Give Me Another Smile (GL) - Reviews

Give Me Another Smile (GL)
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There are these moments in the text where the author just paints a scene so vividly that I had to physically stop reading and stare at my phone like the words did something to me. The first one is when the sunset hits Tang Yu. The text describes it as casting a warm yellow glow, dyeing her eyes amber, making her gentle appearance look even gentler. And Yin Zhao-an is just... frozen. She slows her breathing to admire her like a work of art. Her eyes are described as 'a vast river of stars that contained many secrets.' That image is gorgeous and slightly terrifying because we know Yin Zhao-an wants to explore those secrets but doesn't know where to begin. The lighting, the silence, the proximity — it's cinematic. Then there's the bathroom scene. Tang Yu emerges with pink cheeks and a lazy look in her eyes, steam following her like a halo. She hesitates before sitting on the edge of the bed, waiting until her body cools down, then crawling into sheets that smell like lavender. Lavender is such a specific choice — it's calming, domestic, intimate. These are fresh sheets in someone else's room that she's making feel like home just by existing in them. The nighttime sequence is where the atmosphere really shifts. Yin Zhao-an drying her hair by the staircase, water dripping from her short hair onto the towel around her neck. Her father confronting her about her attitude, their banter cracking like lightning in a living room that feels lived-in and real. Then Yin Zhao-an goes back upstairs, showers again because she's sweaty from fighting her own dad, and climbs into bed where Tang Yu is already sleeping. The final image of the two of them in darkness, breathing in rhythm, is so quietly powerful. No dialogue, no narration beyond the sound of breathing. It's domestic intimacy at its most raw — two people sharing a bed, one clinging to the other like an anchor, and the only sound in the room is the evidence that they're both alive and both present.
... Read More
I need to process what just happened because the stakes escalation in these chapters is NO JOKE. Let's start with Yin Zhao-an's internal conflict — she's having nightmares about someone needing help, and she can't shake the feeling that she failed someone. That's heavy stuff for a kid. Then there's the physical conflict of her pushing her body through martial arts training, getting bruised, hiding injuries from her mom, trying to keep up with Tang Yu while clearly in pain. But the real stakes are in the Tang Yu situation. The two-year time skip goes from daily companionship to Tang Yu being isolated and bullied. The transition isn't shown — we just see the aftermath with the oil pastels and the words on the desk. And this is where the author earns the emotional impact. We know these two were close, we saw the progression, and now Tang Yu is alone and this feels like a direct consequence of whatever drove them apart. The question hanging over everything is: what happened in those two years? The author dangles this information without giving it away, which keeps you turning pages. Yin Zhao-an keeps showing up, keeps training, keeps getting hurt — but the stakes feel higher now because we're worried about Tang Yu specifically, not just the pair in general. The bullying scene at the end raises the external stakes dramatically, and combined with Tang Yu's internal isolation, it sets up what feels like a major confrontation coming. I am NOT ready for what happens next.
... Read More
I'll be honest—I was worried this was getting long and the pacing might be sagging after 54 chapters, but this batch completely shut me up. The author does something really effective here: they open with a quiet character beat (Yin Zhao-an giggling at someone), then immediately pivot to a high-tension military operation, then drop us into a classroom where nothing seems wrong, then YANK the rug out by having Tang Yu summoned to the principal's office equivalent. That whiplash is intentional and it works. The ambush sequence itself is tight—no bloated descriptions, just comms updates, movement orders, and then BANG gunshots. Then the hospital waiting scene slows everything down deliberately, which is the correct call because you NEED the breath after the explosion. The pacing of information is also clever: we learn about the father being shot in layers. First we see the armed men in the car. Then the elevator going to the seventh floor instead of the first. THEN the doctor's announcement. THEN the captain's explanation on the balcony. Each reveal comes at a moment when the emotional impact is highest, not when it's most convenient. The chapter ends with Yin Zhao-an practically vibrating with excitement dragging Tang Yu to her house, which is a perfect tonal shift—from trauma to something almost comedic. That's how you keep readers turning pages.
