Okay, the butterfly metaphor. I need to spend time on this because the author dropped it almost casually and it carries the entire philosophical weight of these chapters:
"Every promotion, every experience, every choice was like the wings of a butterfly fluttering; lurking during the passage of time, pulling life toward some unpredictable direction."
This is the book telling us exactly what it's about: contingency. None of this was supposed to happen. Lin Cang High School. The responsible senior. Yancang University. "It wasn't because of each other that they ended up this way."
But then the real question, the one the whole passage is building toward: "Could a relationship or emotion that began due to luck come to an end when that luck runs out?"
That's not a thematic question, that's an existential one. And it's framed through objects — the coffee shop that closes, the cappuccino that becomes Americano and back, the chocolate snacks thrown into a cart without discussion. These are the artifacts of a relationship that has no label but also needs no label.
The shower scene is symbolic too, obviously — but not in the crude way you might expect. It's about the erosion of boundaries, the way intimacy becomes so normalized that asking permission is just a formality. "We've done it before. If we're doing it together, we'll do it quickly." Efficiency as love language.
And the father's plans for Bian Liming — Cultural Bureau, NGO, university — these represent order, structure, predictability. Everything the butterfly wing theory warns against. The story is asking: can something built on coincidence survive when someone tries to design its future?