At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong - Reviews

At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Let me just say — the structure of these chapters is doing something very deliberate and I need to unpack it. Chapter 3.3 opens with a question and doesn't give you a satisfying answer. 'When did that worker disappear?' 'Early that morning, the same day you mentioned seeing the girl.' Okay, fine. But then it pivots to Laura's disappearance and this outsider who came to Dupleuri Port and stole something valuable and nobody knows what, from whom, or by whom. The chapter ends with Kailen staring at a window on the third floor and vowing to find this girl. That's a cliffhanger that actually works because it's personal — it's about HIM, not just mystery for mystery's sake. Then chapter 3.4 hits you like a freight train. Same day, different world. The funeral has passed, the dust hasn't settled, and already the vultures are circling. Baron Vens bursts in demanding answers, the Duchess dismantles him with cold precision, and Frances — this scarred, silent boy — is the quiet center of the storm. The pacing here is almost theatrical. Every line of dialogue is a knife being drawn. Every pause is loaded. What's brilliant is how the chapters intercut. 3.3 is all outward movement — investigation, pursuit, mystery. 3.4 is all inward pressure — confined spaces, family secrets, suffocating tension. One expands, the other compresses. And somehow both feel like they're running out of time. The ending of 3.4 — Frances asking 'Mother, may I leave now?' with his voice soft, barely above a whisper — it's the quietest possible moment after the loudest possible confrontation. And that's exactly when you know something big is about to happen.
... Read More
Let me just say — the way this plot twist about the Levique Mine unfolded was absolutely filthy in the best way possible. Frances drops the bomb that the mine is depleted, that investors will swarm, that the Imperial Family will step in, and Valeria — who literally only knows how to spend money — has zero framework to process this. Chef's kiss. But here's what really got me: Frances planted this seed knowing full well she couldn't deliver the message herself. "Would the Duchess believe me if I told her this myself?" No. Of course not. So she hands Valeria the ammunition and walks away clean while Valeria goes to her mother looking like she just discovered fire. The chessboard is moving and Frances is three steps ahead of literally everyone. Meanwhile the subplot with Brady Leric losing Frances and then getting cut during the struggle — that's loose thread energy. Something's coming with that. Also the Duchess choosing an ambitious second-in-command over the loyal knight commander instead of handling things herself? That's a character decision that is going to bite her. I'm here for it.
... Read More
Let me just say this upfront: the Necklace is EVERYTHING and the author knows it and I am SHAKING. Here's the setup: Frances's mother died protecting an emerald-green necklace that proves Frances's lineage. The Wiblow family — her REAL family apparently — won't give up on her. And now Hans wants to sell HER. The stakes went from 'survive the slums' to 'your entire identity and family legacy depend on this one object and you just hid it where a murderer can't find it' in the span of three paragraphs. But the REAL tension isn't about the necklace though. It's about the timeline. Frances has been HERE BEFORE. She knows what happens. She knows about Otis, about Valeria's wedding, about Kailen's death. She's trying to change something — 'This time, it has to be different' — but every step forward feels like walking toward the same fate. The suspense isn't 'what will happen' — it's 'CAN she change it?' And the immediate stakes? Hans is going to come back for the necklace. He doesn't know she buried it at the graveyard. He thinks she's just stalling. He's walking around humming a cheerful tune, planning to sell her to some OLD MAN for a hefty sum. And Frances is in a restaurant washing dishes, counting down the hours until he returns, knowing she has to reclaim that necklace before he finds it, knowing that if she's discovered she's NOT just a slum girl but someone with a claim to nobility — what then? What happens when the Wiblow family finds her? The dual timeline anxiety is killing me. Every scene is layered with dramatic irony. We KNOW things Frances is only just relearning. We SEE Kailen alive and healthy and we can't stop imagining his death. We watch Frances pretend to be compliant while her mind races a thousand miles per hour. The conflict isn't just external — it's the war between the girl who survived once and the woman who has to survive AGAIN, armed only with memories and a broken hand and a necklace buried in dirt. How does she win this time? Because I will NOT — I CANNOT — let her lose again.
