I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies - Reviews

I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
What is this story REALLY about? On the surface, it's revenge and rebirth. But dig beneath that and you find something far more unsettling: the violence of forgetting, and the tragedy of love that outlasts identity itself. The ring exchange is the opening symbol — "It didn't matter if it was a ring or handcuffs being slipped onto her finger." Marriage as captivity. Vow as chains. The sacred becoming profane in the instant Diana realizes she's bound to her enemy. Then there's the gun. Diana carries it concealed beneath her wedding dress — the ultimate symbol of feminine performance masking lethal intent. She never fires it at the ceremony. She only pulls the trigger on their wedding night, and even then, Ian takes the bullet meant for him. The gun represents her desire for agency in a world where she has none, and its misuse becomes the instrument of both destruction and salvation. Names matter enormously here. "Diana Ahiel Erden" — the last princess, defined by loss. "Ian Paolle" — the beloved grandson, the spy, the murderer. "Ian Leheits" — the stranger who looks exactly like the man she mourned. Identity as the most fragile thing in this world. When Gilrod calls him "Ian Leheits is an outstanding young man" with zero emotional recognition, the author is showing us that in this rewritten timeline, the bonds that should hold people together have been severed. Blood relation means nothing if memory has been erased. The moon recurs as a symbol — first as the flag-piercing sky above the cathedral (cold, distant, watching), then as "the brilliant full moon carrying the clear energy of spring" on the terrace (warm, hopeful, deceptive). Diana's name means moon. She is the moon in this story — reflecting light that belongs to others, governing tides she cannot control.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about this LIBRARY SCENE because my hands are literally shaking. Diana corners Ian against the bookshelf and what does he do? He BACKS UP. Into a wall. Like a damn cartoon character. And she knows it. She knows exactly what she's doing when she presses in close enough that their breaths mix and whispers about dreams and— "Was it a dream like this?" as her hand slides over his chest. Ian's pupils Trembling. He's supposed to be this cool, unreadable guy, right? That's literally how he's always been described. But one touch from her and the mask cracks. And the best part? She CALLS HIM OUT on it afterward. "Liar... You didn't even smile." When SHE was the one who smiled the whole time. Diana is not having any of his nonsense anymore. But here's what's actually haunting me—her inner monologue: "He was just an old memory she should forget, like a dream." What does that MEAN? What did they share before? The resentment she's clearly carrying, the way she specifically says "What we were to each other"—this isn't a fresh tension, this is HISTORY. They've known each other. Something happened. And now she's weaponizing her attractiveness against him because apparently he hurt her at some point. I NEED to know what happened between them.
... Read More
I need to talk about Ian for a second because oh my god the author wrote him into my soul in this batch. The hospital lounge scene where he's waiting alone? That's the kind of passage that makes you close the book and just stare at the ceiling. Let me break down why this hit me so hard. Ian has always been this polished, controlled, almost performative person — the guy who smiles at everything and gives nothing away. But here he is, alone in a hallway, and the narrative peels him open: 'He never imagined that letting Dale see his lonely expression long ago would still be holding him back now.' DAMN. That one line carries the weight of an entire backstory. Dale saw him at his most vulnerable once, and that moment of honesty became this invisible thread that Ian can't cut, even though he keeps telling himself he should. And then Diana shows up at the hospital and the emotional complexity explodes. She touches Dale's forehead like it's the most natural thing in the world, and Ian's 'expression noticeably darkened' — but what is he feeling? Jealousy? No, not exactly. It's something messier. It's the discomfort of watching someone you care about (even platonically) be tender with someone else, combined with his own inability to be that open, that spontaneous. Then Dale grabs Diana's hand and starts reciting poetry and Ian has to physically step in to rescue her. Not from danger — from affection. From someone else's overwhelming, unguarded emotion. That's such a rich, painful detail. And then at the end when Ian says 'I'll go too' to the hotel trip? I think he's running toward something and away from something at the exact same time. Classic Ian.
