I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies - Reviews

I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Can we talk about how the setting in this book isn't just decoration — it's basically a character itself? The flashback to the Kargen snowy mountains is BRUTAL in its imagery. Blood on white snow — red drops marking the path — the blizzard, the cruel laughter of hunters treating people like game. It's so cold you can feel it through the pages. And then Lea stumbling, Ian rolling down the slope, the bayonet flashing. The visual contrast between the pristine white snow and that violence... chef's kiss. But then — BAM — Erden. Everything changes. "Erden was stunningly beautiful. The city was brimming with life, and the laughter of children filled every street corner. It felt like a place blessed by the unchanging goddess." This is such a deliberate choice by the author. Ian arrives expecting the "primitive" people his father told him about, and instead finds something genuinely magical. The world itself contradicts everything he was taught. That moment where he peeks through the door crack and hears the argument — the palace feels alive, cramped, real. Not some sterile fantasy castle but a place where people actually argue and move through hallways. And then the fireworks scene on the dock deck — the river breeze, the moon rising, the explosions of light painting everything. The contrast between the celebratory crowd and Diana's sudden loneliness is devastating because the author takes the time to make us feel the festive atmosphere FIRST before deflating it. The abandoned cabin on the mountainside — that faint firelight, Lea pulling aside the thin curtain to check outside. So intimate and claustrophobic compared to the vast open palace later. Every location tells us something about Ian's emotional state without ever saying it outright.
... Read More
There's a photograph in this text that wrecked me. Ian finds a crumpled newspaper clipping—a young Diana, age ten, at her birthday celebration. And the narrator specifically notes: "She looked less like a child celebrating her birthday and more like a mourner at a funeral." A ten-year-old girl at her own birthday looking like she's attending a funeral. Just... dropping that image on us like it's nothing. What happened to her? Who died? And why is this image preserved in Ian's belongings like he keeps re-reading it? The fire imagery is everywhere too. The palace "looks like a blazing flame. Like a fire that could consume everything." Ian's nightmare involves a blanket catching fire that could kill thousands. And the Elten River below the dormitory—"sparkling across the city like the Milky Way." Fire and water, destruction and reflection, dreams and reality constantly blurring together. Then there's the library itself—"a place where he could focus, away from people's eyes." The SAME spot Diana occupies. Déjà vu washing over Ian like a melody from a ballroom dance. The spiral staircase modeled after the ballroom. Everything loops back on itself. Is Ian stuck in a time loop? Is this all a cycle he's trying to break? "Why am I writing all of this to someone who never replies?" The unanswered letters. The sealed messages. The silence. This story is built on communication that fails, on words that never reach their destination.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this out loud: the Ian/Diana/Grinelda/Dale web in this section is SO delicately handled and I am here for it. Like, Diana genuinely notices that Grinelda gets all flustered when Dale is around—"Grinelda's face slowly turned red"—and instead of being threatened by it, she's just... amused? Happy even? There's this moment where Diana watches Grinelda talk about Dale and "couldn't help but smile," which tells you everything about Diana's emotional maturity. She's not playing games with people's feelings. And then there's Ian. Oh my god, Ian. The way he climbs up to her balcony, half-joking, half-serious—it's so him. "I don't climb into just any woman's room." That line hit me like a truck. After everything between them, after all the tension, he still makes it clear that she's the exception. But what got me most was watching Ian watch Diana at dinner. When she rushes to help Dale, he notices. He actually says it out loud: "When you rushed to Dale. Everyone else just stood there... but you immediately took command of the situation. It was admirable." That's not just observation—that's someone who pays attention to her in a way that goes way beyond politeness. And Diana? She notices HIM noticing her. The text says she felt "oddly embarrassed, as if she had been caught" when their eyes met across the table. Caught doing what? Feeling things? I'm convinced these two are going to figure it out eventually but it's going to take another whole book minimum lol.
