun Yan's interest could be the modern equivalent of some divine interference, a beautiful but dangerous force entering his insulated world. Even the car ride home feels symbolic — Yan Hai'an driving, steering them both away from danger, while Mo Yisheng sits quietly trusting the wheel. Who's really in control here?
... Read More
Yan Hai'an is such an interesting character, you know? On the surface he's just the caretaker, the one who handles everything so Mo Yisheng can paint in peace. But read closer — he's not meek or shy about it. The text literally says his restraint is "powerful" and that people "want to see it for a lifetime." He chose this role. He's guarding something precious. And the dynamic with Mo Yisheng! There's this heartbreaking asymmetry. Mo Yisheng just... trusts completely. He knows his only job is to draw and leaves the rest to Yan Hai'an. That's adorable but also kind of dangerous. Yan Hai'an himself feels conflicted about it — finds him "cute and precious" but worries his innocence is too vulnerable in this world. Then there's Sun Yan, and oh man, the tension between him and Yan Hai'an when they first meet. That sharp gaze Sun Yan shoots at Yan Hai'an? Yan Hai'an has to literally invent a fake studio emergency just to rescue Mo Yisheng. The author's note even confirms it's Sun Yan x Yan Hai'an, which makes that whole scene SO much more loaded. Li Qing too — she sees right through things. When she says if she were twelve years younger she'd be "crazy for" Yan Hai'an instead of Mo Yisheng, that's not just flirtation. She recognizes something in him. The quiet tree next to the blazing diamond. I keep wondering what happens when Sun Yan decides he wants what Yan Hai'an is protecting.
... Read More
Okay, can we just talk about how the earthquake scene is written? Not the drama — the PHYSICS of it. The author describes the space they're lying in as 'the disgustingly small space' from the night before, between the bed and the desk they HATED. And that tiny gap? It's what keeps them alive. The heavy objects on both sides share the burden of the debris. That's such a clever narrative choice — their dislike of that cramped arrangement literally becomes their salvation. I love when authors do that kind of thing, where earlier annoyance transforms into something precious. The imagery throughout is brutal but controlled. 'Cement and roof rustled down.' 'Prefabricated panels broken into several sections are squeezing them.' There's this clinical precision to the violence of the collapse that makes it feel real. And the sound design! The rumbling like 'a warning before the arrival of death.' The ringing in Yan Hai'an's ears. Sun Yan coughing 'like a dying beast.' The contrast between the roaring chaos outside and that tiny pocket of air where two people are pressed together — it's cinematic without feeling overwrought.
... Read More
Let me just say this — the stakes in this chapter are quiet but they hit hard. Yan Hai'an's external conflict is obvious: he's leaving Mo Yisheng, he's navigating his complicated feelings for Sun Yan, he's dealing with business obligations that pull him away. But the REAL conflict is internal, and it's brutal. He doesn't even know 'how deep his feelings for Sun Yan are.' He can't determine 'to what extent Sun Yan's feelings for him are.' This uncertainty is the whole dang tragedy. Meanwhile Mo Yisheng's stakes are simpler but no less devastating — he's faced with the possibility of abandonment and he doesn't even have the vocabulary to process it. He just says 'Oh' when Yan Hai'an mentions moving out. And Yan Hai'an? He goes to social events where people 'look down on him' because he's protecting Mo Yisheng from that contempt. The conflict isn't a dramatic confrontation — it's a slow unraveling of certainty. Every unanswered text from Sun Yan raises the stakes a little more. And that ending, Yan Hai'an on the sofa drunk, wondering about his own heart... that's the moment where everything could break.
... Read More
The world-building in this chapter is fascinating because it's almost entirely conveyed through what Sun Yan owns and how casually he discusses it. The duplex apartment on floors 7-8, the high-end community, the car showroom visits, the mention of Sun Ling shopping for clothes - these aren't just background details. They construct a world where money solves everything except the one thing that actually matters. The most vivid scene is the car showroom moment. Sun Yan leaning against the door, smoking, the cigarette burning down between his fingers - there's this cinematic quality to it that the author captures without trying. It's the contrast between the sterile luxury of the showroom and Sun Yan's raw, unguarded emotion that makes it land. We're watching a man who can buy any car in the building but can't buy the compliance he craves from the man sitting in the passenger seat. The walk back from the showroom is described with such specificity - the red light, the sluggish atmosphere, Sun Yan regaining his 'strength' like a battery being recharged. The author understands that these environments aren't just backdrop; they're emotional amplifiers. The luxury stores, the expensive cars, the high-end apartments - they create a pressure cooker where Sun Yan's wealth becomes both his power and his prison. What strikes me most is how the author builds this world through absence as much as presence. We never see Yan Hai'an's own space, his own life outside of Sun Yan's orbit. The world-building is deliberately lopsided, just like the relationship itself - everything revolves around Sun Yan's resources, his choices, his vision of their future. The setting tells us everything we need to know about the power dynamic without a single exposition dump.
... Read More
Can we talk about how Yan Hai'an basically became Mo Yisheng's full-time human support system? Like, half his attention is on keeping Yi Sheng alive and fed, and the other half is actively panicking about some entitled art world figure knocking at their door. The level of domestic intimacy here is *chef's kiss* — he notices paint on Mo Yisheng's face without being told, he cleans up brushes, he unscrews cola cans for him, he finds the phone that fell behind the cushions. And Mo Yisheng, sweet socially-awkward artist, just accepts this caretaking like it's completely normal. "I can't change it" when called out for his temper? That's the kind of line that makes me want to squeeze both of them. But what really gets me is the power dynamic underneath all this. Yan Hai'an is clearly the more street-smart one — he handles Sun Yan's threats with that fake business politeness while internally fuming. He knows how to play the game. Meanwhile, Mo Yisheng operates on pure black-and-white principles. He doesn't understand social maneuvering at all. And yet, he's the one everyone seems to want. Sun Yan saw him at an exhibition and immediately wanted to commission him. There's something quietly powerful about that contrast — the artist who can't handle a phone call vs. the guy who talks his way through every uncomfortable situation. Also, the translator's note about "little sisters" made me laugh out loud. These part-time art students are basically their support staff, and Yan Hai'an literally describes himself as "becoming a nanny." I'm here for it.
... Read More
Okay so this whole scene where Sun Yan just appears at the studio and then drags Yan Hai'an to lunch is such a bold move. Like, he literally says "I plan to come often in the future" with no chill whatsoever. That's not a threat, that's a declaration of war, and I love it. The pacing here is also insane — the author just drops this whole confrontation in the middle of what should be a normal day, and suddenly everything shifts. Yan Hai'an is clearly uncomfortable but he can't exactly kick this guy out. What I loved most was how the scene escalates naturally from fake politeness to barely hidden hostility. Sun Yan is sitting there cutting beef like everything's fine while absolutely dismantling Yan Hai'an's composure. The author doesn't overexplain anything either — we just know through context that Sun Yan has this reputation for being a player and Yan Hai'an is trying to protect Yi Sheng from all that. And then the checkout moment? Absolutely iconic. Yan Hai'an paying over 2000 yuan for a meal he can't afford just because Sun Yan invited him? That's the perfect visual metaphor for the whole power dynamic between these two. One more thing — the line "Yi Sheng is still sleeping... he paints all day and night, and he stayed up all night last night" hit me so hard. That detail about Yi Sheng being exhausted and isolated is basically the Inciting Incident of the whole story. Sun Yan sees a vulnerable artist and he's going after him. The plot engine just started revving.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or