I Grant You Permission for Revenge - Reviews

I Grant You Permission for Revenge
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
'Don't forget your place.' That's the opening line of Aishe's scene and I immediately wanted to throw my phone across the room. But also — the writer knows exactly what they're doing. Aishe's dialogue is sharp, clipped, loaded with venom masked as concern. "What did you do to the Grand Duke to receive this?" "Don't mistake his kindness toward you as genuine." Every sentence is a weapon. She's genuinely terrified that Eirene is winning, that Clive's attention is shifting, and instead of processing it maturely she comes at her sister like a cornered animal. And Eirene's responses? Devastating in their calmness. "Of course. I'll always remember." Then internally: "Everything I had to endure because of you. What happened to my family because of you." She doesn't avoid Aishe's glare but she doesn't glare back either. She just receives it with a gentle face and a smile. The contrast between what she says and what she thinks — that's where the real dialogue brilliance lives. Even Clive's letter, which we only see excerpted, has a distinct voice. "My beloved Aishe" — the affection is so palpable it makes your skin crawl. And Aishe's reaction, sobbing about how he's never directly invited her to Dervel Palace before, tells us everything we need to know about their relationship. The dialogue does triple duty — advancing plot, revealing character, and building atmosphere simultaneously. That's craft.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is absolutely masterful. Let me walk through why. Chapter 6 starts with leisurely streetwalking—'Eirene listened carefully to what people were saying'—building atmosphere and establishing the fake fiancée scenario. We get worldbuilding, character moments, casual dialogue. Relaxed pace. Then—BAM—she starts limping. Physical discomfort creates immediate tension. Clive notices. He kneels. The crowd reacts. The stakes shift from 'they're pretending' to 'this is becoming real' in one sequence. The café scene then does something clever: it slows down time. Medical treatment is intimate, deliberate, quiet. But within that quiet, the interrogation begins. 'Now, tell me. Who are you?' The pace accelerates emotionally even as the physical action slows. Eirene's confession comes fast and painful—basement imprisonment, abandonment, switching identities. All in one breathless monologue. The author doesn't give us breaks; she dumps the trauma and we have to process it alongside Clive. Then the deal itself: 'Pretend to love me.' Fast, practical, almost casual—but underneath, everything has changed. The chapter ends with the accidental kiss, which is both the emotional climax AND a scene that propels us into Chapter 7. Chapter 7 immediately interrogates that kiss. 'Why did I do that?' Clive asks himself. Ulik observes. The reader screams at them to just admit it. This callback structure keeps tension high while giving us breathing room between major revelations. What really works is how the author varies scene length. The streetwalk is longer, atmospheric. The café is shorter, punchy. The confession is rapid-fire. The kiss moment is almost frozen in time. And the carriage goodbye is brisk, almost dismissive—which makes it hurt more. By the end of these chapters, we've gone from 'mild curiosity' to 'romantic entanglement' to 'political alliance' to 'unintentional passion.' That's ambitious pacing, and it lands.
... Read More
I read this chapter three times and each time I got more stressed. The pacing is absolutely ruthless. It starts with Siaran interrogating Eirene about the basement — that's page one and already we're deep in mystery territory. How did she get out? How was her body clean? The reader is right there with her, piecing things together, and the author doesn't give us any easy answers. Then it cuts to Aishe arriving, and suddenly we've got this domestic tension layered on top of the mystery. Aishe is anxious, flustered, slaming doors — and Eirene is just... smiling. The shift in their dynamic happens so quickly that you barely have time to process it before the next beat hits. Eirene decides to practice her Divine Power and it WORKS. She purifies her own hands. And the way the author handles this revelation is perfect — she doesn't announce it dramatically, she just quietly tells herself "It worked" and then immediately decides to keep it secret. Then Clive's letter arrives and the stakes escalate again. A week at Dervel Palace. An all-night ball. Everything provided. The Countess says she's finding it burdensome too but needs Eirene to just bear with it. And the chapter ends with Eirene arriving at Dervel Palace and being called by her real name. Each section raises the temperature. There's no breathing room, no filler, just relentless forward momentum.
