Between The Fingers, Boredom - Reviews

Between The Fingers, Boredom
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
There's this one line that keeps haunting me - "Heading east in the morning, returning west in the evening. The two young men walking side by side, forever facing the sun." It's such a simple image but it carries so much weight. The sun as constant companion, as shared direction, as something they both choose to face together while leaving darkness behind. It's basically a thesis statement for their entire relationship. And then there's the piano music - Mendelssohn's "Spring Song" - which is apparently the piece Bian Liming chose to play when he was struggling to find his place academically. Spring as rebirth, as hope, as the season that comes after the longest winter. He was about to give up on his studies and pursue something entirely different, and instead of speaking his frustration, he played this piece about renewal. That's such a powerful choice of symbolism. The whole second gender system is basically a metaphor for how society assigns value based on arbitrary biological markers. Alphas get all the resources because they're "superior," betas have to work twice as hard, omegas can only succeed through marriage. It's a critique of meritocracy that's actually just inherited privilege in disguise. And yet - and this is the brilliant part - the system creates spaces for resistance. The 40% cap at Lin Cang High School is a small crack in an oppressive structure, and our beta protagonists slipped right through it. Bian Liqin's visit is also loaded with symbolic meaning. He's the responsible older brother who can't reach his younger sibling directly, so he enlists an outside helper - like a general recruiting mercenaries because his own army won't listen. The flowers Bian Liming brought home that prompted this whole conversation? Flowers are temporary, they wilt, but the gesture of bringing them home shows care that words couldn't express. Every element in this book seems to carry double meaning. The sun, the song, the flowers, the walk home - they're all symbols of connection, of choosing to face forward together despite whatever obstacles come between you.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the dialogue here does SO much heavy lifting without any character ever saying what they actually mean. Let's start with Bian Liming and his classic line: "If the Bian family doesn't recognize me anymore, would you still care about me?" Zhao Yuan's response is practically perfect - he immediately deflects into comfort, saying things like "You will always be their family" instead of addressing the real question underneath. And you know what kills me? The fact that Bian Liqin shows up and just casually calls him "Brother" while Zhao Yuan doesn't even register the strangeness of it. The scene-by scene progression of dialogue reveals everything: Bian Liming pouring his heart out to Zhao Yuan, then literally running away when Bian Liqin appears, and Bian Liqin's lame excuse about visiting Uncle and Aunt when his parents are on a business trip. The author lets silence do so much work too - that moment where both Bian Liqin and Zhao Yuan watch Bian Liming retreat without following him? That's louder than any dialogue could be.
... Read More
"Ah Yuan." Bian Liming says it like it's a prayer. Like saying the name will somehow summon the person back. And Zhao Qian—Zhao Qian doesn't even flinch visibly, but I swear the narrative itself holds its breath. He hadn't heard that name in years. The old name. The one from before he rebuilt himself, before he became Dr. Zhao Qian in Jianghua City. It belongs to someone else now—a boy from Dongshan Street, from warm sunlight on terraces and rainy springs and autumns with rising winds. This isn't just a friendship. It's something that runs deeper than either of them probably admitted out loud. The way Bian Liming remembers the smallest things—the coffee arguments, the street corner smoking, the fact that Zhao Yuan was afraid of the cold in Jianghua's winters—shows a devotion that borders on unbearable. And Zhao Yuan's reaction? He writes in his notebook instead of speaking. His Adam's apple moves but no sound comes out. He lets the other man call him by a dead name because for six years nobody has. That detail alone wrecked me. The grandparents are gone. The parents crossed the ocean. Only Bian Liming remembered who he used to be.
... Read More
OK I need to talk about Liming because THIS character is walking around in my head now and I can't shake him. Have you seen how he reacts when Zhao Yuan gives him that flower? "He was hesitant to take it... Purely out of reflex, Liming instinctively caught the nearly dropped flower." Refleks. Not choice. He doesn't even WANT to take it but his body betrays him. That's not nothing, folks. That's a person who is starved for casual, no-strings warmth and doesn't know how to process it. And then Bian Liqin enters and everything shifts. This guy is described like he was carved from the same plaster bust as his brother—same high nose, same serious energy—but where Liming is all awkward smiles and pressed-together lips, Bian Liqin moves through the world differently. He knows exactly how to bend his waist and lower his knees to match his grandmother's eye level. He brings an enamel vase he bought at a friend's exhibition that he hasn't even used. Every gesture is precise, rehearsed, appropriate. It's either genuine politeness or... something else. Maybe both. Zhao Yuan is the sunniest presence here and I think that's intentional. "The smile on his face was as bright as the sunshine at that moment." He's the one who initiates, who pushes the flower into Liming's arms, who offers help without being asked. But here's what's eating at me—why does he feel "unexpectedly uneasy" in his own home when Bian Liqin visits? His family has never been this lively since he can remember, and instead of feeling good about it, he feels unsettled. There's something about that house, that history, that connection between the two families that Zhao Yuan senses but can't name yet. The Zhao mother's signal at the end? That tells you everything. She knows more than she's saying. She knows something about Bian Liqin, about the Bian family, about why his son should pay attention. Three people in one room, all holding different pieces of information, and the relationship web is just... expanding. I need to know what happens next.
