At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong - Reviews

At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The imagery in this section is absolutely cinematic and I need to talk about the color palette the author built. We've got red blood falling like petals—frankly that comparison is horrifying because petals suggest beauty and romance, but here it's just a trail leading to death. The cold stone floor of the tower, the blue-tinged skin where magic touches her wounds, the white wedding dress visible through the barred window below, the black smoke of the slum fire in chapter 2. Every scene is defined by this clash between warmth and cold, purity and corruption. The wedding scene below is described with such specific, almost painful detail—the half-mask, the veil woven over months, the shoes peeking out—and all of it is designed for Frances but worn by Valeria. That visual parallel between Frances's blood-soaked dress and the pristine white gown below is the kind of imagery that sticks with you. And then chapter 2 drops us into the slum fire, snow turning to ash, the frozen ground melting into a foul stench. The world feels lived-in because every location has texture and temperature. You can feel the cold stone under Frances's bare feet and the heat of the fire on her skin.
... Read More
There are so many layers here that I only caught on rereading. The entity on Kailen's forehead is absolutely symbolic — it's this dark, concentrated mass that represents everything blocking him from accessing his true power. And when Frances touches it, it doesn't just disappear; it SHATTERS and spreads throughout his entire body. This feels like the author is saying that what was holding Kailen back wasn't some external curse or constitutional flaw — it was something contained, something that could be broken open. Frances, the person everyone dismissed as talentless, is the one who shatters it. The imagery of something broken and scattered becoming something whole and dispersed is powerful. Then there's the recurring motif of darkness. The magic circle creates pure darkness, the moon hides behind clouds, and characters can't see each other's faces. But Frances — somehow — can still see what's on Kailen's forehead. Her ability to perceive what others cannot is literally illuminated in the darkness. And then the moon finally emerges at the end, casting light between them. Light returning at the moment of connection. The concept of "us" versus the individual runs through everything. The Kunst Academy values individual ability above all else — knights, spirit summoners, sorcerers, each department competing. But this test, whatever its true purpose, seems to be demanding something different. Entrusting your back to a comrade. The fractured nobles (Noah and Otis), the invisible fractures in the academy — the story is suggesting that the old way of doing things is breaking apart, and only through genuine partnership can they survive. That bitter smile Kailen has at the end? It's not just about the test. It's about understanding that the world he knew is shifting beneath his feet.
... Read More
"The sunlight streaming in after the rain was painfully beautiful." I need a minute. That line hit me so hard in the middle of this whole toxic hallway confrontation. Frances just got burned alive by her step-sister, her face is a mess of oozing blisters, she's playing pretend to be a fragile noble girl, AND the author puts in a moment about beautiful sunlight like the world hasn't stopped making sense outside these walls. It's got such a cinematic quality — you can see the light cutting through the corridor, the dark shadow Valeria casts over Frances, the contrast between the gorgeous outside world and the rot happening inside this house. And earlier when Frances says "I'm not feeling well" while wiping a forehead that isn't even sweating — that desperate theatrical gesture to escape — it paints this whole estate as this gilded cage where every movement is performance. The long empty corridor where Valeria circles Frances, the drawing room with the lavish rose-patterned teacup, the Duchess pressing her temples like she's holding back an explosion — every space feels loaded with meaning. This world doesn't just exist, it presses in on you.
... Read More
I'm obsessed with how Kailen speaks throughout this entire sequence. His dialogue is spare, almost clinical, and it contrasts so beautifully with Frances's emotional flooding. When he says 'That night... I wasn't mistaken. The woman I saw... was you,' there's this hesitation in the ellipses that makes it feel like he's barely holding onto the words. His voice is described as 'damaged from prolonged torture, sounded like metal scraping against metal' and that physical description carries into every line he delivers. Even his jokes—'The wound you left me with was indeed severe'—come out flat and dry, which makes them land harder because we know he's dying. Meanwhile Frances's dialogue is all fragmentation and breathlessness. 'Hic... Ugh.' 'What have I done?' Her sentences fall apart the way her body is falling apart. The author lets their speech patterns do the character work. Kailen's clipped precision versus Frances's unraveling monotone. And that final line from him, delivered almost gently: 'Next time you make a wish, make it for your own happiness.' It's the most honest thing either of them says, and it comes from the person who has nothing left to lose.
