A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me - Reviews

A Proposal That Was Completely News to Me
+Add to Custom List
Sort
Add review
... Read More
I need to talk about Mary for a second because honestly she stole every scene she was in. She's Rizle's personal maid, sure, but the way the text frames their relationship is so much richer than the servant-master dynamic. Mary knows everything — she's the one Rizle showed the ring to the night before, she's the one who notices the alcohol smell, she's the one whose first instinct isn't to serve but to PROTECT. When she thinks about reporting any man who mistreats Rizle over sleep-talking, that's not duty. That's devotion. And then there's her rivalry with Barselin — petty on the surface, but it's really about loyalty. Barselin got the information first, and Mary bristles because she *should* be the one who knows her mistress best. I also noticed something about Rizle herself: she's sleep-talking about salted pork and chocolate while someone is kneeling and proposing to her. Does this mean she's genuinely ditzy, or is the drunkenness a shield? Either way, the fact that she doesn't remember the proposal at all creates this ache — she's the center of the story and she doesn't even know it yet.
... Read More
Okay so this entire sequence is basically built around one delicious narrative engine: Rizle wants to know what Heizen said during his drunk proposal, and he refuses to tell her. That's it. That's the plot of these chapters. And honestly? It works. The structure is clever because on the surface it's just two people talking back and forth — very contained, very small-scale — but underneath, every exchange peels back another layer of their history. We learn that he proposed while she was drunk, that she remembers nothing, that he has a ring that fits perfectly, that he claims to love her, that he's stubborn about repeating it, that he called himself pathetic afterward. Each detail is a breadcrumb, and the author is playing 4D chess with pacing here. What I love is how the plot refuses to resolve. Fifteen days pass. She tries again. Different approaches — playful, desperate, bargaining, physically blocking his door — and he says no every single time. The tension doesn't break; it compresses. By the time he offers her chocolate just to get her to move, you realize this man is weaponizing his own silence. The mini-twist of him saying "Because you like it" about the chocolate and then immediately touching her face? That's the plot doing double duty — advancing the romance while simultaneously reminding us that he notices everything about her, even the small things she thinks are hidden.
... Read More
I went into this expecting a slow fantasy start and got instead a chapter that moves like it's running from something. Let me break down why this works so well. It opens with chatter — light, almost comedic gossip about a party. Very low stakes. Then it pivots to the war context in a paragraph, which is a heavy beat, but it's delivered efficiently like exposition whispered between scenes. Then we go back to gossip, then to Mary's jealousy, then to Rizle's bedroom — and right when you think we're settling into a cozy slow morning, BOOM, the ring reveal. The pacing is essentially a series of rising waves. Each section ends on a slightly more interesting note than the last, and the final image — Rizle sitting up, mouth open, the words 'I was proposed to?' hanging in the air — is a perfect structural climax for an opening chapter. The author understands that curiosity is a pacing tool. We don't need explosions yet; we need a question so compelling that turning the page becomes physical compulsion. Also noting: the chapter break after 'a young blond man among the' is brutal. I respect it.
... Read More
This whole sequence is a masterclass in pacing, and I need to break down exactly why it works so well. We start IN MEDIA RES with Rizle already wearing the ring and already confused. No boring exposition dumps about how she got here—the author trusts us to figure it out alongside her. That's smart. It puts us immediately in her disoriented headspace, which is exactly where we need to be. Then Mary enters and becomes our guide, asking the questions we're thinking. The elimination process—Lido first, then Lambus—creates this wonderful rhythm of hope and dread. Each time we think, 'Okay, maybe it's just this guy,' the answer shifts. It's almost comedic in how quickly Mary goes from relieved to horrified and back again. But it's not silly comedy; it's genuine tension dressed in casual conversation. The chapter breaks are interesting too. Chapter 1.3 ends with Gilbert confronting them, and chapter 1.4 opens with the big reveal. That's a cliffhanger that actually works because we're desperate for context—we know someone proposed, we don't know who, and the previous chapter ended on the most alarming possibility. When Gilbert walks in, the pacing accelerates hard. He's furious, he's shouting, and then BAM—the name drop. Heizen Warkliber. The pacing shift from the slow, methodical elimination to this sudden explosion of information is jarring in the best way. It mimics exactly how shock feels. What's really clever is how the author handles the exposition about Heizen. Instead of a huge info dump, it's woven into Gilbert's anger and Rizle's internal recollections. We learn about the 'Black Rock' nickname, his lack of interest in women, his war hero status, his refusal to dance at the party—all while the scene is actively moving forward. The information serves the emotional beats, not the other way around. And the final line, trailing off with 'When she asked him if he dislike...'—that's a chapter ending that practically screams 'READ MORE.' It's perfect.
