I Grant You Permission for Revenge - Reviews

I Grant You Permission for Revenge
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The structure of this section is absolutely delicious in how it weaponizes pacing. You start with Eirene alone in the guest room, actually experiencing warmth and comfort for the first time since arriving here. There's a moment of peace—fireplace, soft bed, fresh air—and then WHAM, Aishe bursts in like a tornado and slaps her. That contrast is brutal. One second Eirene is thinking maybe this wasn't so bad, the next she's being shaken by the collar of her dress while the "sweet" sister reveals her true colors. The author didn't ease us into that transition at all. It's jarring on purpose, and it mirrors exactly how Eirene must feel—constantly off-balance in this house. Then the Countess walks in right after Aishe leaves, and the power dynamic shifts again. Aishe gets sent away like a naughty child, and suddenly Eirene is the one being cornered by the matriarch. The hand-holding moment—"Our survival depends on you"—is a masterclass in escalating pressure without raising the volume. No one is yelling. The Countess's voice is gentle. That's worse. And then the banquet scene itself: Clive appears, and the pacing slows down noticeably. The conversation stretches, the silences between lines carry weight, every gesture is measured. It's like the author hit the brakes right when we needed to breathe, forcing us to sit with each awkward exchange. The walk cancellation, the tea room invitation, the Countess's surveillance—each beat lands sequentially, compounding the tension rather than rushing through it. By the time Clive asks about the ring, my heart was actually racing.
... Read More
I can't stop thinking about the name. The Countess tells Eirene that she's told everyone including the Grand Duke that 'Eirene' is Aishe's childhood name. So in public settings she's Aishe, but in private she might be called Eirene. The name has been split in two — literally divided between two people. And Eirene's reaction is quiet devastation. "She couldn't shake the feeling that her name had been stolen." The name Eirene now seems subordinate to Aishe. Aishe doesn't even protest being called by Eirene's name instead of her own. She's apparently fine with it. This ties into everything else about identity and authenticity in the story. Siaran's smile was never real. Eirene's Divine Power was supposedly taken away but it wasn't. Aishe's personality is being performed by Eirene. The whole arrangement is built on borrowed identities. And yet — the snake seal on Clive's letter. Eirene always associated snakes with Clive without understanding why, and now she realizes it's his family seal. Snake as symbol of deception, of something lurking beneath the surface. The Purification ability itself — the foundation of healing, the most basic stage — feels symbolic too. Eirene is being cleansed of the lies she's been living, purified of the false identity she was forced into. And that line from Siaran about purification stages, delivered in the same gentle explanatory tone he always used when they were close — the irony is almost unbearable. He's teaching her about cleansing while being one of the dirty ones.
... Read More
'You're more dangerous than documents.' This line. THIS LINE. It's such a perfect introduction to what their whole dynamic is going to be. Clive literally cannot trust her on paper — he has her sign a confidentiality agreement because verbal promises are too risky — and then immediately undercuts himself by saying SHE'S the danger, not the paperwork. That's both a threat and a compliment wrapped into one sentence and I am HERE for it. And then the cigar scene?? So she asks him nicely not to smoke around her, polite little request, and his entire face HARDENS. He takes the case from her hand like... okay wow. Then he stalks off, asks Ulik 'do I smell?' like a confused man child, and sends Madam Hannon to get him the finest perfume. This man is completely unhinged over a woman who asked him to not smoke near her and he's already trying to change his scent profile. Meanwhile Eirene is over there calculating revenge and probably didn't even register that her one little request threw him into a spiral. The power dynamics here are so wobbly and I love it.
