I’ll Make Him My Favorite! - Reviews

I’ll Make Him My Favorite!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The four directional gardens sequence is one of those moments where the worldbuilding sneaks up on you and hits like a truck. Four gardens, each with flowers that carry symbolic meaning — roses for love and passion to the north, nasturtiums for loyalty and victory to the south, carnations for health and respect to the west, and acacia for friendship and loyalty to the east. This isn't just decoration; it's a language. Every step Eloa takes through this estate is mapped with meaning. And then the eastern garden reveal — white acacia blooming densely across the ceiling, artificial moonlight pooling on a dome-shaped pergola that looks like it was designed specifically for romantic declarations. "Even love that does not exist would come into being" — and right there, Siobhan is standing. The author sets up this almost fairytale atmosphere and then drops your protagonist's actual emotional chaos right into the center of it. But the worldbuilding doesn't stop at flowers. Alb's exposition about the great noble families is seamlessly woven into the garden tour. The Istria family's intellect and foresight, the Hylus bloodline's physical superiority and natural charm, the Herrmann family's financial genius — each dynasty's traits explain why certain marriages make political sense and others don't. When Alb casually mentions that strategic marriages happen once every six generations, and that this year was supposed to be Eden's turn, the entire political landscape of Ermensel becomes suddenly visible. The engagement isn't just personal; it's a seismic shift that upended centuries of tradition. And the ducal residence itself — ceilings and floors decorated with unified but varied art, works by famous painters hanging along walls, an outdoor greenhouse and indoor garden — this isn't just a house, it's a living museum of power and taste.
... Read More
The wisteria garden scene is everything. Like, the author just drops this one detail and suddenly the whole atmosphere shifts. "Not long after leaving the dining room, a small garden with wisteria in full bloom caught my eye. Perhaps it showed that my heart had been captured by those wisteria blossoms. My footsteps slowed without my realizing it." This is Loa experiencing something genuine—beauty stopping her in her tracks—and it's framed as her heart being CAPTURED. Not by Eden, not by the political situation, but by WISTERIA FLOWERS. And then Dias tells her this is "a garden the late Duchess cherished very much." Eden's MOTHER's garden. She's walking through HER space, and Eden finds her there, and the whole emotional weight of that location just... hangs in the air without anyone saying a word about it. Then there's the moonlight detail. So many times I noticed the moonlight reference—it's not accidental. Eden's hair "turned silver beneath the moonlight." His eyes "resembled moonlight." There's this whole ethereal quality to how he's described in this chapter, like he's almost not entirely human when the moon is involved. The Hylus bloodline bewitchment Alb mentioned—could that be connected to the moonlight imagery? Is there a literal supernatural element or is it just atmospheric prose doing heavy lifting? Either way, it works. The dining room scene is also surprisingly vivid. The steaming food, Alb's skillful service, the servants chatting about the master and prospective mistress—the whole household feels ALIVE. This isn't just a castle with NPCs; it's a place with history, with people who care about their lord, with a late duchess whose memory lingers in garden paths. Alb's twenty years of service matter. The fact that he was the servant Eden saw last time (when Loa first arrived) creates this through-line of continuity. And the forest earlier—though we only see it through Eden's POV—there are these sharp, violent images: Loa's slender fingertips trembling, the bandit's blade, the transport magic stone inside the carriage that he had to retrieve. The chaos of it contrasts so sharply with the quiet garden scene. One moment he's ordering mass executions, the next he's chasing his fiancée through flowering vines because she won't meet his eyes. The imperial palace summons is mentioned but not described—we're told the emperor is "about ready to die of curiosity" about the engagement, which tells us everything about the political stakes without needing a full court scene. The world feels lived-in because we get these fragments: a mother's garden, a butler's twenty years of worry, a duke who hasn't slept on his sofa in fifteen years, a prospective duchess who gets assigned a knight who turns tomato-red when Loa kisses her hand. "The late Duchess. That would be referring to Eden's mother." This small realization from Loa—connecting the name to the person—gives us access to the history of this house without an info-dump. We learn about the late duchess the same way Loa does: through fragments, through garden paths, through the quiet spaces where memory lingers. It's atmospheric storytelling at its finest. The setting isn't backdrop—it's emotional architecture.
