Back to My Dad’s Youth - Reviews

Back to My Dad’s Youth
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
This is where the whole class tension hits different. The Lin family wasn't always at the top — they were just 'rich merchants with a bit of fame' under the grandfather, and it took Lin Shen's blood, sweat, and tears to actually make them competitive with families like the Lus. And yet here he is, pretending to be broke, eating at a street stall, using his son as an unwitting pawn in whatever game he's playing. The stakes feel huge because we know the Lu family is established power — deep connections, solid foundation, noble status. They didn't have to build anything. Meanwhile the Lins had to FIGHT for every inch of ground. That's why the rivalry between Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan isn't just personal, it's existential. If Lin Shen loses, the whole family's hard-won position collapses. And Lin Wangye — he's caught between worlds now. He has the comfort of wealth but none of the struggle that built it, and he's starting to realize how much of his life is built on something his father lived for. This is gonna get messy when the truth comes out.
... Read More
I need to talk about this brief but absolutely devastating paragraph about Shi Yuan. Lin Wangye — this guy who just found out his dad's been secretly living a whole other life from him — his FIRST thought when hearing 'buddy' is HIS CRUSH. His father's friend. The elegant, charismatic man he's been pining after since puberty. And the fact that he has to call him 'Uncle' because of the age gap and some moral boundary Shi Yuan won't cross? That's the kind of quiet, aching loneliness that sneaks up on you. He loved someone who will never love him back, and now his dad is calling OTHER people 'number one buddies' while Lin Wangye sits there realizing he doesn't even know his own father. Meanwhile the Lu Chengxuan situation adds another layer — if these two men have a previous life connection, does that mean Lin Wangye's current enemies are actually connected to his father's past in ways that might affect HIM too? The romantic tension with Shi Yuan is simmering somewhere beneath all this family drama, and I'm already emotionally compromised over a man who hasn't even appeared in these chapters yet.
... Read More
I have to talk about Lu Chengxuan's dialogue because WOW. The man says three words and I'm emotionally compromised. Look at his lines: 'Mm.' 'Yeah.' 'Just the difference between a smaller school and a bigger one. Nothing hard to adjust to.' 'Don't overthink it.' 'Sure. Up to you.' This guy is a walking emoji of minimal effort and yet every single response feels SO deliberate. It's not that he's bad at talking—it's that he CHOOSES his words the way some people choose their outfit. Everything is calculated. Everything is controlled. And then the moment he opens up about Lin Shen? The prose shifts completely. Suddenly we're getting FULL PARAGRAPHS of childhood memory, detailed and warm and strangely vulnerable. The contrast between his present-day speech patterns and his flashback narration tells you everything you need to know about who he is when he feels safe enough to speak. Lin Wangye's voice is totally different—bouncy, anxious, conversational, full of interruptions and questions and self-doubt. 'I-I… uh…' My god, the speech disfluencies make him feel SO real. And the author gives each character a completely distinct rhythm. You could cover their names and still know exactly who's speaking. That's craft, people.
... Read More
I need to scream about the phone call scene because my heart is actually hurting. Lin Wangye, who just survived a life-threatening situation, isn't traumatized in a dramatic way—he's just… lonely? He texts 'Are you asleep?' at midnight. He doesn't want comfort, he wants to hear a voice. And Shi Yuan, who is probably also tired and stressed, doesn't even hesitate. He calls back. The dialogue is so sparse but it carries so much weight. 'I just wanted to hear you talk to me.' And Shi Yuan's response? He tries to tell a story about the triangle inequality in functions. A MATH STORY. And it works. Lin Wangye falls asleep, and they just lie there breathing into the phone. 'Their breaths intertwined on the line, slowly syncing.' That is the most intimate non-sexual moment in modern fiction and I am not okay. It's not about grand declarations; it's about presence. It's about two people who are clearly tangled up in each other's lives finding a quiet pocket of peace. Meanwhile, Lu Chengxuan is in his dark room reading the financial newspaper, totally separate, until the phone vibrates. The contrast between that tender, sleepy intimacy and the cold, quiet loneliness of the other room? Devastating.