... Read More
Oh my god. OH MY GOD. The kiss scene. I literally gasped out loud. Eirene is trying SO HARD to follow Clive's instructions—she's standing on her tiptoes, straining to reach his cheek, looking so earnest and slightly ridiculous in the most endearing way. And Clive? He's watching her, and I think we all know what happens next. 'Just as she quickly brought her lips to his cheek, intending a brief touch, Clive turned his face, and her lips met not his cheek but his lips.' The heat rising to her face, her immediate step back—this is the moment everything changes. Because here's the thing: Clive later admits to Ulik that he absolutely did NOT intend to kiss her. 'No matter how much he thought about it, he couldn't understand why he had turned his head at that moment.' That's not manipulation. That's not scheming. That's something far more dangerous—he's falling for her without meaning to. And Eirene? When she pulls her face back and says 'No. Save the kiss for next time,' she's protecting herself. She's got trauma, she's been used, she's not stupid. But watch what happens after: 'How cold of her. After telling the coachman they could leave, Clive turned around as Ulik approached...' He's unsettled. She's unsettled. The reader is definitely unsettled. The author writes: 'An inexplicable emotion stirred in his chest, giving him a strange feeling. Was it because she was different from other women?' NO CLIVE, YOU'RE FALLING FOR HER AND YOU JUST KISSED HER BY ACCIDENT. Also—can we talk about how she's grateful for his kindness but feels burdened? 'Eirene was grateful but felt more burdened. She couldn't understand why he had prepared this in advance, knowing she wasn't the real Aishe.' That tension between gratitude and fear? That's so real. That's so complicated. That's the stuff that makes romance hurt in the best way.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how Eirene speaks? Because her dialogue voice is SO distinct and I love it. Clive tries to be polite: "I was about to leave. I didn't want to disturb you." And Eirene's response is essentially: "You were leaving because you thought you'd disturb me, but you've already disturbed me. So if you hadn't come in from the beginning, there would have been no disturbance..." She doesn't understand why this offends him. Not at all. Her narration tells us: "Not because she felt sorry for Clive or thought she had misspoken. Her expression suggested she couldn't believe she needed to explain something so obvious." Then later, walking in the garden, Clive holds her hand to warm it and she literally says: "Your hand isn't warm either." To the man who's been investing heavily in winning her over. And his response? He CHUCKLES. Says "You're not good at saying pleasant things" and then turns it around: "My hand is cold too, but when we hold them together, they become warm. Can you feel it?" This exchange is everything. She states facts. He makes it romantic. Neither of them is being fake — and that's why it works. Her dialogue has zero pretense, which makes every genuine moment land harder. When she says "Of course" repeated back at him about being curious why they didn't eat together, it's awkward but endearing. She's not manipulating him with sweet words because she genuinely doesn't know how. And Clive seems to prefer it that way — "Stating facts, I like that." The author's narrative voice also has this dry, observant quality that matches Eirene's internal world perfectly.
... Read More
Let me just sit with this for a second: Eirene agreed to pretend to love Clive. A contract. A deal. That's the foundation of their entire relationship and it's already cracking under the weight of actual feelings. The external stakes are clear—this is a political marriage arrangement between powerful houses. If it fails, both families lose face, possibly alliances crumble. But the INTERNAL stakes are what keep me up at night. Because Clive is the one who proposed this arrangement, who wanted her close, and now HE'S the one who's confused. 'Eirene was a woman who complicated Clive's thoughts.' He wrote that about HER, but who complicated whom? The scene where he corners her against the bookshelf is pure tension—physical, emotional, romantic. Less than a step away. She backs up but has nowhere to go. He touches her hair and then stops himself. What was he going to do? What WAS he going to do? And then he just... sighs and says 'You can do whatever you want at Dervel' like he's giving her a gift when really he's surrendering control. But what is Eirene risking? She left somewhere dark. Somewhere she read every book available because it was the only world she had. Now she's in a palace with a man who suspects she's lying about her past, who watches her like a hawk, who calls her 'a woman who complicates things.' If this arrangement fails, does she go back? The text never says, and that silence is terrifying. 'More comfortable than the Phineas Mansion.' 'Yes. It's more comfortable here.' And yet she admits it's 'comfortable yet uncomfortable at the same time.' That's the entire thesis of this relationship in one sentence.