... Read More
This story does something to me that I didn't expect. It's a revenge plot wrapped in a romance wrapped in a time-travel narrative, but at its core, it's about how love and hatred occupy the exact same space in the human heart. Diana holding a gun to Ian's chest while her hands shake and she's sweating and crying — that's not a villain moment. That's a woman whose entire emotional foundation has been blown apart. And the most heartbreaking line in the entire text? "I loved you." She says it while pointing a枪 at the man who destroyed her world, and he hears it and still throws himself in front of that bullet. He loved her enough to die for her. She hated him enough to try to kill him. They both loved and killed, simultaneously. Then in the reborn timeline, Ian smiles at her with those emerald eyes and says he came to hide from the party because drinks make him dizzy, and Diana feels this stupid, treacherous pull because this version of him doesn't know what he's done yet. He's innocent. He's just a bright young man on a terrace under a full moon. And she has to carry the weight of a future that hasn't happened for both of them. The dance scene at the end — he asks her to dance, she knows this song was her parents' favorite, the one named after HER — and she's standing in the center of the ballroom being led by the ghost of the man she mourned, pretending she doesn't remember everything. The romantic tension here is suffocating in the best possible way.
... Read More
"Through her palm, she could feel his heart pounding, as hot as the gaze they exchanged." I keep coming back to this line. That's not just romantic tension—that's two people who are BOTH trying so hard to control something they cannot control. Diana is deliberately mirroring his ballroom seduction tactics. She's choosing THIS moment, THIS approach, because she's done being the passive one. "If seduction is a game where the one who falls loses—then this time, gladly. I'll be the one to seduce him first." But Ian? He's not playing the game. He's genuinely undone. His calm facade shatters in seconds, he's stuttering, he can barely speak when she leans in. The man who walks into a royal library to stalk someone (allegedly) gets pinned against a bookshelf by a princess and short-circuits completely. And then the afterscene hits different— "Liar... You didn't even smile." He's standing there watching her leave, and instead of admitting she got to him, he deflects. Classic Ian. But the vulnerability is there. He couldn't sleep that night. He was tormented by the memory of her. By her face, becoming clearer the more time passed, "to the point that he could hardly breathe." That's not annoyance. That's obsession disguised as duty.
... Read More
These chapters move in this weird breathing rhythm. First there's this slow, dreamy nighttime scene— insects, candlelight, a bicycle leaning against a wall, two people circling each other like they're afraid to get too close but also can't stop. It's languid. Almost sleepy. Then the stable scene kicks things up a notch with the foal, the revelation about Yan, Diana's emotional collapse. It's warmer, brighter, more physical. And then—suddenly—we're on a terrace at dawn with Jerome flustering and Diana pretending she wasn't waiting for Ian. Quick cuts, comedic relief, then she's running through the gardens like her life depends on it. The running scene is great pacing work. From the terrace to the central garden to the walkway to finding Ian at the stables—it's kinetic, breathless, and then it stops dead when she sees him on Yan. The horse greets her, and the chapter goes quiet again. Intimate. Then Natasha arrives like a thunderclap and DRAGS her to the Queen. The Queen's office scene is where the pacing shifts dramatically. It's slower, heavier, more formal. Isabella describes the weather, mentions taking a walk with her niece—a tiny domestic moment—then drops the bomb about Diana leaving. The dialogue here is short, sharp. Every line carries weight. 'I want to stay in the kingdom.' Silence. 'You know well what your father did at my coronation.' More silence. 'I'll do what I can here. I won't run away.' And then the Queen's refusal, followed by the most devastating image in these chapters: 'Isabella deliberately avoided meeting her eyes any further.' And the final beat—Isabella asking Gilrod if it's 'too soon for another checkup' and saying 'Seeing your face makes me feel even sicker'—this is the kind of detail that changes how you re-read the earlier scene. She was smiling, joking with Natasha, commanding her office. But she's dying. She's been dying. And she sent her only niece away to protect her while she couldn't even look at her one last time. The pacing here goes from political drama to personal devastation in three sentences.
