At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong - Reviews

At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need a moment. The part where the Duchess and Valeria literally clink wine glasses like it's a toast after torturing a child and calling it 'generous' is something I will not recover from. But what wrecked me emotionally wasn't even the violence — it was the tenderness between those two women. Valeria wrapping her arm around the Duchess, the mother patting her hand, sharing this intimate little joke about magic scars no healer can touch. They glow at each other. They BLOOM. And Frances is there, kneeling in her own blood, being called 'the mark of his infidelity' like she's a stain on a carpet rather than a person. The Duchess asking 'Could your pain ever surpass mine, having lost my son?' is supposed to be cruel, and it is, but the real horror is how empty that grief sounds next to the warm, almost loving dynamic between Valeria and herself. Frances is alone in that room in every possible sense — abandoned by her dead father's memory, hunted by the mother who despises her, used by the sister who owns her body now. And yet. She doesn't scream. She bites her lip until it splits. She holds Brady's gaze in the mirror afterwards like she's making a deal with the devil without saying a word. That silent defiance is the most heartbreaking thing I've read all year. She's already planning her next move while her face is still healing.
... Read More
Okay so this opening hit me like a truck. The narrator starts by painting Frances as this terrifying villainess—poisoning the Crown Prince, strangling his beloved, beheading him while holding his dead lover's corpse. Like, she's literally laughing atop rivers of blood. And then we cut to Chapter 1.1 and she's putting on wedding shoes. The contrast is *chef's kiss*. You think you're reading a Villainess Isekai with a happy ending, and then by Chapter 1.2 Otis cuts off both her wrists and reveals the whole thing was a setup. This plot twist though—she did ALL of this for him, killed Noah, destroyed Kailen Duvel, and he NEVER asked her to do any of it. He just said 'if only Kailen wasn't around' and she took the initiative to murder him. The audacity of that man is insane.
... Read More
Let's talk about what's actually at stake here because this is NOT a 'she might get caught pretending to be a boy' story anymore. Frances just got permanently disfigured. She can never go back to being the orphan girl from the slums, and she can never be Frances Wiblow the male heir in any normal sense — her face alone guarantees that. The stakes have gone from 'danger of exposure' to 'her body is now a weapon and a cage simultaneously.' She is trapped inside a role that literally scarred her to fit. And the Duchess knows it — that's why she's so satisfied. Frances has zero exit strategy now. Run away? She's unrecognizable and branded. Refuse? They've already proven they'll burn her face again. The only card she has is the information she's gathering, and the fact that Brady just silently switched his loyalty because he saw something in her refusal to break. But wait — the stakes just got worse in the parallel timeline. Laura, the girl with silver hair and green eyes who worked at the tavern, disappeared. Kailen is hunting for her and he got unconscious by someone matching that description. Is this the same Frances we're talking about, or is there a time loop, alternate identity, someone else with that appearance? Because if the Frances being scarred in one timeline is the same girl who blacked out a nobleman in another, then the stakes aren't just personal survival anymore — they're about whether these two timelines are colliding and what happens when the Duchess finds out her 'son' is also the girl haunting Kailen's world. I genuinely do not know what to believe anymore and I love it.
... Read More
I am genuinely heartbroken for Frances and also kind of furious at Otis. Let me explain. Everything Frances did—every drop of blood on her hands—was because she wanted his love. The narration literally says: 'like a dog, she submitted, and like a beggar, she pleaded. All for the gaze, affection, and love of just one person.' And Otis? He played her. Like, he let her believe he was her knight in shining armor, the one person who saw her worth despite everything. When he proposed and publicly declared her his woman even after she was revealed as a woman facing fierce criticism from nobles—that was her moment of true hope. That's the memory she's holding onto while bleeding out on the floor. And the worst part? Frances's first thought when knights burst in is to protect OTIS. Even as they come for HER, she tries to shield HIM. That's how deep the conditioning goes. She's been so thoroughly manipulated that her instinct is still to serve him. And his response? 'You killed them just for that reason?' Like he's disappointed she was too sloppy to hide her devotion. This isn't just betrayal, this is the systematic destruction of someone's entire sense of self-worth.
... Read More
The stakes in this test are ridiculously high and the author makes it clear from the very first line. This isn't some school competition where you lose points — people are SCREAMING as if they've been shot. Yes, the bullets are made of magic paint, but the terror is real. The senior cadets have years of military training and they are OUT HERE hunting fresh recruits with zero remorse. Frances witnesses countless "deaths" — people collapsing, screaming, eliminated from the test. And the worst part? She's one of them. She's exhausted, she can barely detect people nearby, her stamina is gone from the carriage journey, and she's expected to survive a night-long hunt across a military academy. The internal conflict is just as intense though. Frances knows she owes Kailen — she wanted to return to the academy partly to protect him — but every instinct tells her not to trust anyone. She's been surviving alone for so long that the idea of partnership feels alien. And Kailen? He's torn between his pride, his resentment about being assigned to a "talentless" student, and this overwhelming new sensation of mana flowing through him because of HER. The moment he releases her wrist — the one he gripped so hard it bruised — and sits there breathing shallowly, you can feel the weight of everything unsaid between them. What happens if she fails? What happens if he fails? The consequences aren't spelled out explicitly, but the atmosphere makes it clear: failure here isn't just about not getting into the academy. It's about survival itself. And the final image of them walking together in the dark, reaching toward the coast, with the concept of "us" hanging between them like a question mark — that tension between individual survival and collective strength is what makes every page impossible to put down.
... Read More
Okay can we talk about Valeria because this girl is a menace and I cannot look away. She's literally circling Frances like a shark in a hallway and calling it conversation. "I was shocked. Where did you learn such noble etiquette?" — she's poking and prodding, waiting for Frances to slip, and the worst part is I think Valeria genuinely doesn't know whether to hate her or be intrigued. That moment when she demonstrates the Duke's teacup grip and says "Perhaps she's had tea with Father multiple times" — her voice is so calm and elegant while her words are straight-up accusatory. The Duchess losing it on the floor while Valeria watches with that indifferent expression? Chilling. This relationship between the two girls is so layered. Valeria isn't just a generic mean sister — she's sharp, observant, and apparently the only one in that house who might actually be connecting the dots about Frances's true identity. I'm already bracing for when these two finally stop dancing around each other and go full war.
... Read More
There are so many layers I need to unpack here. Fire as transformation and punishment — Valeria uses the poker to brand Frances, literally reshaping her through flame, but fire in this novel isn't just destruction. The blue flames she creates with that magician's powder suggest alchemy, transmutation. She's not just maiming Frances; she's forging her into something new. The mirror is the second key symbol. Frances sees her own face after the burning — bloodshot eyes, raw scar, disfigured — and through that mirror, her eyes meet Brady's. Mirrors in literature always mean identity crisis, self-recognition, duality. Frances is looking at the girl she was and can never be again, while simultaneously making a silent pact with the one person who might become her ally. And then there's the dead son — the ghost of the real Frances Wiblow hangs over every single line of this chapter. The Duchess mourns him but loves Valeria. She wanted a son and got a girl. She got a girl who looks more like her dead husband than her dead son ever did. The replacement isn't just about succession; it's about the mother's inability to let go of the dead while using the living as vessels for her grief. 'Congratulations on becoming my brother, Frances' — this isn't just deception, it's necromancy of a sort. The dead heir lives on through a scarred girl in a sack. The rain outside, the funeral that just ended, the mourning clothes still on — death and rebirth are happening in the same room, and Frances is the sacrifice at the altar of both.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or