... Read More
I need to talk about Yin Zhao-an for a minute because THIS GIRL. She is simultaneously the most annoying and the most endearing person in this entire story. Let's start with the manhole incident—Tang Yu literally saves her from certain death, gets mad, walks away, and Yin Zhao-an has NO IDEA WHAT SHE DID WRONG. She just trails behind with a tearful look. Not even crying! Just... tearfully standing there confused. This girl is a disaster but oh my god, the way she showed up at Tang Yu's house that night. She followed her home for TWO YEARS. TWO. YEARS. Of secretly walking her to her door. And when she finally confesses? Her excuse is "you haven't promised me you'll remember those people's names so I came to remind you." THAT IS THE WORST LIE EVER and Tang Yu clearly knows it but doesn't call her out on it because honestly? Same. Also the scene where Yin Zhao-an runs INTO the potentially dangerous house without thinking and gets PULLED inside? That's her being reckless to the point of self-destruction for Tang Yu. And later, the dumpling scene—making her own dumplings (which look like they went through a war), adding jícama because she KNOWS Tang Yu likes sweet, blocking other people's view of Tang Yu like a proud dragon with its treasure. The boys whistle and Yin Zhao-an just... eats the remaining dumplings while sitting next to Tang Yu like she owns the place. These two have such a dynamic. Tang Yu is all guarded and sharp and traumatized, and Yin Zhao-an is this warm, impulsive, slightly dense force of nature who somehow keeps finding her way back. I swear if Yin Zhao-an ever actually got seriously hurt I would lose it.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—I did not expect to be THIS emotionally wrecked by a school bullying scene, but here we are. Tang Yu and Yin Zhao-an's dynamic is honestly one of the most beautifully written relationships I've read in a long time. It's not just 'girl protects girl,' there's layers upon layers of guilt, history, and this ache that runs through every single interaction between them. The moment that absolutely gutted me was when Yin Zhao-an finds out about the bullying. She's furious—not at Tang Yu, but FOR her. And Tang Yu's internal response? 'What other reason could there be? Isn't it because I don't want to get involved with you?' That line hit me like a truck. She's carrying this entire weight from her previous life, this fear that getting close to Yin Zhao-an will only lead to loss, and yet she still pushes her away even as Yin Zhao-an is literally picking up her dirty books by hand. And then the walking-home sequence—chef's kiss. Tang Yu is so afraid of Yin Zhao-an's silent anger that she literally tries to sneak away, but Yin Zhao-an just takes her bag and walks behind her instead. That small gesture says EVERYTHING. She's not pushing, not demanding, just... there. Present. Then she sees Tang Yu buying breakfast alone and immediately assumes she hasn't eaten. Meanwhile Yin Zhao-an is also thinking about the suicidal student from the news and connecting it to Tang Yu's isolation. She's been carrying this worry silently for years too. The symmetry is devastating.
... Read More
The way this chapter bounces around is genius. You start with something SO mundane—two girls eating breakfast at a roadside stall, Yin Zhao-an judging street food for health reasons—and within three paragraphs you've pivoted HARD into 'Tang Yu is secretly hacking into her father's computer using Morse code and firewall techniques she learned in a past life.' Like. What. The tonal whiplash is incredible and it works. The author just... drops this bomb and moves on. No fanfare, no dramatic pause. Tang Yu saved up her allowance, bought a second-hand laptop, encrypted a message, and now it's just... done. Filed away like a grocery list. That casualness makes it feel MORE dangerous, you know? Like this is her normal now. Then BAM—earthworms in the desk drawer. Which is honestly one of the most creatively disgusting bullying tactics I've ever read. The pacing here is brutal in the best way: you're still processing the hacking revelation and suddenly Tang Yu is on the floor having a visceral reaction. The scene doesn't let you breathe. You go from impressed to horrified to heartbroken in about four paragraphs. And the cliffhanger ending?! 'Look out!' shouldering Yin Zhao-an out of the way, sparking electricity in the background—I literally gasped. The chapter basically never stops. It's like the author knows exactly how to keep you on a leash and refuses to let go until the very last sentence.
... Read More
Can we talk about Zhao Yu for a second because this character is SO important and the author gives him these tiny moments that say everything? The scene where he's at Yin Zhao-an's apartment fixing her PC, half-asleep at 3:30 AM, and then his brother picks him up—that trench coat moment? Yin Zhao-an watches from the balcony and sees this man draping his coat over Zhao Yu and kissing his forehead. And the narration tells us her exact thought: 'She felt that he must have succeeded in securing his own happiness.' This woman who can't even communicate with the person she loves most is watching her friend find love and feeling... what? Relief? Longing? Resignation? The text says 'Probably never...' and I think that's the most heartbreaking three words in the entire passage. But the real character revelation is in how Yin Zhao-an and Tang Yu's relationship is structured. Yin Zhao-an is the protector—the one who grew tall in elementary school and threw fists. Tang Yu is the protected, the one whose family went through 'great changes' and who Yin Zhao-an never left side. But who is actually stronger? Tang Yu faced terminal cancer alone. She faced a murderer alone. Yin Zhao-an faced nothing until it was too late. And then there's Tang Yu's father, Yin Changcheng—the retired soldier whose 'ruthlessness' flashed in his eyes when he heard about the cancer. What is this man capable of? The fact that he tells Yin Zhao-an 'do something practical' instead of just grieving suggests he's already planning something. The relationships in this book are like dominoes waiting to fall.
... Read More
The opening of this chapter is SET THE FUCKING MOOD and I mean that in the best way. Frost on weeds, bitter wind making trees sway, people in black moving cautiously toward a small house. Then that flickering light, the door closing, the wind just... stopping. It's like the author pressed mute on the entire world at that exact moment. That's a movie-level transition and it made me actually pause my reading. Later, the hospital corridor outside the operating room has this incredible atmosphere too—the soldiers who just survived a firefight standing around in face paint and dried blood, some pacing, some frozen still staring at the red light above the door. One young soldier apologizes to Yu Wanrou with tear tracks on his face. There's no music swelling, no narration telling you how tense this is. Just people waiting in a hallway. The contrast between the violent night operation with its gunshots ringing through deserted suburbs and the sterile, hushed hospital corridor is masterful. The author also sprinkles in small domestic details—the Yin family home with its mismatched bookshelf (comic books alongside anatomy textbooks that Wang Zhen forcibly placed there), the hospital cafeteria where they wait by the ICU entrance, the wind on the seventh-floor balcony whipping Yu Wanrou's already-messy hair even more. These details make the world feel lived-in rather than staged.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or