... Read More
I cannot even. The entrance exam at Kunst Academy is absolutely brutal, and I loved every second of it. The dean announces this insane test — everyone has to reach the Finima before dawn, doors locked, no mercy — and the shift from the normal academy life to full-on survival mode was so jarring in the best way. What really got me though is how the plot uses this exam as a pressure cooker to force Frances and Kailen together. At the beginning, Kailen is visibly annoyed about being assigned as Frances's mentor. He doesn't want her there, doesn't think she deserves to pass. But then — and this is the moment that completely flipped everything — Frances touches something on his forehead and shatters this dark entity, and Kailen suddenly FEELS mana for the first time in his life. No mage, no alchemist had ever figured it out, and THIS talentless girl just did it with a touch? That single plot point transforms their entire dynamic. Kailen goes from reluctant guardian to someone who now has a deeply personal reason to ensure she survives. The line where he clenches his fist and then slowly opens it again — you could literally feel his mind working, calculating what this meant. And then the test itself introduces this theme about "us" over individual ability, which seems totally at odds with how the Kunst Academy has operated up to this point. I'm not sure if the test creator is being poetic or if there's something darker going on here, but either way, the story is setting up some serious fractures between how the academy works and what it's supposed to teach. The plot is moving fast but never feels rushed, and every revelation comes right when it's needed most.
... Read More
Okay so Valeria is honestly one of the most terrifying characters I've come across in this story and not because she's some cartoon villain cackling in a corner. She's calculated, yeah, but what really gets me is how she wields sweetness like a scalpel. The scene where she visits Frances while the doctor changes her bandages—she's practically radiating 'concerned sister' energy in front of the doctor, but the second he leaves she drops the act completely and starts dissecting Frances's face like it's a puzzle she's proud of solving. But here's what really blew my mind: Valeria is also a pawn who doesn't know she's being played. She thinks she's outmaneuvering everyone by pushing for the mine sale, by trying to prove herself to the Duchess. Meanwhile Frances is three steps ahead the entire time, handing Valeria what looks like insider information about the South Sea stock exchange while quietly setting her up to take the fall if things go south. "If I were God, I wouldn't have left pointless scars on her cheek. I would've placed meaningful ones in places that would never be forgotten." — I keep coming back to this line. Valeria thinks she's the smartest person in the room and that quote proves it. She literally views cruelty as an art form and self-awareness isn't really her strong suit. That's what makes her so dangerous and so tragic at the same time.
... Read More
I need to talk about this ONE moment because it absolutely wrecked me. After Brady leaves, after all the scheming and plotting and sharp words, Frances is alone in her room and the text says: "Though she pretended to act unaffected, her burned face, branded by Valeria, felt like it was on fire. Even in the fire that had killed her mother, she had survived without a single injury. Yet her face, ruined by her half-sister's hands, throbbed in pain every night." And then she hides her bandaged face and lets out a beast-like sob. That's it. That's the whole emotional payload of these chapters right there. Everything else—the schemes, the manipulation, the academy entrance drama—is just surface noise. The real story is a girl who survived an inferno that killed her mother, who rebuilt herself from nothing, and who is now being slowly destroyed by someone she's supposed to call family. What hit me hardest wasn't even the physical abuse. It was the loneliness. She has no one. Courtney hates her, Valeria is actively torturing her, her father is dead, and the Duchess treats her like garbage. Brady is the only person who shows up unannounced and actually seems to care, and even he's unreliable. The emotional isolation is suffocating and the author doesn't let up for a single page. I literally had to stop reading for a bit. Frances deserved so much better and it made my chest hurt.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this — I am NOT okay after reading these chapters. The stakes are so suffocatingly high in both plotlines it genuinely made me sit back and stare at the ceiling. In chapter 3.3, you've got Laura vanishing, an unknown outsider slipping into Dupleuri Port, something valuable stolen, and we don't know WHO was stolen from, WHAT was taken, or WHO the thief even is. That's a triple mystery stacked on top of each other and Rotani looks like he's about to have a full nervous breakdown over it. Meanwhile Kailen — the kid who literally CANNOT use aura, which for a swordsman from the Northern Seas is basically like being born without legs — he encounters a ghost girl in his own home. A cold hand on his neck, he passes out, and wakes up with silver hair on his floor. Is she an assassin? A ghost? Something else entirely? And what does she want? Then chapter 3.4 drops us into the Wiblow mansion and the stakes just... escalate. Baron Vens wants the dukedom. The Duchess has been hiding her son Frances — an illegitimate child with burn scars, who survived a carriage explosion involving gunpowder meant for a failing mine. The Council is involved. People are planning to poison the heir. And the whole family is playing house while rotting from the inside. The best part? These two storylines are clearly heading toward the same collision. The silver-haired girl Kailen saw. Laura. Rotani's investigation. The Wiblow conspiracy. I swear every time I turn a page another thread tightens and I can't breathe.
