A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me - Reviews

A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
Okay, let me just say this out loud: the plot twist of the century. Rizle wakes up with a ring on her finger, no memory of the night before, and suddenly she's engaged to someone. But here's the genius part—the author doesn't just drop this and move on. They make you SUFFER through the elimination process with Mary. First, it's Lord Lido, right? The obvious flirt. We get all this background on him—charming, manipulative, probably got half the maids pregnant. Mary is rightfully horrified. Rizle remembers him but it was brief, and honestly, it felt like the author was setting up a red herring. You're thinking, yeah, probably not this one. Then comes the real gut punch: what if it's Viscount Lambus? A GAMBLER. With DEBTS. Mary loses her absolute mind here, and honestly, who wouldn't? The idea that Rizle could end up married to a man who'd drain her family dry and then possibly hit her? That's not romance, that's a horror story. And I love that Mary's motivation isn't just about Rizle—it's about her own future too, because she'd have to serve the Lambus household. That detail? Brilliant. It grounds the stakes in something real and human. But then—AND THIS IS THE BEST PART—Gilbert walks in and drops the actual name: Heizen Warkliber. The Black Rock. The guy who barely speaks, who apparently finds women bothersome, who became a war hero for some reason nobody fully understands and then pretended like none of it happened. The man who wouldn't even dance at his own event. And he PROPOSED to Rizle? After three years of being utterly uninterested in everyone around him? That's when my brain went absolutely sideways. Something happened three years ago in Kabakia that changed everything, and the author is playing 4D chess with information. Every time I thought I understood the plot, it flipped upside down. The political implications Gilbert is screaming about—"Everything is going according to that man's wishes"—suggest this isn't just a romantic entanglement, it's a calculated move in some larger game. And Rizle? She was the target from the beginning. I am SHOOK.
... Read More
Okay, let's talk about this chapter because HOLY. The plot twists are relentless here. We go from Heizen being the war hero everyone loves to him basically becoming a criminal mastermind in the making. The way the author structures this is brilliant - Heizen gets the title, gets the land (which is ironically the worst possible location), and then realizes his entire life plan has unraveled before it even began. Boeur as his fiefdom? That's not just bad luck, that's the author telling us something deeper about how fate works. Then there's the whole proposal scene in the garden - and I need to unpack this because it's everything. Heizen has been planning this elaborate kidnapping scheme, right? He has the teleportation stone, he knows the castle layout, he's got the forged letter ready. And what does he actually DO when he finds Rizle alone? He proposes. Like, on one knee in the snow. The contrast between his internal monologue ("I'll just throw her over my shoulder") and what he actually says is absolutely hilarious and heartbreaking at the same time. But here's the thing that got me - Rizle doesn't take it seriously. She thinks he's joking or she's dreaming. She strokes his hair and makes horns out of it. The scene ends on this note where neither of them has said what they really mean, and I'm SCREAMING. The author really knows how to leave you hanging. Also, the subplot with Albert proposing marriage to someone else? That's the ticking clock. Heizen literally cannot wait. Every chapter feels like he's one second away from losing her forever. That's solid plot construction right there.
... Read More
Can we talk about how Rizle speaks? She is consistently, relentlessly herself in every line. "Why are you proposing in winter? Why not in summer?" She is grabbing his face and screaming about romantic symbolism while simultaneously slapping him. That's such a Rizle move—emotional demand wrapped in physical aggression. And then immediately after, she goes all coy with the ring, examining it like a proper lady, then pivots back to accusation like nobody asked. Her dialogue has zero filter and maximum personality. Heizen on the other hand—his lines are short, clipped, earnest. "I'm sorry." "Yes." "No." He doesn't do performances the way she does. When he says "I've been observing you all along in Kabakia" that's basically his equivalent of a soliloquy. The author also nails the family interference comedy—her mother's one line: "I hope there won't be a child before the wedding." Not supportive, not encouraging, just... monitoring reproduction timeline. And the brothers wedging themselves between the couple instead of giving privacy? Chef's kiss. The dialogue across ALL these characters feels distinct enough that you could identify who's speaking without tags.
... Read More
"Slowly raised his hand and gently caressed her cheek. His thumb lightly brushed over her lips, nose, cheeks —" and then he PULLS AWAY to hand her chocolate. I am deceased. Absolutely deceased. This is the kind of moment that makes you scream into a pillow. Heizen builds up this entire intimate atmosphere — warm hands, deep eye contact, her eyes closing in anticipation — and then he deliberately deflates it like a balloon. The cruelty! The tenderness! The fact that he clearly wanted to kiss her but chose patience instead? My heart cannot handle this man. And Rizle's internal reaction is everything. She feels the warmth spreading from his touch all the way to her stomach, she parts her lips, she shuts her eyes expecting something more — and then opens them slightly, confused, disappointed, sensing that something was off. The author captures that exact moment of romantic anticipation being redirected, and it's devastating in the best way. What makes it even more painful is the context: he literally just told her she's the person he loves, then immediately followed it by withholding the one thing she's been begging for (a proper proposal). The emotional whiplash between "you're the person I love" and "I cannot [propose again]" is chef's kiss. Absolute torture. I love it.
