I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies - Reviews

I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The imagery in this section is so intentional and I can't stop thinking about the yellow ribbon motif. It keeps appearing like a ghost throughout the entire yacht scene. First, Jerome notices it: "the ribbon's yellow, isn't it?" And Diana realizes her dress is yellow too. Then Ian bought her a hat WITH a yellow ribbon. And then he's watching the yellow ribbon flutter in the river breeze. Yellow isn't just a color here—it's this quiet symbol of connection, of something almost said out loud but never quite admitted. It's the color of her dress, his gift, and the wind between them. The yacht setting itself is brilliant. "The yacht moved forward, cutting through the current along the riverside. Across the river, the bustling energy of the town was clearly visible." This liminal space—the water between them literally and figuratively, the river connecting two worlds—creates this perfect atmosphere where old wounds bubble up beneath the surface like sediment. There's also this recurring visual of reflections and water. Ian sees a familiar face "reflected in the still surface of the red wine." The Elten River looping back on itself. Diana watching the yacht's bow cut through waves to calm herself. Water is everywhere as a metaphor for memory—churning, reflective, dangerous, beautiful. The contrast between the bright, sunlit exterior and the dark emotions underneath is masterful. People are laughing, Dale and Grinelda are bickering cutely, the riverside village is full of life—and underneath all of that, Diana is confessing to her deepest pain while Ian is drowning in unspoken longing. The setting never feels decorative; it's actively working the emotional heavy lifting.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment because it's been living in my head. Diana is on the horse, in the middle of her demonstration, completely in her element, and she smiles at Ian. The text describes it as 'almost unconscious' — which means it's REAL. She didn't plan that smile. It just happened because seeing him made her happy, and she couldn't suppress it. And Ian? He's waving and smiling back brightly. Two people who have spent God knows how many chapters circling each other, pretending nothing exists between them, and in front of EVERYONE — the Queen, the Dean, the whole stadium — they just... share a moment. No words needed. But what broke me was right after. Diana comes back to the VIP section and all these people are waiting for her with mixed expressions, and her first instinct is to check if THEY think she did something wrong. 'Did I do something wrong?' she asks Jerome. Not 'Did I win?' Not 'Was I good?' She's worried about their approval. And the Queen's satisfied smile when she hears that — oh my god, the Queen is literally shipping them and everyone else is too distracted to notice. I'm not okay.
... Read More
There's a recurring image in these chapters that I can't stop thinking about: the Elten River. Diana traces it with her fingertip on the window. She watches it sparkle under the night sky. Ian stares at it flowing westward from the balcony. It's everywhere. And I keep wondering if the river is meant to symbolize time, or fate, or the things that keep moving whether we're ready or not. Diana literally says "the uncertainty of the future hasn't changed" while looking at it. She knows she has three years before becoming crown princess, one year before the official announcement, and she's trying to find peace in the present moment that she's not sure she'll ever have again. The river doesn't care about any of that. It just flows. There's also the hotel itself as a kind of symbolic space—a place built by people who earned their status rather than inherited it, sitting at roughly the same height as the royal castle but facing it directly. "It is the people of Erden who are truly embracing us"—that line feels like the thematic anchor of the whole section. Diana is literally looking at the kingdom from a new angle, both physically and emotionally. The garden with exotic plants, the elevator operator she greets warmly, the chef from the Oron Republic—every detail reinforces that this world is bigger and more colorful than the palace walls ever allowed her to see.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in pacing. The author knows exactly when to slow down and when to detonate, and the rhythm here is almost musical. It starts SO calm. Ian waking up in a good mood, buying a hat, placing it on Diana's head like it's the most normal thing in the world. The yacht glide is smooth, the conversations are light. We've got Dale being ridiculous about his appendicitis memory, Grinelda gossiping, everyone seemingly having a nice time. The prose feels breezy, almost deceptively so. Then—bam. Diana's conversation with Grinelda shifts from light chitchat to "he abandoned me first" in the span of three paragraphs. The pacing SLAM-DUNKS right into raw vulnerability. One moment she's laughing at Dale and Grinelda's bickering, the next she's confessing that she wants to make him suffer just because he forgot her. The whiplash is intentional and it works PERFECTLY because the reader has been lulled into comfort. Intermittently, the author cuts to Ian's POV and we see the same scene from inside his head. He's acting casual on the surface—flirting, drinking wine, making jokes with Dale—but internally he's spiraling. "His thoughts kept drifting back to her. It was suffocating." These POV switches create this layered tension where we know MORE than either character knows about the other's feelings. The chapter ends with Ian's drunken memory flashbacks—the snow, the blood, the mother he saved. That's the chapter's real cliffhanger. Not a dramatic event, but an emotional one. We're left wondering what exactly Ian remembers and what he's hiding. The pacing doesn't rush to answer; it lets the question hang.