... Read More
This whole section moves like a rollercoaster that someone keeps pulling the emergency brake on and then suddenly accelerating again. You start with the aftermath of the engagement ceremony — relatively calm, lots of dialogue-driven exposition about the bandit attack and Ter Giuo's involvement. Eden's matter-of-fact delivery of "I extracted their testimony and had them all killed" is such a casual way to dispose of people it immediately recalibrates your understanding of who this man is. Then we get the garden tour, which is slower, more atmospheric, and deliberately designed to let you breathe. Alb's narration about the noble families feels almost gentle in its pacing. Siobhan's entrance lands perfectly here — after all that setup, he appears like a light breaking through. Their conversation is warm, funny, emotionally rich. And then BAM. Eden walks in. Right when she's just had this beautiful moment with her favorite character, the romance plot slams back into her face. But the real pacing masterstroke comes at the end. She starts connecting dots — Herrmann, the name, the female lead's surname — and her thoughts race faster and faster until the prose itself seems to panic. "Good heavens. The story of the novel is changing." Every previous assumption she'd built her strategy on is unraveling in real time. The engagement she planned to divorce in two years was supposed to be with Hesse Herrmann's family. The original meeting between Eden and the female lead hasn't happened yet. And the divorce plan? Completely irrelevant if the whole narrative has already shifted. The chapter ends mid-thought with Eden asking "What do you mean by 'how it was supposed to be'" and that unfinished question hangs there like a blade. Perfect cliffhanger. The pacing here knows exactly when to speed up and when to linger, and it never lets you settle into any single emotional register for too long.
... Read More
Okay so Siobhan. SIOBHAN. You know that tragic supporting character you always wished had a happier ending in the original novel? He literally CRASHES into the heroine in this scene like some kind of knightly anime protagonist. The author did NOT come to play. Let's talk about that first impression moment because omg. She's extending her hand for a polite handshake — normal social behavior, you know? — and Siobhan just GRABS her and pulls her into his arms like 'arrow incoming, sorry not sorry.' And then an arrow WHISTS past where her chest would have been if he hadn't moved. That is the most aggressive, most efficient, most romantic rescue in the history of romance novels and I am HERE for it. But here's what actually got me — Siobhan is wearing the ducal knighthood uniform instead of the imperial one. That's a MASSIVE deviation from the original story. In the book, he only joins the imperial knighthood AFTER meeting Hesse Herrmann, and Hylus was the one who originally sponsored him based on his battlefield performance. So something is seriously different now. Either the timeline has shifted because Eloa didn't marry Ter Giuo, or Hylus made different choices than in the original. This means Siobhan's entire arc is changing — he's still loyal to Hylus, still a commoner who rose through the ranks, but now he's physically present in this moment protecting Eloa instead of being a background tragedy. And then — AND THEN — when a bandit charges at Siobhan from the side and knocks him flying, leaving Eloa defenseless with a blade coming at her... he still tries to get back to her. I swear to god. The man is a saint. He's a tragic hero who's supposed to die sad and alone in the original, and here he is throwing himself into danger for the heroine without hesitation. Meanwhile Hylus is interrogating Eloa like a suspicious husband and Siobhan is just over here playing bodyguard. The dynamic between these three is going to be SO interesting. I need to know what happened between Hylus and Siobhan that changed the timeline, and whether Siobhan's loyalty to Hylus will ever be tested. Also can we just appreciate that Eloa immediately asks about Siobhan's well-being before asking about her own injuries? Priorities.