... Read More
"You're not Heizen Warkliber, are you? He never responds to me this well." This line hit me like a small truck. Like, literally right after the proposal scene, Rizle just... questions whether the guy she just agreed to marry is the real deal. And Heizen's response? "The person I dislike is myself, for being so nervous that I frequently missed opportunities to get closer to you." Okay, THAT is a genuinely devastating answer. It reframes everything about their dynamic up to this point—his coldness wasn't rejection, it was self-loathing masking as distance. But then immediately after, the text gives us Rizle thinking about "the dangerous glint in the eyes of the man she thought was so innocent." WHAT. Is he performing innocence or IS he innocent? The book keeps waffling and I love it. Also, the way Heizen immediately goes from proposing to abandoning his elopement plan like it was nothing? He's so impulsive yet so earnest it makes me both want to hug him and shake him.
... Read More
I need to talk about the kiss. Just... the absolute chaos of it. Heizen leans in without warning, captures her lips, and she's so surprised she barely registers it until his tongue is already exploring. The writing here is remarkably physical—'His lips and tongue were so hot they felt like they might melt her.' She's not in a romance. She's in a fever dream. And the author doesn't soft-pedal any of it. Then he bites her neck. THEN puts his hand on her chest. And her response isn't anger—it's flustered indignation mixed with relief. 'First, you kiss me out of nowhere, and now you're touching my chest!' But the subtext screams: SHE NOTICED. She noticed the hardness pressing against her stomach. The suspicion she'd harbored about his capabilities is obliterated in three seconds flat. And then the confession she couldn't resist: 'So you're capable of feeling that way about me?' What a devastatingly vulnerable question to slip out. She's not asking if he's capable at all—she's asking if it's ABOUT HER. The aftermath is what actually broke me. She says 'I didn't dislike it' while fidgeting with her feet, and he looks at her like he needs reassurance that she means it. Not dominance. REASSURANCE. This man who faced down armies and sat across from a marquis threatening his daughter's hand in marriage is rendered speechless by a girl saying she didn't hate kissing him. The chemistry isn't in the grand gestures. It's in the miscommunication, the panic, the accidental truths that slip out when people are too flustered to guard themselves.
... Read More
'What are you doing, Rizle? Sit properly.' 'Are you embarrassed?' The marchioness assumes her daughter is just shy around a man. But reading between the lines—it's not just shyness, it's something more complicated. Rizle is terrified of being seen by him, and simultaneously desperate to be seen. Heizen's silence in that room says everything. While Gilbert is grinding his teeth and Albert is practically vibrating with enthusiasm, Heizen sits perfectly still on that hard wooden chair. Not defiant, not cowed—calibrated. The man is performing emotional restraint as a skill, and it's exhausting to watch. When their eyes meet and she flinches, then hides behind her mother... that's not fear. That's someone caught in the act of wanting something they weren't supposed to want. And then breakfast. She can't stop looking at him. Not once. 'Throughout the meal, she kept sneaking glances at him, pretending to look elsewhere when caught, only to look again moments later.' This is written with such precision it almost hurts. She's narrating her own obsession in real-time without realizing she's doing it. But here's what got me: his misunderstanding. She says 'I want to finish what we couldn't earlier' and he interprets it as physical. The text makes it clear he's not being predatory—he genuinely thought she meant that. His panic when he realizes his mistake ('My apologies') is almost more revealing than the kiss itself. He's nervous about her. Not about getting caught. About HER opinion of him. That's the relationship at its core: two people who keep misreading each other but can't look away.
... Read More
Okay so let me just say this whole arc is BRILLIANT and I need to process it. Heizen gets assigned to guard Rizle for three months in Kabakia. Sir Rey picks him specifically because he's unmoved by beauty — the "Black Rock" of knights. Classic misdirection, right? Because obviously the guy who's supposed to be immune falls HARD. The plot structure here is so clever. It's not a straight romance progression. Heizen goes through these phases: assignment → infatuation → failed conversation → retreat back to normalcy → the snowman incident → full-blown obsessive realization → WAR suddenly interrupts everything. What really sold me was the middle section where he literally practices his answer about the white dress for an entire month, and then she cuts the trip short. That moment when he thinks "Was it because I was boring?" — I literally threw my phone on the bed. The author doesn't give us the resolution we want and instead throws in political intrigue and war. And then the ending of this excerpt has him fighting in a war while thinking about getting back to Rizle, and even hoping the defensive line keeps retreating toward Troskan Castle. That's either the most romantic or the most unhinged thing I've ever read. Probably both. The pacing is what kills me — it moves from quiet observation to full psychological breakdown to battlefield chaos in just a few chapters. There's no filler. Every scene pushes his obsession forward.