... Read More
Let me be honest with you — on the surface, nothing is happening in these chapters. No one is dying. No one is betraying anyone. There's no villain. And yet the stakes feel absolutely enormous to me, which is what makes this writing so good. The external stakes are painfully small: a news broadcast at 7:30 PM. A dinner with a brother who flies ten hours just to say congratulations awkwardly. A decision about whether to throw a party for an achievement that feels already hollow. But the internal stakes? Bian Liming is standing at the edge of giving up the thing that defines him. His father has already decided his future — no more performing, just a comfortable position in a university. The Huazhang Cup wasn't just a competition win, it was described as "the graduation gift he most wanted and liked" and now that gift is being packaged and put away before he's even opened it. Zhao Yuan's stakes are different but equally high. He's the one who's excited about the broadcast, who confirmed the schedule with his TV station parents, who bought snacks for a celebration that will probably happen alone. His investment in Bian Liming's success is visible in every detail — except he can't name what he's investing in. The most tension-filled scene is not a confrontation. It's a supermarket. Two people pushing a cart, shoulders bumping, one looping an arm through the other, talking about the future like it's a weather forecast they can't control. The conflict here is between what's coming and what they want, between the butterfly wing theory and the father's five-year plan, between a relationship that needs no label and a world that keeps demanding definitions. And the suspense? The entire passage is suspense about whether they'll say the thing that changes everything — or whether the thing will change without them saying it at all.
... Read More
What strikes me most about the dialogue here is what ISN'T said. Zhao Qian's lines are clipped, professional, almost surgical—"My surname is Zhao, and I am called Zhao Qian." "Mr. Bian, when did your sleep disorder start?" He repeats his own boundary like a man checking his locks three times. Meanwhile Bian Liming's dialogue is all breath and repetition and desperate curiosity. He circles back to the same pain in different phrasings, each attempt softer than the last, until he's asking about the weather in Jianghua like a man who forgot how to ask directly. The contrast between their voices is brutal. Zhao Qian speaks in full, controlled sentences. Bian Liming speaks in fragments and questions, his thoughts tumbling over each other. And then there's the flashback dialogue—natural, layered with family dynamics. The mother's gentle scolding about alcohol, the grandfather's coaxing tone, Zhao Yuan's impatience at being treated like a child. These voices are DISTINCT and immediate. The author doesn't need narration tags to tell us who's speaking; the speech patterns carry the character. But the real power comes in the silence between lines. When Bian Liming says "Can we spend Christmas Eve together again?" and the narrator simply states "Ah Yuan. Zhao Qian hadn't heard anyone call him that in a long time"—that's when the dialogue transcends words and becomes something almost physical.
... Read More
This might be the most devastating passage in the entire book and I need a minute. Let me go back to it because I keep coming back to it. "Think about it; even though I've known Bian Liming for almost 20 years, it seems like he's not as familiar with me as you are. The first time he learned to play the piano, the first day he went to boarding school, the first friend he made who could talk to him, the first person he fell for… I know nothing about all that." OH MY GOD. That is just—Bian Liqin is sitting up there in the night air telling his brother's best friend that he was too busy being a successful Alpha to be a brother, and now he's watching them get close while he's stuck on the outside. He knows about Bian Liming's love life, he's clearly suspicious about Zhao Yuan, he's teasing him about it—and yet he can't even ask directly. The way he circles around it, pretending it's casual gossip when really he's just terrified of losing the only connection he has left to his brother? I'm literally shaking. And then Zhao Yuan's reaction—stammering, blushing, avoiding eye contact—tells him everything he needs to know and nothing at the same time. Meanwhile Bian Liming is sitting at that piano with dark circles under his eyes, letting Zhao Yuan crouch in front of him and tell him who he really is as a musician. 'It's like letting anyone else play them, and it would sound the same whether you play them or not.' That hit me like a truck. Two different kinds of intimacy happening at the same time in this chapter and I can't breathe.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the pacing in these chapters is absolutely ruthless and I respect it so much. We start in slow motion—the chocolate selection, the freezer aisle conversation about futures, the lemon tea exchange. It's deliberate, almost meditative. You could read this section on a weekend afternoon with a cup of actual tea and feel completely relaxed. And that's the trap, right? Because the author is lulling you into a false sense of security. The chapter transitions feel effortless: supermarket to Zhao Yuan's apartment, buying snacks to settling on the sofa, eating to watching TV. Each scene flows into the next like water, and you don't even notice the tempo shifting until it's too late. Then we get the news broadcast sequence—the opening credits music, the host's voice, the Huazhang Cup announcement—and suddenly the pacing is different. It's tighter, more urgent. Zhao Yuan is watching the clock. Bian Liming is holding his phone ready to photograph his moment. The celebration is building. And then, in the last five lines, the entire narrative accelerates into chaos. The gunshots. The control room. The unknown hand. It's the literary equivalent of someone handing you a gift and then snatching it away. I went from "aww they're so cute" to absolute panic in approximately three paragraphs. This is how you write a cliffhanger that actually works.
