Give Me Another Smile (GL) - Reviews

Give Me Another Smile (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, so let me just... this chapter hit me like a truck. The entire sequence with Tang Zhengyang finding the encrypted message is genuinely tense. A father walks in on his daughter who apparently bypassed his computer firewall and sent him a tip-off in Morse code, all while being a TEN-YEAR-OLD. Like, what IS this kid? And then the twist about the surveillance camera—she thought she was hidden, but the thing buried between the leaves was watching everything. I literally gasped. The way the author structured this was masterful. First we see the nearly-tragic manhole moment (comedy), then the creeping dread of the open door (horror), then Yin Zhao-an swooping in (relief?), then YAO, someone is in the house (pure panic), then the father appears (RELIEF BUT ALSO NO BECAUSE NOW WE KNOW ABOUT THE HACKING), and THEN the camera reveal. That's a rollercoaster in four paragraphs. The narrative arc here is basically: Tang Yu thought she was playing a double life and keeping everyone safe, but the truth is her father already knows more than he lets on. His line "I hope that only the two of us know about this matter" is chilling because it's not a threat—it's something worse. It's a plea. He's scared for her and trying to protect her by keeping it secret. That detail about him returning to the station afterward and promising "I will come back alive" suddenly reframes EVERYTHING. He's not just a dad being weird, he's in actual danger. The plot threads are tightening like a noose and I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
I have to start with this exchange because it is PERFECTION: "Are you alright?" "..." "But...you're shaking." "..." It's none of your business whether I'm trembling or not!! THIS. Yin Zhao-an's dialogue is so character-specific. She speaks in these halting, tentative phrases—"Uh… That…"—and then delivers these devastatingly innocent observations like "you're shaking" as if she hasn't just said the most emotionally perceptive thing possible. Meanwhile Tang Yu's internal voice is ALL caps rage and sarcasm, but her external dialogue is clipped, defensive, almost curt. "Why are you here?" "It's fine. My class is close, so you don't need to send me back." She never says what she means. Even the confession at the end—"...You must be careful." Three words where a paragraph of worry was needed. The narration itself has such a distinctive voice too. Phrases like "her heart thumped," "a chill crawled down her spine," "emotionally overwhelming"—this is thriller language applied to a story about a ten-year-old girl and her weird secret life. And then the father's dialogue is so controlled. He barely speaks and every word weighs something. "I hope that only the two of us know about this matter." "Make sure to come home right after school ends." He's giving her instructions that sound like parental advice but are actually desperate attempts to keep her safe. The narrative voice also does this wonderful thing where it italicizes Tang Yu's internal curses—"Fuck…" "Fuck! This bastard!"—which gives the whole thing this gritty, almost comedic edge that contrasts with the genuine terror underneath. The tonal whiplash between internal screaming and external calm is basically the entire personality of this book and I would read it forever.
... Read More
Okay, I need to talk about what this book seems obsessed with beneath the surface. Food as love language that goes completely unreciprocated. Tang Yu cooks for Yin Zhao-an—freshly caught carp, slow-simmered soup—but can't eat herself. She pours her lunch into a bag for stray dogs instead. The abandoned apartment across the hall with the dusty doorknob, where a previous female tenant lived with someone whose conversations Tang Yu once overheard and blushed at—that empty space feels like a ghost house, like a reminder of something lost or something that couldn't survive. Fish bones, burned fingers, porcelain shards mixed with blood on marble—there's a recurring texture of domestic objects turning into instruments of harm here, even accidental harm. The gaming world where Yin Zhao-an commands respect and power versus the real world where she can't seem to connect with the person right next to her. And then there's the parallel between Tang Yu's radio drama role—an empress figure saying 'May we never meet in the next life' with laughter of liberation—and her actual life where she's trapped in a cycle of neglect she can't escape. The birthday she doesn't expect anyone to remember, except Silent Rain does, except that's a digital friend while the person sharing her apartment barely notices. Is this book about two people who keep missing each other? Or about the space between who we are online and who we are when the screen goes dark? I keep thinking about that last line—'Heh, caught you…'—and wondering if the danger at the river is the point where all these themes finally collapse into a single moment.