... Read More
The way this novel builds its world isn't through grand descriptions of castles or courts—it's through the basement. I mean, the stench. God, the stench. Betty folding two handkerchiefs diagonally, tying them behind her head, holding her breath before even opening the door. And yet, on this particular day, there's no smell. That's the first clue something's wrong. The air itself has changed. Maybe Eirene cleaned herself? Maybe the rot has finally exhausted itself? Either way, the absence of odor is more disturbing than its presence. It signals transformation. Then there's the cracked mirror. Eirene looks at herself and sees not her own reflection but a ghost—pale, tangled hair, eyes like she's already half-dead. The mirror doesn't show a princess; it shows a corpse that hasn't been buried yet. And the library! “The back of the basement room was a library full of books.” This is the only window she ever had. Through pages, she attended balls, kissed imagined lovers, felt wind that wasn't damp and rotting. Books were her escape, but also her cage's only decoration. The contrast between the dusty, dark prison and the vivid worlds she consumed is heartbreaking. Later, when she steps into the hallway and sees the servants lined up outside, the architecture itself becomes a weapon. The Phineas mansion isn't just a home; it's a machine designed to hide its crimes behind polished floors and polite smiles. When Eirene walks into the light, she disrupts that machine. The Countess's panic, the servants' frozen faces, the way one nearly cries out her real name before swallowing the word—it's a visual symphony of guilt. Even the tea room, where Eirene rehearses her fragile performance, feels staged. Every cushion, every candle, every drop of tea is part of a theater where she's forced to play the dying bride. The worldbuilding here is psychological as much as physical. You don't just see the prison; you feel its weight in the air, in the silence, in the way light hurts after too long in darkness.
... Read More
Okay so let me unpack this because holy shit. The entire premise of these chapters is built on a gorgeous house of cards and I am here for it. Eirene pretending to be Aishe while Aishe hides in the basement — that's the kind of swap that screams "things are about to go wrong" and the author keeps feeding us little cracks in the facade. The Countess basically admits they sent the wrong portrait on purpose but then kept going because Clive was "very taken" with Eirene's face. That is not a mistake. That is calculated deception from the start, and it makes the whole Phineas family so much more sinister than a bunch of desperate nobles trying to marry up. But the real plot bomb drops when Clive confronts them at the dress shop. He already knows something is off — he notices the ring isn't on Eirene's finger, he asks why "Miss Baix" is wearing it, and he literally puts the ring back on her himself like a king claiming what's his. The reveal that Aishe is living as a Baix family member? That changes EVERYTHING. This isn't just a swapped identity situation — it's a political web. Also Clive's whole motivation is fascinating. He's not here for romance. He's investigating the Phineas fortune and their true loyalties. The engagement was a cover. And yet — and here's the delicious part — he seemed genuinely affected by Eirene. He called out her old dresses, said they didn't do her justice, and personally escorted her out. Is he playing a double game or is he starting to care? Because if the latter, this plot just got infinitely more dangerous for everyone involved.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are layered and escalating in the best way. On the surface: Eirene needs protection. She's been abused, imprisoned, used as a sacrifice. Clive needs information about the Phineas family for his own political goals. That's the transactional foundation. But beneath that: identity conflict. Who is Eirene? Who is Aishe? The real Aishe is out there somewhere, playing the role of Baix family daughter. Eirene has been stripped of her name, her face, her entire existence. When she reveals herself to Clive, she's risking everything—her safety, her new identity, her fragile hope for freedom. Clive's conflict is equally complex. He's a Grand Duke playing dangerous political games. His engagement to Aishe isn't about love—it's about power. But when he looks at Eirene and feels that 'inexplicable emotion,' his control slips. For a man who operates through calculation, losing control IS the highest stake. The public conflict matters too. Those people bowing as they walk—'Curious eyes followed them. Eirene could hear conversations of people wondering who she was.' They're performing in real-time, with an audience. One wrong move and everything collapses. And the Phineas family? 'Count Phineas becomes more surprising the more we learn about him.' The revelation that he orchestrated the switch, imprisoned his own daughter's alternate, sent the wrong portrait—these are villains with depth, not cartoonish evil. The kiss itself represents the ultimate stakes explosion: what happens when the pretense fails? When Clive can't explain why he turned his head? When Eirene can't pull away fast enough? 'Was it because she was different from other women?' Clive wonders. But the real question is: what happens when pretending becomes the only truth you have left?
