At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong - Reviews

At That Time, It Was Right, But Now It's Wrong
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I have to applaud the author's dialogue writing because everyone sounds distinct and the subtext is always doing heavy lifting. Let me just dump some of my favorite exchanges because honestly they're too good not to quote. Frances to Valeria about the burns: "God is truly merciful, isn't He? If the eyes had been burned, she wouldn't be able to see. If the nose had been burned, she wouldn't be able to breathe or smell. And if the mouth had been burned, she wouldn't be able to eat and would've died." This is Frances speaking, and it's delivered with this calm, almost clinical tone that's absolutely chilling. She's not begging, not crying—she's analyzing her own mutilation like a mathematician solving an equation. The voice here is so distinctly Frances: precise, guarded, hiding fury behind logic. Then Valeria's reply: "Exactly. If I were God, I wouldn't have left pointless scars on her cheek. I would've placed meaningful ones in places that would never be forgotten." Valeria's voice is different—arrogant, performative, almost theatrical. She's enjoying this conversation. She's showing off. And the Braddy exchange about the necklace: "At least a thousand gold coins? No, maybe even ten thousand?" — "Five hundred." The economy of that dialogue is perfect. One line from Braddy showing his greed, one from Frances shattering it. No explanation needed. Their dynamic is entirely conveyed through rhythm and timing. The author never lets dialogue become exposition dumps. Even when characters are explaining plots (the mine, the stocks, the academy), it feels natural because it's always tied to their motives.
... Read More
Okay I need to talk about Kailen because my heart is literally hurting right now and I am NOT okay. Frances sees him at the restaurant, surrounded by his buddies, looking young and boyish and completely unaware of what's coming, and she just freezes. And then Laura says something that absolutely wrecked me — Frances confesses, out of nowhere, that Kailen was the FIRST person to tell her to prioritize her own happiness. THE FIRST. Like, think about that for a second. This is a girl who has been used and discarded and survived on sheer force of will, and somehow this guy saw her worth when literally no one else did. But here's the part that has me absolutely losing it: 'His death had begun with Frances.' She knows it. She's carrying that guilt like it's some physical weight inside her chest. And he — this beautiful, chivalrous idiot — still wished for her happiness even as he was dying. Even after she pushed him to that fate. He never abandoned his principles until the very end, and she callously labels herself 'utter corruption as a sword bearer.' The self-loathing in that line is so thick I can taste it. And then the broken cup cuts her hand and she's suddenly transported back to when her wrist was SEVERED. The parallel between that moment of physical pain and this small cut is devastating. She's not just remembering — she's reliving. Every sensation, every flashback, all of it crashing over her at once while Laura is fussing around her with first aid and she's miles away in her own head. I can't. I genuinely cannot. The fact that he told her to live for herself and she spent her whole life sacrificing everything for everyone else... that's not dramatic irony, that's emotional warfare. And now she's back in the past, seeing him alive and breathing, and she has to pretend she doesn't know how this ends. She has to stand there and watch him laugh and drink and be YOUNG while she carries the memory of his death on her shoulders alone. This CP? This dynamic? It's devastating because it's built on genuine care and mutual sacrifice and neither of them even realizes what the other has done for them. Kailen wanted Frances to be happy. Frances destroyed everything for love of family. Both of them were wrong and both of them were right and now they're stuck in a loop where neither can escape the consequences of the other's choices. How am I supposed to keep reading like this?
... Read More
Let's talk about Kailen Duvel because this man is something else. Everything Frances did to him—she framed him, destroyed his name, erased him from history, put him in chains—and when they meet at the end, what does he do? He doesn't rage. He doesn't gloat. He says 'At least I was never betrayed by my lord, Frances Wiblow.' That line hit me like a truck. He's standing there, dying, and his biggest satisfaction isn't revenge, it's that he stayed loyal. That's not a simple grudge match, that's a guy whose moral core survived torture. And then he offers her the Mermaid's Tear, the thing he had the whole time. 'I always wanted to give it to you.' What kind of person does that even? Meanwhile Frances is down on her knees, missing both hands, begging for forgiveness she knows she'll never get accepted. Their whole dynamic is built on this unbearable gap between what she did and what he deserves. She ruined his life and he still sees her as someone worth protecting. The power balance between them is so inverted and it makes every word he says cut twice as deep.
... Read More
Okay let me just — Valeria picking up that poker and pressing it to Frances's face is the single most unhinged, perfectly choreographed moment in this entire arc. Not the Duchess. Not Brady. The girl who was sprawled on the couch like she was watching a soap opera goes full executioner and no one can even react in time. And the line she delivers afterward, 'Congratulations on becoming my brother, Frances,' delivered with this almost tender smile, is pure villainy wrapped in silk. But here's what gets me: the plot doesn't just throw us a 'she's disfigured now, oops' moment. It's surgical. Valeria specifically chose a scar that makes Frances look more like her dead father, the Duke, than her own brother ever did. She didn't just hide Frances's identity — she reshaped it into something that serves the Wiblow agenda better than the original Frances could have. The Duchess realizing her discomfort came from Frances looking MORE like her husband than her actual son died is chef's kiss plotting. This isn't a setback for Frances, it's a terrifying upgrade. And I am absolutely shaking that this girl is now walking around with permanent disfigurement and an entire noble house treating her as disposable infrastructure. What happens when they realize the illusion has cracks?