... Read More
I reread the pillow scene five times. Five fucking times. Let me just… decompose it for a second. Lin Wangye leans in. Face stops ten centimeters from Shi Yuan's. Close enough that Shi Yuan would notice the fine fuzz on his skin if he wore glasses. Close enough that Shi Yuan smells his shampoo. And then — nothing. Just the echo of that earlier line: ‘As for you, a kiss would be fine too.' Page forcibly turned. Can't go back. Lin Wangye knows it too; he straightens up immediately, produces his phone, says it fell between the pillows. But the damage is done. Not because of any grand romantic declaration, but because of the almost-there. The breath catching. The pulse skipping. The heart pounding like it might leap straight out of the throat. This is where the emotional writing peaks — not with confession or touch, but with proximity and retreat. Shi Yuan's entire body reacts before his mind can catch up, and Lin Wangye reads it. Of course he does. He's been tap-dancing on Shi Yuan's mental minefield since the moment he walked in, completely unaware of the explosions he's triggering. Meanwhile, Lin Shen steals the orange and chews happily, oblivious to the fact that Shi Yuan is having a quiet internal crisis over a simple gesture of generosity. The contrast is brutal. Lin Shen's casual theft feels like a slap to Shi Yuan's self-control, not because it's rude, but because it's mundane. Why does the orange hurt when the almost-kiss doesn't? Because the kiss is hypothetical. The orange is real. The orange is Lin Wangye offering something sweet and letting his dad take a piece without hesitation, without seeing the ripple it causes. But then the scarf. Then the glasses. Then the compliment about his eyes. Each one lands like a small detonation. And Shi Yuan smiles. Nods. Says “Go on then, be careful.” All of it performed. All of it carefully measured. The emotional whiplash is exhausting. You want him to say something. Anything. But he doesn't. He just watches Lin Wangye leave, collects the glasses from where they were placed, and sits in the quiet aftermath of a encounter that changed nothing and everything. That's the ache of it. The romance isn't in the reaching; it's in the not quite touching. In the space between breaths. In the ten centimeters where everything hangs.
... Read More
I need to talk about Lu Chengxuan because this guy is absolutely fascinating in how he operates. Here comes Lin Shen, freshly roasted by some toxic online player, already throwing shade at his own teammate, and what does Lu do? He just... listens. No eye-rolling, no matching the energy, no "you brought me into this mess." Just this calm, "It's fine" energy that basically disarms everything. And that's when it hits me — Lu Chengxuan's emotional stability isn't just a personality trait, it's basically a superpower in this friend group. Lin Shen gets mad, Lu gets... softer? Because Lin Shen immediately feels guilty and apologizes. That's the power move I didn't know I needed. "That attitude made Lin Shen feel even more guilty" — honestly, this might be the most effective form of emotional manipulation in all of fiction and I'm here for it. Then there's the whole thing with their game IDs. Lin Shen = "Deep in the Forest, Unseen by People" (Wang Wei's poem). Lu Chengxuan = "The Bright Moon Comes to Shine" (also Wang Wei, same poem basically). They picked POEM NAMES FOR THEIR GAMING ACCOUNTS. This is either the most romantic thing I've ever heard or the most devastatingly platonic thing depending on how you look at it.
... Read More
The entire scene takes place inside a car — this cramped moving space where four people are trapped together, and the worldbuilding happens through micro-details rather than exposition dumps. Let me just appreciate the sensory layering here. The YSJ lime jasmine air freshener, the hum of city traffic during rush hour, the scratch of a metal bag charm against genuine leather, the rough uneven paint of a ceramic cat charm — these tiny textures make the scene feel incredibly lived-in. You can SMELL this car. The car itself becomes this microcosm of their social dynamics. Lin Qianqian in the driver's seat, authoritative but distracted. Lin Wangye in the front (the 'good seat' reserved for those you want close to you), Lin Shen and Lu Chengxuan compressed into the back like characters in a theatrical farce. The rearview mirror as a framing device — Lin Qianqian watching everyone through it, Lin Shen shrinking from her gaze. It's cinematic. And then there's the city outside: congested roads, endless turns, the oppressive weight of rush hour traffic mirroring the feeling of being trapped in a situation you can't escape. The car is moving but going nowhere fast — which is basically the entire premise of this storyline. The half-million yuan designer bag as a prop is also genius worldbuilding — it tells us everything about Lin Qianqian's economic status, her taste, her vulnerabilities (literally sitting under someone's butt), without a single info-dump paragraph.
... Read More
I've been thinking about this chapter and I can't stop coming back to that opening line about the empty seat next to Lu Chengxuan. It's such a simple detail, but I think it represents so much more than just a cursed座位. The empty seat is a metaphor for loneliness, for someone who exists in the social periphery, and for the mysterious quality that draws attention without inviting connection. Throughout this chapter, there are these small symbolic moments that build on that theme. Fu Xuexue's pink and white notebook—soft, gentle, approachable. It contrasts with the cold indifference Lu Chengxuan projects. Lin Wangye's transformation from confused newcomer to confident class participant mirrors the universal high school experience of finding your place. The rumor about being someone's girlfriend—false on the surface but revealing something true about desire and connection. I also can't ignore the historical references. The Tang dynasty calligraphy lesson isn't just filler academic content. It's about legacy, about carrying forward traditions from the past, about how cultural identity persists across time. Lin Wangye himself is literally a person carrying forward knowledge from another time—he's living history, embodying the intersection of past and present. That's not subtle, but it's effective symbolism that elevates the story beyond its school setting. The most powerful symbolic moment, though, is Lu Chengxuan remaining completely unaffected in the center of the classroom chaos. He's surrounded by noise and laughter but untouched by it. This isolation—whether chosen or imposed—speaks to something deeper about the character and the themes of connection and alienation that run through the narrative.
