Between The Fingers, Boredom - Reviews

Between The Fingers, Boredom
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about the emotional architecture of this section because it operates on such a refined frequency. This isn't melodrama—you know, the kind where characters wail and dramatic music swells. This is quiet grief. This is the kind of sorrow that makes you stand against a wall and smoke cigarettes that smell like someone who's already gone. The moment when Zhao Yuan points his hand at Bian Liming's nose and says "This cigarette belonged to my grandfather"—that's the emotional crescendo of the entire passage. No tears, no breakdown, just a statement so heavy it becomes weightless. And Bian Liming's response? He doesn't offer platitudes. He doesn't say "he's in a better place." He just... stays. His hand on Zhao Yuan's back, patting gently, like you would pat a nervous animal. The romantic tension here is delicious precisely because it's understated. There's no confession, no kiss, no dramatic confrontation. Instead, there's the way Zhao Yuan stares at Bian Liming approaching through the smoke, tilting his head, watching until they're within a meter. That's romance for people who've survived too much to perform. What really gets me is the coffee shop routine. Every time. Freshly ground beans at home versus those terrible campus coffees—they leave campus together. This is intimacy built through repetition. Through showing up. Through two short messages arranging to meet. In a world where everyone's losing people, this small ritual of shared caffeine becomes sacred. The emotional arc from that winter night to the current campus present is handled with such care. We see Zhao Yuan go from someone who "acted irrationally" in grief to someone who has built a new professional identity around preventing others from experiencing similar losses. The bitterness hasn't left him—he still smokes, he still orders cappuccino with hand-whipped foam because he has standards—but it's been transmuted into purpose. Bian Liming calls him "Ah Yuan" when he wants to be intimate. Zhao Yuan lets him. That's the entire love story in two words.
... Read More
Let me tell you, the way this plot is layering things right now is actually kind of masterful. You start with one thread—Zhao Yuan bumping into Liming on the street with a giant bouquet—and then BAM, Bian Liqin shows up at the grandmother's birthday. Two storylines that seemed completely separate collide in the same house, same evening, and the reader is sitting there like "oh." The author doesn't tell you straight-up why this matters, but you can feel the gears turning. "Hello, I'm Bian Liqin. I heard from my younger brother that today is your grandmother's birthday, so I brought a small gift." This line alone does SO much work. It explains how Bian Liqin knew—Liming must've mentioned Zhao Yuan already, which means their interaction wasn't just a passing bump but something that stuck with at least one of them. And the timing? Coming back from a military academy, checking on his brother, AND coincidentally showing up on the grandmother's birthday? Coincidence feels thin here, honestly. What I love is the narrative economy too. We get background on Bian Liqin without an info-dump—he was legendary as a kid, went to a military academy, his family is well-known in the neighborhood—but it all comes through Zhao Yuan's memory, which feels natural. The scene where Zhao Yuan gives Liming a single aster from his grandmother's birthday flowers? That's a tiny moment but it plants a seed for something bigger. Flowers moving from one character to another as a bridge... subtle but deliberate. And that ending? Zhao Yuan's mother giving him a subtle signal as Bian Liqin leaves. Not explained. Just dropped. My hands were literally gripping my phone harder. What was the signal? What did she know that he doesn't? The plot is setting up a reunion arc that feels earned, not forced. I'm invested.
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about the cigarette smell that I can't shake. It's not just a detail — it's the physical evidence of grief that Zhao Yuan has been carrying around in his pockets. His grandfather's scent on his own hands. The dead clinging to the living through habits and smells. He's become a vessel for loss, and Bian Liming is the only one who notices. The immersive play functions as a kind of truth machine. Stripped of their normal routines — the library, the coffee shop, the carefully maintained distance between them — the performance forces them into roles that mirror what's actually happening beneath the surface. They're already living a story where one is drowning and the other is desperately trying to throw a rope. The actors just make it visible. And the rain at the end. Not a gentle drizzle — sudden, heavy, October violence. Things accumulating on the ground. Leaves going down drains. It mirrors the emotional state perfectly: everything is saturated, visibility is low, and you have to decide whether to wait it out or run through it. Bian Liming suggests waiting. Zhao Yuan turns to look at him. The chapter doesn't tell us what happens next. Maybe it should stay that way. The 5 Betas out of 80 students detail also stuck with me. In a world where biology seems to dictate social positioning, Zhao Yuan is a statistical anomaly choosing isolation anyway. He's not hiding because he has to — he's hiding because he wants to. And that's the tragedy Bian Liming is fighting against.