... Read More
Okay so the Frances-Kailen dynamic in these chapters is genuinely incredible and I need to talk about it. Let's start with the physicality of their interactions because WOW. Kailen grabs her wrist during the entity-shattering moment — and the text specifically says it would "undoubtedly bruise by tomorrow" — and then later, when he's treating her wound in the infirmary, his hands are impossibly careful. These are the same hands. The contrast alone tells you everything about how his feelings have shifted. He goes from roughly throwing her through a window to kneeling in front of her, asking permission before touching her face, and meticulously cleaning a wound that was emitting a "foul odor." And his expression doesn't change at all — not disgust, not hesitation, just pure focus. That's character development you don't need a thousand words to explain. But what really got me was Frances's perspective too. She's exhausted beyond belief, she's been through trauma, she's barely keeping up, and yet she's still the one noticing things Kailen isn't. She spots the camellia grove, she reads the magic circle's limitations, she asks the direct question about finding an ally when Kailen is clearly struggling with the "us" concept. The line "For her, who had endured each day just to survive, the concept of 'us' felt like something that belonged to a distant world" absolutely wrecked me. This is someone who has never trusted anyone, and the story is forcing her to learn to entrust her back to a person who literally called her talentless two paragraphs earlier. Their banter is also perfect — Frances's sarcastic remark about the test creator being "unnecessarily romantic" and Kailen actually chuckling? Those tiny moments of levity in the middle of chaos tell you more than any dramatic confession ever could.
... Read More
I need to process this ending because I am genuinely not okay. Frances has been living her entire life for other people—begging for Otis's love, hoping for Noah's approval, sacrificing everything for everyone around her. And in her final moment, Kailen tells her the exact thing she needed to hear: 'Next time you make a wish, make it for your own happiness, not for someone else's, Wiblow.' The tragedy is that she literally can't do that. Not because she won't, but because her entire identity has been constructed around self-erasure. So what does she do? She looks at Kailen dying at her feet and wishes for HIS peace. She swallows that sharp gem, tears her throat open, and dies wishing for someone else's happiness. The emotional logic here is devastating because it's so true to who she is. She couldn't change. And the layer about Valeria—the half-sister wearing Frances's face at her wedding, the crowd praising the woman who destroyed Frances's beauty—that's the final nail. Every desire Frances ever had was taken from her, used against her, and celebrated by everyone she knew. Her last act of love was also her final surrender.
... Read More
'The winter wind blowing from the port was biting cold, but it was perfect for facing reality.' I keep coming back to this line. It's not flashy or overwrought — it's just THERE, sitting between Frances saying goodbye to her mother and deciding what she's going to do next. The cold wind isn't weather. It's atmosphere. It's the story telling you that this is the moment everything changes, that the numbness is about to crack and she's going to have to feel everything all at once. And Camellia Hill — God, I love that name. A communal burial ground with NO GRAVESTONES. Just dirt mounds and camellia trees trembling in the wind. Frances patting Iris's grave gently, whispering goodbye, and the man behind her growing restless because he's thinking about profit. The contrast between sacred and mercenary in one scene is brutal. Then there's the slums themselves. Hans's house 'always been on the verge of collapse' but he claims fire destroyed it. The fact that the city hall didn't even send anyone to investigate when a fire broke out tells you everything you need to know about Dupleuri's port district. These people are invisible. They burn, they die, nobody comes. The restaurant scene is so vivid too — the noise, the students from Kunst Academy flooding in, the competitive drinking culture, the smell of strong liquor mixing with sweat and cheap food. Laura's place feels REAL. You can hear the clatter of dishes, see the steam rising from the kitchen, feel the cramped staircase Frances has to climb. It's not described in detail — it's described THROUGH action and sound and texture. And that final image of Frances watching Hans turn the corner before following Laura up to her new prison... the door closing. The key being thrust in front of her. Room 304, the last room on the third floor. Like she's being assigned a cell. The worldbuilding here doesn't INFO-DUMP. It sneaks up on you through every scene. You learn about the empire, the knight academy, the social hierarchy, the corruption — all through what Frances TOUCHES and SEES and ENDURES. That's how you write setting. That's how you make a place feel alive instead of illustrated.
... Read More
This whole passage is drenched in fire imagery and I'm convinced it's not accidental. Frances's mother died in flames. Frances was burned alive by her own step-sister. The Duke is searching for something with explosives. Wiblow's wealth — built on fire-mining diamonds — is literally running out. Fire is creation and destruction simultaneously, and that's exactly what Frances is: a woman forged in fire trying to burn this house down from the inside. Then there's the teacup. The Duchess's entire identity is wrapped up in porcelain propriety — the rose-patterned cups, the perfect etiquette, the controlled glares. But Valeria demonstrates that teacup grip and the Duchess collapses. The facade cracks because the one thing she thought was hers — her husband's mannerisms, his attention — belonged to someone else. The mine itself is the ultimate symbol: a source of wealth that looks endless from the outside but is hollow underneath. Just like the Wiblow family. Just like the Duchess's marriage. Just like Frances's imposed identity as a sickly boy. Everyone in this story is wearing something that's running dry.
