I Really Am Just A Substitute[E-Sports] - Reviews

I Really Am Just A Substitute[E-Sports]
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The dialogue in this chapter is sharp because almost nobody is saying what they actually mean. Take the pre-match taunts. Zou Hao stops in front of Lin Lan and says 'You're Lin Lan, right?' on the surface it's casual, almost friendly. But the narrative context—a disdainful gaze, scrutinizing from head to toe—transforms those three words into a declaration of war. Zou Hao's voice throughout is defined by arrogance masked as confidence. When he glances back at his teammates after speaking to Lin Lan, he's communicating something private and cruel without uttering a sound. The author lets body language do the dialogue work here, which is brilliant. Then there's the locker room scene, where the dialogue becomes almost performative. Wu Tianqi's explosion is full of rhetorical questions—'Am I a damn fool?', 'Do I look like a fool?', 'Whose decision is this exactly?'—each one designed not to get answers but to demonstrate his own victimhood. He's not having a conversation; he's delivering a monologue of grievance. And the coach's response is equally interesting in its restraint: 'DT has treated you well, and besides, the issue of shares is decided collectively; it requires a vote.' This is bureaucratic, measured language deployed against someone who is pure emotion. The contrast between Wu Tianqi's raw, fragmented shouting and the coach's procedural calm creates a voice dissonance that makes both sides feel real. Lu Shi and Feifei's side conversation about the share issue is where the dialogue gets most natural. They're gossiping, half-aware they shouldn't be, and their voices overlap with mutual understanding. 'Probably because of the share issue, still causing trouble' followed by 'Ha, he still wants shares?' reads exactly like two people talking over each other in anxiety. When Wu Tianqi startles them, Lu Shi's panicked denial—'No, no, I was just talking nonsense'—is the kind of useless lie that only makes things worse. The author captures the specific voice of someone whose guilt immediately overrides their intelligence. The narrative voice itself is worth noting. It's restrained, almost journalistic during the match, then becomes more intimate and sensory during the confrontation. This shift in tone mirrors the chapter's movement from public performance to private destruction.
... Read More
Okay so this premise is actually really clever. You've got Lin Lan showing up in this mirror world version of an esports team, pretending to be a loser when really he's some kind of elite player. The spiritual forms angle is interesting too - kin who can see each other's true forms but not their own. That creates instant dramatic irony because Lin Lan is getting all these weird reactions (claws pinning him down, face turning red, dragons coiling around him) and everyone's misreading it. Meanwhile Wu Tianqi is your classic bully antagonist who's clearly going to get schooled. The plot moves at a good pace - we get worldbuilding, character introductions, conflict, and a bit of romantic tension all in one chapter without it feeling rushed. I'm curious how the survival game/dungeon element fits in since it's listed in the usage guide but hasn't appeared yet. Is this like an infinite flow story where they enter different game worlds? The structure feels like it's building toward something bigger than just team dynamics. Also the detail about Xiao Shengjing being the captain but bowing his head to Lin Lan in the original world - that's a power dynamic shift I want to see explored.
... Read More
There's a moment on the bus where Xiao Shengjing watches Lin Lan sleeping and notices his reflection in the window. The narration explicitly states that sleeping curled up like that is a self-defense posture born from lacking a sense of security. That line hit me harder than I expected. Lin Lan is a professional esports player—confident, skilled, respected by his team—but in private he's still that person who wraps himself in a jacket in the corner and keeps the world at arm's length. The jacket motif repeats throughout the passage. Lin Lan emerges from it like a shed skin, sinks back into it like armor. It's his boundary, his comfort zone, his shield. And every time someone tries to penetrate it—whether it's Lu Shi offering a blanket or Xiao Shengjing trying to close the window for him—there's this underlying question of who gets to care for Lin Lan and on what terms. Then there's the medicine bottle. Yellow, unlisted, given without explanation. It represents the hidden treatments, the controlled information, the ways institutions (hospitals, teams, contracts) keep people dependent. The original host's memories of this same bottle suggest a cycle of manipulation that Lin Lan is now breaking. But the fact that he still has to wear a disguise and carry a voice recorder tells you how deep the rot goes. This isn't just about one bad doctor. It's about systems that profit from vulnerable people.