... Read More
The word 'responsibility' gets thrown around like ten times in these chapters and it's clearly doing heavy thematic lifting. At first it seems like a comedic misunderstanding—she accidentally kisses him, he demands accountability—but by the end it transforms into something far more significant. She says 'I have someone I must take responsibility for' and means both her family AND her own survival. Hylus claims the same word to describe his claim on her. Both are using it as justification, but neither is entirely wrong. The blue butterflies in the greenhouse fascinate me too. They're beautiful, delicate, ethereal—and they're in a GLASS enclosure. Trapped beauty. Our protagonist is literally hiding behind someone's body while butterflies flutter around, and later she visits the Hylus estate which the world fears. There's a parallel between freedom and imprisonment running through every scene. And the newspaper headline—'Duke Hylus Spends a Night of Pleasure with an Engaged Woman, Shattering Her Betrothal!' The media as a weapon. Ter Giuo didn't just lose face; he weaponized scandal to destroy her reputation. The theme of women being judged differently for the same actions is right there in that headline. She's the one 'shattering' her betrothal, but the duke gets the romanticized treatment. The founding families themselves represent different kinds of power—money, diplomacy, war—and our protagonist is caught between them all. She's a count's daughter with no real political leverage trying to navigate a world where every interaction is a transaction. The moonlight, the greenhouse, the gloves, the whispered threats—it all builds this world where love and danger are indistinguishable.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about the atmospheric whiplash in these chapters because wow. We start in a forest—dark, dangerous, immediate. The prose is visceral: 'a chilling sound of a beast reached my ears from nearby. Grrrr.' Just that single onomatopoeia and you're hooked. The archery competition scene is where the worldbuilding really expands and becomes its own kind of character. The hunting competition detail is *everything*. I love that the first prize is a dead rabbit on a string being dragged through a windy field. It's so mundanely hilarious and so perfectly captures a world where nobility treats deadly archery as entertainment. 'This distance must be about twenty meters or so. It was far too close a distance for a South Korean archery athlete.' The narrator's internal voice here—comparing the competition to actual professional archery standards—creates this incredible contrast between the mundane and the extraordinary that defines the entire tone of the book. Then we cut to the imperial social party and the world just EXPANDS. There's a whole ecosystem of noble families, political marriages, social hierarchies, and regional territories all implied through casual dialogue. 'The daughter of Marquis Tepe,' 'Count Rumania,' 'Viscount Russell'—names drop and the world builds itself. The text never gives us an info dump. We learn about the society by watching people navigate it. I also want to highlight the forest exit scene. The protagonist helps the masked man out, he says 'Someone will come soon,' and then walks away into the shadows. This moment—where the world reveals its first layer of conspiracy (the beast wasn't native to this country)—feels like the story is winking at the reader and saying 'you're not just in a romance novel anymore.' The setting itself is becoming a puzzle, and that transition from simple forest survival to political intrigue is seamless. No genre whiplash, just organic expansion of the world's scope. I'm invested.
... Read More
I stayed up way too late reading these chapters and I have no regrets. The pacing here is aggressive in the best possible way. Chapter after chapter of escalating revelations: the contract marriage is proposed and accepted, she discovers the diary blank page, Hylus comes through the window, the forest encounter is revealed to be him, and then—the magical pain episode that ends everything. What I love is how the author modulates tension. The Brandt crying scene provides emotional breathing room after the high-stakes contract negotiation. Then Kayla's warmth lightens the mood. Then Summer knocks and we get a near-intimate moment. Then Hylus reveals the forest man was him all along—which is a huge information drop—and then immediately the pain hits. The structure follows a classic escalation pattern but with smart variations. Each scene introduces a new element: the contract, the diary mystery, the magic stones, the disguise reveal, the pain symptom. None of them repeat the emotional territory of the previous scene. By the time we reach the final paragraph—"I was not in a forest or a bedroom, but in a space of nothing but darkness"—the reader has been throughProposal → Family drama → Romantic tension → Identity reveal → Physical crisis. That's five major story beats and we haven't even hit the midpoint of the chapters. The cliffhanger is brutal. She collapses from magical pain, loses consciousness, and wakes up in a void. The author could have ended on the forest reveal and let readers breathe—but no. One more gut punch to close the section. This is how you keep someone scrolling past midnight.
