I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies - Reviews

I Will Say Goodbye to Your Lies
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the balcony scene because I have not recovered. Diana is lying in bed, looking at the Elten River, having this quiet moment of peace that she clearly doesn't get often—"Even having fun is hard work" is such a Diana thought—and then Ian just appears below her balcony like some kind of brooding romance novel lead. And he climbs UP. Like literally climbs the wall of a hotel to talk to her. The sheer audacity of it made me laugh out loud. But then it gets real. He says he's been "feeling strange lately" and can't bring himself to go inside her room. Not because he doesn't want to—because he knows he shouldn't, and he's respecting that boundary even while being incredibly charming about it. "Is this really okay? Aren't you letting me in a little too easily?" Who talks like that?? And Diana's response—rolling her eyes, telling him to get down safely, trying to play it cool—but she still hands him his vest back, still calls him by his full title "Lord Ian" when she's flustered. The whole dynamic between them is built on this incredible tension where they're constantly orbiting each other but never quite colliding. And that ending line, his quiet "I don't climb into just any woman's room"—it's understated to the point of being devastating. He's saying I chose you without saying I chose you. I've read this passage five times and each time I feel something different.
... Read More
I want to zoom in on Ian's internal narration because honestly it made me slightly uncomfortable and I appreciate the author for that. This passage: 'Captivating people was always easy for Ian. He set the trap, enchanted them, and captured them. People, like now, feared him but eventually wanted him.' That is SO much character in three sentences. That's not romance-novel fluff; that's a man who understands power and knows exactly how to wield it. And the way the narrative voice shifts whenever we're inside Ian's head—it's colder, more analytical, sharper. Contrast that with Diana's interiority, which is more fragmented, emotional, driven by memory and instinct. The author gives each POV its own texture and I notice these things. Then there's Lampman, and oh my god Lampman's dialogue is A MASTERCLASS. He goes from pedagogical to unhinged in two seconds: 'It was a great policy, full of the late king's deep intentions' → 'THEY'RE THE ONES WHO TOOK PRINCE EDGAR FROM US!' The way his voice cracks, the physical trembling, the way he slams the desk—that's not a textbook lecturer anymore; that's a grieving old man who has been compartmentalizing hatred for decades and suddenly his composure shatters because Diana says the word 'discrimination' to his face. And don't even get me started on the Jerome exchange about Diana's horse. 'Who said I dislike horses?' 'You did, Your Highness.' 'I didn't know. I never realized I disliked horses until now.' This is genuinely funny and it does double duty—showing us that Diana's past-life memories are already blurring and changing, which is a brilliant subtle detail that reinforces the time-travel stakes without any exposition dumps. The dialogue carries plot.
... Read More
Okay so here's what I'm processing: Diana dies, gets shot by her own husband who takes the bullet for her, and then wakes up three years before the war. Classic isekai/rebirth trope, right? BUT — and this is where it gets GOOD — the past has CHANGED. Ian isn't Ian Paolle anymore. He's Ian Leheits. His entire identity has been rewritten. Gilrod, his supposed grandfather, doesn't seem to know him as family. Diana's childhood friend Jerome is there but reacts differently. The world has shifted around her like a dream you can't quite hold onto. This is the clever part. Most rebirth stories have the protagonist using foreknowledge to fix everything. But Diana is returning to a timeline where the foundation has already crumbled. She can't trust that the people she knew are the same people. She can't trust her own memories because the evidence around her contradicts them. The author is basically saying: you think going back in time gives you power? Try going back to a world that already forgot who you were. The pacing here is relentless. We go from wedding → assassination attempt → death → rebirth → confusion → recognition of changed timeline → emotional reunion with Gilrod → the dance where the music was once her parents' favorite — all in one chapter. No breathing room. Every beat lands like a punch.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the Yan reveal because my heart literally stopped when Ian mentioned his horse's name. Like, he just casually says 'I named him Yan, after myself' and Diana absolutely loses it. Not because she's mad, but because she knows. We know. This horse—this white horse with black mane—was hers in the previous timeline, and somehow it survived into this world with Ian. That's a plot twist that recontextualizes everything. How did it end up with Ian? Did Diana's past life echo ripple through differently? Or is Ian subconsciously connected to her in ways even he doesn't understand yet? And the structure of these chapters is really smart. It starts intimate—late-night palace encounter, pajama Ian, bicycle Diana—then expands outward to the stables, then to the terrace, then to the Queen's office. Each scene is a stepping stone that raises the stakes. The romantic tension builds through small moments (Ian following her, knowing where she'd go, Yan licking her face) and then BOOM, the Queen tells Diana she has to leave the kingdom. The shift from 'will they won't they' to 'she might have to flee the country entirely' is jarring in the best way. It forces Diana to make a choice, and her answer—'I don't want to have regrets'—feels like a character-defining moment. She's not just a princess following rules anymore. She's fighting back. The narrative arc here is doing exactly what it should: making us root for Diana to stay, to fight, to rewrite her fate, while simultaneously showing us how impossible it seems. The Queen's illness at the end adds another ticking clock. Things are running out of time.
