A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me - Reviews

A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
The chapter structure is almost brutalist in its efficiency. You go from a high-stakes political confrontation—heizen facing down an entire noble family, the marquis laying down conditions about respect and violent retribution if his daughter is harmed—to Rizle accidentally propositioning him for a private conversation, to him literally pinning her against a door, to both of them completely derailing from whatever they intended to do. That transition didn't feel earned through foreshadowing. It felt LIKE real life. The kind of moment where everything you planned falls apart because human beings are chaotic and horny and tired of pretending otherwise. The pacing choice to cut the scene at 'her curiosity got the better of her' is aggressive. We don't get the answer to his question. We don't get her response. The chapter ENDS on a cliffhanger that's both romantic and deeply uncomfortable. He asked her a question about whether she desires him, and she's about to say something she may not fully understand herself. Meanwhile the political subplot doesn't disappear—it's simmering beneath every interaction. The marquis's threat ('I will mobilize all the power of Thruella') echoes in the background even as Heizen and Rizle stumble through awkward romantic territory. Two storylines running parallel, occasionally colliding, never letting you forget that none of this exists in a vacuum. The hunting invitation interruption before Rizle can speak to Heizen alone is a masterclass in comic relief deployed as structural tension. It delays the emotional payoff just enough to make it land harder.
... Read More
There's a lot happening beneath the surface in these chapters if you're willing to look. The ring is the obvious symbol — it fits perfectly, which means he knew her size beforehand. But the text explicitly raises this question: "But how did he know my ring size so precisely?" This isn't just a romantic detail; it's evidence. Physical proof that his feelings aren't sudden or impulsive, that he planned this long before the drunk proposal. The ring becomes a symbol of intentionality in a story full of accidents and forgotten memories. Then there's the chocolate — Germain's chocolate, which is supposedly hard to get. Heizen knows this. He carries it. He uses it as both peace offering and manipulation tool. It's a small, domestic symbol that contrasts sharply with the grand political marriage they're entering. While the plot involves land, titles, and empire-building, the emotional core keeps coming back to: does he remember what she likes to eat? And the snow. Winter at Troskan Castle, everything white, nothing green or yellow or red — this setting isn't accidental. The barren landscape mirrors their relationship: frozen, uncertain, waiting for something to thaw. But Rizle talks about making snowmen, about ambitious goals, about wanting to build something taller than herself. She's the warmth in the ice. She always has been.
... Read More
I need to just... I need a moment. The snowman scene. THE SNOWMAN SCENE. Rizle is out in the freezing cold, making this tiny snowman with her bare hands, completely absorbed in it. Heizen watches from a distance, worried she'll catch a cold, and then — and THEN — he steals it. He wraps it in his coat like it's the most precious artifact in the world and carries it back to his room. "Why did I steal this?" he asks himself. "If someone found out and questioned him, he wouldn't know how to explain. Yet, he had no intention of returning it." That line right there. That's not just obsession, that's devotion. He'd rather be caught as a thief than return something she made. And then the snowman starts melting. A puddle of water on his windowsill. And he feels this indescribable sadness. Not because the snowman is destroyed — but because he's watching something temporary that he can't keep, just like their time together. The internal monologue is where it really gets me: "Through the snowman, Heizen saw Rizle. Coincidentally, its white color reminded him of her in the white dress he had admired." "I should have told her then... that the white dress suited her best." He regrets the unspoken words. He vows to speak next time. But the reader knows — there probably won't be a next time, or if there is, he'll still freeze. And then it escalates. The sadness transforms into something darker. "The truth was, what he truly wanted wasn't the snowman. I need to steal Rizle Thruella." I am not okay. This went from sweet to dangerously possessive in two paragraphs and I didn't see it coming. The emotional whiplash is real. He starts as this devoted but silent guardian and ends as someone fantasizing about kidnapping the woman he's protecting. The author doesn't flinch from showing how love can distort a person's mind. That's brave writing.
