I’ll Make Him My Favorite! - Reviews

I’ll Make Him My Favorite!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I want to talk about how the author handles dialogue because it's actually really clever and I don't think people are giving it enough credit. Take Hylus, for instance. His lines are short, clipped, and devastating. "If you are thinking of running away, I suggest you give up on that idea." Not a question. A statement delivered while looking out the window like he's discussing the weather. That's how you write a duke who has never raised his voice and yet everyone around him trembles. And then later: "Who are you? Are you truly Lady Eloa Rumania?" Short sentences. Direct questions. No preamble. The dialogue itself IS his personality — he doesn't waste words because he doesn't need to. People obey him regardless. But here's what's fascinating — the narrator's internal voice is COMPLETELY different from everyone's spoken dialogue. Eloa's thoughts are chaotic, self-deprecating, full of modern humor and pop-culture references. "Am I going to set a Guinness World Record for the number of times I have passed out?" vs. what she actually says out loud, which is properly formal and composed. That gap between inner voice and outward speech is where the comedy lives, and also where the tension lives. She's performing competence while internally panicking. The carriage scene before the attack is basically pure dialogue-driven character building: "Is it funny?" "Of course. The image of Your Grace being at the mercy of servants is simply unimaginable." "Pfft." That's it. Two lines and we understand their entire dynamic. She sees through his dignity. He lets her. There's warmth there that he'd never admit to in public but shows in private moments like this. And Siobhan's formal introduction — "How do you do, Duchess. I am Siobhan Akane of the Hylus ducal knighthood." — is perfectly stiff and proper, which makes the fact that he immediately grabs her and pulls her into a hug even funnier. His dialogue says one thing, his actions say another. Classic. Schmitz's dialogue is also distinctive — he speaks in measured, academic sentences full of qualifiers: "It is not impossible," "I have only seen it in academic journals myself... this is my first time seeing it in person." You can HEAR the scholar in every word. He's not threatening or commanding — he's observing and cataloguing, which makes his revelation about Eloa's constitution feel clinical rather than dramatic, which somehow makes it MORE dramatic. The dialogue rhythms in this passage are all different for each character. That's skilled writing.
... Read More
Okay, so the bandit ambush happened right after the engagement ceremony, and honestly the stakes kept climbing faster than I could track. First off, fifteen or so bandits isn't normal even for that forest — Eden himself pointed out that he'd already cleared them out the day before. So either someone hired entirely new mercenaries, or this was a completely separate operation. The fact that Ter Giuo paid for it makes sense on the surface — wounded pride after the broken engagement — but something about it felt too small-time for the level of organization involved. Then there's the anti-faction lurking in the background, led by Marchioness Aibel Shaga according to the protagonist's knowledge of the original novel. But here's the thing: the novel never actually explained HOW she was revealed as the leader. Eloa can't remember the details, which means she's operating on incomplete information. That's terrifying. She's walking into political minefields blind, telling the duke her guesses as if they're facts, and hoping he finds evidence to back her up. Meanwhile, Ter Giuo is still at large. Eden promises to catch him, but we know how these things go — the villain escapes to fight another day. The tension isn't just about physical danger; it's about how much of the plot Eloa can actually manipulate when she's missing crucial details. What happens when her memory of the novel fails her at the worst possible moment? That's the real suspense, not the bandits themselves.
... Read More
"I will marry someone I love." Two years as Duchess. Divorce. Marry Siobhan Akane. On the surface this is a simple contract marriage story. But the stakes are stacking up in ways that make my stomach twist with anxiety. Layer one: Eloa needs to break off her engagement to Marquis Ter Giuo. Hylus is helping her, but this is a political gamble— a count's daughter rejecting a marquis is unheard of, and she's using a duke's authority to make it possible. If this goes wrong, her family's standing is ruined. Layer two: She's hiding that she's a transmigrator. Everyone thinks she's just Eloa Rumania with strong opinions. But she nearly slipped up about archery—"I had nearly let slip something from my days as Jang Hye-a." One wrong word and everything collapses. Layer three: The magical pain. This new symptom—"a thunderous roar rang out inside my head. Along with the roar, my heart began racing at an uncontrollable speed, then stopped for a brief moment"—is clearly connected to the soul exchange or the body she's inhabiting. Whatever is happening to her physically, it's escalating. Layer four: Hylus knows something. He recognized her in the forest. He knew who she was at the palace party. He's been playing a longer game than she realizes, and the communication stone he gave her? That's not just convenience—that's control. He's building a channel to her that she can't intercept or monitor. The most terrifying line in this entire section is Hylus saying "She will be the most audacious duchess among all the duchesses in history" with that sly smile. He knows she's plotting something. He's letting her think she's using him while he's using her, and both of them are probably right. I am so nervous for everyone involved.