... Read More
There's so much happening underneath the surface in these chapters and I can't stop thinking about the symbols. Horses are the big one. Yan represents everything Diana lost—her childhood, her safety, her homeland, the person who loved her most selflessly. The fact that this horse, who once stood helplessly before her carriage as she was dragged away to be imprisoned, is now ALIVE and choosing to greet her... it's almost too much. Horses in this story aren't just animals. They're witnesses. Survivors. Silent carriers of memory across timelines. Then there's the Queen's missing arm. 'During her father's reign, Isabella had led Erden's army as a general... in the process, lost her left arm to the Kargen Emperor.' She holds a stack of documents 'that looked as heavy as several bricks' with her ONE remaining arm. She signs royal decrees. She commands an empire. And her right arm—her working arm, her powerful arm—is the one that's left. The metaphor is almost painful: she gave up part of herself to protect her people, and she still can't stop the war. 'Even with the right arm that had repelled countless enemies, she could not stop their treachery.' That line hits like a truck. And the crown itself—Erden's ancient succession law. Crown prince and crown princess named together, then forced to compete, then the younger yields. Diana's father kissed the Queen's feet at the coronation to survive. Now Diana is being sent away 'for her own good'—but the real reason is political survival. Tradition demands it. But Diana's new determination ('I won't run away') directly challenges centuries of tradition. She's not just fighting for love or revenge; she's fighting the structural fate of her entire dynasty. The window imagery too—Isabella gazing out at the capital, the breeze through her hair, the open window as metaphor for a queen who can see everything but control nothing. Diana stares at that window at the end and can't meet her aunt's eyes. Sight and blindness as power dynamics. Who sees clearly? Who chooses not to see?
... Read More
Okay, I need to just sit with this scene for a second because it absolutely wrecked me. Diana and Ian on that yacht—there's this invisible wall between them that's so thick you could cut it with a knife, and yet they keep brushing against it like moths to a flame. Ian is over there buying her a hat with a yellow ribbon, just trying to do something sweet, and then the moment he stands next to her, she immediately looks at Jerome. Not once does she meet his eyes without that guarded expression. And Ian knows it. God, he knows it. He even says it himself: "Those sharp eyes warning him exactly where the line was, how close he was allowed to get." The man is starving for closeness and she's handing him nothing but boundaries. But then Diana turns the tables and says "I just prefer not to create misunderstandings in the first place"—and Ian is visibly shaken. That line cuts deeper than any blade. He's the one who wants to be misunderstood apparently, who throws out "And what's so wrong about being misunderstood?" like it's a joke, but we both know it's not a joke. He WANTS her to think they're closer than they are. And then Diana breaks. Completely. With Grinelda, she lets it all out: "To hate someone so much that you want them to hurt as much as you do? To feel like you'll go mad every time you see that clueless face?" And then the most devastating line—"what I really want is for him… to remember me." She doesn't want revenge. She doesn't want him to suffer. She just wants him to REMEMBER. That's the kind of emotional punch that leaves you sitting there staring at the page. Meanwhile Ian's internal monologue is just… oh boy. "She was nothing more than someone to use, a target he needed to win over. Then why did he feel so powerless before that invisible line she drew?" This man is a walking contradiction and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I keep coming back to the imagery in these chapters and I think the author is building something deeper beneath the surface. Let me connect a few dots. The white powder Gilrod compounds — described as having 'a slight sheen' — Diana immediately associates it with the medicine Queen Isabella takes. The Queen is chronically ill, possibly poisoned, and the war with Kargen hangs over everything. Then Diana rides a WHITE horse named Yan, and Ian rides the same white horse during the match. White horses in this story feel connected to visibility, to performance, to being watched. Diana is performing for the Queen, for the stadium, for Ian. She's putting on a show of competence and confidence while internally panicking about whether she's making the right choices. And then Dale collapses — his complexion described as 'deathly pale,' almost blending with the horses, the uniforms, the powder. The color white keeps appearing in moments of tension and medical urgency. Is the author suggesting that everything beautiful and polished on the surface — the charity match, the royal family's composure, Diana's confident smile — is masking something sick underneath? The Queen's illness, Dale's mysterious collapse, Ian's hidden knowledge — it all feels like cracks in a white porcelain facade.
