Give Me Another Smile (GL) - Reviews

Give Me Another Smile (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The pacing in this section is absolutely filthy in the best way. The author opens with what should be a comedic beat—a girl nearly falling into a manhole, getting scolded, walking away pouting—and you're literally thinking "okay, light slice-of-life chapter, cute friendship moment" and then BOOM, open door, no light, someone is in the house. The shift from comedy to dread happens in two sentences. Tang Yu "leaned against the courtyard wall and crouched down" and suddenly you're sitting with her in that frozen moment of realization that your safe space has been violated. Then Yin Zhao-an appears with her soft voice and for a second you think it's another comedic interlude, but no, the tension doesn't release, it just morphs. Yin Zhao-an runs inside and gets pulled—cut to three people in silence drinking water. The silence is so deliberately paced, you can feel the wordlessness pressing down on the page. And then the laptop reveal. The father doesn't yell. He doesn't even raise his voice. He just shows her the file and watches her cry and she says "I only wanted to buy it to play games with" and he... softens. His hand stiffens but his heart becomes "a pile of mush." That's the kind of pacing choice that makes you sit with a scene longer than you expected because the emotional truth is too heavy to rush past. Then the surveillance camera discovery—Tang Yu thinks she's safe to move, jumps off the sofa, and the door clicks behind her. Immediate jolt. The chapter ends not with a cliffhanger but with this strange, tender domesticity of dumplings and jícama and blushing. The author knows exactly when to punch you and when to stroke your hair. Both are more devastating than either alone.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this upfront because I don't want to bury the lede: the fact that Tang Yu's father is going to be killed on duty in exactly TWO YEARS is the single most important thing in this entire chapter, and I am NOT okay with how casually it's dropped. Like, she's sitting in math class, a kid is pulling someone's braid, and we're just supposed to remember that she's carrying around this ticking time bomb in her chest? That's not foreshadowing, that's psychological torture. "There were still two more years until her father would get killed while on duty." Two sentences. Two plain, unadorned sentences. No drama, no music swelling, just... dead dad in 730 days. And then she immediately pivots to school like nothing happened. The fact that she treats this apocalyptic knowledge as just another item on her todo list—before school, before dealing with Yin Zhao-an, before literally anything—is what makes it so devastating. She's a child with adult grief compressed inside her. Also can we talk about the timeline wrinkle? Yin Zhao-an was supposed to be in the CLASS NEXT DOOR in Tang Yu's memory, but now she's IN HER CLASS. That's not a detail to gloss over. Something shifted. The plot is already warping around Tang Yu's knowledge of the future, and this is just the beginning of that ripple. I have SO many questions and zero patience for slow reveals.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in pacing. It starts almost casually—bullying incident, rescue, walks home—but somewhere around the middle it just quietly detonates and you realize the entire book has been building toward this emotional collapse. The author does something really clever with the structural pivot. You're settling into this school narrative, watching Tang Yu navigate childhood cruelty with her usual quiet endurance, and then BAM—we cut to her home, her parents' absence, the note, the noodles—and suddenly you're realizing this isn't a coming-of-age story, it's a survival story. The transition from the school scene to the evening scene is seamless but devastating. One moment she's being rescued from bullies, the next she's alone in a dark house eating cold noodles while typing codes into a computer. The mundane (cooking noodles) right next to the extraordinary (hacking for the police) creates this rhythm that's almost suffocating in its normalcy. And then the bomb drop about her father—that paragraph where it says 'Even now, Tang Yu still couldn't bring herself to properly remember how she got by that day'—it comes completely out of nowhere, right when you thought the emotional intensity had peaked. The author trusts the reader enough to not explain anything. You just get the white cloth, the broken corpse, the tear on the pink pillow, and then—cut to morning. Next day. 'Morning, Yin Zhao-an. Waiting for your wife again?' That nonchance is what kills me. Life goes on. The trauma doesn't stop it. That's real.
... Read More
I need to talk about Yu Wanrou for a second because THIS woman. She shows up looking absolutely wrecked—hair in a mess, dark circles, bloodshot eyes from staying up all night—and the moment she sees Tang Yu walking out of the school building, her legs literally go weak. Not dramatic crying, just a physical collapse of someone holding themselves together by a thread. And then when the doctor comes out and says the patient is stable? Yu Wanrou doesn't celebrate. She steps back, leans against the wall, and crouches down repeating 'Everything's alright' like she's trying to convince herself. That's not happiness—that's relief so deep it short-circuits your ability to feel anything else. Then there's Yin Zhao-an sprinting over and hugging Tang Yu's waist while sobbing, convinced she'd been abandoned. The contrast between Yu Wanrou's devastating quiet grief and Yin Zhao-an's loud desperate clinginess is chef's kiss. And Tang Yu! She's internalizing all of this, reliving 'the scene from her previous life,' but this time it's different. This time her dad is alive. She's crying tears of joy in an elevator heading to the seventh floor instead of the morgue. The emotional writing in this book is genuinely exceptional. It doesn't melodramatize—it lets silence do the heavy lifting.