... Read More
I have to talk about the dialogue because it is ABSOLUTELY delicious. Every character has such a distinct voice that I could tell them apart with my eyes closed. Mary's voice is chaos incarnate and I love her for it. 'Lord Lido is absolutely out of the question!' 'Miss, please reconsider!' 'Should I just stay at Troskan Castle?' Her dialogue is all exclamation points and desperate pleading, full of em-dashes and abrupt thoughts. She talks in spirals, jumping from one catastrophic scenario to the next. And then there's the gorgeous moment where she literally forgets her own logic: 'Didn't you just say earlier that anyone but Lord Lido would be fine?' 'Now that I think about it, there are far too many unsuitable men in the world.' THAT is how a panicked person actually talks. She's not constructing arguments; she's having thoughts out loud and they're all terrible. Brilliant. Gilbert is sharp and clipped. 'Why do you ask!' 'Don't call him your fiancé just yet.' His dialogue cuts. He's angry but also calculating—you can see him working through the political implications while he's yelling. And then there's this moment where he goes from furious to thoughtful in one beat: 'Gambling? That man gambles?' That pause, that shift from emotional response to strategic thinking, tells us everything about who Gilbert is without a single narrator comment. But the voice that got me was Rizle's. She's not loud or dramatic. Her dialogue is short, deflective, almost dreamy: 'Oh, is it because of this?' 'Mother and Father seem so weak.' 'But I really don't remember anything.' She's in shock and her words are small, like she's trying to make herself smaller in a situation that's swallowing her alive. And then there's that internal voice—the remembered dialogue from three years ago. 'What kind of food do you like?' 'I don't have any.' Just two words. Flat. Cold. And somehow that sparse dialogue from Heizen tells us more about him than any description could. The contrast between his minimal speech and the enormous impact it has on Rizle? Chef's kiss. The author knows exactly what every character sounds like, and that's rare.
... Read More
So Rizle successfully seduces Heizen during the proposal scene. He touches her intimately. She lies in the bath afterward trying to wash away evidence of her arousal. She can't stop blushing. She starts DREAMING about consummating the marriage. And then—plot twist—he literally will not even SHARE A BED with her. He sleeps on the sofa. The MAN FELL ASLEEP ON THE COUCH AFTER BEING ENGAGED TO A WOMAN WHO WAS TRYING HER BEST TO LURE HIM INTO THE BEDROOM AND HE STILL FOUND A REASON TO SLEEP ELSEWHERE. I am physically wheezing. The contrast between his violent capacity in battle and this absolute moral rigidity around her is so specific it had to be intentional. The text says he looked "more like a naive young man who knew nothing of killing" with his messy hair in the morning light, and I literally could not stop smiling at the juxtaposition. Meanwhile Rizle's internal monologue goes from "I admire my own cunningness" to absolute devastation in 0.4 seconds. The push-pull is so sharp it could cut glass.
... Read More
One thing I genuinely appreciate about this text is that every character has a voice, and I mean that literally. The maids in the kitchen — their dialogue is fast, overlapping, gossip-driven. They interrupt each other, they trail off with ellipses, they use phrases like 'guess what?' and 'you'll all be shocked.' It's chaotic and real. Then you switch to Mary, and her internal voice is completely different — more controlled, more analytical, more protective. When she says 'I shouldn't care about this. Just look at how she's intentionally provoking me,' that's not how a maid talks to her mistress; that's how Mary talks to herself. The butler is even more distinct — clipped, formal, almost cold. 'Even if it takes time, make sure she doesn't show up in her nightgown like last time.' That single line tells us everything about the household hierarchy and the butler's personality without a single adjective. And Rizle's dialogue — or lack thereof — is its own statement. She mumbles about food in her sleep, she groans about her headache, she can barely form full sentences. Her voice is fragmented, sleepy, unreliable. Which makes you wonder: is that who she really is, or is the alcohol just lowering her defenses? The author trusts the dialogue to do character work without narration carrying the load.
... Read More
There's something deeply symbolic about a winter proposal where Rizle specifically demands summer imagery—flowers, bloom, romance—and Heizen has to explain he couldn't wait. The winter setting isn't accidental. It mirrors their entire relationship: beautiful but harsh, growing things are dormant, and yet love persists anyway. The ring itself is interesting too—she prefers small multiple stones over large gems, practical beauty over showiness. It reflects who she is. Then there's the entireBoeur subplot where the study connects directly to the bedroom, a literal threshold between public/earned space and private/intimate space. Heizen keeps standing guard at that threshold. He won't cross it. The sun imagery recurs obsessively—"the winter sunlight streaming through the arched corridors suddenly seemed beautiful" and then that warmth turns to ice when he remembers she forgot everything. Light becomes emotional barometer. And most hauntingly, that line about memory: "If I can't remember, it doesn't count. Last night's events never happened!" Whatever that means in context, it transforms the entire emotional landscape. The proposal, the intimacy, the future—they're all built on potentially erasingable ground. That's not romance, that's architectural instability.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or