... Read More
The stakes here are massive. Eloa collapsed for five days. Five days! That's not a minor illness. Something is wrong with her, physically or magically or both. And then immediately, without recovery, she's thrust into an engagement ceremony. The pressure is relentless. What is the source of her collapse? The nightmare with the sorcerer hints at dark magic, possibly tied to her identity. Is she being hunted? Is her very existence a threat? And Hylus—he knows something. He visited her at night, sent his physician, gave her a communication stone. He's involved, but how deep? The conflict isn't just external; it's internal. Eloa is a transmigrator, Jang Hye-a inside Eloa Rumania's body. She remembers her past life, she knows the plot, she knows she'll divorce in two years. But every day she stays in this body, she risks becoming entangled. Her feelings for her adoptive family, her guilt, her confusion—they're all weapons the story can use against her. The stakes aren't just about survival or romance; they're about identity, autonomy, and whether she can rewrite her fate or if she's trapped in someone else's story. And that final scene in the carriage, heading to the temple, with her father crying and her mother smiling—it's beautiful and heartbreaking. Because we know it's all a lie. And yet, she's starting to care. That's the real danger.
... Read More
THE BACK AND FORTH between Rumania and Hylus is everything. I'm not even mad that he's calling her lip a peck after literally kissing her hand. His line 'You have taken my first kiss, so you must take responsibility' had me wheezing. The sheer AUDACITY of this man showing up to a scandal and just… leaning into it? Chef's kiss. But what I really appreciate is how the author gives each character a distinct voice. Ter Giuo sounds desperate and self-important—'Lady Rumania, I searched for you for quite a while' while simultaneously being the kind of guy who writes newspaper hit pieces about women. Hylus is dry, controlled, almost amused even in tense moments. And Rumania's internal monologue? Pure chaotic energy. 'This wasn't a kiss, it was a peck!' she insists, and then immediately contradicts herself. She's flustered and funny and I adore her. The office confrontation later is peak dialogue: 'I only believe what I have seen with my own eyes. If I ever witness Your Grace devouring someone alive, I shall make sure to come with a knight next time.' She's standing in the territory of the most dangerous duke in the empire and she's making jokes. That's character development through speech alone. And the narrative voice—first person, very immediate, very present-tense-feeling even though it's past tense. It reads like someone telling you a wild story at 2am. Very conversational, very relatable, zero pretension.
... Read More
"In that instant, my leg caught on the chair nearby and my body lurched sharply to one side." "Before even a short gasp could escape me, I was caught by Hylus's firm arms." Holy. Just—holy. Okay let's talk about the absolute choreography happening between Eloa and Hylus here because my heart cannot handle it. This man comes into her room through the WINDOW at night like some kind of romantic supervillain and she... she covers his mouth without thinking. That is not the reaction of someone who is intimidated or afraid. That is the reaction of someone who is protecting him. Who has his back. And then she trips and falls into his arms and his robe slips open and he's wearing BLACK HAIR and oh my god the layering. But what really got me is this moment: "Miss, why are you standing there?" Summer knocking on the door and Eloa's immediate instinct is to silence her future husband. She doesn't hesitate. She doesn't consider her own position. She just—acts. And then the awareness hits her afterward and she steps back and trips. That sequence is everything. It's how you show chemistry without having them touch in any traditionally romantic way. And Hylus—this man who came in claiming he'd make rumors into fact, who looked at her like a predator—let's be honest he's the one who's been caught here. He climbed through her third-floor window. He dyed his hair. He brought her a communication stone so they could stay in touch. "I cannot come to your home every single time." That line hit me like a truck. He's planning a future with her and he's doing it through magic stones and stealthy window entries. The forest reveal changed everything for me. The man she helped before—Eden Cler, Hylus in disguise, with patchy dye—had already seen her face. He knew who she was at the palace party and still helped her. Every interaction they've had has been layered with secrets on both sides. Neither of them is showing their full hand. And that's what makes every scene between them electric. I am not ready for this marriage to actually happen. I need to sit down.