... Read More
I cannot stop thinking about the scene where Ian helps Diana with her helmet and their eyes lock. The text says his gaze was 'even more intense than then' — referring to the last ball, whatever that moment was. These two are playing a game where neither will admit they care, and honestly it's the most electric dynamic in the whole book. Diana says 'You don't get hurt either' and Ian smiles like he heard exactly what he wanted to hear. She's not just asking about physical safety — she's asking whether he's okay emotionally, whether she hurt him. And she says it without saying it. Meanwhile, Diana's internal monologue about walking 'the precarious line — giving him what he wants without getting swept away' — this woman is surviving on intellect alone. She literally just told herself she has to stay in control while her hand is still warm from his touch. Also, can we talk about Queen Isabella watching them exchange smiles and then rubbing her chin with a 'curious expression'? The Queen sees everything. She's not stupid. That satisfied smile when Diana asks if she did something wrong? Isabella knows more than she's letting on, and I am HERE for it.
... Read More
I need to talk about the structural genius of this chapter because WOW. It opens with such a sharp, tense moment — Jerome dropping the vest bomb on Ian, the wineglass hitting the table with that SHARP CLACK, and Ian storming out. You're hooked immediately. No slow warmup, just: someone knows something, something happened, what is going on. Then it MOVES. Ian goes to the deck, the fireworks start, he sees Diana, the whole emotional realization hits, and THEN — smoothly, almost imperceptibly — we drop into the flashback. The transition is effortless. He closes his eyes, fireworks still exploding above him, and we're suddenly in the snow. Five years earlier. The pacing here is fascinating because we're getting TWO timelines simultaneously: 1. Present day: Ian at the fireworks, coming to terms with his feelings 2. Past: How he and Diana first met as kids And the way they INTERLOCK is what makes this chapter brilliant. The present-day realization triggers the memory, and the memory recontextualizes everything. We learned about the vest situation in the present, and then in the past we see Diana's very first impression of Ian — she pouts, complains, gets lost in her own house, and still insists on helping him. She was ALWAYS this caring, even when she didn't know who he was. "Phew. Fine! I wasn't going to ask since you don't seem to want to talk, but I need to know your parents' names. I might get confused with room numbers, but I never forget faces and names." Such a small line but it tells us everything about who Diana is. And then Ian's last words to her: "Ian. Farewell, Princess Diana." He knew. He somehow KNEW they'd meet again. The chapter ends on this note of quiet inevitability. Not a cliffhanger per se, but the sense that everything is building toward something huge. And the cut-off line "How are you going to take responsibi..." — UGH. The author leaves us there and I NEED the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
The western hill scene. I need to just sit with it for a moment. Diana and Ian standing above the capital, looking out at all of Erden spread below them, and the way the author describes it—it's not just scenery, it's CHARACTER. "Warm orange lights spread through every corner of the city, settling like branches reaching out in the darkness." That simile alone should be required reading in every creative writing program. It makes the city feel alive, like it's breathing, like it's reaching for something. And then Ian starts describing the village below— the flower shop, the bakery, the clothing store—and suddenly this entire kingdom comes into focus through the eyes of someone who claims to be an outsider. "The Erden he described was truly beautiful. During the day, it was filled with people's energy, and at night, the Elten River, sparkling with starlight, guarded the sleeping city." Guarded. Not just flowed beside it. GUARDED. That's the author whispering something about Diana herself too, isn't it? She's guarding this city, guarding her place in it, guarding her heart. The palace garden scene earlier is worth mentioning too—Jerome watching from the terrace like a paranoid hawk himself while Diana pretends to only want a casual walk. The whole visual of her with arms wide open, eyes closed, feeling spring petals on her fingers, and then hearing a scuffle and following it instinctively—it's such a perfect introduction to her character. She wants peace, she craves normalcy, but trouble (and Ian) keeps finding her. The contrast between the suffocating palace interior and that wide-open western hill is genius worldbuilding. You can literally feel the difference in air pressure.