... Read More
Okay so first off can we just take a moment for how the author handles transitions between the personal and the political? You've got this intimate sun shower on Yutong Mountain - the kind where you're trapped under a rock overhang with someone, physical closeness forced by weather - and then BAM, you're watching the news about international diplomacy. The yutong Mountain inn itself feels like this weird liminal space, right? These two travelers - the couple who can't even properly order food in Mandarin - they're just trying to go home, completely unaware that beneath them is this massive geopolitical conference about territorial disputes spanning half a century. The contrast is wild. And then Bian Liming singing his guitar on moss-covered stone steps while his father and brother are upstairs plotting state affairs. I love how the setting mirrors the emotional architecture here - everyone is literally on the same mountain but in completely different worlds.
... Read More
The stakes in this story are already climbing and we're only four chapters in. Let me explain why. On the surface, this looks like a story about a therapist whose former connection shows up unexpectedly. But dig deeper and there are layers of conflict stacking up like dominoes waiting to fall. Zhao Qian's internal conflict is immediately visible: he's built a life of deliberate detachment in Jianghua City, and the very first patient of the day shatters that. He mentions he never wanted to get involved in political matters, that his clinic serves the privileged and transparent—meaning people with power, people who can make or break things. And now one of them has shown up at his door under a false name with a sleep disorder that might be real or might be an excuse. The external conflict is hinted at but barely scratched. The "Beta" classification suggests a world where people are categorized, possibly by status or ability. Bian Liming's emotional state—trembling voice, volcano metaphor—suggests he's been through something devastating. And Zhao Qian's slip, saying "Ah Yuan" instead of keeping professional distance, means the personal and professional lines are already blurred before the session even starts. What makes the tension so good is that NOTHING has exploded yet, but everything feels like it's about to. The coffee cup landing on the table, the unfinished sentence about breakfast—these are small moments carrying enormous weight. Zhao Qian is a man who has chosen solitude, and Bian Liming is walking back into his life with a gesture of kindness that might be the most dangerous thing of all. How long can professional boundaries hold when one person has clearly never stopped caring? That's the question hanging in the snow-covered air.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Bian Liming playing the piano because this scene literally wrecked me. I don't care how you feel about it just hear me out. Zhao Yuan couldn't even listen to the music he was so flustered that his heart was jumping into his throat and blood was surging to his earlobes. The author just casually drops this line about Bian Liming's fingers moving across the keys as if caressing a familiar body and I was like wait what is happening right now. This is the moment where everything shifts between them isn't it? Because before this you could read it as deep friendship or unspoken tension but after this you can't pretend it's nothing. And then the shower scene oh god the shower scene. Zhao Yuan gets caught in such a vulnerable state and Bian Liming just walks in and the way the author describes it with the steam and the hot water and Bian Liming getting soaked standing there in front of him... I was actually shaking my phone from how excited I was. But what got me the most wasn't even the romantic tension it was the morning after. Both of them acting completely normal like nothing happened. Bian Liming yawning and stretching and saying let's go for a walk like he didn't spend the night in the same bed. And then in the pavilion when Zhao Yuan finally asks about it and Bian Liming says don't worry about it we were both awake and willing last night. That line just hits different doesn't it? It's so straightforward yet so loaded with meaning. And then the rain starts falling and they're both just sitting there knees touching neither moving away. I literally had to pause reading and stare at the ceiling for ten minutes because my heart was pounding.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say—this competition scene was genuinely one of the best plot moments I've read in a while. The setup where Bian Liming gets pushed onto stage during the Q&A? Total chaos energy, which made his response absolutely shine. And honestly, the way the question about Lin Cang Concert Hall basically handed him an open book essay was chef's kiss. He turned what could've been an awkward situation into a masterclass moment. But here's what really got me—the fact that he saw through the question so quickly. Recognized Zhou Jieyuan as the performance manager, connected it to sponsorship, and still gave a thoughtful answer that wasn't just flattery. That's plot-level competence. Also the whole thing about the Special Prize being above first prize added this tiny undercurrent of 'could he go higher' without even making it a big deal. Subtle. I love when the author trusts the reader to notice those details without spelling everything out.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or