... Read More
Let me talk about the snowman because this symbol is doing HEAVY lifting. On the surface, it's a cute little thing Rizle made with her bare hands in the cold. But it represents everything about Heizen's situation: it's fragile, temporary, beautiful, and it melts the moment you try to hold onto it. He wraps it in his coat — an attempt to preserve it — and in doing so, he's加速ing its destruction. The warmer his body heat, the faster it melts. That's such a devastating metaphor for trying to possess something you love. The white dress recurs as a symbol too. Heizen sees her in white during the party and thinks it's the most stunning. Then the snowman is white and reminds him of that dress. White = purity = Rizle = the thing he can't quite reach. It's a visual through-line connecting his admiration to his obsession. There's also the war, which arrives like a metaphor you can't ignore. The Empire is conquering everything, pushing north toward Loen. Heizen is literally fighting in a war that could destroy everything while his personal war — against his own feelings — is raging inside him. The external conflict mirrors the internal one. "Black Rock" as a nickname for Heizen is symbolic too. A rock is immovable, unfeeling, permanent. But rocks crack. Rocks erode. Rocks get swept away by water. Sir Rey calls him Black Rock thinking it's a compliment to his stoicism, but it's actually a prophecy of what happens when emotion breaks through stillness. And the ending — Heizen fighting in battle, half-hearted,只想着回到T罗斯坎——it's like the war is both real obstacle and catalyst. He needs chaos to justify his chaos. The political turmoil gives him permission to stop being just a guard and become someone who acts. The story is really about the tension between duty and desire, between the role you play and the person you are underneath.
... Read More
I have been absolutely losing it over this whole proposal subplot. Let me just say - Rizle accepting a proposal while drunk is the most chaotic energy I have ever encountered, and I am HERE for it. The whole situation is built on such a delicious premise: she forgets the details of how he proposed, refuses to accept that it happened, and decides she needs him to propose again properly. The fact that Heizen somehow overheard her declaring this to her maid and brother is pure comedy gold. But what I love most about this section is how the plot keeps escalating tension without ever letting up. Rizle literally tackles Heizen into a locked room - that is not something you expect in a romance novel and yet it works so well. She demands confirmation about the ring, and when he tries to talk about land and wealth and mansions, she interrupts with something way more vulnerable: she wants kisses. Daily kisses. From her husband. And then his response - 'I can't guarantee I'll be able to stop there' - gives me chills every time. The author set this up perfectly by showing us earlier that Heizen never agreed to talk to her, gave only one-word answers, seemed completely cold and distant. But here he is, admitting something so charged and dangerous. The narrative pacing is masterful because every scene ends with a mini cliffhanger or an emotional bomb. Gilbert confronting Heizen in the hallway, the threat of a duel hanging in the air, Albert swooping in to drag everyone to the family meeting - the author never lets the reader breathe and I absolutely cannot complain.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is just SO vivid. I want to live in this castle and also never leave because the energy is immaculate. Let me break down what makes these scenes feel so cinematic. First, the cold corridor. The text specifically mentions Heizen's face being flushed in Kabakia's heat but now pale in the cold corridor. That single detail does so much work - it tells us about geography, about climate, about how far he's come, and about his current emotional state all at once. His furrowed brows in that cold light make him look almost vulnerable for the first time. 'So he was human after all, not a stone' - Rizle's observation here is both funny and oddly poignant because it marks the first moment we see her truly looking at him instead of just reacting to his reputation. Then there's the locked room scene. Just the sound of the door clicking shut changes everything about the atmosphere. You go from a wide hallway full of witnesses and an audience (Mary, Gilbert, the whole family drama) to a private, charged space where only two people exist. The author uses this shift brilliantly - the physical confinement mirrors the emotional confinement these two are about to navigate. And the family study at the end! The Marquis collapsed in his chair from shock, the Marchioness trying to maintain composure, Albert with his easy grin and arm draped over Gilbert's shoulder like nothing is wrong. Every character occupies that room differently, and you can practically see the lighting, the furniture, the tension thick enough to cut. This world feels lived-in and real in a way that makes the romantic elements hit even harder.