... Read More
I need a minute. I need to sit with this. The hospital scenes hit different because the author never romanticizes them. There's no dramatic music swell, no tears streaming down faces. Just... facts. Chemotherapy hasn't started yet. They're still in the initial examination stage. The doctor says the timing of their arrival was crucial. Hair loss is inevitable. A CHILD is facing all of this and she doesn't cry or make a fuss during blood tests and bone marrow aspirations. She cries but still cooperates, "as if she understood that this was the rare opportunity for her to save her life." And then Lin Wangye walks in with lunch, all bright energy, and the first thing Xu Suihe does is ask him: "Did Brother Xiao Lin stay happy?" When HE asks HER that question. She's repeating his words back to him, mirroring his joy, making sure that even in this sterile hospital room, his victory matters. "Amazing!" she claps for his 92 in math. Just... amazing. Like his small win is a big deal. Like she's been counting. What gets me is the casual warmth of it all. This is a kid who's facing death and her response is to play video games with visitors and celebrate her friend's test scores. There's no bitterness, no self-pity, just this fierce, quiet gratitude for whatever normal moments she can snag. And Lin Wangye — this big loud kid who can't learn advanced math no matter how many lifetimes he studies — he beams like he just won the lottery when she says amazing. Their bond isn't sentimental. It's real. It's two kids who found each other in the wreckage and decided to be happy anyway. I've read this scene five times and it still makes my chest hurt in the best way.
... Read More
Okay so this whole section where Lin Shen is just... observing Wangye? It hit different. Like, Lin Shen originally thought he found someone equally adrift, someone who was just going with the flow. But then he watches Wangye pull an all-nighter studying AND doing game training, and it completely wrecks his equilibrium. Lin Shen starts watching news with Lu Chengxuan for the first time ever. The guy who couldn't lose at games now feels guilt playing them. That's such a subtle shift. And Wangye himself? The contrast between him casually nailing a history question that tripped up everyone else, then immediately burying his head back into math problems he struggles with... that's such a vivid character portrait. He's not putting on airs. He just knows what he needs to do and does it. The most interesting part though is the Lin Shen-Wangye dynamic. Lin Shen starts feeling guilty, starts looking up to him. Their relationship is shifting from equals to something else entirely. Lin Shen's watching him with this mixture of admiration and discomfort. He's not used to someone outworking him. And Wangye? He doesn't even seem to notice he's being watched. He's just... moving forward. I also love the side detail about Jiang Bowen and Wangye walking with arms around each other's shoulders, eating grilled sausages. These small friendship moments make the world feel real. Wangye is surrounded by people who care about him, even if some of those people (like the love-letter-sending girls) don't quite know how to approach him directly.
... Read More
Okay so let's talk about how this chapter does the absolute most with very little actual event happening. Lin Shen comes back to school, there's confetti, Jiang Bowen set off a firecracker, Zhao Youyou yells at them about cleaning — on the surface it's a slice-of-life warm fuzzy scene, right? Wrong. Because underneath all that golden pink paper falling from the ceiling, Zhao Youyou drops a bomb about Shi Yuan's entire family collapsing. His dad is a gambler who took the death insurance after the mom died in a fire, and the sister has acute lymphoblastic leukemia. This is the kind of chapter that looks like it's breathing easy but is actually holding its breath the whole time. And the way the plot weaves things — Lin Wangye remembering the past life, the Zhua Zhou ceremony detail where baby Shi Yuan crawled straight to Lin Wangye's legs — that's not just worldbuilding fill, that's the author quietly establishing that these two are bound by something deeper than just friendship. The grandfather's death was the crack that split everything open, and now we're seeing what that fracture looks like in the present. Also, Lin Shen threatening to haunt both of them in his dreams? Iconic. The humor works because the author knows exactly when to land a punchline right after a gut punch.
... Read More
There's a line that keeps haunting me: "I must've been out of my mind when I fell into that damn ditch with Xu Suinian. And now look—just like that, my grown son's gone!" A ditch. Both literally and metaphorically. Lin Shen fell into a physical ditch with Xu Suinian, and that fall led directly to everything — the connection, the revelations, the fact that his son is now in love with someone connected to that whole situation. And now he's "lost" his son to love. The ditch as origin point for all of this is almost mythological. Then there's the king bed. A piece of furniture that exists only because of a logistical decision (Lu Chengxuan booking a suite instead of two standard rooms) and it becomes the literal site where everything changes. The bed that wasn't supposed to hold two people becomes the bed where confession happens. The bed that creates the problem also creates the solution. And the mess in the living room — scattered cushions, flipped rugs, chaos — it's the physical residue of an emotional explosion. Whatever happened between Wangye and Shi Yuan that night wasn't just a conversation. Something broke open. Something was lost (as Lu Chengxuan overheard). And the aftermath is written all over those overturned cushions. The theme here isn't just "love happens." It's about how the spaces we inhabit — beds, suites, hotel rooms, ditches — become the containers for our most vulnerable moments. The architecture of intimacy.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or