... Read More
I need to talk about the sunset scene because it is PERFECTION and I don't care if it's overdramatic, it WORKED. "Yin Zhao-an stood in place as she watched Tang Yu tread home, step after step, all the while the setting sun in the west cast its afterglow on Tang Yu's lonely back and stretched her shadow across the street. Eventually, the street became empty as the solitary world devoured that little figure." SOLI-TAR-Y WORLD. Devoured. This isn't just description, this is TONE. You can feel the weight of it. Tang Yu walking away into that golden light while carrying knowledge about her father's death, while feeling like she's lost something irreparable inside herself compared to Yin Zhao-an's pristine innocence—"She, on the other hand... was riddled with scars and bruises, and she had long since lost the qualifications for innocence." OOF. That line hit me in the chest. Then Yin Zhao-an is left alone in the street shivering, burying her chin in her fur collar, looking left and right, realizing she zoned out standing in the middle of the road. The contrast between Tang Yu's heavy, shadowed exit and Yin Zhao-an's clumsy, vulnerable isolation is cinematic. I swear I could see the film frame. The military compound, the dusk light, the emptying street—it all builds this world that feels real and aching and specific.
... Read More
"...her schoolbag wasn't exactly pink now since shoeprints densely decorated it." I need to sit with this image for a second. The word 'decorated'—used so casually for something so violent. This is the kind of detail that makes you immediately understand the cruelty without needing any exposition dump. And then there's the contrast the author sets up so perfectly. First the classroom: fluorescent lights, jeering voices, a girl on her knees picking up scattered books while bullies stand above her. Then it cuts to Tang Yu's home—dark, empty, a note on the coffee table written in restrained cursive. The house has everything a child could need but nothing a child actually wants: a mother who leaves notes instead of hugs, money carefully exchanged into small bills so she can't be cheated, instant noodles removed from the fridge after Yin Zhao-an's nosebleeds. The home isn't just a setting—it's a character. Tang Yu cooking handmade noodles on a stool because she's too short to reach the stove, tapping away on her computer with half-cold noodles going untouched. That visual of her dark pupils reflecting the blue screen light is something I would absolutely steal for my own writing. The glow of information against the darkness of her apartment mirrors her dual life—this child who seems to be handling everything alone while secretly running information ops for the police. And the ending image of her buying a custard bun and soy milk alone at a stall while Yin Zhao-an watches from behind—that ordinary morning ritual feels so painfully grounded.
... Read More
There are so many layers to unpack here and I barely have words. Let me start with the doors. The chapter opens with an open manhole cover—a hole in the ground that could swallow you—and ends with Tang Yu's house door being pushed open by the wind. Both are thresholds. Both represent vulnerability. The manhole is physical danger; the open door is the invasion of her private, secret self. And then the camera—the hidden eye between the leaves. Tang Yu lives a double life, hacking systems and sending coded messages, but she never imagined she was being watched by her own father. The surveillance camera is symbolic of the central tension of the entire narrative: who is protecting whom, and from what? Tang Yu thinks she's the protector—she's keeping her family safe with her foresight and hacking skills. But the camera reveals that her father has also been watching, also been preparing, also been operating in shadows. Neither of them is truly in control. The curry rice in the microwave is another symbol that got me. After all the paranoia and tension, the house responds with warmth. Something cooking. Something waiting. The domestic becomes the sanctuary. And the dumplings—misshapen, imperfect, but made with intention and a specific ingredient chosen because someone paid attention. The story seems to be asking: in a world where you can't trust what you see (open doors, coded messages, hidden cameras), what remains? The answer, apparently, is bad dumplings and people who bring them to you. The jícama sweetness cutting through the salt of the peanut sauce—maybe that's the point. Life is threaded with danger and secrecy and fear, but the small, specific acts of care are what make it bearable. Or maybe I'm overthinking it. Maybe it's just dumplings.