... Read More
Let me be real about the pacing here because this chapter is a masterclass in controlled tension. The first half moves relatively fast - we get the war ending, the rewards ceremony, Heizen getting his title, Albert dropping the marriage bombshell, and Heizen's elaborate planning sequence. It's almost too much information packed in, but somehow it works because each beat builds on the last. Then we hit the middle section where Heizen is WAITING. The ring being made, the castle repairs, the villa search in Kabakia. This could have been filler content, right? But no - the author uses this waiting period to heighten the stakes. Every day that passes is another day Rizle could get married off. The anxiety is contagious. And then the party scene. FINALLY. The pacing shifts dramatically here. We go from weeks of anticipation to one night that changes everything. The party itself is described almost superficially - Heizen doesn't enjoy it, his mind is racing, he's fiddling with that teleportation stone. But then Rizle leaves, and we follow her into the garden. The transition from the crowded banquet hall to the quiet, snowy garden is perfect. It's like the world shrinks down to just the two of them. The garden scene itself is paced beautifully. Short sentences. Quick exchanges. The dialogue snaps back and forth like a tennis match neither of them wants to lose. And that ending - abrupt, unresolved, hilarious. It's the perfect cliffhanger that makes you immediately want to read the next chapter. Some might argue the middle section dragged, but I'd say it was necessary suffering. You needed to feel the weight of those waiting days to appreciate the catharsis of the proposal scene.
... Read More
Alright, let's talk about the stakes because this chapter ramps them UP. Heizen isn't just fighting a war anymore - he's fighting TIME itself. Every chapter that passes is another chapter Rizle could be discussing marriage proposals with her family. The urgency is palpable, and I'm literally sweating for this man. The external conflicts are stacked high: Heizen needs to convince the Thruella family to let him marry Rizle, but he can't even approach them formally because he's technically a stranger now. His title of Count of Warkliber puts him in a weird position - he's noble enough to be considered, but not connected enough to be trusted. And Boeur? That's basically a death sentence if the Emperor decides to invade again. So he's supposed to secure their future in a war zone? Classic. But the REAL conflict is internal. Heizen is torn between his honorable nature and his desperate desire to TAKE what he wants. He plans to kidnap her, to use that teleportation stone to snatch her away. But he also wants to do things properly, to win her heart. These two impulses are at war inside him, and it's making him do stupid things like proposing while she's clearly drunk and not paying attention. The stakes keep rising. Albert mentions Rizle's younger sibling is unmarried - wait, does that mean Rizle is next in line for marriage? The political implications are enormous. If she marries someone else, Heizen loses her forever. And not just loses her - he loses his entire reason for fighting in the war. What was he defending if not the chance to be with her? The tension in that garden scene is absolutely electric. He's kneeling there with a ring, she's playing with his hair like he's a dog, and the reader is screaming "JUST GIVE HER THE RING AND EXPLAIN YOURSELF." The gap between what Heizen wants to do and what he's actually doing is the source of all the comedy and pathos in this chapter. I'm invested. I'm concerned. I need this to resolve.