... Read More
I need to talk about Clive and Eirene because WOW. The way these two interact is so nuanced and complex. Let's start with Clive. On the surface he's this cold Grand Duke who plays with people's lives like chess pieces. But watch him kneel in the middle of a busy street to tend to Eirene's wounded feet—'What do I care about people's stares when my fiancée is in pain?'—and suddenly you see something softer beneath that predator exterior. He's experienced trauma (battlefield wounds, obviously) and he recognizes it in others. But then—and this is crucial—he immediately switches back to interrogation mode. One moment he's bandaging her feet like a proper gentleman, the next he's looming over her like 'now tell me, who are you? That shadow of a massive predator slowly rising.' The man is terrifying and protective in equal measures, and Eirene is the first person who doesn't immediately cower. Eirene herself—she's survived imprisonment in a basement, abandonment to die, and deception. She's got this incredible mix of vulnerability and steel. When she says 'You don't look the part' to Clive's face about trustworthiness, and he actually appreciates it? That's rare chemistry. Their deal—pretending to love each other while using each other for revenge—is honestly the healthiest relationship dynamic I've read in a while. They're being transparent about their motives, which is more than most fictional couples do. And that hand-holding moment? 'Only today did she fully feel the hardness of his palm, embedded with calluses. It was a soft hand.' The physical details reveal everything about their connection. Ulik as Clive's shadow-aide is also interesting. The way he observes everything but knows his boundaries—that's how you write a supporting character who adds depth without stealing scenes.
... Read More
There's this one moment where Eirene opens the window in that guest room and just… breathes. I had to stop reading because my chest actually tightened. After ten days in a basement so foul she could taste the rot through folded handkerchiefs, the first clean air hitting her lungs is described like a spiritual event. “The sunlight she was seeing for the first time was so bright that she couldn't properly open her eyes.” Not just bright—new. She's never felt real wind, real sun, real space. Books taught her about the world, but books don't teach you how air feels when it's not stale. And then the rage comes. “They had prevented her from enjoying what every living being born into this world should naturally be able to enjoy.” That line broke me. It's not just about imprisonment; it's about stolen normalcy. She didn't ask for vengeance when she was fed moldy bread. She didn't plot murder when she was too weak to stand. But after feeling sunlight on her skin? That's when the human part of her wakes up, and with it, the fire. The emotional core of this section isn't the revenge plot—it's the small, sensory rediscovery of being alive. Even her interaction with Betty is layered with this quiet grief. Betty spills soup on her, calls her foolish, rushes off because she's “going to die from all the work.” And Eirene laughs. Not a happy laugh—a bitter, broken thing. Because the present is unchanged, but she's changed. She remembers Clive now. Not the man, but the ghost of who he might have been. She wrote letters for Aishe, using the right words, and he never noticed. That's not just deception; it's the death of a hope she didn't even know she held. Now she's using that same path to walk toward justice, or something close to it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just... okay. Eirene's little shift in mindset here is HUGE and I think the author deliberately sets this up as the turning point of her entire strategy. She arrives at the Grand Duke's palace, sees the servants bowing, walks through these gorgeous halls — and instead of just thinking 'haha revenge on Aishe,' she actually goes: what if I become the mistress of this place? That's not petty anymore, that's strategic. Like, imagine being locked in a basement dreaming of watching your enemies suffer, and then you walk into a palace and your brain just goes 'yeah but why stop there.' The plot just escalated from 'revenge game' to 'I will literally take over this world.' And Clive? He's the tool she's using now. But is he really? That's the question, isn't it? Because the way he keeps surprising her — the dresses, the veil, the fact that he remembered where she shops — it feels like HE might be the one getting played, or maybe they're both playing each other and neither knows it yet.