... Read More
I need to scream about Yin Zhao-an's dialogue because THIS CHARACTER. The voice writing is immaculate. Her lines are so distinctly HER—colloquial, physical, occasionally absurd. 'My bed is big enough for the both of us!' said with the desperate hope of someone who just wants to sleep near their person. Then later, walking backward in front of Tang Yu like an enthusiastic dog: 'Come on, do it for my desk. Remember them, okay? Okay...?' That trailing 'okay...?' with the repeated pleading is SO specific. You can hear her voice. You can SEE her face. And the contrast with Tang Yu's near-silence makes Yin Zhao-an's verbal energy pop even more. Tang Yu barely speaks—'... ' 'What are you doing?' 'Look out!'—and every word carries weight because she rarely wastes them. The narrative voice itself is also doing heavy lifting. It's got this dry, slightly sardonic commentary woven in—like when Tang Yu thinks 'people are much cuter when they are still children' and then immediately corrects herself. Or the aside about Yin Zhao-an's usual behavior versus the 'unruly adult' hint that flashes across her face. The narrator is observant, wry, and intimately attuned to both characters' inner lives without ever becoming purple or pretentious. And the humor! Yin Zhao-an's 'Weren't you hinting at me to console you, Tang-Tang? There, there. With me around, they won't dare to bully you anymore!' while patting Tang Yu's back 'like a mother consoling her child'—I laughed out loud. The author's comic timing is spot-on throughout.
... Read More
The pacing in this batch is actually really sneaky good. It starts with interior monologue—Tang Yu's dread about her father—and you think, okay, this is going to be heavy, we're settling in for a serious chapter. Then BOOM, it cuts to a noisy elementary school classroom with kids pulling braids and chasing each other around. The tonal whiplash is intentional, I think. It mirrors how Tang Yu's mind works: she can't stay in her grief because she's a SIX-YEAR-OLD who also has to deal with RIGHT NOW. And then the Yin Zhao-an entrance is pure comedic timing. The teacher announcing a new student, the formal self-introduction that's somehow both impressive and cringe-worthy for a first grader—"Yin is the yin in Jing Zhaoyin"—and the class is just sitting there like, kid, what are you doing. The humor lands because it's so sudden after all that heaviness. The pencil incident escalates FAST. Smack. Chair scraping. Kids running around screaming "Someone's fighting!" And then the teacher walks in and it all deflates instantly. No punishment, no drama, just "do try to get along" and she leaves. The conflict rises and falls in what, three paragraphs? Then it transitions to the walking-home scene which is slower, quieter, more atmospheric. And then—the next day, the cold, the waiting, Wang Zhen appearing like a dragon mom grabbing her chick by the collar. The chapter ends on a mini cliffhanger with those phone numbers mocking Yin Zhao-an. Each beat serves a purpose. Nothing drags. Irespect it.
... Read More
The sensory writing in this book is no joke. Let me just start with the fish soup scene because this image haunts me now. Tang Yu simmering the carp over a small flame, forgetting about it, coming back to find the soup reduced to 'cloudy white' with a 'rich fishy fragrance' that smells 'a little sweet.' That description does triple duty—it's domestic, it's unsettling, and it's essentially a metaphor for her entire relationship with food and care. She makes it for Yin Zhao-an, not for herself. The whole kitchen sequence with the burning fingertips, the rag, the blood mixing with porcelain shards on the marble floor—this is cinema-level scene crafting. I can SEE it. The market scene too, with the fishmonger's 'smooth and brutal technique' and Tang Yu's eyes twitching but buying the carp anyway because 'An-An always drank it until the last drop.' There's also the gaming world contrast that's doing heavy lifting. Yin Zhao-an's room when she's in-game is all clicking keyboards and shouted commands, isolated by a headset. Tang Yu's room is described more quietly—just a desk under a window with a flashing notification. The physical spaces mirror their emotional states. And that ending by the river—the rustling leaves, the darkness, the sudden 'Heh, caught you…'—the environment shifts from safe domestic space to something shadowy and dangerous almost imperceptibly. The author doesn't announce the tonal shift; they just let the scenery do the work.