... Read More
Okay so I gotta talk about this opening nightmare sequence because it's genuinely one of the best hooks I've read in a while. Yin Zhao-an wakes up screaming from this dream where she hears this voice saying "save me" and "I was wrong" over and over again. Like, this isn't just a bad dream, right? This is clearly some kind of trauma or premonition that's driving everything that follows. What's interesting is how the plot uses this nightmare as the catalyst for literally everything else. After this, she immediately asks her dad to teach her martial arts because "I have someone I want to protect." The cause-and-effect is clean and satisfying. The story doesn't waste time explaining why she wants to learn to fight — the dream does the heavy lifting. Then there's the two-year time skip that happens right when you're starting to get comfortable with their daily routine. We see Tang Yu becoming more isolated, then the bullying starts, and the chapter ends on this cliffhanger with oil pastels and words like "ugly" and "mute" on her desk. The author really knows how to build tension by knowing when to cut away. My only minor complaint is that some transitions feel a bit jumpy, but honestly, the emotional through-line is so strong that I didn't even care. The plot serves the characters, not the other way around.
... Read More
Okay let me just say this chapter structure is absolute CHAOS and I love it. We open with this deceptively slice-of-life domestic scene—Yin Zhao-an at home, Zhao Yu fixing her PC, the whole cozy night routine—and then BAM, the tone completely drops. Tang Yu doesn't come home, sends that devastating message, and suddenly we're in full thriller territory. The pacing is genius here because the author lulls you into thinking this is just another domestic drama about two girls navigating life together, and then the rug gets pulled so hard. The part that really got me was the parallel editing. While Yin Zhao-an is gaming, completely oblivious, the text cuts to Tang Yu in that cold basement—doomed, dying, whispering 'An-An will realize I'm missing, right?' And then Yin Zhao-an is over here ignoring calls like 'Who cares about you?!' The dramatic irony was absolutely killing me. Every time the phone buzzed and she silenced it, I was screaming at the pages. Then the discovery scene—Tang Yu's body in that abandoned factory, the forensic details, her father's rage—all of it lands with brutal efficiency. And the final twist about the stomach cancer? I literally gasped. All this time the murder was the surface-level mystery, but the deeper tragedy was that she was already dying and nobody knew. The author layered two tragedies on top of each other and then added the supernatural tease at the end with the voice calling her 'Mommy.' What is happening?? I need the next chapter immediately.
... Read More
Okay so the chapter structure here is actually really smart when I think about it. You've got three threads running parallel—Yin Zhao-an's little moment of observing someone, the coordinated ambush operation with Alpha/Charlie comms chatter, and then Tang Yu at school getting called out. The author threads them together by having Tang Yu's father be the one leading the operation, and the reveal that he took a bullet for his own team? That's a legit gut punch because we'd already established through Tang Yu's panic and the 'morgue vs operating room' tension that something was wrong. The way the ambush unfolds—the fake venue clearing first, then the real team moving in, the gunfight erupting—feels tactical and grounded rather than chaotic for chaos's sake. What I love most is the detail about the traitor who fled, said he'd surrender, then shot the newcomer. That's not just action flavor; it's a plot thread that's clearly going to come back. The killer jumped off a cliff and hasn't been found. I'm already speculating this guy is going to resurface, and honestly that keeps me hooked. The chapter ends with Tang Yu being shuttled to the Yin family home, which shifts the story from crisis mode into a new living situation—classic transitional chapter that sets up the next arc without feeling rushed or padded.
... Read More
This story is wrestling with this really interesting idea about protection — both as something you seek and something you can't escape. Yin Zhao-an wants to protect Tang Yu. That's her entire motivation for learning martial arts, for pushing through pain, for being the one who shows up at the crossroads every morning. But the symbolism keeps flipping this idea on its head. Tang Yu is the one applying ointment. Tang Yu is the one who notices the bruises first. Tang Yu is the one who seems to carry this guilt that Yin Zhao-an can sense but never fully understand. The bruises themselves are such a loaded symbol. They represent violence — either from training or from something else — and they represent vulnerability. Yin Zhao-an is covered in them but keeps showing up anyway. And Tang Yu's reaction to seeing them is this mix of panic, guilt, and tenderness that suggests she knows more than she's letting on. Then there's the recurring water imagery — the cold medicine, the warm water, the ointment that's applied cold, the sink where Tang Yu washes her hands afterward. Water as cleansing but also as something that reveals. When Tang Yu looks at her own hand after applying the ointment and purses her lips, she's literally processing what just happened. The nightmare's voice saying "save me" and "I was wrong" — is that directed at Yin Zhao-an? At Tang Yu? At both? The symbolism here is deliberately ambiguous, which makes the whole thing feel richer.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this dinner scene is absolutely hilarious and I'm not even going to try to be subtle about it. Yin Changcheng comes home with dinner, sets up this wholesome family moment, and his daughter looks him dead in the eye and says she'll marry Tang Yu so she can call her wife. The man just FLEES to his study. Bro really thought he could handle this conversation and immediately recognized he couldn't. But here's the thing that actually hits different — under all the comedy, the plot is doing something really clever. Tang Yu is clearly experiencing some kind of emotional breakdown at the dinner table, and instead of addressing it head-on, the author wraps it in humor. Tang Yu chokes on her food, starts crying for no apparent reason to anyone watching, and then bolts to the bathroom. Yin Zhao-an follows her, visibly confused and worried, and the reader is left sitting there going WHAT JUST HAPPENED. I think the author is setting up a really interesting tension between the two timelines — the Yin Zhao-an of the past versus the Yin Zhao-an of the present. Tang Yu is the only one who notices the differences because SHE REMEMBERS. That's a plot device that gives her exclusive access to the emotional truth of the story, and it makes every interaction between them layered with this unspoken knowledge. When Yin Zhao-an feeds her and says 'you can give the extras to me if you can't finish,' Tang Yu's reaction isn't just confusion — it's grief. She's mourning the version of Yin Zhao-an she used to know. And then there's the comic book subplot that runs parallel to all of this. The story within the story about twin girls where one sacrifices herself and nobody remembers her. I have a feeling we're supposed to draw some kind of parallel there, and I'm not wrong to think that.