... Read More
Let me just say — the stakes in this batch are deceptively low-key and that's what makes them so effective. On the surface: someone has appendicitis, they get surgery, they recover. Pretty straightforward medical drama. But underneath, everything is at stake for every character in this scene. For Diana, the stakes are identity. She's a princess who has built her entire survival strategy on being unseen, unthreatening, gentle. Then she's on a battlefield (well, a polo field) and she drops into action mode like she's lived this before — because she has. But she can't tell anyone that. So she saves Dale's life and has to pretend it's just normal princess stuff. The tension of that concealment is unbearable and the author writes it with such restraint. For Ian, the stakes are emotional. He's watching Dale — someone he considers a burden, someone he can't afford to care about — being saved by Diana, someone he's complicated about. And then Dale starts profusely thanking Diana while holding her hand, and Ian has to be the one to end it. Not with words. Just by appearing. His presence is the intervention. For Dale, the stakes are social survival. He's the useless younger son of a military family, and here he is barely alive because a princess pressed on his belly and diagnosed what the doctors missed. His gratitude is genuine but it's also performative — he's reciting poetry to someone who just saved his life and he knows he owes her everything. And Grinelda? Her stakes are romantic territoriality. She walks in on her potential rival holding another man's hand, and instead of exploding she becomes aggressively polite. 'It's an honor to meet you!' — while her eyes are doing absolutely not that. The conflict here isn't shouted. It's whispered, smiled through, and simmering. The hospital scene is a pressure chamber and everyone in it is holding their breath.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say — the author absolutely nailed the pacing in this batch. You've got a full-blown medical emergency happening at a polo match, Diana stepping up like she's on a battlefield (which, plot twist, she literally was), and then the fallout ripples out in ways that completely reshape the social dynamics between these characters. What struck me most is how the appendicitis scene works on two levels. On the surface, it's a crisis — Dale is dying, Diana saves him, everyone gasps. But underneath, it's a structural pivot that forces every major character into a new positioning. Ian goes from bystander to someone sitting in a hospital lounge having a full existential crisis about his friendship with Dale. Diana goes from shadow-princess to public hero. Grinelda enters the scene and suddenly the romantic geometry shifts again. And the hospital visit scene? Pure tension. Dale grabs Diana's hand, pours out this glowing poem of gratitude, and you can literally see Ian's jaw tighten. Then Grinelda walks in — perfect timing, almost cinematic — and the whole room becomes a pressure cooker. I actually chuckled out loud at Jerome whispering 'almost sounds like you're confessing your love to Her Highness' because honestly same energy. The Rovice Hotel setup at the end is the author's way of saying 'oh we're not done here.' It's a vacation invitation that's really a narrative trap door — everyone's going to fall through it together. I'm genuinely curious how this unfolds.
... Read More
Can we talk about how the Rovice Hotel basically functions as its own character in these chapters? The description of the staircase alone—"modeled after the golden spiral staircase of the royal palace"—tells you everything you need to know about this family's ambition. They're not old nobility. They built themselves up from a small construction business during the post-war reconstruction. Count Rovice is the self-made man par excellence, and the hotel is his monument. Diana notices this explicitly: "Before the royal palace stood as the center of the kingdom, this beautiful land was the one embracing the palace." That's such a loaded observation coming from her—the princess who's seen the court's coldness and is now standing in a place where commoners feel welcome. The hotel is full of light and laughter and exotic plants and a chef Grinelda personally recruited from another continent. Compare that to Diana's own description of the palace: "No people, no laughter. They'd all be disappointed if they knew." The contrast isn't accidental. This setting is the author's way of showing Diana an alternative version of royalty—one where warmth and hospitality matter more than protocol. And the riverside at the end, with the yachts lined up and Grinelda in that green dress, is practically cinematic. Every scene in this hotel feels lived-in and intentional.