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the NARRATOR's voice in this? Because it is DELICIOUS. Take the Yin Zhao-an introduction scene. The narrator doesn't just tell us she's showing off—they deliver the line "If Tang Yu were to describe Yin Zhao-an's introduction with modern language, she would probably say that Yin Zhao-an was…a showoff?" That ellipsis, that question mark, that whole tentative judgment—it's hilarious and so specific. It's the narrator WINKING at us. And then later: "If Wang Zhen knew about Yin Zhao-an's thoughts, she would definitely take out their family heirloom—the feather duster, and greet her daughter with it from all directions while saying: Little friend? Tang Yu is six months older than you! You should be calling her 'Big Sister!'" I wheezed. The feather duster as a family HEIRLOOM. The image of Wang Zhen enthusiastically spanking her daughter with a feather duster over a title dispute is one of the funniest things I have ever read in this genre. Yin Zhao-an's dialogue is bubbly and slightly unhinged—"That person is sick in the head, Tang-Tang"—while Tang Yu's dialogue is basically silence and "..." and one-word answers. Zhao Yu speaks like an actual arrogant little rich kid who tries too hard. Each voice is distinct and I never once got confused about who was talking. The narrative tone balances absurdity with genuine pathos and I'm HERE for it.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about the comic book because I genuinely think it's the key to understanding everything that happens in this entire passage. The story within the story is about twin girls — one pure and angelic, the other a murderous devil. But here's the twist that matters: the evil one sacrifices herself to save everyone, and 'nobody bothered to remember her deeds or her existence after her death.' The final scene is a grave with white flowers and daisies stained with dew, and someone placed them there but we don't know who. Tang Yu reads this and immediately starts thinking about who placed those flowers. The text says she hoped her thoughts were correct. This is NOT a casual observation — Tang Yu is projecting her own relationship with Yin Zhao-an onto this comic, and the parallel is devastating. Think about it. In Tang Yu's memory, the old Yin Zhao-an was the 'devil' — aggressive, violent, protective in a rough way. She fought street thugs, she wore her scars like armor, she said 'I'm the only one who can bully her' as if that explained everything. But was that really who Yin Zhao-an was? Or was that just the costume she wore to keep people at a distance? The new Yin Zhao-an — the reincarnated one — is softer, sweeter, openly affectionate. She feeds Tang Yu, she clings to her in sleep, she worries when Tang Yu cries. But Tang Yu doesn't trust this version. She misses the sharp edges because those edges were proof that Yin Zhao-an chose to protect her, even if she refused to admit it. The comic asks a question that the whole novel seems to be circling around: who gets remembered, and who gets erased? The sacrificial devil dies and is forgotten. The pure angel lives and is celebrated. But what if the truth is more complicated? What if the person who sacrifices themselves is the one who loves the most, even if nobody acknowledges it? That grave with the daisies — I have a terrible feeling we're supposed to know who placed them. And I have an even worse feeling about what that means for Tang Yu and Yin Zhao-an.
... Read More
'Cold…' That single word opens the final section and it's doing so much heavy lifting. Let me trace the coldness through this entire passage because it's not accidental—I'm convinced the author is building a symbolic language here. Tang Yu is described as 'cold and lifeless' when Yin Zhao-an touches her hand. She's shivering in that 'cold and damp basement.' Her lips are 'purple and freezing.' But then there's the memory of her mother's hand—'warm and soft'—wiping her face. The contrast between physical coldness and emotional warmth is the central tension of the text. Tang Yu died cold (physically abandoned, medically untreated, emotionally isolated) but she reached for warmth ('Mommy...') in her final moments. Then there's the cake—the warm, tantalizing smell of milk that contrasts with Yin Zhao-an's bloodshot, sleep-deprived state. Food as love, food as absence, food as the promise of celebration that never comes. The birthday cake becomes a symbol of all the moments that should have been shared but weren't. And that 'white glow' at the end—the blindness, the purification, the afterlife? It's the opposite of that dark basement. Light versus darkness, warmth versus cold, presence versus absence. The author is building this entire symbolic system around sensory experience, and I'm convinced the rebirth/reincarnation angle (given the book's title about 'Tokyo Rebirth') means none of this imagery is wasted. Every cold detail was foreshadowing something.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or