... Read More
The visual journey in these chapters is something else. We start in that basement — the coldest, darkest part of the mansion — and by the end, Eirene is walking through city streets breathing air that isn't stale. The contrast isn't just physical, it's symbolic and the author paints it beautifully. The opening image of Eirene finally getting some proper food after weeks of subsisting on scraps. Betty placing the tray down gently instead of carelessly — these tiny environmental details tell us everything about how her status has shifted, even before anyone says it out loud. More bread doesn't seem like much but for someone who was being starved, it's monumental. Then the carriage scene — the rattling sound, the swaying, unmelted snow fluttering down from the trees. 'The earth beneath her feet seemed to speak to her.' This line gave me chills. It's such a simple sensory detail but it captures the entire emotional weight of two months of imprisonment ending. The cold air isn't the bleak winter cold of the basement anymore — it's 'clean, pleasant coolness.' Same temperature, completely different meaning. The dress shop is another standout scene. Through the mirror, Eirene watches the Countess and Aishe having a silent conversation, their expressions shifting constantly. The reflection-as-witness device is so cinematic. And Clive appearing in that space — a man of power and wealth walking into a modest designer's shop where everyone else is performing — creates this incredible tension between the private world of the shop and the public world he represents. The final image of Eirene gripping the window frame, frightened by the speed, then gradually taking in the city streets — it's the visual metaphor for her entire arc so far. Terrified but fascinated, supported but exposed, moving forward even when she wants to close her eyes.
... Read More
Oh my god, the cousin detail. I had to go back and re-read that part because it was so casually dropped but absolutely massive for Eirene's whole strategy. So the Count and Countess basically say, “Why not just pay off that cousin and make him disappear?” as if human lives are line items on a ledger. And Eirene's first thought isn't, “How cruel,” it's, “Could I use him?” That shift in her morality is terrifying and brilliant. She's already recalibrating what she's willing to sacrifice. But then she dismisses it—smart. If he knew she was imprisoned and starving in a basement, he'd only come for money. He's not a savior; he's another predator. That realization alone shows how much she's changed from the girl who trusted Aishe. The relationship with Aishe is the real horror though. Aishe didn't just steal her power—she fed on it. “I'm alive because I've been feeding on you bit by bit for a long time.” That's not healing; that's parasitism. And Eirene now knows it. Meanwhile, Clive walks in and instantly adopts the role of rescuer without knowing half the truth. He calls her “my fiancée” in front of everyone, and the Phineas couple freezes. That one sentence shifts the entire power dynamic in the room. Eirene realizes she can wear Aishe's face like a mask and watch them panic. It's not love; it's tactical deception. But then there's Betty. The maid who brings her meals, who complains about being overworked but still checks on her. Eirene notes, “Betty was among the kinder ones.” In a house full of monsters, even a little cruelty from below is noted. It makes Eirene's isolation feel even sharper—she's trapped between people who want her dead and people who just don't care enough to look.
... Read More
Okay so the lunch scene on the road to Dervel is probably one of the most quietly beautiful moments in this entire book and I need people to appreciate it. It's winter, the mountains are covered in snow, there's no wind so the cold is bearable, and Eirene — who hasn't eaten with another person since she came out of the basement — practically forces her escorts to eat with her. She pushes aside food, seats Matilda, calls over the guards. "Food always tastes better when shared." Just this simple, devastating line that says everything about how starved she is for human connection. The contrast with the Phineas mansion is brutal. There she ate alone every single meal, confined to her room, losing her appetite despite the higher quality food. And here, in the middle of nowhere with strangers, she eats more heartily than she has in weeks. The author doesn't even make a big deal out of it — it's just there, woven into the travel narrative. Eirene stands up, looks around, notices that winter is slowly passing. This small moment of warmth in the snow is doing so much emotional work. Then they arrive at Dervel Palace at night and it's described as more magnificent than the Phineas mansion — of course, it's the residence of the Emperor's son — but the real magic is in the details. Margaret Hannon greeting her, calling her Eirene not Aishe. The staff already knowing her real name before she even arrived.
