Give Me Another Smile (GL) - Reviews

Give Me Another Smile (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because this chapter is playing 4D chess with tension and I am here for it. On the external level, Tang Yu is running TWO separate dangerous missions simultaneously. First: feeding intel about outlaws to her father's computer. If she gets caught, what happens? She's a kid—nobody would believe her, but that doesn't mean nothing would happen to her. The fact that she prepared a denial ('I'll simply refuse to admit it') shows she's thinking three steps ahead but also that she's fully aware of how exposed she is. Second: surviving school bullies who put ACTUAL EARTHWORMS in her desk drawer. This isn't playground teasing—this is psychological warfare with a side of biological horror. And the worst part? The text specifically says Tang Yu 'wasn't good at memorizing faces'—so she can't even properly identify who's targeting her. That's isolating. That's dangerous. But the INTERNAL stakes are what really get me. Every time Yin Zhao-an gets closer—to the point of calling Tang Yu her 'big sister' in front of authority figures, of physically shielding her, of apparently also being reincarnated—Tang Yu pulls away. The stakes here aren't about life and death, they're about TRUST. Tang Yu has lived a whole life already, carry secrets that could destroy her, and Yin Zhao-an is becoming someone she can't afford to lose—or someone she's terrified of losing because understanding means vulnerability. And that ending with the sparking electricity? Physical danger entering the frame RIGHT WHEN the emotional tension peaks. Masterclass stuff.
... Read More
CAN WE TALK ABOUT THE RESTROOM SCENE THOUGH. I have never related to this much in my life. Tang Yu finds Yin Zhao-an sitting on a bench after Yin Zhao-an basically forces herself to keep up with Tang Yu despite being clearly hurt. And then Tang Yu — this girl who's been walking away, who's been distant, who literally says "Can't we just be strangers?!" internally — she doesn't walk away. She goes to the restroom with Yin Zhao-an and applies ointment to her bruises. The detail about Tang Yu seeing "patches of blue and purple covering Yin Zhao-an's fair skin" and then looking at someone who was feeling guilty? That's such a loaded moment. Tang Yu suspects someone hurt Yin Zhao-an, and the fact that she still helps her despite all her confusion and frustration says SO much about her character. And Yin Zhao-an! She's blushing and stammering "T-Tang Tang, don't you have to go to class?" while clearly embarrassed but also probably the most content she's been all chapter. The physical proximity, the intimacy of touching someone's wounds, the quiet competence of Tang Yu just handling it without making a big deal out of it — this is peak character writing. Their whole dynamic is this push-and-pull where Tang Yu keeps trying to create distance but can't actually stay away, and Yin Zhao-an keeps clinging on even when it clearly hurts her. The koala imagery earlier in the text perfectly captures this.
... Read More
I'm not even going to pretend this chapter doesn't have some structural issues because honestly the pacing goes from zero to a hundred and then back down to nothing in the span of three scenes. Let's start with what works. The chapter opens with a warm, funny beat — Yin Changcheng setting up the bedding, thedad dad energy, the whole domestic setup. Then it pivots into the comic book scene, which is slower and more atmospheric. The author takes time here, letting us sit with Tang Yu's internal realization that this comic is somehow connected to something deeper. The transition from laughter to silence when the lights come on is genuinely well-paced — it's like the author hit the brakes on the comedy and forced everyone, including the reader, to snap out of it. But then we hit the dinner scene and the structure gets messy. The comedy escalates quickly with the wife joke, Yin Changcheng fleeing, the food overload, Tang Yu choking and crying — it's a lot happening in rapid succession and I'm not sure the author lets any of it breathe. Tang Yu's breakdown happens SO fast after the comedic peak that it feels almost jarring in a way that might be intentional or might just be rough writing. After the bathroom escape, the chapter resets into something much calmer — showers, bed, quiet. The pacing here is almost too slow after the emotional whiplash of the dinner scene. We go from Tang Yu crying uncontrollably to both girls falling asleep in complete silence, and while that contrast might be meaningful, I found myself wondering if the author should have given us even a moment of aftermath between those two beats. The chapter ends on an ambiguous note with Tang Yu muttering something incomprehensible in her sleep, which is a classic hook. But I'm left wondering: is the structure serving the emotional arc, or is the emotional arc forcing the structure to bend in ways that don't quite fit?