... Read More
I have to talk about this one scene because it completely wrecked me in the best way. Diana reaching for Ian's hand on Yan—she didn't even think about it. Five years of loving him, of carrying that ache around like a second heartbeat, and her body just remembered what her mind was trying to convince herself to forget. The text says it straight up: "She'd never thought it would be easy. Still, she knew. In the end… someday she would have to let him go, just as he had once let her go." And yet here she is, still grabbing his hand like a girl who hasn't moved on at all. That's the tragedy of it, isn't it? She's trying so hard to be strong, to be the crown princess who makes her own path, but her heart is still stuck in whatever moment five years ago made her fall for him. And Ian—oh god, Ian. He's the one who reached for HER first. He pulled her onto Yan like he had every right to, like he wasn't some illegitimate bastard from another empire sneaking into her world. The fact that he wrapped his arms around her waist to keep her from falling and neither of them let go right away… I literally pressed my phone away from my face for a second. The riding scene later where she takes the reins and pulls him up behind her, laughing into the wind—that's not just adventure. That's her taking control, taking CHARGE, and doing it WITH him. She's the one riding now. She's the one leading. And that moment when "Diana laughed brightly as she cut through the wind" and felt complete freedom? That's the most romantic thing I've read all year, and I'm not even mad about it.
... Read More
Let me just—pause for a second. Ian has a NIGHTMARE. A dream about a burning blanket in a university dormitory. And what does he do? He doesn't ignore it. He doesn't shrug it off and go back to bed. He peddles his bicycle through the dark at night, crashes it, dumps WATER INTO A FIREPLACE to extinguish a burning blanket, and YELLS at a sleepy college kid named Dale. And Dale's reaction? "Alright. Calm down. I was stupid. I must be out of my mind." He just... accepts it? Like Ian showing up at 2 AM drenched in sweat and threatening to pour water on a fire is a totally reasonable thing to do? Ian himself acknowledges: "Every nightmare he had ever had came true without exception." This isn't the first time. This is a PATTERN. He's been fighting fate since he was young, and now he's made it a personal rule—if he dreams it, he goes and stops it. "If there was something he could change, he would change it." Meanwhile, the political stakes are PILING UP. Crown Prince Louis is in Oron with a fleet being prepared. The Kargen Empire is suspicious. There's a sealed letter from the Minister to Admiral Bliven that Ian is carrying around like it's nothing. And then Jerome shows up sweating because Diana has DISAPPEARED AGAIN. "She's become quite the expert at running away lately!" So Ian is simultaneously a spy carrying secret correspondence, a prophetic dreamer preventing disasters, and a guy who keeps bumping into the princess he's apparently supposed to be watching. The tensions aren't just rising—they're converging. And I have a very strong feeling that Diana's disappearances and Ian's nightmares are connected to something much bigger than either of them realizes. What is this letter REALLY about? What's the Crown Prince actually doing in Oron? And why does Diana keep running toward problems instead of away from them?
... Read More
Okay this is going to sound weird but hear me out — there are some incredibly dense symbolic moments packed into what on the surface is a pretty conventional 'someone gets sick' storyline. Let's start with the vomit. Yes, actual vomit on the princess's clothes. And Diana doesn't flinch. She wipes Dale's forehead, keeps his airway clear, diagnoses the burst appendix — all while covered in bodily fluids. This is huge for a character who has spent her entire existence being treated as fragile, decorative, invisible. The Princess who touches what others won't touch. The one who gets messy while everyone else stays pristine. Then there's the hospital flowers — specifically noted as 'hospital flowers that don't scatter pollen.' Such a tiny detail but it made me pause. Everything in Diana's world is about not causing trouble, not scattering, not disrupting. Even her gifts are chosen to be harmless. But the most powerful symbol in this batch is the castle itself. Diana watches it recede into the distance as she travels to the hotel, and she thinks about her brother Louis — 'a man born with a free spirit, like a hawk soaring leisurely through the sky. But he had given up the sky for everyone else.' That hawk image is everywhere in this novel, isn't it? Free, soaring, trapped by duty. Diana identifies with him here. 'I miss him a little' — and then stops herself, because saying it out loud would make it real. The Rovice Hotel perched above the kingdom, offering a view FROM which you can see the castle as just another building — that's the thesis statement of the entire arc. What looks like the center of the world from inside it is just a structure when you step far enough away. Diana is literally and figuratively gaining altitude.
