I Grant You Permission for Revenge - Reviews

I Grant You Permission for Revenge
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's this one image I keep coming back to—Eirene sitting by the window in the frozen morning light, her nose red from cold, skin whiter than snow, breath visible in the air. Madam Hannon notices it and her maternal instincts immediately kick in: 'You must return home in good health. If you fall ill, His Grace will be blamed.' And I just... okay, the political stakes are already baked into every domestic moment in this story. The guest palace behind the western side of the main residence. In spring there would've been lawns and flowers, but winter makes it bleak. And yet Eirene gazes at this ordinary, almost tedious scenery 'with curious eyes, treating it like a welcome sight or something she was seeing for the first time.' That line broke me. Who looks at a winter landscape the way someone who's never seen the sky before would? The library is such a perfect setting for her character. Half the size of the first and second floors combined, moonlight streaming through windows, books arranged like dominoes. Eirene walking between the shelves, slowly reading titles, hungry for something I can only assume was denied to her for years. 'All of them. I haven't seen any of these before.' Not a single one. Where has she been reading? And Madam Hannon's observation about Eirene being 'like the Snow Princess trapped in a tower from children's fairy tales'—that's not just a pretty description, that's thematic Foreshadowing 101. A girl preserved in ice, beautiful and untouched by the world, waiting for someone to thaw her out. But also... what if the princess doesn't want to be rescued? What if she's fine in her tower?
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about Clive and Eirene because THIS dynamic is everything. Clive is genuinely rattled by her, and I love that. He walks into this situation thinking he's got the upper hand—he's the powerful Grand Duke, she's some girl he pulled from obscurity, right? Wrong. The moment that killed me was when he caught her standing by the open window in just a shawl, breathing in winter air like it was oxygen after drowning. A normal noble girl would never do that. A normal noble girl wouldn't open ALL the curtains herself. And yet Eirene does these things with such matter-of-fact grace that it makes Clive question literally everything he assumed about her. And the library scene?! When he pins her against the bookshelf and she just... doesn't flinch? She says 'Yes. It's more comfortable here.' More comfortable than Phineas Mansion. More comfortable than wherever the hell she came from. That line hit me like a truck. What did she endure before this? But here's what I can't stop thinking about—Clive asked her to pretend to love him, and now he's saying 'I can't invite someone I love and have them stay for just one day.' He's projecting, isn't he? Or maybe he's starting to feel something and his brain is catching up slower than his heart. Also, the hair moment. He GRABS her hair, looks at it, then lets it go with a frustrated sigh. What does that say about HIM? Like he wants to do something else with it but stops himself? CHOKING ME.
... Read More
Okay so let me just process what just happened because my brain is still catching up. Eirene—the actual impostor, not Aishe—was mistaken for her by the Grand Duke. And the Phineas family just... decided she had to play along? Like that's a thing you just casually ask someone to do. Aishe literally slapped her, screamed at her, and then promptly transformed back into the sweet, apologetic sister. What a psycho. But here's the thing that really got me—Eirene herself initiated this whole thing. She told Betty that she agreed to attend the banquet. She *chose* to step into this role. That's the plot hook I cannot let go of. And then Clive. Oh my god, Clive's scene. He's sitting right across from her, basically peeling her alive with his gaze. "I'm glad to see your eyes directly." Wait, WHAT does that mean? He's clearly noticing something off—he noticed she has no engagement ring on, he questioned whether she's really been sick, he called her eyes "so clear." He's suspicious. But also... he seems to genuinely want to believe she's Aishe? The way he touched her wrist and then pulled back, like he was testing her reaction? That's not the behavior of a man who thinks he's talking to a stranger. That's a man whose instincts are going haywire but can't quite name why. The Countess's surveillance behind the tea room door is giving me serious "I've prepared for war" vibes. The whole family is playing a high-stakes game and Eirene's the card they're betting everything on.
... Read More
Let me geek out about one specific scene because the author really delivered here. The café encounter—this is where everything shifts from 'political convenience' to 'something real.' The setting is perfect: they're in a private room, away from prying eyes but still in public. The owner immediately understands the situation and brings medicine. This is a world where nobles might act oddly, but servants are used to their eccentricities. The description of Clive tending to Eirene's wounds is visceral and intimate without being inappropriate. 'He poured clean water to wash away the blood and carefully applied disinfectant. His hands were very skilled at wrapping the bandage.' There's something so tender about a battlefield-hardened warrior being gentle with someone's feet. But the worldbuilding shines through in the details. When Eirene overhears strangers discussing her—'Is that her? The Grand Duke's fiancée?'—you realize how isolated she's been. She's lived in a mansion basement, never seeing the world. And now she's walking down streets, feeling people's curiosity like physical touches. The shopping district scene earlier also matters—'Absorbed in sightseeing, her nausea completely disappeared.' This is a woman experiencing freedom for possibly the first time, and the author makes you feel it through sensory details. Ulik's entrance with the shoes is another standout. He's described as 'the Grand Duke's aide' who appears 'so gentle that he seemed unrelated to the person who had looked at Eirene with coldness and disgust.' This duality tells us so much about Clive's world—everyone wears masks, everyone has hidden depths. And the carriage scene at the end—'Eirene's face' appearing through the slightly opened window, the distance between them as he watches the carriage disappear—captures longing so perfectly without words.