... Read More
"The dumplings were delicious." Four words. That's it. That's the entire emotional climax of the chapter and I am on the floor. Let me explain why this destroyed me. Everything that happened before—the fear of the intruder, the confrontation with her father, the realization that she's been watched, the whispered promise that he'll come back alive—Tang Yu is carrying all of that weight. She's alone in this massive secret, her dad is in danger, and she's ten years old. And then the next morning, Yin Zhao-an drags her away from a breakfast stall and produces INSULATED CONTAINER dumplings that she MADE HERSELF. With jícama. Because she remembered. Tang Yu's stomach growls and her ears turn red and she says "Mhm, it's very sweet" and I literally cannot function. The tenderness in that moment is unbearable. It's not dramatic. No one is confessing feelings or anything. She just... made breakfast for her friend. But after everything—the near-death at the manhole, the terror of the open door, the father-daughter confrontation, the secret surveillance—that stupid little insulated container with misshapen dumplings is the most romantic thing in the entire book. And then Yin Zhao-an biting the last dumpling from Tang Yu's chopsticks like it's nothing, while Tang Yu sits there flustered and blushing. Meanwhile Tang Yu just got her dad to promise he'd come back alive and now she's worrying about whether Yin Zhao-an noticed her ears turning red. The emotional whiplash of this chapter is unreal. One moment you're heartbroken, the next you're melting. I love this story so much it hurts.
... Read More
This boy brought her CANDIES. CANDIES, Tang Yu. He dressed up in a suit, walked all the way to her desk, and offered her sweets like a total romantic novice and she just... took them and put them in her drawer like a receipt. "..." is all she says. Three dots. That's the entire response. And Zhao Yu, bless his heart, EXPECTS this. He "rubbed his nose awkwardly when he received the indifferent response he had expected." He KNEW. He knew she'd be cold and he did it anyway. That's either the sweetest thing I've ever read or the most pathetic, I can't decide. Then the pencil incident happens and I literally screamed. Zhao Yu just... snatches her pencil as a joke. And Yin Zhao-an absolutely LOSES IT. Not a little annoyed, not a verbal warning—she SMACKS his desk hard enough to scrape her chair across the floor and GLARES at him like she wants him dead. And the best part? Tang Yu pulls Yin Zhao-an back because she's worried about PARENTAL INVOLVEMENT. Meanwhile Yin Zhao-an is over here thinking "Oh no, did I scare Tang-Tang?" The miscommunication is EVERYTHING. And then the ending? Yin Zhao-an waiting outside in the COLD for Tang Yu who never shows, and Wang Zhen grabbing her by the collar like a chicken. "What are you idling here for?" Mom, your daughter is standing in freezing weather at six in the morning because someone didn't come to walk to school with her. She's not idling. She's hurting. And those numbers on the phone screen mocking her? I need a moment.
... Read More
Okay so this first batch of chapters is doing something really interesting with pacing. On the surface it looks like a slice-of-life setup—roommates, gaming, voice acting—but underneath there's a lot of tension being built through what isn't said. The plot threads are braiding together nicely. You've got Yin Zhao-an's guild leadership and dungeon runs on one side, Tang Yu's voice acting work on the other, and then the real-world complications—the birthday party setup with Silent Rain, Tang Yu's deteriorating health, that ending at the riverside that definitely didn't feel like a casual scene. The author drops these small bombs regularly: Tang Yu throwing food away without eating, the burned fingertips ignored, the silence after Yin Zhao-an yells 'Get out!' Each one lands because the reader knows something's wrong even when the characters aren't fully acknowledging it yet. And that ending—'Heh, caught you…'—that's a proper cliffhanger. But what I found most compelling is how the domestic scenes counterweight the gaming world. The game world feels high-energy and loud, while Tang Yu's home life feels hollowed out. That contrast IS the plot, honestly. It's not just 'weird roommate drama'—it's two people orbiting each other, one drowning in noise and the other drowning in silence, and the question the whole thing is building toward is what happens when those two currents collide.
