I’ll Make Him My Favorite! - Reviews

I’ll Make Him My Favorite!
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There are so many layers happening beneath the surface of these chapters and I can't stop thinking about them. The glove Schmitz makes is such a loaded symbol. Loa's body now absorbs magical energy from stones just by touching them — her very nature has changed, become dangerous to herself. The glove is supposed to protect her, to create a barrier between her and the world. But she puts it on and it changes color to match her outfit, becomes nearly invisible. The protection is seamless, almost invisible. Is she being protected or is she being contained? Both, probably. Then there's Raven putting her to sleep. He teaches her the ancient language by making her unconscious — she gains knowledge but loses awareness. The gift comes with loss. And his eyes looked 'somehow a little sad' when he watched her sleep. Sad about what? About lying to her? About what she'll discover? About himself? The library sections are symbolic too. Sorcery in D600 — forbidden knowledge, erased history. Romance in J200, divorce law in J300 — the institutions that bind and release people. The <100 Ways to Divorce> book is a satire of institutional control over relationships. And yet the real divorce Loa wants is the one that already exists on paper — the contract — which neither of them has told anyone about. The secret contract mirrors the secret history of sorcery: both are hidden truths that the powerful want to keep buried. 'Raven, who said he would teach me the ancient language and then put me to sleep' — knowledge without consent, wisdom delivered through manipulation. That's the pattern of this world, isn't it? The victors write history, the powerful control information, and the protagonists are kept sleeping while everything is decided around them.
... Read More
I need to talk about this engagement scene because my heart is literally UNWELL. So they just survived a bandit attack. Eloa shot an arrow at a person — her first time killing — Siobhan almost died, the horse is bleeding out in the forest, and Eloa passed out from magical energy entering her body. And then the very next day they're holding an engagement ceremony. Like... the emotional whiplash here is incredible. But the real moment — THE moment — is when the priest says "please share the kiss of the vow" and Eloa is internally screaming because THIS WAS NOT IN THE SCRIPT. She's thinking about how they're only in a contractual relationship and Hylus is just smiling and drawing closer and she's completely flustered. And then he whispers "hand kiss" and presses his lips to her thumb instead. Do you understand what just happened? This man was literally just interrogating her like a suspect, asking "who are you, are you really Lady Eloa Rumania, what proof do you have that you're not part of the anti-faction," with eyes that were TREMBLING and full of sorrow. And now he's giving her a HAND KISS at their engagement ceremony like he's the most gentlemanly duke in existence. The contrast between those two versions of Hylus is DEVASTATING. He's clearly suspicious of her — she knows things she shouldn't, she dreamed about the future, she acted strangely during the attack — but he trusts her enough to stake his life on her word. And then he gives her the option of a hand kiss instead of a real one because he knows this is overwhelming for her. That's not just politeness, that's genuine care masked as formality. "As though sensing my hesitation, his hand tightened around mine." Just that small detail. He felt her hesitation and instead of pulling away or pushing forward, he just... held on tighter. I'm not okay. And Eloa's internal monologue throughout is just pure chaos — "This was not in the script!" and earlier when she's imagining Hylus being fussed over by servants and laughing in the carriage. She's trying so hard to treat this like a business arrangement while her heart is clearly doing gymnastics. These two are going to be so good for each other and also so terrible at communicating their feelings. I can't wait.