... Read More
I keep coming back to that one line: 'Before she could be swept away by old memories, she took a step back.' Diana literally knows Ian's smile is dangerous. She's been burned before. And yet. And yet he says 'This is better. For now.' and he strides toward her like he owns the ground she walks on, and she can't walk away even though she tries. This push-pull is everything. Ian is so interesting here. On the surface he's the casual, lounging-about-in-pajamas noble who happens to be ridiculously charming. But look at what he does: he notices her sadness about the foal without being asked. He sits beside her in the stable. He says 'Are you worried about it?' in this quiet, almost tender way. And then he reveals Yan exists—naming his horse after himself, talking about raising him from birth. He has no idea what he's doing to her. Or does he? Maybe he does. The fact that he 'didn't notice' her stunned face might be the most Ian thing ever—either genuinely oblivious or playing dumb. But Diana. Oh god, Diana. Her whole 'I'll seduce him like he seduced me' resolve crumbles the moment Yan nuzzles her hand. She hugs the horse and whispers 'I'm sorry' to something from five years ago. Then she wipes her tears and tries to play it off as 'he looks like a horse I once knew.' Lying through her teeth to someone who's been watching her every move. The irony is brutal because she forgot that her last memory with Yan was the night she was taken prisoner—Yan standing in front of the carriage, helpless. And now Yan is alive, healthy, and choosing to lick her face like nothing happened. She breaks. Completely. And Ian just... watches. Smiles. Says 'I'm happier seeing Your Highness smile.' Like he didn't just become the most important person in her rewritten future. Natasha watching Ian with that cold, calculating gaze is also worth noting. She sees everything. She already suspects.
... Read More
Okay so this section absolutely wrecked me in the best way because the plot just LAYS IT ALL OUT on the table and I'm sitting here taking notes like the drama deserves it. Let me start by saying the central pivot point here—Diana pushing Ian away during the dance—isn't just some random romantic comedy beat. It's MASSIVE. Because suddenly this book stops being just about time travel and revenge and becomes something far more dangerous: a story about two people whose entire worldviews are in violent collision. The structure of these chapters is brilliant because it keeps oscillating between intimate character moments and the terrifying political machinery underneath. Diana goes from fleeing Ian in the garden straight into a confrontational history lesson with Lampman, and those two scenes bookend each other like they're trying to suffocate her. The political plot—the 'differentiation policy,' the Ops persecution, the civil war, her father's assassination—all of it is woven into her personal trauma in ways that feel earned, not forced. Lampman's line 'They're the ones who took Prince Edgar from us!' hits like a truck because it reframes EVERYTHING. The enemy isn't abstract; it's the people who killed her dad. And Ian showing up at the library at the end? Chef's kiss. The parallel structure between Diana reading about her dead father and Ian waiting for her—both of them haunted by people who are gone, both of them searching for answers in books—creates this quiet, devastating symmetry. History hasn't changed, Diana realizes, which means she's running out of time. I literally gasped at that line. The plot is tightening like a noose and I cannot look away.
... Read More
Okay so this entire sequence at the stadium is basically the calm before the storm, and I love how the author uses a seemingly lighthearted event to drop so many plot bombs. Diana showing up unannounced, volunteering for a polo demonstration, getting in front of the Queen — none of this is casual. And then the ending with Dale collapsing? Chills. The author sets this up so perfectly: we get little breadcrumbs like Gilrod making medicine for Queen Isabella right at the start, the mention that the queen's condition worsened before the war with Kargen, and then suddenly Dale looks deathly pale on the field. The parallel between the Queen's chronic illness and Dale's sudden collapse is NOT a coincidence, I'm telling you. And Ian's reaction to seeing Dale — that look of being completely taken aback — what does it mean? Was he expecting Dale to be there? Did he know something was wrong? The author is weaving three threads here: the political tension around Diana's public appearance, the health crisis involving the Queen, and whatever connection exists between Ian and Dale. All converging at one stadium. That's tight plotting.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or