... Read More
Okay so this part absolutely wrecked me and I need to talk about it. Jerome telling Ian "stop shaking her" — that line hit me like a truck. Because everyone keeps treating Diana like the fragile one, the one who needs protecting, but Jerome sees through it immediately. She's the strong one. She's holding herself together in that position alone. And Ian? Ian's the one who's been falling apart. Then the fireworks scene. Oh my god. This is the moment everything shifted for him. He's watching her from across the crowd and she's smiling — radiant, perfect — and then she sees the Rovice father and daughter and that smile just... dies. Jerome's words echo in his head: "Most people completely misunderstand her." And Ian finally gets it. 'Ian recalled Jerome's words. Yeah. You're right. But... you're wrong.' THE ONE WHO WAS SHAKEN WASN'T HER. I literally gasped out loud. All this time he's been convince himself he's the danger to her, that HE needs to stay away, but really — really — she's the one who's been keeping herself together through sheer will while he's been the one losing his mind over her. And then his internal monologue just implodes: "This is driving me insane." He closes his eyes and we go straight into the flashback of their FIRST meeting. But what got me wasn't even the romance part — it was watching him process his own feelings in real time. The frustration, the anger at himself, the realization dawning slowly like sunrise. He literally can't look at her because he doesn't want to face what he's feeling. That's such honest writing for a guy who's clearly never dealt with anything like this before. The CP chemistry isn't in grand declarations — it's in him watching her from across a crowd and feeling his whole world rearrange itself.
... Read More
I keep noticing birds everywhere in this text and I think the author is building something intentional here. The hawk cry that interrupts Isabella's confession to Gilrod—"the cry of a hawk soaring freely in the sky rang out from outside the window"—right when Isabella says she hopes she's wrong about her plans for Diana. A hawk. Free. Soaring. While the queen sits trapped in her duty, her regrets, her grief. Isabella watched her own father's wishes destroy her family and her country, and now she's trying to protect Diana by controlling her future, convinced she knows better. But the hawk doesn't care about queens or plans or protection. It just flies. Then there's Jerome himself—constantly watching from the terrace, eyes narrowed, tracking Diana's every move like a predator. But he's not a hawk. He's something else entirely. A guard dog, maybe. Loyal to a fault. And Ian rides Yan, which is apparently some kind of extraordinary mount, across the western hills with Diana clinging to him, both of them caught in this moment of pure motion. The flower shop Ian points out downstairs—"a treat for both the eyes and the nose"—that's a small but crucial symbol too. Diana has never been allowed to just... enjoy things. Her life is duty, schedule, appearances. But Ian describes ordinary pleasures like they're sacred. That bakery, that clothing alley, that flower shop—these are the things she's been denied, and they make the world feel MORE real than any throne room ever could. The recurring motif of hands is also worth noting: Isabella's stiff right hand, clenched and unclenching as she speaks of killing her own kin; Diana instinctively reaching for Ian's hand; Ian holding her waist; Diana pulling the reins herself. Hands as control. Hands as connection. Hands as the difference between being trapped and being free.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment because I have been thinking about it nonstop since I finished reading. Ian says to Diana at dawn, right after this walk where he's being weirdly gentle and following her around clearing his throat like a nervous teenager—which is such a funny, humanizing detail for someone who clearly lives to manipulate people—and he says: 'The next time we meet, I'll make you smile.' And Diana literally spends the rest of these chapters unable to stop thinking about his confident smile. She hates that she can't shake it. She pushes him away at the ball, flees the garden, and yet his face won't leave her mind. This is NOT a simple