... Read More
I need to talk about Jiang Jin because honestly he deserves his own analysis post. The way this text portrays his relationship with Lin Lan is so quietly beautiful. Think about it — Jiang Jin is the only person on the DT team who KNOWS about Lin Lan's smurf account. When the commentators are losing their minds about whether Lin Lan secretly practiced Lucian, Jiang Jin is sitting there smirking because he's the one person with this privileged knowledge. That moment where he sneakily asks "Did you learn this from watching videos?" is such a Jiang Jin move — curious, supportive, but also aware that Lin Lan's got secrets he doesn't fully share. But here's what really got me: before this match, Lin Lan had been feeling frustrated every day since coming to the LPL. He used to be the one dominating, now he's forced into this defensive top-laner role and he's "quite annoyed." And yet — who does he turn to for game strategy? Not Wu Tianqi, not Feifei, not Xiao Shengjing. He talks to JIANG JIN. "Captain, you just need to help counter-gank." He frames the entire strategy around what Jiang Jin can do. That's trust. That's partnership. And Jiang Jin immediately agrees because he's "thoroughly studied this version." He doesn't hesitate. He doesn't question whether Lin Lan actually knows how to play Lucian — he just commits. Feifei and Xiao Shengjing "trusted Lin Lan a lot" too, but Wu Tianqi? "Whether he believed it or not was no longer important." The text deliberately excludes Wu Tianqi from this信任 circle, which says SO MUCH about the team dynamics. It's not a unanimous consensus — it's a core group of people who chose to believe in Lin Lan despite all evidence to the contrary. The contrast between how the outside world treats DT ("hastily assembled theater troupe") and how this inner circle treats Lin Lan (absolute faith in his abilities) is really powerful character work. Jiang Jin isn't just a support player — he's the emotional anchor holding this fragile team together. And Lin Lan, despite being the powerhouse carry, relies on him more than he probably admits out loud.
... Read More
The ring. Let me just sit with this for a moment. Xie Zilu sends Lin Lan THE ring—specifically the one Lin Lan had liked in Zhang Ran's Moments. That's not a gift, that's a message. It's Xie Zilu saying 'I know what you want, I control what you want, and I'm giving it to you as a leash.' And Lin Lan? He finds a listening device inside the roses first. So he already knows this is a trap, knows he's being watched. Instead of playing along, he takes the most visceral, symbolic revenge possible: he stomps on the ring. On camera. For Xie Zilu to watch. He's trampling the very symbol of Xie Zilu's control and making sure the controller sees it. The roses and ring thrown in the trash? Garbage is still garbage no matter how expensive. That line hit me so hard. And the dog head—Xie Zilu watching through a camera like a predator, thinking he's in control, while Lin Lan holds up a puppet dog and mocks him. Who's really trapped here? Who's really the one barking wildly without being able to bite anyone? I keep thinking about the memory loss angle too—'selective memory loss as self-protection.' Is that what Lin Lan is doing metaphorically? Choosing what to remember, what to discard, what to pretend? The whole sequence is layered with symbolism about power, observation, and who holds the camera.