... Read More
There's this recurring motif throughout these chapters that I can't stop thinking about: fire and its relationship to identity. Frances survived a fire that killed her mother and came out physically untouched, but Valeria burned her face and now Frances carries the visible marks of that violence every single day. The author keeps drawing this parallel—fire as destruction versus fire as transformation—and I think the deeper question the story is asking is: what makes you who you are? Is it your lineage, your looks, your position in the family hierarchy? Frances was born a bastard, marked by birth just as surely as Valeria marked her face. But the face scars are chosen violence, intentional cruelty designed to make Frances unrecognizable and therefore powerless. And yet Frances keeps going. Keeps planning. Keeps outmaneuvering everyone. The necklace is another loaded symbol. It represents the Wiblow family's legitimacy, the dynastic inheritance that Frances is systematically divesting herself from. When she tells Brady to sell it and invest in the South Sea, she's literally converting old aristocratic wealth into something new and uncertain. It's a rejection of the system that gave her nothing. And the academy itself—Kunst Academy—stands for the meritocratic ideal that noble families claim to uphold but systematically corrupt. Frances is about to walk into a space that should reward talent, and the entire structure is rigged against her. The tension between what the academy represents and what it actually is mirrors the tension between what nobility promises and what it delivers.
... Read More
Can we just appreciate how DIFFERENT every character sounds here because the dialogue writing is serving me? The Duchess opens with 'How dare a mere woman have the same name as my son' — immediately establishes her as entitled, status-obsessed, and completely lacking in self-awareness. Her voice is sharp, clipped, dripping with aristocratic contempt. Then Valeria is in a completely different register: slow, drawling, almost playful. 'Perhaps this is for the best, Mother.' 'Turn a girl into a man? Don't tell me you've been meeting with those strange magicians again!' She speaks like she's enjoying a game only she understands. And the lines she drops are basically poetry wrapped in threat: 'It's a matter of making her my brother. As her older sister, shouldn't I take care of this myself?' The word 'sister' used as both affection and weapon. Brady's internal monologue is functional, observant — he notices things but doesn't philosophize. And Frances? She barely speaks at all, which somehow makes her presence louder. Her silence IS her voice in this scene. When she finally does respond, it's a broken 'N-no' to the Duchess's torture, and it hits different because we know she's lying through her teeth. The narrative voice itself is worth noting — it's close third person but dips into Frances's interiority just enough to make us feel every burn without drowning us in exposition. The author knows when to show and when to let the reader's imagination do the heavy lifting. The 'Sizzle.' and 'Drip.' as standalone lines? Those aren't just onomatopoeia, they're punctuation for trauma.
... Read More
This whole passage is soaked in symbols and I can't stop thinking about what the Mermaid's Tear actually represents. On the surface it's a magical object Frances desperately wanted to save Noah, but the deeper reading is about wishes themselves. Kailen's dying advice—that she should wish for her own happiness—reframes the entire story as a tragedy about misdirected love. Frances spent her life wishing for others, and every wish cost her something more. The tear is sharp enough to tear her throat when she swallows it, which feels symbolic: using self-destruction as an act of love is still self-destruction. The wedding mask is another layer—Valeria literally wearing Frances's stolen face at her wedding means Frances's identity was consumed by everyone around her. She wasn't just robbed of love, she was robbed of self. And the tower itself, the highest point of the imperial palace, is where she meets the person who actually sees her. Not Otis who used her, not Noah who died because of her, but Kailen who loved her despite everything she did. The height suggests isolation but also clarity—in that tower, stripped of everything, Frances finally understands what she was living for.
... Read More
I need to talk about how the author handles pacing here because it is WILD. Chapter 1.1 spends a long time building this almost romantic, fairytale wedding atmosphere. We're getting all the details—the shoes, the dress, the maids praising Frances, Otis walking in with those violet eyes, the tender moments where he strokes her hair. It feels like a slow-burn romance. And then Chapter 1.2 hits like a freight train. The shift happens almost immediately with that one line 'it doesn't matter now' and Otis's tone changing. Within a few paragraphs we go from wedding prep to double wrist-severing to public betrayal. The cliffhanger at the end of 1.1 is also genius—'Was it a little softer than this?' Otis tilting his head at Frances's hair while thinking about the previous night. At first you think this is some weird romantic detail, but by 1.2 it clearly refers to something much darker. That recontextualization is brilliant. The author is playing with reader expectations on a structural level here—making us feel safe before yanking the rug out. I stayed up until 2am reading because I needed to know what happened to Frances.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or