... Read More
I need to talk about Florian because this boy is genuinely precious and I'm not okay. "Brother!" — that's how he runs after Clive. Not "Your Highness," not "Grand Duke," just "brother." And Clive keeps correcting him about public vs private settings, and Florian just smiles and calls him brother anyway because honestly who needs titles when you have family? The scene where Clive lowers himself to stroke Florian's hair and Florian wrinkles his nose and blocks his hand like a kid? I actually laughed out loud. These two have such a specific dynamic—Florian is sickly, moves with difficulty, but his energy when he's with Clive is pure sunshine. On cloudy days he feels better apparently, which is such a small but specific worldbuilding detail that makes him feel real. But then immediately after this heartwarming scene, we get Aishe. And the whiplash is intentional. Clive's demeanor shifts from warm to glacier in approximately zero seconds when Aishe grabs his collar. The text literally says his perfunctory smile "completely vanished." And the worst part? She's pretending. She's playing this delicate, distressed cousin asking about Eirene, and Clive—who now KNOWS she's actually the surviving Phineas who had everyone killed—has to sit there and pretend he doesn't know anything. His line "She's having a very comfortable and good time. With me" when asked about Eirene is so casually possessive it's almost unconscious. He doesn't even realize he's saying it. And Aishe's eyes drying instantly when she hears Eirene is with Clive? Chilling. Absolutely chilling. The shift from fake teary eyes to calculating stillness in one sentence. Meanwhile Ulik is just happily oblivious in the carriage calling Aishe a star while Clive side-eyes him. Their friendship is so wholesome it hurts next to all this plotting. Ulik has spent days trying to dig up dirt on Aishe's past and found nothing because the forgery was planned before she was even born. The fact that someone constructed an entire identity from scratch just to get close to the Phineas family—or whatever her endgame is—should be terrifying and it IS, but the book never lets you forget that Clive is surrounded by people who genuinely care about him (Ulik, Florian, Madam Hannon) while also being hunted by someone wearing a face like a mask.
... Read More
Can we just talk about how gut-wrenching it is to watch Siaran's facade literally crumble? The moment when Eirene says she left because the door was open and his perpetually smiling face just... crumpled? I lost my mind. Here's this guy who has been maintaining this flawless, polite smile for the entire story, sitting there with his hands neatly on his knees like some kind of porcelain doll, and for one split second you see the real person underneath. The Count and Countess included him in this conspiracy — all of them deceived Eirene, all for Aishe's sake. But Siaran? He was the one she trusted most. She relied on him to explain things she didn't understand, the one person who felt genuinely close to her. And it turns out that closeness was manufactured. But here's what really got me — Eirene doesn't even flinch. She just looks into his eyes and sees the shadow hidden in his smile for the first time. That line, "Now that she understood his true feelings, she could finally see it" — it hit me like a truck. She's not sad about it. She's not angry. She's just... done pretending. And then the Aishe confrontation! Aishe showing up with red eyes, throwing a letter at Eirene, acting all fierce and threatening. "Don't mistake his kindness toward you as genuine." Meanwhile Eirene just sits there smiling gently, absorbing the glare like it's nothing. The power dynamic has completely reversed and I am LIVING for it.
... Read More
The winter snow flower metaphor is everything. Clive thinks of Aishe as a cute flower blooming in spring — warm, bright, surrounded by love. And Eirene? She's a flower grown in winter snow. That's not just a personality description, that's a whole life story in three words. She survived something that should've killed her. She grew in conditions that would destroy most people. And now she's being placed in this gorgeous palace with silk dresses and fancy food, and she's still that winter flower — beautiful, sure, but forged in cold and hardship. The veil is another symbol that hits different when you think about it. Clive puts a veil in her dressing room without fully understanding why it matters, probably because Aishe always wore one. It's like he's trying to dress Eirene in Aishe's aesthetics without realizing that Eirene is not Aishe, that she'll wear the veil differently, that she'll make it her own. And the cigar — smoke, something that lingers, something people either love or hate. Eirene hates the smell but can't escape it because it clings to him. He wants to change it for her but doesn't know how. These small details keep coming back like little symbols of their entire situation: proximity without intimacy, performance without authenticity, two people trying to figure out if they can actually be real with each other or if they're just costumes and smoke.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or