... Read More
There's so much happening symbolically beneath the surface of this chapter and I'm still picking at the threads. The yellow ribbon. Again again again. It connects Diana's dress to Ian's gift to the wind on the river to Jerome's pointed observation. Yellow in literature often means caution, betrayal, jealousy—but here it feels more like something fragile and bright that could easily be lost. The ribbon is tied neatly, but it flutters in the wind. Just like their relationship. The yacht itself is a symbol of liminality—they're neither fully on shore nor fully at sea. They're suspended in this moment where the past is bubbling up but nobody will name it directly. The Elten River literally loops back on itself, which mirrors how Diana and Ian's story keeps circling the same wounds. Then there's the wine. Ian's drinking red wine while watching Diana drink whiskey. The red wine makes him see memories—blood on snow, his mother's face. Alcohol as a truth serum. Jerome claims Diana and he share a taste for whiskey (strong liquor, harsh, unsoftened), while Ian prefers wine (lighter, paired with meals, civilized). Their drinking preferences literally map onto their emotional availability. But the deepest symbol is probably the hat itself. Ian buys it almost absentmindedly—"a hat he bought almost absentmindedly, but watching Diana grow farther and farther away made his steps quicken without him realizing." He reaches toward her without knowing why. The hat is too big for her head. She looks up at him from under the brim. It's this image of protection, of shelter, of someone trying to cover something fragile—and Diana accepting it while simultaneously pulling away. That's their entire dynamic in one物件.
... Read More
The stakes in this section are layered like an onion and I am HERE for it. On the surface: Jerome warns Ian about the vest. Simple, right? Someone had access to Diana's chambers, someone left evidence behind, and now it looks suspicious. But the REAL stakes are so much deeper. Ian's entire identity is built on a foundation of secrets. His mother's past, his father's cruelty, being sent away as a page, lying about his name to Diana when they first met. And now he's falling for the princess — the one person he absolutely cannot be honest with. Every moment of happiness with her is poisoned by the lies he's already told. The duke's line haunts me: "If I stop my wife, what will you give me in return?" This man sold his own son's safety like a commodity. And Ian agreed. "I'll be your loyal hound." That moment defines him. He chose survival and protection for his mother over dignity. And now he's repeating the same pattern — swallowing his feelings, obeying orders, playing the role everyone expects. But Diana complicates everything. In the flashback, her reaction to finding him unconscious is SO genuine — she's worried, helpful, accidentally charming. And the present-day Ian sees her watching other families at the fireworks and realizes: she's lonely too. They're both performing versions of themselves they think others want to see. The crown prince is another layer of threat. He called Ian a "brat who can't even break his own leash" and yet kept him close. That's not friendship — that's ownership. And now Ian's developing feelings for Diana that go beyond duty? The prince would see that as weakness or rebellion. Every conflict in this chapter feeds into the central question: Can Ian ever be honest with the person he loves, or will his past always sabotage his present?
... Read More
I have to say, the Rovice Hotel description is one of those passages where the setting basically becomes a character. Let me paint this for you: the hotel sits on a high mountain facing the royal castle, and it's described as giving you 'the feeling of looking down upon the kingdom from the royal palace itself.' That's not just worldbuilding — that's thematic architecture. The Rovice family built a place where commoners can literally look down on the seat of power, and Diana notices this while riding there. The whole journey to the hotel is saturated with atmosphere. She's crossing the Elten River south for the first time on an official vacation — a small detail that somehow carries enormous weight. This is a princess who has barely left the palace grounds, and now she's moving voluntarily away from it. The text says: 'Seeing the castle grow distant gave Diana an odd feeling.' Not fear. Not sadness. Something lighter, like 'a refreshing breeze was blowing.' And then there's the hotel itself — 'immense scale,' 'grounds must be second only to the royal palace,' gardens with unique plants, a panoramic view that's 'famously said to give the feeling of looking down upon the kingdom.' The Rovice family didn't just build a hotel; they built a statement. All their properties across the country are booked through next year. This is economic power disguised as hospitality. What I love is how every scene in this batch is visually distinct. The chaotic polo field. The sterile, silent hospital hallway. The cramped hospital room with its awkward triangular tension. Then opening up to this vast, luxurious hotel space that feels almost like a new world. The author is using environment to track Diana's emotional expansion. She's literally leaving the castle's shadow behind, and the prose makes you feel that widening horizon.