... Read More
I have to talk about this one scene because it's SO cinematic. Eirene is walking through the annex garden at night, it's winter, the flowers haven't bloomed yet, and Matilda is pointing out where blooms will come in spring. There's something almost poetic about describing a barren winter garden while talking about a ball that celebrates spring — the contrast is beautiful. And then: "Perhaps pricked by a thorn, Eirene quickly put her finger to her lips. Though one might have screamed at such a moment, she merely parted her lips slightly." This detail! This is the kind of writing that makes me stop and re-read. Most characters would yelp or fuss over a rose thorn prick, but Eirene just... stops. Part her lips. Like she's experienced worse. And when Matilda panics about disinfecting and scars, Eirene's response is practically cold: "Have you ever gotten a scar from a rose thorn?" And then the confirmation she's not like other noble ladies — "You're not the same as me" from Matilda, and Eirene's quiet insistence that they ARE the same. But they're not, and we know it. The ball preparation scene is another highlight. Flowers arriving, color returning to Eirene's pale face — the author literally connects her coming alive with the arrival of flowers. And then the white jewel-encrusted dress, the deep purple amethyst necklace matching her eyes. Every sensory detail is purposeful. The winter cold, the warmth of joined hands, the scent of roses. This world feels tangible, not like generic fantasy backdrop.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at risk here because it's not just 'revenge on the Phineas family' anymore. Eirene starts this section vowing to make the Phineas family experience what she went through — locked in darkness, hungry, cold, suffering until death. That's specific. That's personal. That's someone who has nothing left to lose except their need for justice. But then she upgrades. She decides that cooperating with Clive just to break Aishe's engagement is 'too shallow.' She wants MORE. She wants to become the mistress of this palace. The stakes have shifted from 'hurt my enemies' to 'gain ultimate power in this empire.' And Clive? He's recruiting her for something dangerous — financial intelligence on the Phineas family, extracting information about their wealth and where it comes from and where it goes. That's not casual espionage, that's life-or-death if she gets caught. He puts it in writing because he 'doesn't completely trust her' but also because the consequences of failure are obviously severe. Meanwhile he's asking her to pretend to be his loving fiancée while gathering dirt on her own family. She's playing double agent inside her own revenge plot inside a political arrangement. And the worst part? They're both terrible at pretending. She cracks when food tastes good. He cracks when she asks him not to smoke. Who's actually in control here? Neither of them. And that's what makes this so gripping.
... Read More
There's this one detail that kept bouncing around in my head after I finished these chapters: the palace is being constantly rebuilt. Fountains replaced, structures dug up and installed anew. The Emperor won't explain why. And right alongside this physical transformation of the imperial space, Aishe appears having completely reinvented herself—from Phineas survivor to Lady Baix, from dead girl to someone walking around with a forged identity so perfect that even birth documents can't contradict it. The parallel is unmistakable. Just as the Emperor keeps changing the palace's appearance for reasons nobody understands, Aishe has been reshaping her entire identity like a building renovation—digging up the old foundations, laying new ones, making sure everything looks legitimate from the outside. "It's a good excuse for moving between both places without raising suspicion." The text literally uses construction language to describe her deception. Then there's the scent motif, which is way more loaded than it first appears. Eirene has a strong aversion to the cigar smell associated with Count Phineas—that's her sensory link to the family Aishe destroyed. When she notices Clive smells DIFFERENT, not like that cursed cigar smoke, it's almost like her body is registering that he exists outside the Phineas tragedy. He's not contaminated by that history. And yet he's also entangled with it now through his engagement to Eirene, through being Aishe's target. The mask imagery is everywhere. Aishe's literal veil in public, her fake teary eyes that dry instantly, her performative shyness. Clive's own masks—the infuriating grand duke, the drunk breakfast drinker, the cold interrogator. Even Eirene wears one: her placid expression that only breaks for dessert. Everyone in this book is performing. The question isn't who's wearing a mask—it's who's tired of taking it off. And Florian, blessed bright Florian, is the only character who never puts one on. He calls Clive "brother" in private because he means it. He worries about his drinking because he cares. His illness makes him sensitive to sunlight, to brightness, to harsh things—and yet he's the most genuine presence in every scene he's in. Maybe that's why Clive protects him so fiercely. In a world of forged documents and false identities and palace renovations covering up old foundations, Florian is the one thing that's authentically, undeniably real.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or