... Read More
'I kept the cake in the fridge. Once you wake up, I'll celebrate your birthday with you, okay?' I am not okay. I am not okay at all. This novel has absolutely destroyed me and I have never been more grateful for it. The entire emotional arc between Yin Zhao-an and Tang Yu is built on this beautiful, aching foundation of unspoken devotion. Yin Zhao-an has been protective of Tang Yu since they were kids—remember, she took punches for her, she promised her father she'd keep her safe—and yet the most heartbreaking thing is how blind she was. Not blind to Tang Yu's feelings necessarily, but blind to Tang Yu's suffering. She was so focused on being the protector that she never noticed her friend was dying inside AND outside. The dinner scene where she sits alone with the cake is one of the most devastating moments I've read. She ordered it for Tang Yu's birthday, waiting, eating nothing herself, and when the delivery guy shows up with that cake in the pouring rain—it feels like the universe's cruelest joke. The cake represents everything she wanted to give her: celebration, love, presence. And Tang Yu was gone. And then her father slaps her. 'Is this how you take care of Little Yu?' That line just... it destroys her. She falls apart at the corpse, calling it a joke, and the slap isn't just physical—it's the weight of every unkept promise, every missed call, every moment she chose a game over her friend. The guilt is going to eat her alive, and honestly? That's what makes this relationship feel so painfully real. It's not perfect love—it's flawed, distracted, human love that wasn't enough in time.
... Read More
The line "Can't we just be strangers?!" literally made me gasp out loud. Not because it's spoken out loud — it's Tang Yu's internal monologue — but because it captures SO perfectly what this character is going through. Tang Yu's voice is this great mix of internal drama and external stoicism. She's thinking all these intense thoughts but her external dialogue is barely above a whisper. When she tells Yin Zhao-an to "hurry up" at the restroom, she's clearly flustered but trying to maintain some kind of composure. And Yin Zhao-an's responses are adorable in their simplicity — "Ah, I'm coming" with all the warmth of a little dog who just got noticed. The parent dialogue is also surprisingly good. Yin Changcheng's scene where he caves to his daughter's request is written with such natural comedic timing. The negotiation where Yin Zhao-an promises to wake up early and do five-kilometer runs and keep it secret — it reads exactly like how a determined kid would actually talk to their parent. And then his condition that she blame him if mom finds out? Chef's kiss. The dialogue carries the emotional weight without ever feeling overwritten. Some authors would have Tang Yu give a big speech about why she's confused, but instead she just applies ointment faster and leaves. That silence says more than any monologue could.
... Read More
What's striking about the dialogue in this book is how much it communicates through what's withheld. Yin Zhao-an's voice is all sharp edges and impatience—'Screw him!', 'Get out!', 'I told you to get out!'—but underneath that there's this desperate, flustered energy. When she calls Tang Yu and her palms are sweaty? That's not in the dialogue but it changes everything about how you read the preceding anger. She's not actually mad, she's terrified. And Tang Yu—God, Tang Yu's dialogue is barely there. 'None of your business.' 'I didn't mean to…' 'An-An…' Each line is fragmented, hesitant, like she's physically struggling to form words. The only time her voice really opens up is in the radio drama script she's recording, and even then it's a character voice, not hers. The contrast between Yin Zhao-an's loud gaming chat ('Healers, guard the circle! I'll draw aggro!') and Tang Yu's near-silent existence in the same apartment is the whole communication dynamic of this book distilled into one reading experience. The Steam/online interactions are also doing interesting work. Silent Rain's bubbly 'Well, this little one shall take her leave now, Lord!' versus Tang Yu's exhausted 'Thank you' tells you everything about their mismatched energy levels. Yin Zhao-an's line 'Shouldn't you be asking if I have a boyfriend?' when someone assumes she's a guy—it's played for a quick laugh but it also reveals how she constructs herself in digital spaces versus real ones.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or