... Read More
There is a recurring image in this section that I cannot stop thinking about and I need to write about it before it leaves my head: the full moon. Diana is literally born on the night of a full moon, which the text tells us was 'colored by the joy of peace, the sorrow of loss, and the birth of new life, all mixing together to stain the unusually bright moon with confusion.' That sentence is poetry. It compresses her entire existence into one image. And then when she runs to the garden after the ball, the moon is still there—'Of all days, she had to be born on the night of a full moon, so there was nowhere to hide.' It's watching her. It's accusing her. It's been with her since the moment she drew breath and it won't let her forget what her life cost. The garden itself is described with this cold, almost cinematic quality—the well-manicured paths, the chilly air, the moonlight shining into every secluded corner. Diana feels exposed, as if all her weaknesses would be visible under that light. There's something visceral about how the setting mirrors her emotional state without the author ever needing to say 'Diana felt vulnerable.' The moonlight just does the work for her. Contrast that with the dean's office—dim, enclosed, dominated by the portrait of Prince Edgar looking down from above, watching Lampman as much as Diana. The final image of Lampman's sunken eyes gazing endlessly up at that portrait, after his breakdown, after Diana storms out—that lingers. Two spaces, two kinds of haunting. The garden is haunted by the past Diana can't change; the office is haunted by the grief that made her brother and her teacher into enemies of the people she wants to protect. And Ian appears in both, which means HE is part of the haunting too.
... Read More
I am not okay with how good Ian's dialogue is in this section. The man is a menace. Let me just list some highlights. First: "Did you miss me?" — delivered with zero shame after literally not showing up all day. Then when Diana tries to play it off: "Your Highness stands out no matter where you are." That's not even a good line but he says it like he means it and somehow it works. And then the whole climb-up-the-wall sequence: "I can't get down. What if I fall?" — playing the victim while perched on a railing like an absolute goblin. Classic Ian. But the writer also gives Diana such a distinct voice. Her internal monologue is sharp and self-aware—"That's the first time I've heard someone say that… The one who stands out is Louis, not me"—while her external dialogue is this perfect mix of regal composure and exasperated affection. "What are you doing, really? Get down right now!" followed immediately by inviting him inside. She's trying so hard to maintain the princess facade and failing adorably. And Grinelda's dialogue is totally different—her questions about Dale, her flustered stammering, it all feels like a completely different species of character. You can tell every person in this scene has a fully realized voice. The author clearly enjoys writing dialogue because these conversations just flow.
... Read More
Okay first of all can we just take a moment to appreciate that Jerome is genuinely one of the most entertaining characters I've ever encountered in any novel, period. The man runs after Diana like a lovesick golden retriever and I am HERE FOR IT. The dialogue between them is so natural and funny—it reads exactly like how two people who have known each other since childhood actually talk. When she tells him to go date someone and his reaction is basically to ignore her and start dusting while muttering things just loud enough for her to hear? That is PEAK subtext delivery. "I don't date just anyone." Then a beat. Then: "I don't date. Anyone." Diana thinking he looks a bit pathetic while also not calling him out on it—this is a whole dynamic compressed into three lines. And his investigative work! He finds out Ian's illegitimacy like it's a Tuesday chore and just… drops it on her. No fanfare. No dramatic pause. Just straight facts while she's spiraling internally. The Queen and Gilrod scene is different energy entirely—so much quieter, so much heavier. Gilrod reading her sighs like a weather forecast: "Normally it's just 'ha...' but today it's 'haa...'" That's not just humor, that's genuine intimacy between two people who've survived everything together. And Isabella telling him she's only stayed sane because of "those two children"—you can feel the weight of every word. The author switches between these tones so seamlessly that you never feel whiplash. One moment you're laughing at Jerome's pouting and the next you're sitting with Isabella's grief about the civil war and her dead son Edgar. That's skillful writing, plain and simple.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or