A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me - Reviews

A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay so let me just start by saying this opening is brilliant in its misdirection. On the surface it looks like a typical fantasy romance — nobles, parties, a mysterious proposal. But the moment Rizle wakes up and genuinely doesn't remember who proposed to her? That hit me like a truck. The author has handed us a locked-room mystery inside what seems like a courtship drama. Who proposed? Why does Rizle not remember? And why did the maids all seem to know before she did? The plot here is doing triple duty — it's setting up the political backdrop (Empire vs Rowen, Heizen's heroics), establishing the social world (marriage as political currency), AND dropping the central question that's going to drive the whole narrative. I love how the gossip in the kitchen isn't just flavor text; it's literally the mechanism that delivers the inciting incident to the protagonist. Two years of war, a kingdom on the verge of collapse, and the emotional core of the story starts with a girl who can't remember the most important moment of her life. That's tight writing.
... Read More
Can we just take a moment to appreciate how efficient this dialogue is? Heizen's signature line is literally three words: "I cannot." He says it multiple times across these chapters and each time it means something slightly different. First instance: cold refusal. Second instance: when she calls him petty, he just says it again like a wall. Third time: when she tries the sad eyes approach. By the fourth or fifth iteration, it's stopped being a refusal and started being a character trait — this man has boundaries and they are made of granite. But the dialogue shines brightest in the contrast between these two voices. Rizle's lines are fast, bouncing between questions, jokes, complaints, and demands. She talks in paragraphs. Heizen talks in fragments. And yet, somehow, the conversation flows. The author lets their speech patterns do the heavy lifting — you always know who's talking without seeing the tag. My absolute favorite exchange: "I'm sorry, but I don't want to hear lies." "If you give me more time, I'll come up with something." That's not just good dialogue — that's character revelation through conversation. Heizen admitting he'd lie is the most honest thing either of them has said all chapter. And Rizle finding it "fascinating" that he'd openly admit to lying? That tells us everything about her: she'd rather hear a truth that hurts than a polite fiction.
... Read More
What strikes me most about this text is how much the author communicates through what characters DON'T say. Heizen's dialogue is barely there. His longest meaningful exchange is basically: "I don't have one." when asked about his favorite food. That's it. Four words. And yet the internal monologue that follows is pages long. The contrast between his silence outwardly and his chaotic thoughts internally IS the character. Rizle's dialogue, on the other hand, is light and natural. She asks about food, asks about dresses, chats with Mary. She talks to fill space, out of curiosity. "What kind of food do you like?" She doesn't mean anything deeper by it. But Heizen hears it like a test he's failing. The narration style is third-person limited, stuck firmly in Heizen's head. And the author does something really smart — they let Heizen misinterpret things constantly. When he thinks "She must think talking to me is boring and not worth it anymore" after she stops asking questions, the narrator doesn't correct him. We're trapped in his anxiety. That's tight POV work. There's also this wonderful line: "Her eyes, her blue, sparkling eyes, made it impossible for him to think. His mind went blank, and he couldn't even recall the name of a single dish." The repetition of "her eyes, her blue, sparkling eyes" mimics how Heizen experiences her — overwhelming, repeated, inescapable. The prose itself becomes breathless. Sir Rey's dialogue is efficient and practical. She gives instructions, explains reasoning, provides exposition. Her voice is functional compared to Heizen's tortured interiority. That contrast between her calm professionalism and his internal screaming is what makes the humor work. The author's voice overall — restrained on the surface, turbulent underneath. Very Heizen-like, if the narration had a personality.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or