... Read More
"Among the pages densely filled with writing on both sides, only this one sheet was clean. Even when held up to the light, nothing appeared. It was simply a clean piece of paper." A blank page in a diary that's otherwise full. What does that mean? Is something being erased? Is there a message hidden that requires a specific key to reveal? Or is it symbolic—representing Eloa's own position as someone who doesn't yet have her story written in this world? Then there's the hair. Hylus's natural hair is bright—silver, the text says, "resembling moonlight." But he dyes it black to move incognito. And when Eloa sees him with black hair, she feels a "strangely familiar sensation." The dye is wearing off in patches in the forest, which is why she noticed something was off even then. Silver under black. The truth always shows through. This motif of surfaces versus realities runs through everything. The contract marriage is a surface arrangement covering her real goal of meeting Siobhan. Hylus appears as a dangerous predator but shows vulnerability through his window visits. Eloa pretends to be a normal noble lady but is actually a transmigrator with knowledge of the novel's plot. The blank diary page hides something invisible. And the emperor who chose divorce over concubinage—"taking a concubine was no different from doing a terrible wrong to the empress"—that historical detail isn't just world flavor. It's a thematic statement about the story itself: the question of whether authentic choice matters more than social appearance. Eloa is literally choosing her own path through a fake marriage, which makes her the living embodiment of that imperial precedent. I keep thinking about that blank page.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: I have never been more invested in whether someone lives or dies in a novel than I was during this forest sequence. The carriage wheel breaks. They're in the bandit capital of the world. They switch to horses. A dagger hits the horse's thigh. The horse bolts. Eloa — who has NEVER properly ridden a horse in her life — has to DISEMBARK from a thrashing, screaming animal while an arrow is aimed at her. And what does she do? She yanks the reins toward the bandit, leaps off, and lets the injured horse charge into him. That is not the action of a terrified princess. That is the action of someone who refused to die quietly. Then she tears her own dress with an arrowhead so she can run faster. FEWER WORDS. MORE ACTION. She's holding a bow now, hands shaking, never shot at a person before, and she puts an arrow straight through a bandit's forehead. And when Siobhan gets knocked down and another bandit comes at her with a sword — no arrows left, no time to react — the communication stone SHATTERS and releases a blast of magical energy that blinds the attacker. Every single threat is met with a desperate counter. The pacing here is relentless. There is no breather. No moment where you can set the book down and make tea. Bandit → horse → arrow → dress tear → kill → bandit behind Siobhan → sword → magic stone explosion → collapse. But what really raises the stakes isn't just the physical danger. It's the question Hylus levels at her afterward: "Who are you? Are you truly Lady Eloa Rumania? What proof is there that you're not part of the anti-faction?" Her eyes trembling. His voice cold. The implication that if she's lying, she dies. Not just imprisoned — DIE. And Eloa's response? "I am staking everything I have on these words... even my life." She doesn't flinch. She looks him in the eye and offers her life as collateral. That moment right there — survival in the forest followed by survival in the bedroom interrogation — is the perfect structural mirror. First she fights for her life against bandits. Then she fights for her identity against the man she's supposed to marry. Both scenes are about proving she deserves to exist in this world. The stakes keep compounding. The anti-faction exists. Hylus already captured them in the original novel, which means the political situation is different now. Siobhan's timeline has shifted. And Eloa's body has absorbed magical energy, giving her a constitution that appears in only 1 in 100,000 people — which could save her life or kill her if too much energy floods in at once. Every advantage comes with a deadly cost.
... Read More
The nightmare imagery is so rich with symbolism. Hair and blood. Those are classic ritual elements, yes, but they also represent identity, sacrifice, and perhaps a bond that can't be broken. Eloa gives her hair and a vial of dark crimson liquid—likely her own blood—to a sorcerer who looks exactly like her. That's surreal and deeply unsettling. It suggests a duality, a split self, maybe even a magical tether between her current life and whatever darkness she's trying to escape or confront. Then there's the color green. Hylus wears deep green to match her dress. Green in literature often means renewal, but also envy, sickness, or something unnatural. Here, it feels like a mask—a unified front for the public, a performance of partnership. But underneath, everything is fractured. The engagement itself is a symbol of arrangement, of duty over desire, of two people playing roles while hiding their true selves. And the temple blessing? A tradition promising a hundred years of happiness, which Eloa knows she'll shatter. The irony is thick. The novel keeps repeating these contrasts: light and dark, surface and depth, belief and cynicism. It's not just a romance; it's a meditation on what we wear, what we hide, and what we're willing to sacrifice for survival.
