Between The Fingers, Boredom - Reviews

Between The Fingers, Boredom
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I want to talk about how this author controls time because it is genuinely masterful and I am not being dramatic. Chapter 44 starts with a father replying with an emoji. Three fucking chapters later his son is deciding whether to give up music entirely and the pacing makes it feel completely inevitable rather than rushed. Let me walk through how that happens. First, we get the brother scene — short, awkward, repetitive. "Congratulations on winning the award." Three times. It's uncomfortable to read and that discomfort is the point. The author could have made this a warm family reunion but instead chose to show us that celebration is hard when people don't know how to be close. Then the coffee shop scene — this is where the pacing slows down almost to a standstill. Five years of university compressed into the memory of two people swapping coffees and never mentioning the saliva. This is 200 words doing the work of a montage sequence. No exposition about their relationship development, just the evidence of it accumulated in small gestures. Then the dialogue section — the rapid-fire Q&A about physical intimacy. This accelerates everything. It's breathless and casual and somehow the most intimate part of the entire passage. Then back to stillness. The supermarket. The future conversation. The father's plans. The ending that doesn't end but just... stops. The author never rushes the big moments. The Huazhang Cup win is mentioned almost in passing. The news interview is treated like a minor inconvenience. The real drama happens in the space between sentences, in what Bian Liming doesn't say when Zhao Yuan asks about after-graduation plans.
... Read More
Okay, the butterfly metaphor. I need to spend time on this because the author dropped it almost casually and it carries the entire philosophical weight of these chapters: "Every promotion, every experience, every choice was like the wings of a butterfly fluttering; lurking during the passage of time, pulling life toward some unpredictable direction." This is the book telling us exactly what it's about: contingency. None of this was supposed to happen. Lin Cang High School. The responsible senior. Yancang University. "It wasn't because of each other that they ended up this way." But then the real question, the one the whole passage is building toward: "Could a relationship or emotion that began due to luck come to an end when that luck runs out?" That's not a thematic question, that's an existential one. And it's framed through objects — the coffee shop that closes, the cappuccino that becomes Americano and back, the chocolate snacks thrown into a cart without discussion. These are the artifacts of a relationship that has no label but also needs no label. The shower scene is symbolic too, obviously — but not in the crude way you might expect. It's about the erosion of boundaries, the way intimacy becomes so normalized that asking permission is just a formality. "We've done it before. If we're doing it together, we'll do it quickly." Efficiency as love language. And the father's plans for Bian Liming — Cultural Bureau, NGO, university — these represent order, structure, predictability. Everything the butterfly wing theory warns against. The story is asking: can something built on coincidence survive when someone tries to design its future?
... Read More
Okay so the pacing in these chapters is doing something I really appreciate. It starts slow—young Zhao Yuan remembering a face he barely paid attention to, the mundane task of buying flowers, the physical comedy of trying to walk while half your vision is blocked by a giant bouquet. Very slice-of-life, very grounded. Then the collision happens and the tempo picks up instantly. "Liming?" Zhao Yuan interrupts. Just two syllables and the whole scene transforms from accidental bump into something with weight and history. The conversation that follows is brisk, almost clipped on Liming's end—"I am Liming. And you are..."—while Zhao Yuan fills the space with warmth and unnecessary detail about being in the student council. This contrast in dialogue rhythm tells you everything about their personalities without the author saying a word. Then—chapter break energy, we leave Liming behind, and we go home. The flower arrangement scene is deliberately slow. Trimming eucalyptus leaves. Placing asters in vases. The scent lingering on fingertips. This is the author letting us breathe, letting the earlier momentum settle into something domestic and calm. Like a camera panning across a room after an exciting conversation. And then Bian Liqin appears. Just like that. One moment we're admiring flowers on a dining table, the next there's a tall figure at the gate with a gift bag and a reason to be there that the narrative won't fully explain. The transition is so seamless you almost miss the shift in gears. The ending is where the pacing really pays off though. All this setup—the encounter, the flowers, the birthday, the family gathering—and then it cuts on a signal. A glance. An unspoken instruction. The author could have had Bian Liqin stay for dinner, could have had a long conversation, but instead chooses to exit at the moment of maximum curiosity. Classic technique. Makes you want to turn the page immediately.