... Read More
Let's talk stakes because this chapter quietly raised the temperature from 'childhood drama' to 'existential threat' and I was NOT ready. On the surface level, the stakes are clear: Tang Yu is being bullied at school, she's alone at home, and her best friend is trying to get close while Tang Yu keeps pushing her away. Simple, right? Wrong. Because then you get the father reveal and suddenly EVERYTHING changes. The parents aren't just busy with work—they're involved in something dangerous. Tang Yu knows about a firearms smuggling gang. She has INSIDER INFORMATION. She's feeding intelligence to the police while dealing with homework and bullies and the ghost of her dead father. The stakes just went from 'will she survive middle school' to 'will she survive THE ADULT WORLD.' And here's what makes it terrifying: she KNOWS. 'Even now, Tang Yu still couldn't bring herself to properly remember how she got by that day.' She's aware of the danger. She's made a choice to stay involved. And she's doing it alone because she can't involve Yin Zhao-an—probably because she's already lost her father and refuses to lose anyone else. Meanwhile Yin Zhao-an is walking beside her, worrying about depression and isolation, having no idea that the girl she's protecting is operating in a completely different category of danger. That dramatic irony is exquisite and I'm vibrating. The smugglers planted a time bomb at the ambush site. Tang Chengyang was stationed there. Tang Yu watched her father die. And now she's hacking into police systems at night while eating cold noodles and pretending nothing is wrong. That is not a protagonist I would want to cross.
... Read More
There's something really interesting happening beneath the surface of this chapter that I keep coming back to. Tang Yu has clearly lived this before—or at least witnessed this moment before—and her entire internal monologue revolves around how things are supposed to be DIFFERENT now. 'Weren't things supposed to change already? Wasn't there supposed to be a new plan?' The tragedy of her situation is that she's not sure the changes are sticking. The scene where she's relieved the elevator goes to the seventh floor instead of the first—that's not just plot convenience, it's the whole thematic point of the rebirth premise crystallized in one moment. The frost-covered weeds and bitter wind at the chapter's opening also feel loaded. Winter imagery, death imagery, the coldness of a suburban night where people are hunting other people. And then later, the red light above the operating room—the universal symbol of life hanging in the balance. The bandage-wrapped father lying unconscious behind glass, Yu Wanrou's fingers leaving marks on the window as they slide down—it's all imagery about how fragile life is and how close the edge is. But underneath all that, there's also this theme of chosen family. Tang Yu ends up staying with the Yin family, with Yin Changcheng offering to take her in, Yin Zhao-an clinging to her. The biological family is in crisis, so the found family steps in. That's the quiet emotional architecture holding all of this together.
... Read More
I need to talk about this scene where Tang Yu breaks down at the dinner table because honestly it wrecked me and I've been thinking about it ever since. On the surface, Yin Zhao-an is being this sweet, clingy, overfeeding-type girlfriend energy and everyone else is just laughing along. But Tang Yu? Tang Yu is having a full emotional crisis. She looks at this girl who used to be all sharp edges and aggression — the one who fought street thugs, who walked in front like a leader, who was too picky to eat anything not freshly made — and now this girl is gently putting prawns in her bowl and saying 'it's okay, I'll eat your leftovers.' The text literally says Tang Yu's bowl was snatched away and she watched Yin Zhao-an scarf down her leftovers with a smile. And Tang Yu's response is to frown and say 'stop eating it.' Not because she's mad — because she's GRIEVING. The Yin Zhao-an in her memories would NEVER have done that. This new version is softer, warmer, more vulnerable, and Tang Yu doesn't know how to process that. Then she bolts to the bathroom and cries. And Yin Zhao-an follows her, wiping her wet hands on her shirt, hugging her with one arm, handing her tissues — completely lost but trying so hard. You can feel Tang Yu's guilt in that moment. She wants to explain, but she can't. How do you tell someone they're different now and you miss the old version without sounding ungrateful? The ending of this passage is devastating in the quietest way. Yin Zhao-an falls asleep clinging to Tang Yu's arm, and Tang Yu stays awake considering whether she could actually fight her if she wanted to. She can't. The gap is too big. So she just... lets herself fall asleep in the embrace. That's not surrender, that's acceptance. She's choosing to trust this new person even though she doesn't fully understand her yet.