... Read More
I need to talk about this exchange because I have not recovered: "Can I… can I kiss you? Oh, never mind, I'm just talking nonsense. My mind is not very clear right now, don't take it seriously." "……uuumh" That's it. That's the whole thing. No grand confession, no dramatic music. Just a hesitation, a retreat, and then... hmm. That "hmm" is doing SO much work. It's not a yes. It's not a no. It's the sound of someone who wants to say something but doesn't know how yet. And honestly, the whole relationship between these two is written in these tiny moments. The coffee swap — they try each other's drink, take one sip, and immediately swap back, but neither mentions the saliva thing anymore. They just... accept it. That's intimacy without vocabulary. "Can I link arms with you?" "Sure." "Can I hug you?" "Of course." "The guest room isn't prepared. Can we sleep together?" "Sure! No need to be so polite." This reads like a conversation between two people who have already figured out everything except the word for what they're doing. The fact that it's framed as a series of permission requests is both adorable and kind of heartbreaking — because at some point, one of them is going to stop asking. But here's what really got me: when Zhao Yuan finds out about the news broadcast, he's "almost jumping with excitement" while Bian Liming's joy is "not even one-tenth" of that. And then Zhao Yuan pats his shoulder. And Bian Liming asks, with this devastating casualness: "But you'll still come to celebrate with me that day, right?" Not "will you watch it with me." Not "will you be there." Just... come celebrate. Like the smallest version of this moment is still more than he expects.
... Read More
I have to praise this dialogue scene because the author gave Bian Liming one of the most natural-sounding improvised speech moments I've read. The judge asks this random question about Lin Cang Concert Hall, and Bian Liming's response? Absolutely perfect. He breaks it down: literal meaning first, then pronunciation play, then cultural reference to the ancient saying about being well-fed before pursuing etiquette. It's confident without being arrogant, thoughtful without being pretentious. And the judge's follow-up—"Truly the character reflects the music!"—feels exactly like something a slightly amateurish competition judge would say. Realistic. Then Bian Liming's casual exchange with Zhao Yuan backstage: "I want some too." "I'm a bit nervous." Two lines, two people, completely different ways of communicating anxiety. Bian Liming externalizes it through action, Zhao Yuan internalizes it through observation. Their dialogue styles are totally distinct, and that's no accident. The author clearly understands these characters at a fundamental level.
... Read More
I keep coming back to that final image. The door closing. The mother's signal. And I need to understand what stakes are being set up here because on the surface nothing is happening but underneath everything feels like it's about to change. Let's talk about what each character stands to lose or gain. Liming is entering high school—he's clearly not thriving socially (the awkward smile, the pressed lips, the reflexive catching of a flower he wasn't sure he wanted). He's the younger brother of a legendary figure who went to a military academy and apparently carries himself with this disciplined precision. The weight of that comparison must be enormous. Finding a senior who remembers him, who is genuinely warm, who gives him a flower without expecting anything back—that's potentially destabilizing in the best way. Or the worst way, if he's not ready for it. Zhao Yuan's stakes feel quieter but no less real. He lives in a historical district, his family is close to their grandmother, their home is an unlocked gate and shared birthdays and longevity noodles. His world is small and warm and apparently known by everyone in the neighborhood—including the Bian family, who seem to know details about them that they don't know about themselves. When Bian Liqin shows up with perfect manners and a gift that arrives precisely on time, the question becomes: why do they know so much about us? And the mother's signal—that's the conflict trigger. She's not surprised by Bian Liqin's visit. She's been expecting something, waiting for something, knowing something. Whatever that signal meant, it was directed at Zhao Yuan specifically. Some information is being passed, some warning issued, some truth about to be revealed. The stakes here aren't about life or death—they're about trust, about history, about the gap between what you think you know about your neighborhood and what actually exists just beyond your gate. And the story is building toward that gap closing.