enemies-to-lovers setup. This is something messier and far more interesting. What destroys me is the contrast between the full moon scene and everything else. The moon is literally described as something that stains Diana's birth night with confusion—joy, sorrow, new life all twisted together. She was born on a full moon during peace, but her parents paid for it with their lives. And Ian wraps a blanket around her shoulders in that cold garden while she's crying and pretending not to. He doesn't push. He just walks beside her, saying 'watch your step,' like he's giving her space while never actually leaving her side. Then there's Lampman breaking down about Diana's father, and you realize the entire political conflict is built on grief. Her brother Louis grew up hating the Ops; Diana grew up without parents and doesn't fully understand that hatred. Ian, meanwhile, is watching her from across a library, completely infatuated but masking it behind calculated charm. Every emotional thread in this book is tangled together and I am not okay.
... Read More
I need to talk about Ian. I literally cannot stop thinking about him. The way the author paints this man — he was her first love, her everything since childhood, the person she built her identity around — and then reveals he was a spy. A spy who leaked royal secrets and orchestrated the destruction of her kingdom. The layered cruelty of it is just... "I thought you were my friend. I thought you were the only one who truly understood me. I believed I couldn't be whole without you." Diana's line hits like a freight train. She didn't just lose her country — she lost her understanding of reality. Every tender moment they shared, every trust she placed in him, was a weapon aimed at her heart. And yet. And yet, in the rewritten timeline where they meet again on that terrace, something is SO OFF. He's suddenly "Ian Leheits" — a completely different identity. His grandmother Gilrod doesn't recognize him anymore. The author is setting up this delicious, agonizing tension where Diana has all this history with a boy who no longer exists in the same form. Then there's Gilrod. The sweet old teacher who was taken away after the war. In the new timeline, he's alive, smiling, calling Ian an "excellent student" with this weird detachment that makes my skin crawl. He doesn't seem to know his own grandson? What the hell did they do to this timeline? The dynamic between Diana and Ian on that terrace — he calls himself Ian Leheits with this bright smile that pretends none of the horror exists, and Diana is holding back a century of grief while also feeling this stupid, traitorous warmth because HE'S ALIVE and he's looking at her the way he used to — it's absolutely devastating.
... Read More
Let me start with the wedding scene because OH MY GOD the imagery is cinematic as hell. The grand cathedral of the Kargen Empire, Diana walking down the aisle like a prisoner in a wedding dress, the children's holy choir singing while her kingdom lies in ruins beneath that flag. The contrast is so sharp it practically hurts. And that flag — described as fluttering with force that seemed to pierce the sky — it's not just a flag, it's the symbol of everything that destroyed her world. Then the bedroom scene. God, the bedroom scene. Diana checking the nightstand for her pistol. The storm raging outside mirroring her inner chaos. Ian saying "You don't have to forgive me, but please don't cry" while touching her face — this man who destroyed her country still has that gentle, almost reverent way with her. And then the gunshot. The white wedding dress stained red. His blood replacing her tears on her cheek. This isn't just dramatic, it's visually BRUTAL in the best way. And then — transition to the terrace. Flower petals drifting on a night breeze. The brilliant full moon carrying "the clear energy of spring." People laughing in the ballroom below, knowing nothing of the war that hasn't happened yet. Diana standing there, isolated among oblivious joy. The juxtaposition of that spring moonlight against everything she carries in her heart? Chef's kiss. The author builds worlds through atmosphere the way some authors build them through exposition, and it works so much better.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or