... Read More
Let me just say this: the stakes in this chapter went from 'dad might die' to 'dad survived but the threat is STILL OUT THERE' and that escalation is ruthless. The ambush itself is high-stakes by nature—armed criminals, a coordinated police operation, people could die. But what really spikes the tension is the captain's confession on the balcony. They COULD have taken everyone down in one move. They didn't because someone was hiding in a criminal's car. A COMRADE got shot because the rookie dropped his guard after the target supposedly surrendered. And the target JUMPED OFF A CLIFF. NOT KILLED. NOT CAPTURED. Just gone. The author makes this hurt more by having the soldier apologize to Yu Wanrou with actual tears on his painted face. These people care about each other, and that makes the violence feel personal rather than abstract. Tang Yu overhears all of this while hiding in a corner pretending to wash her hands—it's a brilliant touch because she's both a child and someone who knows exactly how dangerous this situation is. The conflict isn't resolved; it's suspended. And that suspension is where the real tension lives. Every chapter after this, I'm going to be watching for that guy. Who was he? Why was he in the car? What does he want? The stakes just shifted from survival to revenge, and I am HERE FOR IT.
... Read More
Okay I need to just sit with this one moment for a sec. When Yin Zhao-an is wiping Tang Yu's tears and just... sighs and says 'Why won't you ever tell me anything?' That hit me so hard. Like, here's this character who clearly cares, who ran all the way across the school the second she heard what happened, who called Tang Yu her 'big sister' in front of the teacher like it was the most natural thing in the world—and Tang Yu is over there having a full existential crisis because she's convinced Yin Zhao-an might ALSO be reincarnated. The layering here is insane. Tang Yu looks into Yin Zhao-an's eyes and sees something 'pristine'—an adult's eyes would be different, right?—and instead of feeling relieved, she feels... disappointed? That's such a human, complicated reaction. She WANTS Yin Zhao-an to understand, she WANTS that connection, but part of her is terrified of what it means if the answer is yes. And then the hug. The 'amateurish' embrace, the stiff arms, the 'there there, with me around they won't dare bully you anymore'—it's so earnest and clumsy and perfect. Yin Zhao-an has no idea what she's doing but she's trying so hard. Meanwhile Tang Yu is over here mentally spiraling about parallel existences and reincarnation coincidences and I just want to shake her and say 'just let someone hold you!' Also can we talk about the 'big sister' moment? Yin Zhao-an repeating 'she is my big sister' like she's planting a flag. That's not just defending Tang Yu from the teacher—that's claiming her. In front of everyone. I got actual chills.
... Read More
There's this one line that I cannot stop thinking about, and it's basically the thesis of everything happening in these chapters: "Those eyes of Yin Zhao-an's were too pristine, never polluted by the world's taint. She, on the other hand... was riddled with scars and bruises, and she had long since lost the qualifications for innocence." Innocence as qualification. Like it's something you earn the right to possess, and Tang Yu feels she's been DE-qualified. But here's what's haunting me: Tang Yu HAS her memories. She KNOWS what's coming. In a strange way, her knowledge IS her burden and her power. She's not actually powerless—she's trying to prevent her father's death, she's navigating a world she's lived before. But emotionally? She feels disqualified from the simple, warm friendship that Yin Zhao-an is offering so freely. The contrast between the sunset consuming Tang Yu's lonely figure and Yin Zhao-an shivering alone in the street later—that's not just imagery, it's thematic symmetry. Both girls are isolated in different ways. Tang Yu by knowledge and grief, Yin Zhao-an by longing and rejection. And yet Yin Zhao-an is the one waiting in the cold the next morning, proving that innocence doesn't mean happiness. It just means a different kind of wound. What is this story actually saying about childhood, memory, and the things we carry that no one else can see? I need to keep reading to find out.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or