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this immediately: the fact that Bian Liming refuses to throw a party for winning the Huazhang Cup absolutely wrecked me. Like, he just broke some huge record, right? Consecutive victories? And his response is basically... nobody? He can't even pretend to invite classmates because they're competitors now? That line hit so hard: "From their perspective, I don't think they would be happy about someone else's achievements. Instead of forcing them to congratulate me insincerely, it's better not to make things difficult for them." It's such a clean, honest thing to say and also deeply sad. The plot of this story isn't really about the awards or the competitions — it's about the growing distance between people who are succeeding at different speeds. His brother flying over from the "independent state on the main island" just to say congratulations three times? That's not a side plot, that's the whole story compressed into one awkward dinner scene. And then the ending drops this bomb about his dad already mapping out his future — Cultural Bureau, NGO, university position, no more performing. After everything we just read about him breaking records and calling this his dream graduation gift? That's not foreshadowing, that's a slow-motion car crash and we're all watching it happen. The narrative structure here is doing something really smart though. It doesn't dramaticize any of this. Nothing explodes. People just... drift. His brother is polite but distant. His classmates are competitors. Even Zhao Yuan, who's clearly the most important person in his life, can only respond by "mechanically pat[ting] his back." The plot is built on absence, not presence.
... Read More
I need to talk about this one moment because it's everything. They're in a supermarket of all places, surrounded by people discussing grocery budgets and plastic bags, and Bian Liming just... loses it. "What if we get separated, will you still remember me? Will you still remember me!" The repetition isn't accidental—it's the sound of someone whose entire emotional defense system just cracked open. This is the same person who can casually talk about influence and power, who treats politics like a game of chess, but strip all that away and he's just a guy terrified of being forgotten by the person he clearly cares about most. And Zhao Yuan's response—teasing him about being a famous pianist who'll forget an unknown half-finished doctor—is pure deflection. He's also scared. Both of them are standing on a precipice and pretending they're not. The fist bump Zhao Yuan gives him afterward, muttering "don't be silly," is one of the most quietly devastating physical gestures I've read in years. It's intimacy disguised as dismissal. When Bian Liming later says "Just you here is enough; I'm satisfied" after Zhao Yuan's joke about the party lacking people, that's not flirtation—that's someone laying their cards on the table without having to say the words. I am NOT okay.
... Read More
I need to talk about the worldbuilding in this book because it is DELICATE. The author doesn't just tell us where things happen—they make us FEEL the geography. Dongshan Street is introduced with such specificity: Western-style buildings with courtyards, banyan trees thick enough for two people to hug, branches sprawling over walls into yards, neatly trimmed like someone's manicured eyebrows. The summer shade nearly covers the whole road. In winter, the rain is cold and damp, leaves falling to pick up mud and dust under shoe soles and tires. This isn't decorative description—it's emotional geography. Dongshan Street represents everything Zhao Yuan lost: warmth, family, history, belonging. And Jianghua? Jianghua is cold. Christmas Eve cold. Six years cold. The contrast between the two cities mirrors the contrast between two lives—the warm Christmas Eve dinner with eggnog and roasted turkey, five people around a table with rain tapping against the window, versus the therapist's office with its single sofa and clinical boundaries. And the ABO dynamics are woven in so naturally. Zhao Yuan's parents are both Betas who wanted a simple, stable life for their child. Bian Liming's father is a military Deputy Commander, his older brother Bian Liqin is a dominant Alpha destined for power. Bian Liming himself is a Beta with no expectations placed on him, which explains so much about why he was free enough to become Zhao Yuan's closest friend. The world feels lived-in, not manufactured.