... Read More
There is something deeply symbolic about that ring that the author keeps bringing back to, and I think it's worth unpacking because it goes beyond just being a plot device. The ring appears on Rizle's finger and immediately becomes the center of gravity for every interaction. Gilbert pounds his chest looking at it. Rizle clenches her ringed hand into a fist. When Heizen arrives, his glare seems fixed on that exact spot. The ring is no longer just jewelry - it's a symbol of obligation, of a promise made under unclear circumstances, of two people whose lives have been irrevocably linked despite neither of them fully understanding how or why. What fascinates me most is the contrast between what the ring represents to each of them. For Rizle, it's tied to her childhood dreams of romance - the proper proposal, the daily kisses, the kind of love she watched her parents share. The ring is supposed to be a key to that dream. For Heizen, the ring seems heavier, more complicated. When he talks about land and wealth and a mansion in Kabakia, he's trying to frame the marriage in practical terms - as a contract, a arrangement, something manageable. But his own words betray him. 'I can't guarantee I'll be able to stop there' - that admission shatters the practical framework he's built around the ring. The sun rising in the east becomes another symbolic touchstone. Rizle uses it to express how unnatural this situation feels to her. But what if it's not unnatural at all? What if the sun rises in the east and Heizen Warkliber proposes to Rizle Thruella, and that's just how the world works now? I keep thinking about this and I'm not over it.
... Read More
"So I'm boring." Heizen used to say this to himself without a care. Now the same word from Rizle makes him want to crawl into a hole and hide. That one shift tells you EVERYTHING about how this relationship changes him. Let's talk about the asymmetry here, because it's delicious and painful. Sir Rey chooses Heizen because she thinks he won't be affected by Rizle's beauty. The irony is almost comedic. She literally says: "someone like 'Black Rock' would neither fall for Rizle nor attempt any foolish behavior." And then within days he's the one sweating because he can't form a sentence around her. Rizle herself is fascinating. She's impulsive, curious, completely unaware of the effect she has on people. She asks Heizen questions out of sheer curiosity, not malice, but the damage is done. He takes every interaction seriously while she's just... living. When she asks about the white dress, she's not testing him — she genuinely wants an opinion. And he fails again. The power dynamic is so interesting too. Heizen has the position of bodyguard, which theoretically gives him authority, but in practice he's the most powerless person in the room. He can't speak. He can't act. He can only watch and internalize. And then there's Albert, her brother, who Heizen saves in battle. The author drops this in so casually — "Albert was Rizle's older brother. It was advantageous for Heizen to leave a good impression on her family." Heizen literally thinks about using his heroic act as future insurance. The man is calculating his way into her life while simultaneously losing his ability to think clearly around her. The relationship between Heizen and Sir Rey is also worth noting. She genuinely believes she made the right choice. She has no idea her "Black Rock" is crumbling into an obsessed mess. That dramatic irony is chef's kiss.
... Read More
There's so much going on symbolically in this chapter that most readers probably miss on first read. Let me break it down because I'm obsessed with the deeper meanings. First, the ring. Heizen commissions this ring in secret - no one knows about it, not even the people closest to him. It represents his hidden feelings, his private devotion. But here's the thing: he never actually gives it to her. She's so drunk she doesn't even register it. The ring becomes a symbol of unspoken love, of intentions that never quite reach their destination. Classic Heizen - always one step behind. Then there's the teleportation stone. This is fascinating on multiple levels. It's a shortcut, a way to bypass obstacles, but it's rendered useless by the castle's protective barrier. Symbolically, this represents Heizen's entire situation - he has the means to take what he wants, but the social structures (the barrier) prevent him from using it directly. He needs to work around it, to find another path. Which is exactly what he does. The castle itself is a major symbol. It's where Rizle lives, where her father is the Marquis, where she's protected and caged all at once. Heizen knows the layout because he once served there, but he's now an outsider. The physical barrier between the bedroom and the study that Heizen orders torn down? That's interesting - he's literally remodeling the space for when she might come to live with him. He's planning their future while pretending to just "retrieve belongings." And the snow. Everything happens in the snow. Cold, pristine, covering everything. Rizle touches it, rubs it on her face. It's beautiful but cold, much like their relationship right now. Perfect on the surface, but there's something chilling underneath. The title Heizen receives - Count of Warkliber, lord of Boeur. Boeur is described as "the worst possible land" because it's on the Empire's invasion path. Symbolically, this is Heizen's love life - precarious, dangerous, constantly under threat. He got what he wanted (a title, land to support her) but it's not what he actually needed. The irony is delicious.