... Read More
Let's talk about pacing because this section is a masterclass in temporal manipulation. The author opens in the present—Bian Liming at the piano, Zhao Yuan's reaction—and then drops us into a flashback that spans months of grief before returning to the present timeline. This isn't disorienting; it's emotionally logical. Grief doesn't happen in chronological order. It loops. It revisits. It finds you when you least expect it. The transition from Bian Liming's piano to Zhao Yuan's memory is seamless because it's triggered by emotional resonance, not plot convenience. The music becomes the doorway. And once we're in the flashback, the pacing accelerates in a way that mirrors the overwhelming speed of tragedy. One week. Grandmother's fever becomes ICU. Grandfather's heart attack. Death. Death. It happens fast because that's how it happens in real life. Then—pivot—we land in the present with that coffee shop routine. The pacing slows down again, settling into a comfortable rhythm. Two messages. Meeting up. Smoking. This is the pacing of recovery, of building new habits around old wounds. I want to highlight the chapter structure choice here. Instead of dumping all the backstory at once, the author distributes it: a hint here, a fuller scene there, the grandfather's cigarette reveal at the emotional climax of the passage. This is controlled revelation. The reader learns with Zhao Yuan, or rather, learns alongside him as memories resurface. The ending—Zhao Yuan ordering cappuccino, Bian Liming choosing different Americano beans each time—feels like a breath after holding it for three chapters. It's not a cliffhanger; it's a exhale. And that's appropriate because what we've just experienced is heavy. The author knows when to let the reader breathe. One thing I will say: the transition from the funeral preparations to the year-later university scenes could have used slightly more connective tissue. But maybe that's intentional—grief makes time feel discontinuous, and the narrative structure mirrors that experience.
... Read More
Zhao Yuan's father's dialogue is genuinely one of the best pieces of writing in this entire batch. 'Presenting facts from an unbiased perspective, giving a voice to those who can't speak, that's what your mom and I have always wanted to do.' Simple. Direct. No flowery language, just pure conviction. You can hear the love and pride in his voice when he says it. And the mother's follow-up about their 'demotion'—from production team to frontline reporters—not really being a demotion at all but a CHOICE because they couldn't stand producing 'superficial research' and 'content we don't like' anymore. This dialogue does THREE things at once: explains character motivation, advances plot, and deepens worldbuilding about the media landscape in this story's universe. Bian Liming's dialogue, on the other hand, is all nervous energy. 'Cappuccino, I specifically told them to hand froth the milk. Taste it?' He's trying so hard to seem casual and generous at the same time. The subtext is screaming. Meanwhile Zhao Yuan's responses are measured, gentle—'Oh... it's okay. It shouldn't have left directly at that time'—and that controlled calmness is almost more powerful than any outburst. The contrast in their voices tells you everything about who these people are without the narrator having to explain it.
... Read More
I need to think about what this story is really about beyond the surface romance. Water appears constantly throughout this chapter and I don't think that's accidental. The electric heater light isn't bright enough. Hot water from the shower. Milky white steam filling the cramped bathroom. The mountain stream they follow downstream. Rain falling on the pavilion roof dripping dripping. Even the water droplets on Bian Liming's eyelashes. This recurring image of water connects to something deeper about transformation and surrender. Water is soft but it can move mountains. It's fluid and takes the shape of whatever container holds it. Isn't that what these characters are doing? Learning to accept something that doesn't fit into neat categories. They're both men both Betas with the same first and second gender yet the feelings between them transcend these labels. The pavilion scene takes on new meaning when you consider it as a symbol. It's not luxurious but has natural charm nestled under the tree canopy like a hidden treasure. This is their relationship isn't it? Something beautiful that exists outside conventional structures. And the rain starting while the sun still shines. A paradox that mirrors their situation. Society might say this shouldn't exist but it does. The author uses these symbolic elements subtly without being heavy handed. They don't announce themselves as themes but accumulate power through repetition. By the end you can't read the water imagery the same way again. Everything becomes connected. The shower steam the mountain stream the rain all pointing toward the same truth about acceptance and the fluid nature of love itself.
... Read More
There's a line that keeps echoing in my head: the grandparents gave him the name Ah Yuan and then "passed away one after another, and the pine trees stood tall." Pine trees. Evergreen. Surviving. The imagery is doing so much heavy lifting here. The Zhao family name, the name Ah Yuan, the identity Zhao Qian—all of these are layered like geological strata, and Bian Liming is the only one who can read them. The banyan trees on Dongshan Street are another powerful symbol. They send roots downward AND outward, some branches crossing property lines into neighboring yards, creating a canopy that connects separate homes under one shade. This is exactly what the friendship between Zhao Yuan and Bian Liming was—roots that crossed boundaries, a canopy that sheltered both of them. And now those trees still stand in Yancang while Zhao Yuan is frozen in Jianghua, while the Bian family's shipping empire grew and Bian Liqin became an Alpha in a military academy, while everything changed except Bian Liming's memory. The name Ah Yuan was buried under six years of snow and professional distance, and the moment Bian Liming speaks it, something cracks open. This story is fundamentally about identity—who we were, who we become, and who refuses to let us forget.
... Read More
I need to talk about Bian Liqin because he's dead and yet he dominates every single page of this passage, and that is the most unfair thing an author can do to a reader. He's described as "so dazzling and perfect, no one could find fault with him; yet, he always bowed humbly, even with an outstanding height, never looking down on anyone." A man who climbed desperately to connect with his brother at his grandmother's birthday, holding an enamel vase, trying everything to make Bian Liming's life smoother. And then he's shot dead at a government building and the only thing left is his clothing in a coffin. The scene where Zhao Yuan stands before that coffin and a tear falls with a "plop" onto the white shirt—I read that sentence seven times. Seven. The simplicity of it. No dramatic monologue, no grand gesture. Just gravity doing what gravity does. And the worst part? Zhao Yuan wants to reach out to Bian Liming. He knows "the taste of losing a loved one is not easily digestible, and the support at this time is crucial." He tries. He really tries. But Bian Liming pushes him away with words sharper than any blade, and Zhao Yuan leaves standing in the rain. There's this ache of everything unsaid between them, this friendship that exists in the space between grief and pride, and I genuinely cannot breathe.