... Read More
Let me just say this out loud: DIANA SAID 'I WON'T RUN AWAY' AND I AM NOT OKAY. My chest actually hurts. The stakes here are stacked so high it's ridiculous and I love it. On the external level: the crown prince is returning. Diana must leave the kingdom or rebel against tradition. If she stays, she risks war, political elimination, possibly death. If she goes, she loses everything—her home, her chance to change the future, maybe Ian. The Kargen Empire is still an existential threat. The Queen is secretly dying. Nobody is whole, everybody is compromised, and the whole kingdom is one bad decision away from burning. But the INTERNAL conflict is what gets me. Diana knows what's coming. She lived through the destruction of her kingdom, the death of everyone she loved, the betrayal by the Duke of Promes and the Kargen crown prince. She came back to STOP IT. And now the Queen is ordering her to leave—right when she needs to be here most. Every instinct screams RUN AWAY TO SURVIVE. That's what she did before. That's what her father did. That's what everyone in this family does—they yield, they sacrifice themselves, they kiss the Queen's feet to survive another day. And Diana is choosing to stay anyway. Not because it's smart. Not because it's safe. But because 'I don't want to have regrets.' That line is so simple and so devastating. She's not confident. She's not sure she'll win. She literally says 'Even if I get caught up in a mudslinging fight and lose my life.' She's making her choice WITH HER EYES OPEN. The tension in the Queen's office scene is suffocating. Isabella could have argued. Could have explained further. Instead she says 'You've grown a lot' and immediately calls Natasha to escort Diana out. She won't let Diana see her cry. She won't let herself waver. The mother figure who lost her arm in war can't lose her composure one more time. And Diana—brilliant, stubborn, terrified Diana—walks out and asks about her aunt's health like she suspects something. Like she cares enough to notice. This isn't just a romance now. This is a girl standing between a crumbling kingdom and total destruction, with one arm's-worth of allies and a horse that remembers her from five years ago. And I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually happening beneath all these pretty horseback rides and garden walks, because the stakes in this book are absolutely ratching up and I am not okay. On the surface, Diana wants to make public appearances. She wants people to see her as crown princess material, not just Prince Louis's younger sister. That sounds simple, right? Wrong. Because every appearance she makes is a political statement in a kingdom that's already fracture-lining. The civil war Isabella lived through killed people—including Isabella's own kin. And now Diana is positioning herself in the open, vulnerable, visible. What happens when someone decides the crown princess should disappear? Jerome uncovered Ian's secret—he's not adopted into the Leheits family, he's an illegitimate child, and his real father is the Duke of Promes in the Kargen Empire. Do you understand what that means? This man Diana is falling for is literally from the enemy's nobility, hiding his true parentage, and nobody in Erden knows except Jerome and now Diana. Meanwhile, Isabella is making her own moves—protecting Diana by controlling her future, convinced that her past mistakes about following her father's wishes shouldn't be repeated. But here's the terrifying part: Isabella might be RIGHT about something being dangerous for Diana, even if her methods are suffocating. The polo event announcement is Diana's first public power play. She's about to step onto a field in front of the entire kingdom, on horseback (which Jerome reveals she's NEVER ridden before), and perform. The irony is almost cruel—she wants to prove she's capable and independent, but she's doing it on something she hasn't even mastered yet. And Ian, who can ride, is going to be there too. What happens when she falls? What happens when someone uses that against her? The tension between wanting freedom and needing to survive it is what makes this book absolutely grip me.
... Read More
The prose in this novel is sharp enough to draw blood. Let me just highlight a few moments where the writing goes beyond describing and actually makes you FEEL: "Her feet heavy as if they were rooted to the ground." That's it. Five words and I can feel Diana's paralysis, the way grief physically anchors you when your entire world has just collapsed. "The mournful hymn" playing as she imagines putting bullets through foreheads — the author doesn't need to explain the irony. The sacred music juxtaposed with cold-blooded murder fantasy says everything. "Her first love, who made her burn with fever every night since childhood." The word "fever" is doing triple duty here — illness, passion, obsession. All at once. And then the shift in the rebirth scene. The language becomes softer, warmer: "flower petals drifted into the terrace on the night breeze," "the brilliant full moon, carrying the clear energy of spring." The author literally changes the texture of the prose when Diana returns to the past, as if the world itself is gentler before it learns to hate. Dialogue-wise, each character has a distinct fingerprint. Diana's internal monologue is fierce and wounded. Ian's spoken words are measured, almost performative — even in the past timeline, there's something slightly off about how carefully he chooses his phrases. Jerome is comic relief but grounded in genuine concern. Gilrod speaks with the warm authority of someone who's seen too much but chooses kindness anyway. The narrative voice carries this haunting quality throughout — like a ghost telling you its own story, knowing exactly how it ends but having to live through it all over again.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or