... Read More
Okay first of all — Hans. Who IS this man. Let me just say: the man literally threatens a grieving teenager with sexual violence and then offers to help bury her mother IN EXCHANGE FOR HER MOTHER'S BURIAL COSTS. That is not a normal transaction. That is not a normal thought process. And yet Frances handles it like a boss. 'Hans, the man, was covered in sweat, dirt, and ash. What's the matter? This is the payment for the funeral, and the cost of repairing the house is extra.' HE ASKS FOR EXTRA. AFTER WHAT HE DID. AFTER HE JUST BURIED A DEAD WOMAN AND PLANNED TO SELL THE GIRL. And Frances LAUGHS. She literally laughs at his audacity. Can you imagine? seventeen years old, just found your mother's charred body, and you're standing there laughing at a grown man's greed because it's so absurdly funny that it almost breaks you. The dialogue throughout these chapters is SO sharp. Frances's internal voice is completely different from her external voice. Outside, she's cold, calculated, negotiating with thugs. Inside, she's screaming. 'If I hadn't sat there like a fool, I could've stopped it.' That's the Frances who lived through tragedy once — she GUARDS her thoughts like they're weapons. And Laura! I love Laura so much already. She's the bartender who discovers Frances is a girl during dishwashing and immediately starts teasing her about academy boys, but then drops this genuinely compassionate line: 'Your life really is pitiful. Of all people, you had to get caught by that scumbag Hans.' That's not performative kindness. That's someone who's seen enough of the world to know when something is unjust and saying it anyway. The cadet shouting 'You've only had two drinks so far. You can't call yourself a member of Kunst Academy unless you drink at least five!' — perfect worldbuilding through dialogue. You learn about the academy's culture, about Kailen's reputation, about the social dynamics of this place in THREE LINES. And Frances's line to Hans: 'Wouldn't it be scarier if I were in my right mind?' CHILLS. Absolutely chills. That's a person who has survived hell and is using madness as a shield. The author writes her internal monologue in italics like little gasps of consciousness — you can feel the distance between what Frances says and what Frances thinks. It's exhausting to read and I cannot stop.
... Read More
The dialogue in these chapters is layered with meaning on every level and I'm obsessed. Take this exchange from 1.1: 'You look so handsome. Enough to make me fall for you all over again.' 'No way! I looked in the mirror and thought a crow was standing there.' On the surface it's cute couple banter. But rereading it knowing what happens? Otis is performing. He's maintaining the charade right up until the moment he needs to drop it. And Frances? She's the one doing all the emotional labor even here—'You're the only one who tells me I'm beautiful' followed immediately by 'Thank goodness. I'm the only one who recognizes your beauty.' She's anchoring her entire sense of worth to him. Then in 1.2 the dialogue turns razor-sharp. 'What kind of place is this to make a woman with hideous burn scars an Empress? I can't let someone like you leave a stain on my perfect life.' This is the coldest line in the entire text. He's not even pretending anymore. And Frances's response throughout is almost pitiful—'I won't let you get away with this, Otis! I'll kill you!'—half-threat, half-sob. She has no idea who she's talking to anymore. The shift from 'Your Majesty the Emperor!' to raw desperation captures the complete collapse of her world.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is absolutely electric. I keep coming back to the opening scene — the academy plunged into complete darkness, the moon hiding behind clouds, and then this voice booming through a magical loudspeaker announcing the survival test. The visual of all those cadets scrambling, screams echoing, people running blindly through darkness — it read like a film sequence. But the worldbuilding details are what make it land so hard. The Kunst Academy isn't just some fancy magic school. It's a military stronghold. Students operate ships. They fight pirates. There are departments for knights, spirit summoners, AND sorcerers. This is a nation's weapon, not a classroom. And the test itself reflects that — magic paint bullets that make you SCREAM as if you've been shot, senior cadets who have years of military training mercilessly picking off fresh recruits. The detail about the Path of Battle leading directly to the coast, the camellia grove near the cliff, the infirmary as a safe zone — every location feels purposeful, like the entire academy is a chessboard and the author has placed every piece deliberately. What I found most striking was how the environment itself seems alive. The darkness is described as "pure darkness" with an activated magic circle making vision impossible. Then the magic circle's effects are limited to within the academy grounds, which Frances figures out by looking at the direction of the coast rather than the academy itself. The world has rules, and the characters who understand those rules survive. The scene in the infirmary with the moonlight finally emerging, falling softly between them — after all that chaos and darkness, that quiet moment with the crescent moon rising felt almost sacred. The author really knows how to use light and dark as storytelling tools.