... Read More
The central conflict of these chapters is deceptively simple: Rizle wants a redo of the proposal, Heizen won't give it to her. But the stakes keep escalating in ways you don't expect. Initially it's just curiosity — she wants to know what he said. Then it becomes about validation — does he actually like her, or is this arrangement hollow? Then it shifts to power — who controls the narrative of their relationship? When she blocks his doorway, it's no longer about the proposal; it's about who gets to dictate the terms of their interaction. And here's the thing that got me genuinely worried: she loses that confrontation. Ten minutes of standing still and her arms are shaking. He doesn't even need to say anything — he just stands there, arms crossed, patiently outlasting her. This is a man who defended an empire, and he applies the same tactical patience to getting her to move aside so he can access his room and his chocolate stash. But the external stakes are also humming in the background. Boeur. The southern lands. A marriage that's partly political. Rizle mentions she doesn't know a single person there. Every cute moment of them bickering about proposals is layered on top of the fact that she's about to be uprooted and dropped into a foreign place. The personal conflict and the larger stakes are braided together, and that's what makes you keep turning pages.
... Read More
I need to talk about Heizen because this character is doing SO MUCH with barely any lines. Like, the man is a walking contradiction and I am HERE for it. On one hand, he's "The Black Rock" — stoic, unreadable, gives one-word answers. On the other hand, he remembers her favorite food (venison — and not just that, he tracks whether her family brings back deer after hunting), he knows exactly what chocolate she likes, his ring fits her perfectly, and he gets flustered when she leans in close. The gap between his exterior and interior is where all the charm lives. But the real character moment for me isn't the romantic stuff — it's when he admits, completely flatly, that he'd lie if pressed. "If you give me more time, I'll come up with something." This man cannot maintain the ice-cold persona for five minutes before confessing he'd fabricate a hobby. He's bad at small talk. He's bad at pretending he's some unfeeling robot. And instead of hiding that, he just... says it. Rizle's growth as a character here is subtler but equally interesting. She goes from embarrassed and apologetic to confidently teasing him, from hoping he'll relent to strategically exploiting his weaknesses (chocolate bribery works!). She's reclaiming agency in this arranged marriage situation instead of just being a passive participant. Their dynamic has shifted from "nervous engagement" to something way more playful and equal.
... Read More
OK so can we just talk about the cheek kiss scene because MY HEART. I read it three times and each time I got more flustered. Let me walk through why this hit me so hard. Rizle has this entire dream built around watching her parents - the Marchioness kissing the Marquis every single day, still doing it even now. That's her template for love. Not grand gestures or dramatic confessions, but everyday tenderness. And when she asks Heizen if he'll kiss her, she's not being frivolous - she's asking for the most basic version of the life she's dreamed of her whole life. And he resists. He literally grimaces. Rizle's disappointment in that moment is so sharp you can feel it through the page. Then he gives in. Leans in. Presses his lips to her cheek. And the narration hits you with this devastating simplicity: 'His lips are so warm!' That's it. That's the entire sentence and it wrecked me because it's pure sensation, pure surprise, pure vulnerability all at once. She's frozen. She can't process it. And he? He's already stepping back, averting his gaze, scowling like he's been wounded. The contrast between them here is everything. She's experiencing this moment as something magical and overwhelming. He's treating it like a chore he barely agreed to complete. And yet - and THIS is the part that made me sit with my phone staring blankly for ten minutes - his final line completely undercuts everything he's been projecting. 'I can't guarantee I'll be able to stop there.' That is not the words of someone who finds her annoying or burdensome. That is the words of someone who is already fighting something he doesn't understand. I am literally shaking.