... Read More
"Even if you didn't smoke before, your hand already smells like your grandfather's now." This line wrecked me. It's so casual on the surface — just an observation, right? But Bian Liming is basically saying I see what you've become and it hurts me. The whole coffee shop scene is dripping with unspoken tension. Zhao Yuan pushing the cappuccino back, then switching them when he realizes he made a mistake, his ears turning red — he's flustered and he doesn't even know why. Then Bian Liming shows up with the milk foam on his upper lip and Zhao Yuan can't look away. He notices details now. Little things. That's not friendship orbiting there. And then the play. God, the play. Everyone around them assuming they're a couple, actors feeding them lines about being together for over ten years, and they just... go along with it. Zhao Yuan is anxious the whole time, waiting for it to end, but he never pulls away. Never says no. The rain at the end — October in Yangcang City, sudden and fierce, leaves pooling on the road, fallen leaves drifting to the drains. It feels like their whole relationship right now. Unexpected. Heavy. Beautiful in a messy way.
... Read More
Okay so this entire chapter sequence is basically built on the most delicious dramatic irony possible. We spend like eighty percent of the text in this incredibly domestic, almost mundane setting—shopping for chocolate, picking out lemon tea, sprawling on a sofa—and every tiny detail is engineered to make us feel safe. You literally forget danger is coming because the tone is so cozy. Then BAM. The breaking news about the shooting incident. Not just any news, but news that crashes into their celebration of Bian Liming's piano victory. The structural choice to have the Huazhang Cup announcement come FIRST, letting us (and Zhao Yuan) breathe a sigh of relief, and THEN hit us with the gunshots? That's not accidental pacing—that's tactical. The author is playing 4D chess with reader emotions here. Zhao Yuan has been watching the clock the entire time, counting down to 7:55 like it's some kind of detonation timer, and when the camera finally cuts to that control room shot and an unknown hand slides a paper to the host, my stomach actually dropped. What happens in that gap between the peace and the violence? That's the plot hook that's going to keep me up until 3 AM.
... Read More
"So, you took both tickets from her?" "Yeah. Aren't we a couple?" I have read this exchange approximately fourteen times now and it gets funnier AND sadder every single time. The casualness of it. The complete lack of dramatic framing. It's just two people standing in the rain having what should be a huge moment but is instead delivered like they're discussing what to order for dinner. Zhao Yuan's voice in this chapter is so distinct and I love him for it. He's the one who has to process things out loud, who verbalizes his confusion, who asks the questions the reader is thinking. "Why did you choose this play? Just to tease me and make me fall in love?" — This line is everything. It's defensive humor masking genuine vulnerability. It's the kind of thing someone says when they want to believe the answer is yes but are terrified that it actually is. Bian Liming's dialogue is shorter, sparser, but every word carries. His explanations are almost clinical in their directness. "It wasn't my choice." "Yeah." "Just tell me what you want to hear." He doesn't ornament anything. And somehow that makes his few lines land harder than anyone else's monologues in this entire chapter. The innkeeper's dialogue is minimal but functional—setting up the international couple detail, turning on the stereo, asking about the piano. These small touches create the ambient social world around our two leads without intruding on their dynamic. The other guests are basically set dressing, but intentionally so. They're there to make the intimate space between Zhao Yuan and Bian Liming feel even more exclusive. My favorite micro-moment: "Isn't it too dark to see the keyboard clearly?" — Zhao Yuan, slightly drunk, processing the fact that he's about to watch someone play piano in near-darkness with someone he's emotionally entangled with, and his brain outputs this completely practical question. The humor is involuntary and painfully human.
... Read More
I need to talk about the smoking room scene because THIS is where the entire relationship between Zhao Yuan and Bian Liming crystallized for me. So Bian Liming walks in all dressed up, asks for a cigarette, and just TAKES the half-smoked one off Zhao Yuan's lips? Without asking? Without even hesitating? And Zhao Yuan stands there literally unable to form words because this guy is smoking a cigarette that has saliva on it??? And then Zhao Yuan is just wondering whether to remind him that's a thing??? The fact that he doesn't say anything is so telling about his character—he's holding back, not wanting to ruin the moment, even though part of him knows it's intimate in a way that makes his lungs itch and his throat throb. Then Bian Liming puts the cigarette down and talks about nervousness like nothing happened. But Zhao Yuan watches him win and literally thinks Bian Liming looks like a sunflower blooming in sunlight. A SUNFLOWER. This isn't just admiration, this is devotion. And the ending where Zhao Yuan grabs him and says "You're my number one"—what a line. What a perfect line. It means everything and nothing at the same time.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or