... Read More
Okay so we need to talk about Eden because this chapter absolutely laid him bare. The guy is literally wrestling with his own jealousy and it's both devastating and adorable. Here's the thing: he pushed back Siobhan's imperial knighthood assignment to PROTECT Eden (Loa), and now he's thinking about moving it up AGAIN because of... what? Because she smiles when she talks about Siobhan? That's not just jealousy, that's him realizing he's been caught. And the most telling part is how he describes it: "She had done nothing, yet she made him jealous, and made him childish." He literally calls himself out on it. That self-awareness from someone who's clearly not used to examining his own feelings? The forest scene earlier though—when he found her with the bandit's blade coming at her—his reaction was instantaneous. No hesitation, just "pulled her roughly into his arms" and ordered every person in that forest killed. "Make sure not a single one who was in this forest leaves it alive." And then he couldn't even stay with her afterward because he was worried about appearing vulnerable. "Unable to delay even a moment leaving the collapsed Loa behind, he moved to the ducal residence rather than the temple." This man cares so much he can't even handle it. And then later, after she wakes up, he's sitting there spiraling about whether she's a spy—"Just what is her true identity?"—but then the very next paragraph, she opens her eyes, looks at him, and his entire suspicion just... melts. "Whatever she might be hiding from him, he would likely believe anything she said." Bro. You went from suspecting her of espionage to full-blown devotion in approximately four seconds. The Hylus bloodline bewitchment thing might be real but honestly I think it's just Eden being completely gone for her. The way he assigns Dias to her is also interesting. On the surface it's practical—she needs a personal knight at the ducal residence. But the subtext? He's putting a loyal guard closest to her because he can't stop thinking about her. He can't even let her exist in his space without monitoring who surrounds her. Dias's reaction to Loa though—turning red and practically fleeing—is one of my favorite details. The girl literally can't handle how lovely Loa is. And then Loa, bless her, tries to do the novel-perfect response where she kisses Dias's hand and blesses her, and Dias short-circuits completely. This is a woman who is going to be LOYAL to Loa until she dies, and it started with a flustered blush. What I love most is how Eden's vulnerability keeps peaking through his rigid exterior. Skipping meals for god knows how long, collapsing on that sofa after fifteen years, eating like a normal person for the first time because she's there. The servants are noticing. Alb explicitly says he's been worried about his master skipping meals, and now Loa has him eating properly. She's fixing him without even trying. "He liked her. Without a doubt." And then immediately pivots to thinking about moving up Siobhan's knighthood date as revenge for making him jealous. That's not a powerful duke. That's a lovesick idiot who happens to have absolute authority. ...Am I the only one who thinks the engagement contract is going to be the least complicated thing about this relationship at this point?