... Read More
There's a recurring motif here that I can't stop thinking about—eyes and visibility. The Grand Duke keeps fixating on Eirene's eyes. "I'm glad to see your eyes directly." "Your eyes are so clear." But what does that really mean in context? Eirene has spent her entire life invisible to this family. She was the shadow sibling, the girl kept alive only as a medical reservoir for Aishe. And now, paradoxically, being seen is the most dangerous thing that could happen to her. Clive sees her—truly sees her—but he's seeing the wrong person. Or is he? His gaze feels less like desire and more like recognition of something he can't quite place. The eyes become this symbol of identity itself: who sees whom, and what happens when the wrong person is perceived. Then there's the engagement ring. Where is it? It's absent. Eirene has no ring because it was never hers to wear. But its absence is louder than any jewelry could be. It's a physical manifestation of the lie she's living—every moment without it is another reminder that she's playing a role she never signed up for. When Clive asks about it, the question cuts through the performance. And speaking of performances—Eirene's bath. Betty notices she's impossibly clean, as if God herself scrubbed her for this moment. The water becomes a baptism motif. She emerges from it not just physically transformed but symbolically reborn into this new identity. The basement was her grave; the guest room, the bath, the dress—these are all rituals of becoming someone else. The question haunting me is whether Eirene will ever be able to return to herself after this, or if she'll lose herself entirely in the performance.
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying—Clive blushing at Eirene telling him he smells nice is ONE OF THE GREATEST MOMENTS IN THIS BOOK AND I WILL DIE ON THIS HILL. Like, think about it. This is a man who sits on desks, drinks half a bottle of alcohol for breakfast, and intimidates entire palaces with his presence. And Eirene goes "you smell nice" and he SHORT-CIRCUITS. He literally says "nothing has changed from yesterday" like a panicked toddler, which is hilariously unhinged because of course something changed—it's just that HE changed, not his stupid cologne. And then the dinner scene?? Madam Hannon noticing his flushed face while Eirene stays perfectly composed until she sees the dessert? The contrast is everything. Eirene doesn't show much reaction to anything except food, and Clive NOTICED that detail. He had the chef go all out on desserts specifically for her. That's not just plot advancement, that's a whole character arc compressed into a single gesture. But here's what really gets me—the library scene where Clive just sits on the desk and watches Eirene read instead of saying anything. He says "I was waiting to see how long you wouldn't notice me" and honestly that line hit me like a truck. He came up there just to be near her and couldn't even admit it. And when she tries to leave, he sighs and lets her go but not before that exasperated shout Ulik later hears. The tension in this book is INSANE and it's all built on things they don't say to each other. Then you pivot hard into the Aishe reveal and suddenly it's like a different genre. The political intrigue layer with the Pope overstepping, the Emperor's silence about the palace renovations, Clive's drinking accelerating—all of this converges. The pacing in these chapters is deliberately choppy: quiet domestic moments followed by cold, razor-sharp confrontations with Aishe. It keeps you off balance in exactly the right way.
... Read More
Okay so this whole subplot about Kailro Phineas is honestly GENIUS and I need to talk about it. Clive and Ulik are spying on the Phineas family, trying to get information, and somehow they stumble onto the fact that Kailro — who rarely shows his face, supposedly doesn't even drink — has started saying something wild when he's drunk: he claims to have a "beautiful hidden sister." Here's the thing that made me sit up straight: nobody in the story (and honestly, nobody reading) would assume Kailro is talking about Eirene at first, right? Because Eirene is basically invisible — she's been hiding underground, barely exists in society. But think about it. Clive himself admits: "The more he learned, the more interesting this family became." And Kailro looks EXACTLY like Aishe, which Clive literally never connected before. The Phineas family is full of people hiding things from everyone, including each other. If Kailro IS talking about Eirene, that changes EVERYTHING. It means the brother of the woman Eirene is replacing knows the truth, or at least suspects it, and he's not just keeping quiet — he's apparently protective of her. "Beautiful hidden sister" isn't exactly hostile language. This could be a massive turning point where Eirene gains an unexpected ally from inside the enemy camp. Also, Clive's investigation thread is so satisfying. He's connecting dots between the Phineas family and the Temple, and the narrative keeps layering secrets on top of secrets. The plot doesn't feel rushed at all — it's methodical, almost like a detective story wrapped in a romance. Every chapter reveals something new without feeling forced.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or