... Read More
I need to talk about the stakes escalation in these chapters because the author is playing 4D chess with tension and I am HERE FOR IT. Let me break down what our protagonist is actually up against, because it's more complex than it first appears: On the physical level: she's in an unknown forest with unfamiliar beasts, injured and disoriented, and she just saved a mysterious man who may or may not be trustworthy. That's Chapter 1 stakes. Survival. On the social level: she's engaged to a man who is actively coercing her into marriage, has damaged his reputation by harassing other noble ladies, and has the political power to make her life hell if she crosses him. That's Chapter 2-7 stakes. Reputation, freedom, safety. On the identity level: she's inhabiting a body that isn't hers, in a world she only knows from reading, and if she makes the wrong move, she could die. Or worse—she could get stuck here forever, playing a role she never chose. The genius of the conflict structure is that each scene raises the stakes while simultaneously giving her a tool to survive. The hunting competition isn't just a chance to show off— it's a social opportunity to build alliances that could protect her from Giuo. When she wins and the young ladies start flocking to her, she's not just gaining friends. She's building a support network. She's creating social capital in a world where women have almost none. But here's what really gets me: the author maintains suspense about the masked man across these chapters without ever resolving it. 'I owe you my life, so I will repay it.' Repay how? Who is he? The text never tells us, and that deliberate withholding of information keeps the reader on edge. Every time we see a shadow in the periphery, we remember that man. The stakes feel personal because the unresolved threads feel dangerous. And Giuo himself? The text reveals through dialogue that he has a pattern of harassment, uses his noble rank to intimidate, and shows no remorse. 'Why should a marquis apologize to a viscount's daughter?' This isn't a misunderstanding. This is a man who has never faced consequences. The stakes of breaking off the engagement aren't just social awkwardness—they're real, personal danger. And the protagonist knows this. That's why she doesn't just announce her breakup publicly. She maneuvers. She's smart. And that intelligence is what makes the conflict so compelling.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the emotional setup here is chef's kiss. Our protagonist wakes up in a completely alien body, in a completely alien world, with a burning thirst and no memory of how she got there. And then—plot twist—she realizes she's inside a romance fantasy novel and her absolute favorite character, Siobhan Akane, exists in this world. The moment I read that, I literally gasped. Her entire emotional motivation crystallizes instantly: she wants to find him. She wants to marry him. Not because some plot demands it, but because in a world that has completely undone her, he is her anchor, her comfort object, her reason to keep going. But what makes the emotional writing genuinely excellent is the gap between her internal experience and external presentation. On the outside, she's the composed noble lady, deflecting marriage proposals with practiced elegance, charming the other young ladies with polite apologies and sweet words. On the inside? She's a former archery athlete mentally screaming. The text captures this so well. When she says, 'I just want to leave this world. I want to swap souls with someone and live their life,' it hits like a physical blow. This is grief. She's grieving her own life. And then there's the masked man in the forest. Just one glance—'His hair was mottled with patches of gray and black mixed here and there'—and she's entranced. Not because he's conventionally beautiful, the text insists, but because eye contact alone makes her feel spellbound. I need to know who this man is immediately. The most emotionally layered scene for me though? When she's surrounded by these sweet young ladies who genuinely admire her, and she has to perform regret while internally calculating. She says 'I'm so sorry! I said something I should not have said so carelessly' and then immediately follows up with 'What? But...'—the hesitation is SO real. She's not just acting; she's becoming someone. And the reader can't tell where the performance ends and the person begins. That's emotionally sophisticated writing. Also, the fact that she planned to break off her engagement with Giuo before she even knew this world had politics? That's not strategy—that's instinct. Her desire for freedom runs deeper than her desire for Siobhan. And that changes everything about how I read her choices going forward.
... Read More
I've been turning over the symbolism of the bow in these opening chapters, and I keep coming back to the same conclusion: the bow represents competence, identity, and ultimately, agency in a world that has stripped all three away. The very first line we get about the protagonist is 'I opened my eyes to a burning thirst. From that very moment, my entire body ached.' Physical vulnerability. Complete helplessness. And then—'a bow was clutched in my hand.' Even in total disorientation, her body knows what to hold onto. The bow is her muscle memory, her expertise, her identity as an athlete. When she says 'It was not the bow I had cherished and honed over five long years,' it's not just about equipment. It's about losing the one thing that defined her in her old world. Then there's the narrative title itself: The Lady Who Holds the Leash. A leash implies control, ownership, dominance. But the lady is the one holding it. The imagery flips the expected power dynamic immediately. Who is being leashed? Who is doing the leashing? The engagement to Ter Giuo represents one kind of leash—one imposed by family duty, political convenience, and social expectation. But the protagonist's refusal to accept that leash, her attempts to break free, her strategic social maneuvering to escape the engagement—all of that is her holding a different kind of leash. The soul-swapping technique mentioned in the diary is the most potent symbol though. It's a literal manifestation of the theme: can you escape yourself? Can you shed a life that doesn't fit? The fact that she WAS considering this before she ended up here—meaning her original self, Eloa, also wanted to escape—creates this layered commentary on identity. Two women, same body, same desire for a different life. That's not coincidence. That's the book telling us something about the nature of selfhood. And then there's Siobhan, described as 'warm and gentle... like sunshine.' Light as a symbolic counterpoint to everything dark and constraining in the story. His absence in these chapters is felt more than his presence, which is a brilliant thematic choice—the sun is most powerful when you're standing in the shade.