... Read More
I need to sit with this for a moment. "Each syllable was carefully enunciated, spat out with deliberate venom." Frances calling the Duchess 'Mother' isn't a word of affection — it's a weapon. And the text literally tells us she's imbuing it with the memory of her biological mother who "perished in flames." Flames. Fire. The same fire that killed her real mother is the same fire that Valeria just used on HER face. The layers of betrayal and violence tied to fire in this story are stacking up and I am not okay. But what wrecked me was the moment after Frances exits and finally lets herself breathe. "Her entire body ached as if she had been beaten." Not emotionally — physically. All that tension, all that performed fragility, it was draining her dry. She couldn't even bring herself to lie down. Just closed her eyes and let the darkness take her. That's not resilience, that's survival mode running on fumes. And Valeria? The girl who torture-laughed through the whole hallway scene — she also saw her dead brother in Frances and got confused. Two broken girls orbiting each other in a house full of ghosts. I'm a mess.
... Read More
The stakes in these chapters are layered like an onion and each layer makes the previous one feel inadequate. Let's break this down because the escalation is brutal. On the surface level, Frances needs to pass the Kunst Academy entrance exam. But we know from the text that this exam is notoriously difficult—people fail three or four times—and if she fails, Brady's entire gamble collapses. So it's not just Frances's future, it's Brady's survival too. Layer two: the family power struggle. The Duchess is consolidating control faster than anyone expected, backed by the knight captain. Every move Frances makes is happening under the watchful eye of someone who could have her killed. The mine sale to Baron Vens is part of this larger maneuvering, and if Valeria's investment scheme fails, the Duchess won't just be disappointed—she'll be ruthless. Layer three, and this is the one that got me: Frances is literally being erased. Her face is being destroyed, her clothes are rags, she has no allies inside the manor. Yet she's orchestrating financial schemes, manipulating her half-sister, preparing for an exam that could change everything. The tension comes from knowing how precarious her position is while watching her play 4D chess with people who think she's a pawn. "The moment you sell it, the Duchess will have you killed." That line from Frances to Brady is the thesis statement for the entire situation. Death is not hyperbole here—it's a realistic risk. And still Frances keeps moving forward, which makes every scene feel electric with danger.
... Read More
Okay so I need to just talk about this tower scene because honestly it wrecked me. Frances gets thrown into the highest tower, both hands gone, bleeding out, and she expects to die alone—classic tragic heroine setup, right? But then she opens her eyes and Kailen is THERE. Like, chained to a wall with an iron ball, coughing blood, probably hours from dying himself. The writer could have made this a clean break where they never see each other again, but instead they find each other at the absolute worst possible moment. And the timing! Otis's wedding bells are literally ringing while they're up there dying together. The parallel cuts so deep—I keep thinking about how the cheers from below are for Valeria, the half-sister who stole Frances's face, and Frances is just... lying in her own blood watching through a window. The structure here is brutal in the best way. Every beat undercuts whatever hope the character has left. First she thinks she'll join Noah and Kailen in death, then discovers Kailen survived, then realizes he's the one who supposedly killed Noah, then he apologizes to HER, then she swallows the gem and dies wishing for his peace. The plot doesn't give a single gift without taking two things away first.
... Read More
I want to just sit in the imagery of these chapters for a minute because the atmosphere is absolutely dripping. Dupleuri Port hits you right away — there's this twilight coastline where Kailen walks home and the waves come crashing in only to retreat quickly, 'as if mocking his determination.' I keep coming back to that line. The ocean doesn't care that this kid can't use aura. The sea monsters don't care. Nature is indifferent and the writing makes that feel visceral. The Red Beard Pirate Tavern itself feels like a character. Rotani sprinkling salt as he shows Kailen out — why does that image stick with me? It's such a small, weird detail. A man running a tavern by the sea, throwing salt behind departing customers like some superstitious ritual. It makes the place feel lived-in and ancient and slightly unhinged. Then we cut to the Wiblow mansion and the contrast is BRUTAL. Oppressive silence. Black dresses buttoned to the neck. Crimson lips that look alluring only because everything else is drained of color. The first-floor reception room is the only place that isn't gloomy — except the gloom is so thick it's palpable, pressing against the walls like humidity. Baron Vens screaming like a demon while the Duchess sits perfectly still, and Frances — wrapped in bandages like a mummy — watching everything with those sharp green eyes. And the sunlight! That warm sunlight hitting Frances's burn scars, making the pus feel sticky and real, while he's sitting there pretending to drink tea he never touches. The sensory contrast between the warmth outside and the rot inside — that's the whole book in one image.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or