... Read More
Let me just say this once and be done with it: Count Brandt is my new favorite father figure in fiction and I will fight anyone who disagrees. "Loaaa, my one and only daughter!" he wails, then proceeds to cry against his wife's shoulder like a toddler. And Kayla—sweet, pragmatic Kayla—who immediately switches from delighted to comforting mode, telling her husband "Please don't cry so much. The time has come for us to send our Loa off." This couple is absolutely iconic. What strikes me is the emotional honesty of it all. Brandt isn't pretending he's fine. He's not doing that noble father thing where he suppresses his feelings for political appearances. He is openly, unabashedly sad that his daughter is growing up and leaving home. And then he immediately pivots to practicality—"we would like to proceed with an engagement first"—because that's what fathers do, right? They fall apart and then they make arrangements. Kayla's line cut me the deepest though: "Mama and Papa just want you to be happy. Please do not think of the family, and marry for your own happiness." In a story full of political marriages and contract arrangements, the Rumania family genuinely prioritizing their daughter's emotional wellbeing over status is radical. Eloa had told Summer earlier that she wore such an expression when engaged to Marquis Ter Giuo, "as though you were being sold off." And now her parents are looking at her choosing HER path and the dad is sobbing. Meanwhile Eloa is eating corn soup alone in her room because she can't face her crying father, which is both funny and devastating. She's a transmigrator who doesn't truly belong to this family, and yet these people love her enough to break down at the thought of losing her. That contrast between her internal alienation and their genuine warmth is what makes this family feel so real.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this greenhouse scene because omg. The way the author describes it is so cinematic—moonlight streaming through glass, blue butterflies fluttering around, and the whole thing just feels like a painting. 'Beneath the brightly shining moonlight, blue butterflies danced and fluttering about, creating a breathtaking sight.' I literally stopped scrolling and just stared at my phone for a second. This is the kind of description that makes you feel like you're actually THERE, standing in that garden with the protagonist, heart pounding, trying to hide behind some random duke. And the contrast! You've got this gorgeous, almost dreamy setting—blue butterflies, shimmering moonlight—and then it cuts to Ter Giuo's voice calling out, shattering the moment completely. The author uses the environment so well to build tension. The greenhouse becomes this private bubble away from the party, but it's also a trap because there's no real escape route. Every time Ter Giuo gets closer, the protagonist grips Hylus's sleeve tighter. The setting mirrors the emotional squeeze she's in. Also? The Hylus ducal estate. Later when she goes to confront him there, the narrator mentions it's known as a place where they 'devour even the living.' That worldbuilding detail drops so casually but it's actually terrifying when you think about it. These noble families aren't just rich—they're dangerous. The founding families' history (war, wealth, diplomacy) is woven into the political landscape in a way that makes the whole world feel layered and real. I love it.
... Read More
This part where they travel to the temple for the blessing—such a quiet, almost mundane scene after all the tension. But the world-building details are everywhere. The magic stones can't be used near temples because divine power and magical energy are opposite. That's a cool rule. It makes the world feel lived-in, like there are actual laws of physics and metaphysics at play. And the tradition of couples going to the temple to be blessed for a hundred years of happiness—it's sweet, traditional, and completely ironic because Eloa plans to divorce in two years. She even thinks about that. 'Though I would be divorcing Hylus in two years, so I would be unintentionally breaking that belief.' Little moments like that show how detached she is from this role she's playing. Meanwhile, the description of the carriage, the white carpet, the servants in livery, Hylus waiting at the end dressed in deep green to match her dress—it's all so cinematic. You can see it. The green suit, the dark hair, the formal posture. It's visually striking. And then her father crying, her mother comforting him. They're celebrating. But Eloa feels nothing but guilt. 'They were the family of the real Eloa Rumania, not the Eloa Rumania that Jang Hye-a had entered.' That line hit me hard. It's a reminder that every beautiful scene has a shadow underneath. The world is lush, detailed, and alive—but so is the pain.
... Read More
The pacing here is wild. One minute she's having this gut-wrenching nightmare about a sorcerer and her own blood, the next she's waking up to Hylus in her room, then a week later she's getting dressed for an engagement ceremony. That's a huge jump. But somehow it works. The nightmare scene is short, intense, and leaves questions. Then the waking scene is quieter, more conversational, letting you breathe. The time skip to a week before the ceremony is handled with a simple newspaper delivery. 'There is a nationwide newspaper article saying that you are getting engaged to Duke Hylus!' Boom. Done. No prolonged preparation scenes, no drama about choosing guests or discussing terms. Just... it's happening. And then the ceremony day arrives almost immediately. The author knows how to move. Some parts drag if you let them, but this section never does. Even the dress-fitting scene—with all those colorful descriptions—is brief and efficient. You get the sense of luxury, the variety, the weight of expectation, but you don't linger. It's all forward momentum. I loved it. And the ending of this batch, with them in the carriage heading to the temple, feels like a calm before the storm. Because we know something's going to break. The pacing makes you trust the author to deliver.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or