... Read More
This chapter is a masterclass in escalating dread. It opens with Frances already trapped in a sack — we don't get the buildup, we drop into the horror mid-scene, and that's a deliberate choice that forces you to lean in instead of pulling back. The pacing inside the drawing room is glacial, almost suffocating. Long pauses. Slow movements. Valeria 'strolling toward the crackling fireplace, her steps light and graceful, as if she were dancing.' The contrast between her languid tempo and the violence she's about to commit makes every second stretch. Then — Bang. Sizzle. Clang. Drip. The onomatopoeia acts like quick cuts in a film, snapping the rhythm from slow-burn to shock. After the violence peaks, the author doesn't rush. The Duchess circles Frances like a vulture, the dialogue slows down to venomous whispers, and we get that devastating mirror scene. Only after Frances has endured everything does the chapter pivot — cut to Kailen at the tavern, completely different tone, different location, but the same question hovering underneath: where is the silver-haired girl? The structure here is essentially two rooms: the Wiblow mansion (past/present intertwining, claustrophobic) and the Red Beard Pirate Tavern (present-day investigation, slightly lighter but ominous). The transition works because both scenes share the same thematic DNA — people searching for someone who doesn't want to be found. But that ending with Rotani revealing Laura disappeared and Kailen getting knocked out? That's a hook so sharp it drew blood. I immediately flipped to the next chapter.
... Read More
The imagery in these chapters is genuinely cinematic and I want to highlight two scenes that will be stuck in my head for weeks. First, the Courtney scene. A head maid snatching clothes from Frances, calling her a lowly thing, and then staring at the scars on Frances's pale body with what the text describes as a 'satisfied smile.' The visual of those red lines across Frances's skin compared to 'blooming flowers' is simultaneously beautiful and horrifying. Courtney is essentially treating torture as aesthetic appreciation. The way the author layers the humiliation—forced to wear rags, forced to undress in front of an abuser, the whisper of 'to think instead of being served by a lowborn I'm forced to serve one'—creates this suffocating atmosphere of domestic tyranny. Second, the Valeria-and-Frances scene with the necklace. Moonlight pouring through the window, the family heirloom diamond pendant glinting in Frances's palm, Brady dropping a yelp when he catches it. There's this almost poetic contrast between the cold beauty of the jewel and the ugliness of the power dynamics around it. Every object in this house is weaponized—the clothes, the whip, the bandages, the diamond. The world itself feels hostile, like the walls are closing in. And Dupleuri, with its South Sea trade routes and new stock exchange, represents this flicker of possibility and freedom just beyond the manor gates. The setting isn't background decoration, it's active pressure.
... Read More
The visual contrast in these chapters is absolutely cinematic. You've got this pristine white wedding dress—Made of white silk from the Kingdom of Benita, lace veil woven over several days, camellia corsages, pearls. Everything is white and perfect and pure. And then it gets drenched in blood. The image of Frances sitting on the floor in that white dress, both wrists severed, the dress turning red—this is the kind of scene that sticks with you for days. Then there's the mask. That white half-mask crafted from ground pearls, covering her burn scars from Valeria. Frances touches it almost reverently in Chapter 1.1, wishing she didn't have it so she could be the 'perfect bride.' And Otis? He pulls it off like it's nothing. The moment the mask comes off and we see the scars—the scars from the magic that burned her—he shoves her face away saying 'get that disgusting face out of my sight.' The cruelty of him having let her wear that mask this long, letting her think it was acceptable, and then using it as the moment to reveal everything is devastating. And the SOUND design—the maids bowing, the knights' iron masks making that 'shrrk' sound as blood spurted, the wedding music and laughter drifting through the window while inside is absolute hell. Heaven and hell separated by a single wall. This author knows how to write atmosphere.