... Read More
I need to talk about the dialogue in this section because the author truly understands how to make characters sound distinct and the humor is chef's kiss. Let me start with Raven because this character is already giving me main energy. The way he delivers exposition about sorcery — 'History is written by the victors, after all' — that's not info-dumping, that's conversational philosophy. And his joke about the romance and divorce law sections?? 'Books on romance and marriage are in section J200, and books on divorce law are in section J300.' I laughed out loud. It's witty, it's self-aware, and it reveals everything about his character — he's observant, he has dry humor, and he's clearly intrigued by Loa's reaction. Eden's dialogue is delightfully minimal but loaded. 'My fiancée is not in the best of health.' Said while carrying her against her will. That's not concern, that's territorial performance for the librarian's benefit. And 'Get used to it. There will be more once we are married' — so casual about escalating physical intimacy while she's internally panicking about divorce. The contrast between his offhand delivery and the weight of what he's saying is perfect characterization. Schmitz is pure sunshine energy: 'Ahem, it was not particularly difficult.' The classic genius who can't resist a little humblebrag. And Loa's reaction — clasping hands, spinning around, jumping up and down — her dialogue matches her physical energy perfectly. The <100 Ways to Divorce Your Husband> bit had me wheezing. Method 87: 'Find another woman for your husband to fall in love with. He will naturally become neglectful of you.' This is not a legal text, this is a joke book, and Loa's internal 'I really should not have looked at that' is the most honest reaction possible.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened. Our protagonist is trapped in a novel she knows, the worst possible scenario unfolds, and instead of panicking she KISSES A STRANGER'S THUMB to hide. That is either the most brave or most unhinged thing I've ever read and I LOVE IT. But the emotional core here—Hylus saying 'you must take responsibility' and then later, when she confronts him at his estate, him calmly saying 'I will'—that's a pivotal shift. He could have abandoned her. He could have handed her over to Ter Giuo and saved himself. Instead he steps in and claims HER as the one who needs protection. And when she goes to his estate the next day, she's not cowering. She's there because she's trying to survive, yes, but also because something between them has already ignited. The tension is electric. Every time they're near each other there's this undercurrent—her trembling when Ter Giuo speaks, his arms tightening around her waist, the moment she interlaces her fingers with his to sell the performance for Ter Giuo's benefit and feels his warmth through the gloves. That detail! She notices the warmth and it matters. It's small but it signals the beginning of something real underneath all the chaos. Also the fact that she hasn't even met her favorite character Siobhan yet and she's already entangled with the male lead?? The universe is ruthless but I'm here for it.
... Read More
Can we talk about how good Hylus sounds in dialogue? So smooth, so controlled, but with these little cracks where emotion leaks through. The communication stone scene is perfect. He calls her, she throws the stone in surprise, he notices immediately: 'The sound of it does not seem very pleasant.' She recovers instantly with a fake compliment about his four qualities. And his response? Silence. Then a simple 'How are you feeling?' No joke, no follow-up. Just... care.masked as casual inquiry. His voice is never loud, never overly emotional, but it carries weight. Every word is chosen. Even when he's being playful—'You have lovely eyelashes'—it feels deliberate, like he's testing her reaction. And when he announces the engagement date? No hesitation. 'Let us hold the engagement ceremony next week.' 'But I have not yet spoken to Marquis Ter Giuo about...' 'I will handle it.' That's it. Authority. Confidence. And yet, there's tenderness underneath. He visits her at night after she collapses. He sends his personal physician. He matches her dress color. All without saying much. The dialogue between them is sparse but loaded. It's not about what they say, it's about what they don't say. And the narrator's voice—the internal monologue—is sharp, self-aware, sometimes cynical, often vulnerable. It contrasts beautifully with Hylus's cool exterior. I live for their exchanges.
... Read More
I need a minute because the Siobhan scene absolutely destroyed me in the best way. "Everyone in the world, please look at my favorite character." THAT IS THE ENERGY. The moment she spots him standing in that silver pergola under white acacia, watching him turn those brown eyes toward her — you could feel the narrator's heart rate spike through the page. And then his blush when she asks if he has someone he loves? Chef's kiss. The bittersweet devotion angle is everything. In the novel, he loved Hesse Herrmann more than anyone, maybe even more than Eden did, and he was ready to step aside if she found happiness. That selfless, aching loyalty is exactly what makes him lovable. But here's where it gets complicated — and heartbreaking. Eloa is literally thinking about marrying HIM while standing next to her own fiancé. She swallowed the words "it is not Eden Cler Hylus but you, Siobhan Akane, who is my favorite character" and instead said something totally different. The fan etiquette of never showing your true feelings in front of your favorite character is both hilarious and painfully relatable. Meanwhile, Eden walks in right after and she casually mentions wanting to move up the divorce timeline. His expression hardens. Something forlorn crosses his face. AND SHE STILL DOESN'T REALIZE. This romantic triangle isn't even a triangle yet — it's more like a square where two people are desperately trying not to look at each other while one of them is pining for someone else entirely. The dramatic irony is SUFFOCATING.