... Read More
This whole dynamic between Lin Lan and Xiao Shengjing has me Absolutely SHOOK. Like, on one level you have this surface conflict—Lin Lan thinks Xiao Shengjing abandoned him, and Xiao Shengjing thinks Lin Lan came to DT for revenge. But then you peel it back and WHOA. Neither of them actually knows the truth. Xiao Shengjing insists he didn't abandon him, but he can't even fully explain what happened. And Lin Lan is lying about recovering memories when he's basically fabricating everything in real-time. The stakes keep escalating too. First it's emotional—will they trust each other? Then it's physical survival—Lin Lan was almost killed in that alley. Then it becomes existential—what happened to the original Lin Lan? Was it suicide or murder? And now, with that new figure appearing at the end, the stakes just got even higher. Someone is hunting Lin Lan, and they know he's pretending. "How long are you going to pretend?" That question from the clown man is literally the central question of the entire story. If Lin Lan's mask slips, he dies. And Xiao Shengjing? His entire understanding of his relationship with Lin Lan is built on a foundation of incomplete information. They're both fighting blind, and the reader is the only one who can see how fragile everything is. The internal conflict is just as intense. Lin Lan touching that scar and being pulled into a flashback he never lived—he's literally experiencing trauma that isn't his. How do you process that? How do you grieve for someone else's death while trying to survive your own? The emotional complexity here is unreal. I'm not okay.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say it straight: the pacing in these chapters is absolutely brutal in the best way. You start with this tense confrontation between Lin Lan and Xiao Shengjing, right? Back and forth, probing, Lies layering on top of lies. The whole scene reads like a dance where both people are terrified of stepping wrong. And then—BAM—you're dropped into the alley flashback. No warning. Just like that, you're on the cold ground with Lin Lan feeling every kick. The transition is jarring but it works. The author uses that scar as the bridge, touches the seventh vertebra, and suddenly we're pulled into memory. It's a classic but effective device, and the execution is sharp. What I love most is how the pacing shifts between these two timelines. The present-day scenes are tight, controlled, every word measured. But the flashback? It's chaotic. Fragmented. Disorderly footsteps. Laughing crowds. Electric shocks. The prose itself seems to lose control, matching Lin Lan's sensory overload. "Lin Lan, my patience is limited." That line though—that was the moment my stomach dropped. The author drops it right when things are at their most vulnerable, and then immediately follows with the handkerchief wipe. The cruelty in that small action says more than any description could. And then the cliffhanger ending with that neatly dressed figure appearing in the alley? I literally had to scroll. Had to know who it was. Classic misdirection too—just when you think Xiao Shengjing is the threat, someone else steps in. Masterful tension maintenance.
... Read More
The pacing in this chapter segment is absolutely relentless and I mean that in the best possible way. It opens with a micro-scale confrontation, a one-on-one duel between Lin Lan and Kai'Sa that resolves in seconds with Flash-Q for first blood. Very quick. Very sharp. Almost like a appetizer that is so good you immediately want more. Then it pulls back to show the reaction shots. The chat going wild. Xiao Shengjing admitting Lin Lan's brilliance. The opposing team's juniors complaining. This gives the reader a moment to breathe and process what just happened before the author ramps it up again. Next comes the mid-game domination sequence. The author moves through this efficiently with bullet-point style descriptions of their unilateral pressure. Outer turret falling, mid lane rotating, dragon securing, vision control with Kalista W ghosts. This section reads like a highlight reel and it works because we already care about the players from the first blood moment. Then BOOM the pacing slams on the brakes right when things seem too comfortable. Wu Tianqi dies. Feifei dies. Four opponents converge on the dragon pit. Suddenly the comfortable victory lap turns into a do-or-die survival scenario. The health bar countdowns (2500... 1500... 800...) function as a built-in metronome creating urgency on every single line. The release comes with the E skill detonation and the dragon falling. And then the chapter just ends mid-sentence almost with the commentator still talking. Which is honestly perfect because it leaves you hanging exactly like a real match would leave you breathless.
... Read More
This chapter is structured like a wave and I think that's intentional. The first wave is the external world reacting to Lin Lan — broadcasters, professional players, online discussions. Everyone is losing their minds over his gameplay. The second wave is the personal — the hair salon, the cola, the awkward sitting, the hand touch. The third wave is the memory/dream sequence that pulls us back to wherever they were before all of this, somewhere dangerous and hot and desperate. What's clever is how each wave raises the stakes differently. Wave one establishes Lin Lan's competence and public rise — he's no longer just a new player, he's a phenomenon. Wave two establishes something far more fragile and personal — a connection between him and Xiao Shengjing that exists in glances and brief touches and unspoken understandings. Wave three reminds us that none of this ease and normalcy is guaranteed. The desert wasn't safe. That warmth under the scorching sun could have killed him. The structure also plays with information control. We don't know where 'here' is relative to 'there.' The salon feels contemporary and safe; the desert feels primal and threatening. But they occupy the same narrative space, bleeding into each other through Lin Lan's half-asleep state. The chapter ends mid-sentence — 'had a focused and te' — which is either a truncation or a deliberate choice. If deliberate, it's brilliant. It mirrors Lin Lan's own fragmented consciousness, caught between worlds, never fully landing in either. If accidental, well, still works in my favor because now I'm obsessed with what that sentence was going to say.