... Read More
The pacing in these chapters is masterful and I want to dissect it because the author clearly knows exactly what they're doing. The opening hits you with anannouncement — immediate stakes, immediate danger, no warm-up. Cadets have to reach a ship before dawn or they fail. Period. Then you get this incredible sequence of escalating tension: the group of cadets finding Kailen and Frances hiding, the screams from the dormitory side, Kailen pinning Frances beneath him in the bushes, Frances discovering the entity on his forehead. Each moment pushes the pace faster, and then — BAM — the entity shatters and everything stops. The pacing drops into this almost surreal silence where Kailen is sitting on the ground processing the fact that he can finally feel mana. The crescent moon rising, the whispers of shouts from all directions pulling them back to reality. That transition from frantic action to quiet awe and back to action again is exactly how you keep readers hooked. And then the infirmary scene — this is where I think the author really earned their keep. After all that running and screaming and near-death experiences, we get a scene where they're just... breathing. Kailen treating a wound. Frances catching her breath. A conversation about what happened. It's the narrative equivalent of letting someone exhale after holding their breath for ten minutes, except that exhale reveals even MORE tension instead of less. The pacing then picks back up as they head toward the coast, with Frances noticing the camellia grove and the whole "us vs individual" conversation happening. Every beat serves the story.
... Read More
"The scars from the burns, still unhealed, were horrifyingly grotesque." I need to talk about this book's relationship with faces because honestly it's obsessed with them and I am HERE for it. Frances's face is wrapped in bandages — hideous, secret, protected. The Duchess's face barely shows emotion, but when her whites go red with rage, you see everything. Baron Vens can't even look at Frances without flinching. And then there's the whole business with Laura's "girl" being possibly connected to someone who vanished into thin air. Everyone in this book is hiding something beneath the surface and the imagery keeps coming back to it. The silver hair — Kailen picks it up off his floor like it's evidence of a crime, like it's the only proof he has that the encounter was real and not some liquor-induced hallucination. Silver hair as a trail marker. As a fingerprint. As something that connects the ghost girl to the missing Laura. And the burns on Frances — sustained while sifting through ASHES to find a body. That image alone is devastating. Fire destroyed everything, and his hands are the proof. But here's the thing: the mine is ALREADY finished. The wealth that held this family's power together is gone. The fire didn't just scar a boy's face — it exposed the emptiness underneath everything they built. The gunpowder that killed the Duke and his legitimate son was meant to SAVE the mine's production. Desperation disguised as duty. "Perhaps at least one of them might have survived." Those words from the Duchess — is she mourning? Or is she calculating? The narrative won't tell us, and that ambiguity is what makes it so good.
... Read More
First of all — ROTANI. Sir, you are the most tired man in fiction and I love him for it. He's literally pulling out his remaining strands of hair, he's feigning ignorance so hard it's painful to watch, he's spraying salt at students trying to enter his tavern like some kind of desperate exorcism. And through ALL of that he's still running a operation, still investigating Laura's disappearance, still trying to piece together who this mysterious outsider was. The man is functioning on fumes and I cannot respect him more. But Kailen — oh man. Here's a kid who has EVERYTHING except the one thing he needs. Top student at Kunst Academy. Spirit of a warrior. Presence of a great swordsman. Can't use aura. In the NORTHERN SEAS where aura is essential for survival against monsters. That's not just a weakness — that's an existential crisis wrapped in a uniform. And then this girl appears. A cold hand on his neck. Silver hair on his floor. His face turns RED and he's simultaneously terrified and determined. 'I'll find her, no matter what.' This kid is about to get himself killed and I need him to be more careful. Now the Wiblow family dynamics are something else entirely. The Duchess — Valeria — playing the grieving widow while secretly despising the illegitimate son she's forced to take in. Her shoes are 'excessively ornate' because all her unfulfilled desires have been projected onto her footwear. That detail alone tells you everything about a woman who smiles while her soul rots. And Frances, watching her, biting his own cheek until it bleeds to suppress a smirk. He sees through EVERYONE and says nothing. These characters are all wearing masks and none of them trust each other. And that's the beauty of it.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or