... Read More
I need to sit down because this chapter literally destroyed me. HEIZEN'S FEELINGS. Where do I even start? This man has been holding onto his love for Rizle in absolute silence. He didn't tell anyone - not Albert, not his knights, nobody. Why? Because he was afraid other war heroes would discover her and compete for her hand. Can you imagine carrying that much love all by yourself? My heart actually aches for him. And that scene in the garden - THE SCENE. He follows her because he sees other men approaching her. Not just any men, but Lords and Viscounts. His jealousy is palpable through the page. He watches her stumble through the snow, half-drunk, and something in him just breaks. When he kneels and pulls out that ring he had commissioned in secret, risking everything... But Rizle. Oh, Rizle. She's so drunk she thinks he's joking. She touches his face, plays with his hair, calls his hair "so black" like she's some kind of mad scientist discovering a new specimen. And Heizen - this battle-hardened knight, this man who faced armies without flinching - is completely at a loss. His mouth goes dry. He considers literally throwing her over his shoulder. The frustration is UNREAL. What kills me is that they're both feeling the exact same thing but can't communicate it. He thinks she dislikes him. She thinks he has someone else he likes at the party. The misunderstanding is so thick you could cut it with a knife. And that's when she presses his head down and starts playing with his hair like he's a plushie. I'm not crying, you're crying. This CP has so much untapped potential and the author is just TOYING with us. The chemistry is there but it's buried under layers of miscommunication and social barriers. I need them to just TALK.
... Read More
Let's talk about what everyone is actually risking here because the surface conflict (will he get permission to marry the daughter) obscures so much deeper stuff. Gilbert is the most interesting case. He loves his brother but thinks Albert's reasoning is 'nonsense.' His entire posture in this chapter is someone watching his world rearrange itself around people he's supposed to trust. 'Even if Gilbert acts prickly, try to understand'—Albert literally apologizes FOR him to Heizen before the agreement is even formalized. Gilbert doesn't get to speak his mind because the narrative has already decided he's the antagonist of this moment. The marquis's two conditions are where the real stakes live. First: mutual respect. That's the polite one. Second: if anything happens to Rizle, Thruella will come for him with 'all the power.' The text specifically notes his temple throbbing when he imagines what 'anything' means. This isn't just a father's threat—it's a military strategist's warning. Troskan was never breached by the Empire. This man doesn't make empty promises. But the deepest conflict is internal, and it's Rizle's. She's caught between wanting to understand Heizen's intentions and being unable to read him at all. She wonders if he dislikes her, then discovers he requested southern land for her comfort, then can't stop staring at him during breakfast, then says something unintelligible when finally alone with him. Every impulse contradicts the last, and the reader feels every contradiction like a physical pull. The stakes aren't just marriage approval. They're identity, loyalty, desire, and survival—and the chapter treats them all as equally real.
... Read More
The atmosphere in these chapters is something I can't get over. You've got this castle in the far north, the last refuge of a kingdom that nearly fell, and instead of grim darkness the author gives us... a party. The maids are gossiping about lace decorations and love affairs. People are complaining about having to work harder. It's almost offensively normal, and that's what makes it so powerful. The war is there — two years of it, kings fleeing, armies decapitated — but it's background noise to people who just want to survive and enjoy themselves. The sensory details are what sell it though: the stifling heat of the kitchen, the sharp smell of alcohol on Rizle's breath, the bright sunlight flooding into her bedroom, the weapons collection the Marquis displays as a hobby. Every scene has texture. The northern staircase, the third door, the red and yellow blankets piled on the bed — you can literally see this place. It feels lived-in, not decorated. The world doesn't announce itself as fantastical; it just exists around you.

Leave a comment

You must be logged in to leave comments. or