... Read More
The worldbuilding in this section is sneaky good. The author doesn't dump info on you—they weave it into character moments and economic calculations. Take the magic stone scene. Hylus opens his palm and there it is—a three-centimeter transport magic stone. And instead of just describing it, the narrative immediately grounds it in Eloa's practical mind: "The smaller the magic stone, the more expensive it became. This was because it needed to be easy to carry." This is how you build a magic system that feels economically real. Someone is cutting these stones. Someone is transporting raw materials. There's a supply chain behind magic. Then the imperial palace library reveal—that was a masterclass in showing, not telling. "The families permitted access to the imperial palace library were the Hylus ducal family and the Herrmann ducal family. Only those of rank three or above working within the imperial palace were granted entry." This single paragraph does three things: establishes the magic/sorcery connection to the plot, creates a concrete goal (marry Hylus to gain library access), and maps out the political hierarchy all at once. The window scene itself is cinematic. Black robes against the night, a man stepping through an open third-floor window like it's nothing, the warm yellow light of the dining table, the corn soup steam rising. "Yur Gra?" she mumbles through a mouthful of soup. This is the visual comedy timing that makes romance scenes work—it's not all intensity, it's also slightly ridiculous. And that ending space of darkness, floating in midair—just "a space of nothing but darkness." The contrast between the warmly detailed bedroom and this featureless void is jarring in the best way. It signals that something fundamental is shifting for our protagonist.
... Read More
The stakes setup in these chapters is absolutely brutal and I love it. Eden opens with 'Do not have a private audience with the emperor.' Just drops that like it's nothing. And Loa's response — 'Excuse me. Are you not speaking far too casually about something that is not your situation to deal with?' — she's right to be annoyed but also, she has no idea what's actually at stake here. The emperor is apparently capable of forcing a private audience 'by any means possible.' That means he has absolute power over noble movements within his own palace. Eden, a duke, can't prevent it. The highest-ranking people in the land are still pawns to this man. And Eden's wariness makes so much more sense now — 'Upon leaving Loa's room, he immediately sought out Alb. There was simply too much information she was receiving through Alb.' He's protecting her from the emperor's reach, and he can't even tell her why. Meanwhile, Loa has her own conflicts multiplying: her body is changing (absorbing magical energy uncontrollably), she needs to find information about Eloa's sorcery, she has a secret contract she can't reveal, and now she's studying ancient texts about a forbidden practice. Every answer she finds creates new questions and new dangers. The physical comedy of Eden carrying her around while she's trying to maintain dignity and they're bickering like an old married couple — because they essentially are — masks the real tension. They're sneaking into the imperial palace. They're hiding information from each other. The librarian Raven is suspicious and possibly dangerous. And somewhere, the emperor is planning something. All while Loa is worryingly distracted by how nice it feels to have Eden escort her through the palace gates.
... Read More
There's a symbol in this chapter that I can't stop thinking about, and it's the communication stone. On the surface it's just a plot device — Hylus gave it to Eloa, she wears it as a necklace, it saves her life when a bandit's blade splits it open and releases magical energy. But the symbolism runs much deeper than that. The stone was a gift from Hylus. It represented his trust in her, his desire to keep her safe, his attempt to maintain connection across distance. And when it SHATTERS protecting her, that's arguably the most romantic moment in the entire chapter — his gift becomes her shield. The object of their connection literally breaks itself to save her life. That's not accidental writing. But then Schmitz reveals something that changes the meaning entirely: Eloa's body has absorbed the magical energy from the stone. She has a constitution that allows her to absorb magic stones — a trait that doesn't exist in the original novel. The stone didn't just save her; it ALTERED her fundamentally. She is now something new, something the story didn't predict. This connects to the larger theme of divergence. The entire premise of this story is that the protagonist knows the plot of a novel, but her presence has already changed everything. Siobhan is in a different knighthood. The anti-faction hasn't been fully captured. And now Eloa herself has a supernatural ability that could make her either the most powerful person in this world or its biggest target. The stone is also a symbol of fate vs. choice. In the original novel, Eloa would have died or suffered a different fate. Instead, a random encounter with a bandit, a shattered stone, and a rare constitution have redirected her entire trajectory. Is she still the same person? Schmitz says her body has changed. Hylus asks "Who are you?" The stone's destruction is a literal breaking point — after this, nothing goes back to how it was supposed to go. And there's one more layer I can't ignore: the stone was split by a BLADE aimed at her chest. The weapon meant to kill her becomes the instrument of her transformation. Violence and protection, destruction and creation — they're the same event viewed from different angles. That's the kind of thematic density that makes this story feel smarter than it has any right to be.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or