... Read More
Okay can we just talk about this one line for a second because I literally squealed into my pillow. "Get used to it. There will be more once we are married." Said so casually, like he's just telling her to stock up on socks or something, and I was completely undone. The whole carry-into-arms thing already had me questioning my life choices — he just lifts her like she weighs nothing, transports them across the palace, refuses to put her down even when she's punching his chest — and then he presses his lips to her forehead? Like, excuse me, since when does my fictional fiancé act this tenderly?? But here's the thing that got me: she's flustered and confused and her heart is beating faster, and her internal monologue immediately goes to DIVORCE. That's the emotional whiplash I'm here for. Every time he does something sweet, she reminders herself it's temporary. "Whenever talk of marriage with him came up, divorce always followed close behind in my thoughts like a shadow." Oof. That's not just bickering chemistry — that's genuine sadness underneath all the physical closeness. She's falling for someone who's already promised to leave her. That's not romance, that's a tragedy wearing a romantic comedy costume. And the hand-kiss! The forearm hug! The forehead press! He's doing ALL the things and she's sitting there internally short-circuiting while outwardly complaining about being carried around like a parcel. Also Schmitz moment where he and Loa spin around clasping hands like besties and Eden just watches with a gentle hand on her head?? That domestic softness is not fair to me personally.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about this nightmare sequence. It was so vivid and terrifying. Eloa sees herself, but also not herself—like her soul is watching from outside. The sorcerer with the silver dagger, the crimson liquid, the hair, the vial... everything felt so ritualistic and dark. And that moment when 'the eyes of Eloa... met mine'—chills. Actual chills. It makes you wonder what kind of ritual this is, what's at stake, and why Eloa is seeing it through a dream. Is it a premonition? A memory from another timeline? The book doesn't explain, but it sure as hell hooks you. I kept reading just to understand what that meant. Also, the way Hylus appears right after she wakes up—it's like the nightmare bleeds into reality. He touches her face, she instinctively leans into his hand. But then she remembers Summer might wake up. That tiny detail shows how fragile this whole situation is. They're playing a game where one wrong move could expose everything. Their relationship is so layered. On the surface, it's an arranged engagement. Underneath? Secret meetings at night, whispered conversations, unspoken understandings. And that line when he says 'You have lovely eyelashes'—it's casual, almost playful, but it's also intimate. He's checking her, reading her, knowing her. Then he drops the bomb about the engagement ceremony next week. No discussion, no negotiation. Just 'I will handle it.' That's not romantic, that's power. But also protection? Or control? I don't know which scares me more. Either way, I'm obsessed with where this goes.
... Read More
The garden scene. THE GARDEN SCENE. I need everyone to understand what just happened because my heart cannot handle this. So Loa is walking through this wisteria garden that belonged to Eden's late mother, and she's having this quiet moment, and Eden shows up, and what does he do? He gets in her face. Not metaphorically—literally. "Eden, who had stopped walking, suddenly thrust his face toward hers. His eyes, which resembled moonlight, shone with a forlorn glow." FORLORN. He looks at her like she's something he's about to lose. And then she runs. Of course she runs, because this is exactly the kind of intense eye contact that makes you panic when you're still pretending this is just a contract marriage, and he chases her through a garden at night like some kind of romantic horror movie villain but make it cute. "Do not look at me with those eyes." "Those eyes, what kind of eyes do you mean?" "Do not follow me!" "Loa, you are going to fall." She trips. She literally trips while fleeing him. And he catches her. Not gently—firmly, pulling her into his chest so she can't escape. And then the negotiation: "So then, what kind of eyes did you mean?" "Since I could not run away, I would at least have to cover his eyes. I carefully placed both hands over Eden's face." "If you promise to stay like this." "...Very well." He AGREES. The Duke of Hylus, the Sword of the Empire, the man who ordered an entire forest cleared of witnesses, agrees to a condition set by a woman covering his eyes with her hands because she can't handle looking at him. And then—AND THEN—she tries to keep her hands over his eyes and he just lifts her into his arms so her hands fall away. Of course he does. He's not letting her hide. He's carrying her through the garden like she weighs nothing and she's pressing "people are watching" like it's an argument and he responds with "They will think we are a close and affectionate pair of engaged people." LIKE HE WANTS them to think that. LIKE HE WANTS this to be visible. "We are in a contractual relationship." And his expression doesn't change at all. Not a flicker. He doesn't argue, he doesn't get angry, he doesn't even acknowledge the word "contractual" like it hurts him. He just... continues carrying her. As if the word has no power over whatever is happening between them. This is the most charged romantic moment in the entire series and it happens because SHE TRIPPED in a garden and he refused to let her hit the ground. The whole thing with Siobhan too—Loa smiling whenever she talks about Siobhan, and Eden feeling this childish jealousy about it—is just so painfully real. He knows he shouldn't feel this way. He knows she's supposed to be his arranged fiancée, not someone he's genuinely jealous over. And yet. "Perhaps it was time to admit it a little. He liked her. Without a doubt." And then he can't even admit that out loud so he just sits on his sofa and falls asleep after fifteen years because apparently processing his own emotions is physically exhausting for him. "Watch out, you are falling." "Because of Eden holding me tightly and refusing to let go, I had no choice but to face him directly." This man refuses to let her go even when she's trying to run from him. Even when she's covering his eyes. Even when she whispers that they're only contractual. He carries her anyway. I'm not okay.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or