... Read More
I have so many feelings about Lu Shi and I don't even know where to start. This guy lent Lin Lan money, urged him to keep it, and when Lin Lan actually pays him back in full—the text literally says Lu Shi 'became hesitant again' and asked if it was enough for himself. That's not just about money, people. That is the emotional language of someone who doesn't want the transaction to end because the transaction was the only thing keeping them connected. And Lin Lan, sweet oblivious Lin Lan, completely misses it and just says 'You have a hard time earning money, and your old bike needs to be replaced.' BRO. He's being considerate about a BICYCLE while Lu Shi is having an existential crisis about their relationship dynamics. But then—then the printer behind them is running and Xiao Shengjing hears ALL of this. All of it. The borrowing, the repayment, the vulnerability. And afterward he can't stop looking at Lin Lan with these 'subtly moving' eyes, clearly not focused on the documents at all. He asks 'Why do you owe money to Lu Shi?' like he's trying to understand the shape of this connection. And Lin Lan just casually explains everything like it's nothing, like admitting you can't afford to eat properly after paying back a friend isn't a tragic detail. I kept re-reading that part where Lin Lan had 'just over two thousand left, barely enough for meals' and I genuinely felt upset for him. He's carrying so much alone and he doesn't even seem to realize it.
... Read More
I need to talk about THIS passage for a second because I genuinely did not expect to be crying over an esports novel: "When he stood on the world stage for the third time, holding the trophy, he didn't feel like it was for himself." AND THEN "When the roaring truck approached, heading straight towards him, for a moment, Lin Lan felt like he could dodge it. But he didn't." I am not okay. What?? The author just casually dropped two of the most devastating lines in the book and I was sitting there like—wait, what happened? What truck? Is he— OH. OH NO. So all of this—his composure on stage, his calmness in the draft, that steady mountain energy everyone's praising—that's not just professional discipline. That's someone who already checked out. The fact that he's playing like this now, facing the same online violence that basically destroyed his previous self, feels almost like he's running toward something instead of away from it. And Jiang Jin watching him, knowing what's coming, feeling helpless because he can't protect him from something that lives on screens and keyboards and comment sections—that's the emotional core of this entire scene. It's not about winning or losing a game. It's about whether someone who has already been broken by this world will survive it one more time. I keep thinking about those fans saying "just for today, I'm a fan for life" and it feels so fragile, so temporary, against the tide of people who've been waiting for him to fail.
... Read More
There's this one phrase that keeps coming back to me: "Years of online violence made him build a thick skin, and his passion for the game gradually cooled. He even developed a physical aversion to the mid-lane position." Physical aversion. Not emotional—PHYSICAL. His body literally rejects the thing he loves. That's such a powerful image because it shows how online violence isn't just words on a screen. It doesn't stay in the digital world. It gets inside you. It becomes part of your nervous system. The mid-lane position, which was probably where he felt most alive and competent, became associated with pain and exposure until his body started reacting before his mind even had a chance. And the "thick skin" metaphor works on so many levels. It's the classic advice everyone gives to public figures—just build a thick skin, don't let it bother you. But the text shows us the lie behind that platitude. Thick skin isn't protection. It's numbness. It's the slow death of passion. It's learning to feel nothing so that the words can't hurt you anymore. Then there's the whole thread about how "the truth no longer matters." That sentence about the team that fell apart three years ago—everyone's still being demonized, every tiny flaw amplified. The internet doesn't want justice or understanding. It wants a story, and it will keep rewriting it forever. Lin Lan stepping into this arena knowing this is basically him choosing to fight a battle that has no winner, only survival. What is this story really saying about public judgment? About the cost of being watched? I don't think it's giving easy answers. That's what makes it honest.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or