... Read More
Let me sit with this for a second. There are recurring symbols that keep coming back and they're NOT accidental. First: the magnolia tree. No white petals. Just glossy green leaves. Zhao Yuan sees it every time he passes by Bian's courtyard. Is this about Bian Liming? About something beautiful that isn't quite showing itself yet? About patience and waiting? Or maybe about how some things bloom at their own time and you can't force it? Second: the coffee shop with a new name and redecorated interior, still serving coffee. Continuity and change existing side by side. The physical space evolves but the essence remains. Zhao Yuan can go back to the same place and find both familiarity and difference. Third—and this is the big one: freedom. 'His freedom came at such a significant cost. Therefore, it couldn't be treated casually.' This theme cuts through everything. The parents chose freedom (to do meaningful work) and paid for it with safety. Zhao Yuan has freedom (from parental oversight) but is paying for it with emotional pain. Bian Liming wants freedom (from Beta insecurity) and is building toward it through ambition. Every character in this story is negotiating with freedom in their own way. And the Asia Minor conflict looming in the background? That's the ultimate expression of this theme—who gets to be free, and who pays the price for others' freedom.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about how painfully realistic the dialogue is here? The opening scene with Bian Liqin showing up is pure gold because of how awkward it is. Zhao Yuan doesn't even know how to address him - calling him by name feels disrespectful, "brother" is too intimate, "young master Bian" is weird. This small detail tells us everything about their relationship without the author having to explain it directly. Brilliant. And Bian Liqin! He's so gracefully charming while being completely transparent about his motives. When he asks Zhao Yuan to help his brother, he does it with this weary, self-deprecating smile that says he knows he's asking a favor but he's also genuinely grateful. The line "Otherwise, he might not even listen to you anymore" when telling Zhao Yuan not't tell his brother about this visit - that's such a human moment. He's not just manipulative, he's strategically protecting his relationship with his sibling. The high school flashback dialogue is where this author really shines though. Zhao Yuan complimenting Bian Liming's crew cut after seeing him so dejected - "In fact, the crew cut looks good on you. I hadn't noticed how perfect your facial features were before." That's such a natural way for someone to comfort a friend without being overly sentimental. It's clumsy in the best way - exactly how a real person would try to cheer someone up. What I love is how each character has such a distinct voice. Bian Liqin speaks with measured grace, always aware of social dynamics. Zhao Yuan is warmer, more direct. And Bian Liming's silence speaks louder than words - especially in that piano scene where he barely says anything but communicates everything through his playing. The author clearly understands that good dialogue isn't about witty banter or dramatic declarations. It's about the subtext, the awkward pauses, the things people don't say out loud.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how this author WRITES snow? Because most authors use weather as backdrop, but here the snow is a CHARACTER. Let me give you the best lines: "The cold north wind carried clustered snowflakes, swirling wildly in all directions. It seemed as if the entire city's air had turned semi-transparent white." That image of the air becoming semi-transparent white—how do you even describe that? It's not just white, it's like the atmosphere itself has changed state. And then later, the snowflakes on his coat are compared to "pristine white pupae lying quietly." PUPAE. Not snowflakes, not butterflies, but the dormant stage before transformation. That's not accidental writing. That's the author embedding meaning into imagery. The contrast between outside and inside is gorgeous too. The grey sky, the cold, the pedestrians slowing down reverently like the snow is sacred—and then inside the clinic, it's all clinical light (eventually), patient folders, soy milk in sealed cups, the hum of professional detachment. The treatment room is unlit even with curtains open, gloomy, and Zhao Qian is pacing like a caged animal until the patient arrives and everything shifts. Jianghua City itself feels alive. High altitude, subtropical latitude, rare snowfall—these details ground us. The first snow isn't just weather, it's an EVENT. Even the shop assistant says they haven't seen snow in years. And then there's the breakfast shop with its bamboo steamer and steam rising into the cold air, snowflakes getting stifled mid-flight by that steam. That specific image stayed with me. I can SEE it. It feels like a movie frame. The world feels lived-in, not explained. We learn about the clinic's confidentiality system, the encrypted IDs, the Beta classification—not through exposition dumps but through Zhao Qian's casual observation while eating his bun. Efficient worldbuilding.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or