... Read More
"Should we cross the border? If we escape to the Empire, even the Marquis of Thruella wouldn't be able to chase us, would he?" This line came out of Heizen's mouth and I actually stopped breathing for a second. This is the moment the story shifts from romantic comedy to psychological thriller territory and I am HERE for it. Let's break down the stakes layer by layer because they stack fast: Layer 1: Personal. Heizen wants to be noticed by Rizle. Simple, right? Wrong — because his desire has escalated to the point where he's contemplating kidnapping her. The internal conflict isn't just "does she like me" anymore. It's "am I a good person or am I becoming a villain." Layer 2: Social/Political. Rizle is the daughter of the Marquis of Thruella, who commands the second-largest knight force in Loen. If Heizen actually goes through with anything, the consequences aren't just personal — they're treason-level. The Marquis would unleash all his forces. Layer 3: Military. The Empire is invading. Loen's capital has fallen. King Loen may have fled to Troskan. Half of Troskan's forces are already deployed to Boeur. Heizen himself is drafted into this war. The external conflict is escalating in real time. Layer 4: Romantic. Heizen saved Albert (Rizle's brother) in battle. Now he has a debt owed by her family — but also a secret he'll never tell. If the truth comes out, everything collapses. What I love is how the author keeps raising the stakes while Heizen is simultaneously spiraling internally. The war gives him a reason to leave, but also a reason to rush back. Every battle he fights is both protecting Loen AND bringing him closer to Rizle — or taking him further away, depending on who wins. The suspense is maintained perfectly because we know Heizen's mental state is unstable, but we don't know if he'll ACT on his darkest thoughts. Will he confess about the snowman? Will he actually try to "steal" Rizle? Will the war force them apart forever? Each chapter opens new questions while answering old ones.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this first because it bugged me: the scene where Heizen gets put on that wooden chair while everyone else sits on sofas is such a blatant power move, and the author doesn't even try to hide it. It's brilliant actually because it immediately establishes the social hierarchy without a single exposition dump. The marquis didn't invite him to be equal—he invited him to prove he wasn't a threat. That's plot economy right there. And then the real meat of the chapter—the negotiation itself. Heizen asking for southern land, the father pushing back, the revelation about Kabakia... it unfolds like a chess game where every move has been premeditated. The count claims he wanted warmer climate for his wife, which is honestly both a genuine consideration AND a strategic statement at the same time. He's showing he already imagines Rizle as his wife before anyone formally agreed to anything. That's either incredibly bold or dangerously arrogant depending on how you read it. The marchioness flipping the script by demanding he stay in Boeur rather than send her daughter away was the moment I actually sat up straight. She reframed his 'consideration' as an insult to the position of a wife. That's not just plot—it's a character weaponizing etiquette to assert dominance. And then the ring reveal on Rizle's hand? Chilling. The marquis literally deflating like a balloon after seeing it... the narrative doesn't overexplain his resignation, it just shows it. I love that. One thing that threw me: Albert being more excited than the actual betrothed couple. Is that intentional satire? Or just family dynamics playing out realistically? Either way it added genuine texture to what could have been a sterile negotiation scene.
... Read More
Can we just talk about Mary for a second? Because I am OBSESSED. This woman is the emotional anchor of the entire scene and I need her to get her own spin-off series immediately. Let me paint you a picture: Rizle has just woken up from a bender, possibly engaged to a complete stranger, and Mary is over HERE pulling her own hair out. She's frantic, she's pleading, she's calculating odds. And the moment Gilbert drops the name Heizen? Her reaction is PRICELESS. She goes from despair to action in one beat, absolutely losing her mind about the gambling debts because finally, FINALLY, there's ammunition. "Please, Young Master Gilbert. Please stop sending Miss to such a gambling debtor!" I almost fell out of my chair laughing. This woman is fighting battles on every front. But then—then the quiet moment. When Gilbert is furious at Rizle and she's just sitting there trying to process, Mary 'sank into despair' watching them. I keep coming back to that image. She's caught between loyalty to her miss and the horrifying prospect of having to stay at Troskan Castle, which apparently means facing Barselin every single day. Her personal stakes are just as high as Rizle's, and she's handling it by basically short-circuiting into hopelessness. That's not just a servant— that's a friend who loves her and has nowhere to run. And what about Rizle herself? There's this tiny moment where she thinks, 'Did Viscount Lambus truly have feelings for me? Come to think of it, he did say I looked beautiful today.' And I just— my heart. She's so vulnerable here, trying to find warmth in a situation that's already terrifying. The fact that she's grasping at any positive detail shows how much she's struggling to maintain hope when everything's falling apart. Then there's the Kabakia thing, three years ago, when he was her escort and was completely cold to her. She found it exhausting. And now he's proposing? The emotional whiplash is unreal. Who is this man and why does he suddenly want her? I need answers and I need them NOW.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or